Composer responds: You can see from the above that you are wrong.
Tawhano wrote: Not at all, I can see from your response that you are wrong. You fail to prove that sin is inherited.
Composer responds: The Scriptures disagree with you Tawhano?
Romans 5:12
Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned:
Tawhano wrote: This verse does not say we inherited sin at all.
Composer responds: Read it again and then explain why you later contradict yourself?
. . . and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned:
Tawhano wrote: Adam had no rules, save the one, to live by.
Composer responds: Make up your mind, if he had one rule then there were rules. You want 5 bob each way.
Tawhano wrote: Nothing was a sin at that time: there was no sin. Then Adam and Eve disobeyed God and ate of the fruit, which opened their eyes to good and evil, and sin entered into the world and the result of that action brought death to mankind.
Notice that God didnt punish them with death but that death was the result of them partaking of the fruit.
Composer responds: Please read the Bible Tawhano, it disagrees with you. The punishment of death was given before they sinned - Proof: - But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die. {thou shalt surely...: Heb. dying thou shalt die} (Gen. 2:17) KJS
Indeed Eve was also aware that the punishment was Death - Proof: -
But of the fruit of the tree which [is] in the midst of the garden, God hath said, Ye shall not eat of it, neither shall ye touch it, lest ye die. (Gen. 3: 3) KJS
So God surely did forewarn them that death would be brought against them if they disobeyed God's warning.
Tawhano wrote: God punished them by throwing them out of the garden, that was their punishment for disobeying Him.
Composer responds: You are wrong. Read again Gen. 2:17 KJS
Tawhano wrote: Sin was manifested when they ate of the fruit and that introduced sin to the world; not inherited as you claim.
No one is punished for the sins of Adam.
Composer responds: Here you go again, you then contradict yourself -
You wrote: Adam simply brought death to mankind as well as the knowledge of good and evil.
Composer responds: So you say that no one is punished for Adam's sins and then contradict yourself and say Adam DID bring death to mankind?
Tawhano wrote: The flesh is weak and therefore succumbs to sin.
Composer responds: Indeed flesh is now inherently weak, as a direct result of Adam's disobedience -
So now you agree that you were wrong?
Also Jesus' flesh was EXACTLY like our flesh as Rom. 8: 3 proves, -
For what the law could not do, in that it was weak through the flesh, God sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin, condemned sin in the flesh: {for sin: or, by a sacrifice for sin} (Rom. 8:3) KJS
Yet he did not weaken, Jesus did what no man has ever done and did what Adam failed to do. Jesus came to destroy that inherent weakness by DOING NO ADDED SINS and that is why he defeated the Devil, because the Devil is a metaphor for the inherent sins of the flesh.
Tawhano wrote: Matthew 26:41
Watch and pray, that ye enter not into temptation: the spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak.
Galatians 5:17
For the flesh lusteth against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh: and these are contrary the one to the other: so that ye cannot do the things that ye would
Again, I repeat, you failed to show that mankind has inherited sin. As with all of your other doctrines you only have one or two verses to support your claim and ignore all the others that clearly say you are wrong.
Composer responds: You agree that my Scriptures support me and then you claim that others do not?
You are therefore in error, because Scriptures DO NOT contradict themselves. Thus the conclusion is that it is your misrepresentation of those Scriptures that is at fault, because Scriptures DO NOT contradict themselves.
I say again, Scriptures DO NOT contradict themselves, you claim they do, that makes YOUR reasoning of them in error. My reasoning they all fit perfectly for Jesus DID no Sin but overcame his inherent sinful flesh that we ALL inherit from Adam's disobedience.
Composer Said:
Now read carefully "likeness" -
Strong's Concordance Renders: -
BDB/Thayers # 3667
3667 homoioma {hom-oy'-o-mah}
from 3666; TDNT - 5:191,684; n n
AV - likeness 3, made like to 1, similitude 1, shape 1; 6
1) that which has been made after the likeness of something
1a) a figure, image, likeness, representation
1b) likeness i.e. resemblance, such as amounts almost to equality or identity
NB. . . . resemblance, such as amounts almost to equality or identity
Tawhamo wrote: No, you read carefully: ALMOST to equality or identity. It means a representation of; resemblance of; NOT an exact copy.
Composer responds: I have given you the exact Strong's Concordance definition of "likeness" meaning "exactly like us, now you present your alleged definition that "likeness" means "not like us?"
Tawhano wrote: You said the Scriptures do not contradict one another so you explain how it is that you believe the scriptures say Jesus was sinful like us and yet the scriptures say He was without sin. You keep repeating that all have sinned and then say Jesus didnt do any added sin. This is nonsense. The scriptures say all have sinned not that all have inherited sin. Big difference.
Composer responds: A baby at birth is born immediately with a sinful nature.
If a baby were born "without sin" then it would not die. For the wages of sin is death (Rom. 6:23) KJS
So if it was born inherently sinless then explain why babies die at birth when you claim they have no sin in them?
This is proved again by the Scriptures -
Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned: {for that: or, in whom} (Rom. 5:12) KJS
For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God; (Rom. 3:23)
So explain how the scriptures contradict themselves under your interpretation.
Composer said:
You keep saying that Jesus DID NO SIN, which is absolutely true, but Jesus died for the sins of which he could not help and was born with as are ALL in the flesh born with as I have proved countless times and do so here again with all the scriptures I have presented.
Tawhano wrote: No you have proven nothing of the sort. All you have done is repeated your opinions countless times. You provide no scripture that says Jesus, or anyone else for that matter, has inherited sin. Please show me one verse that says we inherited sin from Adam. Yes sin entered into the world through the actions of Adam. Yes our flesh now dies because of the actions of Adam.
Nowhere does it say we are punished for Adams sin.
Composer responds: Once again the Scriptures contradict your claims Tawhano - Proof: -
Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned: (Rom. 5:12) KJS
So which man do you suggest was the cause of all mankind (including Jesus) inheriting Sin if it was NOT Adam as you claim?