Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
For if I see somebody drowning and I choose to not save them
This is why you don't understand God's sovereignty in election. You see unregenerate man as a victim, not the perpetrator that he is.
Then He is not sovereign. He is at the mercy of anyone with a "free will".
So then babies are not saved then?
...
This is why you don't understand God's sovereignty in election. You see unregenerate man as a victim, not the perpetrator that he is.
This is a good example of the logical fallacies which Calvinism requires. Calvinists believe that man is born totally depraved, unable to choose to cooperate with God's grace. Because no one can choose to accept grace, being totally depraved, God randomly decides to save people. In Calvinism, God sends people to hell because he chose to save them, while not saving others. God also sends people to hell because he chose not to save them. At no point did the person choose to be a sinner. They admit that. They admit God punishes people for being a sinner despite the fact they had no choice but to be a sinner.
There is no justice for God in Calvinism and this is why so many orthodox Christians reject the teachings of Calvin. There is nothing just about punishing a person when no personal choice is involved. So they respond by appealing to orthodox Christian views - that a person chooses to be a sinner. In this case, that you must think yourself the victim for your sins if you believe it is unjust for God to punish you for sin.
Yes, if you believe in orthodox Christianity, you are responsible for your sins. While you may be inclinded to sin because of the presence of sin in the world, the eternal grace of God is offered at every moment. You are given a choice between the inclination of the flesh, and the spiritual graces of God. But they appeal to something which does not exist for them. In Calvinism, humans aren't inclinded to sin, they are born to do nothing but sin. Humans receive no offer of grace from God at every moment of their existence. God only offers a moment of grace so overwhelming that you have no choice but to accept Him.
As an orthodox Christian, I accept the fact that I am both a victim of sin and a perpetrater of sin. I accept that on the day of judgment, God will consider what has been done to me and what I have done to others. I cannot accept that one can call God just if He rewards people in Heaven because He decided to save them, and send others to eternal suffering, because he chose not to free them from a slavery they were born into and had no choice but to live.
In Calvinism, all men are born slaves. Yet, they can never escape slavery, no matter how hard they try. God randomly decides to free men from slavery. On the day of their death, he sends slaves to hell, and free men to Heaven. Calvinists accept this fact and rather than openly admitting it, will utilize every logical fallacy to avoid admitting it.
As an orthodox Christian, I was not born a slave, with no choice to be a slave, only to be punished for being a slave.
How are people saved from God's wrath? What does the Bible have to say about that?
Do all people choose to be sinners?
How are people saved from God's wrath? What does the Bible have to say about that?
This is why you don't understand God's sovereignty in election. You see unregenerate man as a victim, not the perpetrator that he is.
Nothing forced about a free choice. Why invent buzzwords and supposed concepts that have no meaning or value?
Salvation in Christ is all of grace. There's no cooperation with Gods grace. And by saying such you deny the gospel altogether. You promote works righteousness like all pelagians do. Instead of having a tantrum on what's fair and just, read Romans 9. Paul rhetorically ask the same questions you ask.. "why doth He yet find fault? For who has resisted His will?" As all do, SELF will worshippers always question Gods justness and fairness. "Nah but, Oh man, who art thou that repliest against God".. Your fight is against the God of the Bible and His WordThis is a good example of the logical fallacies which Calvinism requires. Calvinists believe that man is born totally depraved, unable to choose to cooperate with God's grace. Because no one can choose to accept grace, being totally depraved, God randomly decides to save people. In Calvinism, God sends people to hell because he chose to save them, while not saving others. God also sends people to hell because he chose not to save them. At no point did the person choose to be a sinner. They admit that. They admit God punishes people for being a sinner despite the fact they had no choice but to be a sinner.
There is no justice for God in Calvinism and this is why so many orthodox Christians reject the teachings of Calvin. There is nothing just about punishing a person when no personal choice is involved. So they respond by appealing to orthodox Christian views - that a person chooses to be a sinner. In this case, that you must think yourself the victim for your sins if you believe it is unjust for God to punish you for sin.
Yes, if you believe in orthodox Christianity, you are responsible for your sins. While you may be inclinded to sin because of the presence of sin in the world, the eternal grace of God is offered at every moment. You are given a choice between the inclination of the flesh, and the spiritual graces of God. But they appeal to something which does not exist for them. In Calvinism, humans aren't inclinded to sin, they are born to do nothing but sin. Humans receive no offer of grace from God at every moment of their existence. God only offers a moment of grace so overwhelming that you have no choice but to accept Him.
As an orthodox Christian, I accept the fact that I am both a victim of sin and a perpetrater of sin. I accept that on the day of judgment, God will consider what has been done to me and what I have done to others. I cannot accept that one can call God just if He rewards people in Heaven because He decided to save them, and send others to eternal suffering, because he chose not to free them from a slavery they were born into and had no choice but to live.
In Calvinism, all men are born slaves. Yet, they can never escape slavery, no matter how hard they try. God randomly decides to free men from slavery. On the day of their death, he sends slaves to hell, and free men to Heaven. Calvinists accept this fact and rather than openly admitting it, will utilize every logical fallacy to avoid admitting it.
As an orthodox Christian, I was not born a slave, with no choice to be a slave, only to be punished for being a slave.
He is not a liar. Just because it takes time to make us perfect and sin free does not mean He is at our mercy. It means He is true and faithful.Then He is not sovereign. He is at the mercy of anyone with a "free will".
We do not decide to 'be good'. We decide that we hopeless doomed sinners accept His gift. Any goodness is from Him.Well, you are talking about Once Saved Always Saved. A one time free will decision forever force saves you into God's Kingdom with this kind of belief. Once you checked in, you can't check out. You can do evil and still be saved. Or you are changed beyond your initial free will decision to be good only and thereby eliminating free will.
God judges us in this life. David got punished. He let's us go through things for our good. Jonas refused...but eventually learned his refusal was wrong. Paul talked of some people that blew it so bad, they had to die, but we're still saved. Like gold tried in a fire, He burns off the crud in our lives. It is a life long process. We do not become purest gold the moment we get saved. The decision puts us on that long road to being made perfect. That decision was of our free choice.For no more free will decisions to refuse God can really be made anymore. It is "Forced Salvationism" just like Calvinism.
..
Right. It was in response to a post on propitiation. So we can either discuss propitiation or the "world". Adding other ideas not mentioned in the verse from the OP is moving the goalposts.You said..."That would be a form of universalism." Post # 37
We do not decide to 'be good'. We decide that we hopeless doomed sinners accept His gift. Any goodness is from Him.
So far, I have agreed with most of your views, but I must disagree on this subject because according to the scriptures a person who is born again and saved becomes a new creation in Christ and old things have passed away. One who is a new creation in Christ cannot then become unborn and go back to their unregenerate state. This does mean that a saved person is forced to obey or remove the responsibility of the saved person to exercise their will in choosing daily to trust and follow Christ or mean that a saved person does not at times sin and need to confess and repent.Well, you are talking about Once Saved Always Saved. A one time free will decision forever force saves you into God's Kingdom with this kind of belief. Once you checked in, you can't check out. You can do evil and still be saved. Or you are changed beyond your initial free will decision to be good only and thereby eliminating free will. Either way there are huge problems with Once Saved Always Saved (Which is not all that different from Calvinism). While Calvinism seeks to make God out to be something dark that He is not, Once Saved Always Saved does a similar thing. It either seeks to say that God can agree with your plan of salvation that says you can sin and still be saved (meaning, that God can agree with sin) or it seeks to make God out to be Calvinistic by taking away a believer's free will in going back to his old life of sin. A believer will be changed or forced to be good because of a one time free will decision. For no more free will decisions to refuse God can really be made anymore. It is "Forced Salvationism" just like Calvinism.
...
I think you are the one who moved it by bringing up universalism in the first place. If you want to discuss propitiation or the world, just do so. But don't throw in the charge of universallism and then say I am the one moving the goalposts by bringing up universalism.Right. It was in response to a post on propitiation. So we can either discuss propitiation or the "world". Adding other ideas not mentioned in the verse from the OP is moving the goalposts.
Universalism was the logical result of your view. Propitiation means God's wrath was satisfied. If satisfied for the whole world, then you are a left with a view approaching universalism.I think you are the one who moved it by bringing up universalism in the first place. If you want to discuss propitiation or the world, just do so. But don't throw in the charge of universallism and then say I am the one moving the goalposts by bringing up universalism.
You want me to believe that is all about me trying to save myself (without God's grace and without Him working in me) so as to justify your wrong belief.
That is not the issue. The issue is the Calvinistic trampling of free will, and the idea that we keep ourselves saved by works. (otherwise we were not predestined quite the right way)I believe it is ultimately God or Christ doing the good work in the believer.
People who claim to be holy and wholly sanctified and sinless in this life are far from the truth.I believe Jesus saves both in Justification and in Sanctification.
Of course we should really try. But you will fail in large measure at times. Judgment begins with believers, so God is on the case and helping us work out our lives, preparing us for eternity to come.There is no denying that. But one has to also cooperate with the good work the Lord does within a believer. Why else would the Lord say to his faithful servant?
Yes, I might add that the guy probably also had some area in his life that were not quite perfect. He got a commendation for the good things."His lord said unto him, Well done, good and faithful servant; thou hast been faithful over a few things, I will make thee ruler over many things: enter thou into the joy of thy lord." (Matthew 25:23).
Nor did He say 'well done perfect guy, in all areas you are perfect'.Notice how it does not say, "Well done, you who were sometimes a good and occasionally a faithful servant, you have been somewhat faithful because you have a belief only on me, so I will make you ruler of nothing in my kingdom, but yet can still enter thou into the joy of thy Lord."
It may be, but we will never die even if our works are burned up.For faith without works is dead.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?