• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

The origins of atheism

Status
Not open for further replies.

Freodin

Devout believer in a theologically different God
Mar 9, 2002
15,713
3,762
Germany, Bavaria, Middle Franconia
Visit site
✟260,281.00
Faith
Atheist
A better term would have been demonstrate.

You being finite can't possibly demonstrate something that is eternal and infinite. Logically, only something that is eternal and infinite can demonstrate itself.
I didn't even attempt to demonstrate it. I only presented the rational conclusions that lead it it.

Incidentally this is what I've been saying from the beginning, I can't demonstrate God to you, only God can demonstrate Himself to you, but if you don't want Him to, He won't because He can't control your will to not want Him.
Hey, look... that is just what I have been saying from the beginning: I can't demonstrate Primal Chaos to you... but Primal Chaos can. Though it doesn't bother what you want or what you don't want... or what itself 'wants'.
Primal Chaos has been demonstrated to me. There is nothing I can do or you can do to get that demonstration... but you can admit that it is as rational an explanation as God is.
 
Upvote 0

Chriliman

Everything I need to be joyful is right here
May 22, 2015
5,895
569
✟173,001.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married

This argument of yours suggests that primal chaos is the reason for your existence. Are you saying primal chaos takes the form of being your god?
 
Upvote 0

Colter

Member
Nov 9, 2004
8,711
1,407
61
✟100,301.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Other Religion
Marital Status
Married

What you call an "essay" is a statement of belief about the world, about the approach to life, to the world. If I were an Atheist or Humanist I would still call my worldview a belief about the world, about a Godless universe.
 
Upvote 0

Chriliman

Everything I need to be joyful is right here
May 22, 2015
5,895
569
✟173,001.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married

So primal chaos isn't eternal and infinite? You've got me confused again.
 
Upvote 0

AirPo

with a Touch of Grey
Oct 31, 2003
26,363
7,214
61
✟176,857.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
What you call an "essay" is a statement of belief about the world, about the approach to life, to the world. If I were an Atheist or Humanist I would still call my worldview a belief about the world, about a Godless universe.
Then you wouldn't be an atheist.
 
Upvote 0

Freodin

Devout believer in a theologically different God
Mar 9, 2002
15,713
3,762
Germany, Bavaria, Middle Franconia
Visit site
✟260,281.00
Faith
Atheist
So primal chaos isn't eternal and infinite? You've got me confused again.
Primal Chaos is eternal, because there is no time. It is infinite, because there aren't any boundaries.

But none of these descriptions really fit. The only fitting description you could make about Primal Chaos is that it is undescribable.

As for your confusion: look into your own worldview. Eternal and infinite... is that ALL that God is?
 
Upvote 0

Archaeopteryx

Wanderer
Jul 1, 2007
22,229
2,608
✟78,240.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
What you call an "essay" is a statement of belief about the world, about the approach to life, to the world. If I were an Atheist or Humanist I would still call my worldview a belief about the world, about a Godless universe.
I'm getting the impression that you didn't even read the essay, although you linked to it.
 
Upvote 0

AirPo

with a Touch of Grey
Oct 31, 2003
26,363
7,214
61
✟176,857.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
You said this:Of the 108,000,000,000 people purported to ever have lived, who discovered how to survive?
Only the ones who are still alive.

If someone has discovered how to survive, then why did you say atheism is [still] concerned with how to survive?
But he didn't say atheism is concerned with how to survive.
 
Upvote 0

Chriliman

Everything I need to be joyful is right here
May 22, 2015
5,895
569
✟173,001.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Primal Chaos is eternal, because there is no time. It is infinite, because there aren't any boundaries.

So logically you came from primal chaos, or are you outside primal chaos?

But none of these descriptions really fit. The only fitting description you could make about Primal Chaos is that it is undescribable.

Yet you just described it clearly and I understand what your saying, but you claim you didn't come from primal chaos which logically means you're outside of primal chaos.

As for your confusion: look into your own worldview. Eternal and infinite... is that ALL that God is?

My world view makes sense, apparently your's doesn't as I've pointed out above.
 
Upvote 0

Ana the Ist

Aggressively serene!
Feb 21, 2012
39,990
12,573
✟487,130.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married

Whew! I can see that I struck a nerve with you...and we both know that wouldn't have happened if I didn't speak the truth. Your post reads like a man desperately trying to convince himself.

I understand from my own personal experience that the transition to atheism was difficult...not all truths are comforting. I also know from the anecdotes of my fellow atheists that it was difficult for them too. The key thing for us was to remember that the truth matters...and ultimately one is better for accepting it even if it means losing the "christian" part of one's identity.

60 years old isn't too late to start accepting the truth and it's consequences.
 
Upvote 0

Freodin

Devout believer in a theologically different God
Mar 9, 2002
15,713
3,762
Germany, Bavaria, Middle Franconia
Visit site
✟260,281.00
Faith
Atheist
So logically you came from primal chaos, or are you outside primal chaos?



Yet you just described it clearly and I understand what your saying,...
Hm... if you understand what I am saying... then why are you incapable of representing it correctly?
... but you claim you didn't come from primal chaos which logically means you're outside of primal chaos.
Like here. "... but you claim you didn't come from primal chaos...".

I did? Where?

My world view makes sense, apparently your's doesn't as I've pointed out above.
I see that you evaded my question, which is not a good way to demonstrate your understanding of my position.

I try again: eternal and infinite... is that ALL that your God is? Nothing else? How about "love" and "truth"? How about "father"? How about all these concepts and ideas about God that are found in the Bible? Do you really want to say that nothing of that is correct... God isn't love and truth, God only is "infinite" and "eternal"?

Primal Chaos can be said - as far as we can say anything at all - to be "infinite" and "eternal". But Primal Chaos is neither truth nor falsehood, neither love nor hate nor indifference. Not as we see these concepts.
So if that is what makes "God"... Primal Chaos isn't God.

But let's play: Primal Chaos IS infinite and eternal. That makes it my God! So what now?
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

Chriliman

Everything I need to be joyful is right here
May 22, 2015
5,895
569
✟173,001.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Like here. "... but you claim you didn't come from primal chaos...".

So you did come from primal chaos? So something eternal and infinite that you can't comprehend caused you to exist. And since this primal chaos cannot demonstrate itself to you, you don't think it "created" you intentionally? Yet somehow you have this "idea" of primal chaos that was never demonstrated to you? So you literally created this idea out of nothing. Now that makes sense.


These are all correct attributes of God. He is eternally and infinitely everything good and He created me. What's your point?


Right, primal chaos isn't God. What now?

But let's play: Primal Chaos IS infinite and eternal. That makes it my God! So what now?

If your god is primal chaos then you've just admitted your god has no truth to it. Your god is neutral, neither claiming truth or denying truth. Which sounds about right because intellectually honest atheists should all admit they're making no truth claims about God, they just don't know either way. As I've pointed out before.

"But Primal Chaos is neither truth nor falsehood, neither love nor hate nor indifference. Not as we see these concepts."
 
Upvote 0

Freodin

Devout believer in a theologically different God
Mar 9, 2002
15,713
3,762
Germany, Bavaria, Middle Franconia
Visit site
✟260,281.00
Faith
Atheist
So you did come from primal chaos?
Ultimately, yes. As did you.
So something eternal and infinite that you can't comprehend caused you to exist.
No. That is an incorrect description. This is the reason why I objected to the term "reason for our objection" earlier. It did not "cause" me to exist. It is the base of our existence.
Another example of how well (or not) you understand my position.
And since this primal chaos cannot demonstrate itself to you,...
And again... where do you get this notion, when I said the direct opposite in post #2540. How can you claim to understand me, when you cannot even correctly represent me?

... you don't think it "created" you intentionally?
No. The fact that something like "intention" is not a concept that would work here nonwithstanding... why should I think so?

Yet somehow you have this "idea" of primal chaos that was never demonstrated to you? So you literally created this idea out of nothing. Now that makes sense.
As I said, this "idea" of primal chaos was demonstrated to me. It was demonstrated to me rationally.

And you cannot accept that... I wonder why? (No, I don't. I know why. But rhetorical questions are fun.)

These are all correct attributes of God. He is eternally and infinitely everything good and He created me. What's your point?
My point is that you seemed to imply that, if something is infinite and eternal, it must be God. And if something isn't God, it mustn't be infinite and eternal.
I propose something infinite and eternal that isn't God, because it is different from God in most other concepts.

Right, primal chaos isn't God. What now?
Atheism!

So now we are again at the idea that "God" has to be truth, claiming truth, denying truth. Ok, I understand your claim here.

But that isn't the ground of it all. You keep picking certain ideas about God, and use them as they fit your narrative. But you miss the whole: as God isn't only infinite and eternal and "truth" and "good" and whatever you want to claim... but also the prima causa, the creator of everything out of nothing.

This he cannot be. Primal chaos is the basis of all. No creation out of nothing. No first cause.


And here now we come to the really amusing part of that all: I do indeed make no statements of knowledge about "God" as a powerful entity who forms universes. I just don't believe in it. But I do claim knowledge about "God" as the eternal and infinite cause of all.
 
Upvote 0

Chriliman

Everything I need to be joyful is right here
May 22, 2015
5,895
569
✟173,001.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
He's done a fine job of doing that. You're either incapable or intentional in your misunderstanding.​

I understand him just fine. It just doesn't make sense as I've pointed out in my responses. I'm trying to make sense of it. Of course he'll say that primal chaos cannot be made sense of. If that's the case why should I believe primal chaos is real if it can't be made sense of? I prefer to remain rational in what I believe in and not just willy nilly believe in anything even if it doesn't make sense.
 
Upvote 0

Freodin

Devout believer in a theologically different God
Mar 9, 2002
15,713
3,762
Germany, Bavaria, Middle Franconia
Visit site
✟260,281.00
Faith
Atheist
I understand him just fine.
That must be the reason why you keep stating that I say something when I say the direct opposite: because you understand me just fine!

God cannot be made sense of. You - limited, not eternal, not infinite - cannot understand (that is what "make sense of" means) God... at least this is what you claim. If you could, you could demonstrate this understanding.

The only difference here is that you keep asserting that whatever you say is "rational"... even if it isn't... while I admit it when it isn't.


That said: the idea of Primal Chaos isn't irrational at all... Primal Chaos itself is. The concept of why it is - must be! - is completely rational.
 
Upvote 0

JonFromMinnesota

Well-Known Member
Sep 3, 2015
2,171
1,608
Minnesota
✟60,266.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single

Sounds like a good thing to add to a book figuring people would eventually not buy into it anymore. Just another way to control a congregation. Just as hope & fear are ways to control populations.
 
Upvote 0

Chriliman

Everything I need to be joyful is right here
May 22, 2015
5,895
569
✟173,001.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Ultimately, yes. As did you.

So you are finite, but primal chaos is eternal and infinite and you're claiming it did not cause you to exist meaning you can describe yourself as eternal and infinite, not having a cause?



My bold. Apparently, even if I believe this nonsense of yours, it'll never be demonstrated to me from primal chaos itself. So why believe it? There is literally no reason to believe what you're saying because you've just claimed that primal chaos does not care about what I want. So the only reason to believe it would be to deny an eternal infinite God that does care about what I want.

As I said, this "idea" of primal chaos was demonstrated to me. It was demonstrated to me rationally.

Ah, you've used your own version of "rational thinking" to demonstrate something irrational to yourself. Got it. I've already pointed out this "rational" is based on the contradiction that atheism is making a truth claim. Is atheism making a truth claim now? I'm still confused.

And you cannot accept that... I wonder why? (No, I don't. I know why. But rhetorical questions are fun.)

Simple. It. Doesn't. Make. Sense. All that makes sense here is that you're being irrational.


And you have to think yourself to be infinite and eternal in order to make sense of this. If something infinite and eternal exists, then something finite was cause by that infinite eternal existence, there's no way around that.


Oh you mean, irrationalism?



Common misunderstanding about God is that he created everything out of nothing. In actually if you really think about an eternal infinite God then you'd realize everything was created from Himself. He has no beginning and no end, so everything with a beginning came from that eternal infinite source, not "nothing". With this understanding you realize there can never be "nothing" or "non-existence", which would makes sense because we finite humans can never know "nothing" or "non-existence".

This he cannot be. Primal chaos is the basis of all. No creation out of nothing. No first cause.

Not if you understand God correctly, as I explained above.


So you don't believe God exists and you also don't believe God does not exist, this means you don't know. Glad we cleared that up. Just wish we didn't have to go through all of this to get to the truth that you don't know if God exists or not.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.