I do think I know where you are coming from. I am as clean today as I was the day Christ washed away all of my sin. I am born again, under grace and not the law. I cannot sin,
Perfect! It appeared you were in contention (as stuartlawrence) with me.
not because I do not sin but because I am no longer under the Law. God no longer imputes sin onto me.
Here I disagree. You say; "I cannot sin"; but then imply "you do sin".
Should we have a wishy washy standing that is opposites?
Isn't that like sitting on the fence, not sure of which side to claim to stand on?
Isn't that in direct opposition to Scripture? Since there is no middle ground in scripture?
We are WITH HIM, or AGAINST HIM ~ no wishy washy "in the middle" claiming opposites apply.
under grace and not the law.
I am under grace. "Under the law", never had ANYTHING whatsoever to do with me.
I am a Gentile. Hebrew/Jewish Law was never something I was under, and thus I had no needs to accept Gods grace, for the purpose; to be out from under the Law.
Gods Grace upon me; is His grafting in, inclusion of, the Gentiles, which does apply to me.
Gods Grace upon me; is His revealing His WAY, of HOW TO overcome separation from Him. Since I have accepted His teaching, followed His WAY, received from Him His reconciliation unto Him...His Grace upon me has been worthy, BECAUSE I believe and accepted what He offered.
I am in Christ, He has washed me white as snow. We definitely have liberty in Christ, yet we are not to use it maliciously...Amen.
Great; then you are claiming to TRUST Gods works in you are sufficient.
John was saying if he or us claimed we do not sin, than Christ is not in us. This does apply to us.
Wait ~ How "DOES" currently now that apply to you?; after you just stated Christ already affected "CHANGES" in you?
It is why he follows it up with If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. Christ is our advocate with the Father,
Wait ~ how does "if one does fail" apply to you, after you just claimed you have been forgiven and washed ?
A just (we are just in Christ) man falls seven times.
Who is such a man that IS IN CHRIST.....And Gods POWER IN THE MAN....that such particular man FALLS?
That IS NOT A MAN who has made an election to submit unto God. Gods POWER in a submitted man DOES NOT FAIL, ever!
A man WHO, (like Judas, a good example); followed along after Christ. Judas was being enlightened to the Truth of God. Judas was believing, doubting, wondering, LIKE ALL STUDENTS DO when they are learning ABOUT God. The STARK difference between Judas and the other disciples is Judas, FELL AWAY in Trusting the Lord. Judas began superseding his minds thoughts were CORRECT, and Jesus' way was NOT CORRECT.
Judas FELL AWAY from believing; KEY WISDOM...
man CAN fall away, from believing, from following, as Judas did...
The deal with Judas is...after he fell away...he NEVER returned following, and trusting Jesus.
Men do what Judas did....all the time.
AND...some men fall away from believing, from following.....BUT then RETURN...and continue following .... UNTIL they are sure to make their election to SUBMIT unto God.
Once the SUBMISSION is effected....IT IS THEN, the Lord works within the man to CHANGE the man...(not before). Once the Lord effects the CHANGE .... there is NO Falling away BY THE MAN! THAT man belongs to God and NOTHING can change that!
John.10
- [28] And I give unto them eternal life; and they shall never perish, neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand.
So no. A man WHO has truthfully submitted unto Christ and been reconciled unto Christ; is NOT a man who falls away!
We live by God's grace, in faith in Christ.
"We" is subjective. It does not apply to all men.
It does not apply to a natural man.
It does not apply to a man simply learning about God.
It does not apply to a man who rejects God.
It does apply to a man WHO HAS submitted in true faithfulness to God.
And such a man is forever with the Lord.
TO teach; forever with the Lord, cleansed and washed in Jesus' blood....but STILL sins against God, is false.
Yet we know, we are in Christ...there is no condemnations in us. Not because of what we do, or what we don't do. But because of Christ and His passion towards us. We, as Christians look to Christ for our righteousness...we do not look to ourselves. Christ alone has defeated sin, Christ alone is sinless. He fulfilled the Law for us.
There is a HUGE difference between "sinless"...and ... Being without sin, and being incapable of sinning.
Christ the Lord is SINLESS - because He NEVER had sin or was sin.
Mankind IS born in sin, and commits sin ~ thus can NEVER be SINLESS.
God provided a WAY for OT men to have their sins forgiven and covered.
God provided a WAY for NT men and now to have their sins forgiven and cleansed from them.
That forgiveness is effected specifically BY a man being CLEANSED.
How many times does a man required cleansing, that it be sufficient? Once according to scripture.
Well ? If you claim to STILL SIN, do you also think you require another, and another, and another cleansing ? Would that also mean, Jesus needs to repeatedly spill His blood over and over and over for your cleansing?
For me; Christs forgiveness ONCE is sufficient.
For me; Christ cleansing me ONCE is sufficient.
I don't claim to be the strength to resist sinning.
What I do claim is the POWER of God IN ME, is the strength that keeps me from sinning.
Thus by and through and because of Him...I sin no more. I can not fall. I can not sin.
What we are arguing against here is finding righteousness in our flesh by obeying the Law, with Christ thrown in. Jason, the one you have been talking to in the Noah thread has said...Christ was our initial salvation. We now have to do our part and not sin to be saved. If any man adds anything to God's grace, Christ and His Passion, ...that man has made Christ's sacrifice nothing.
Bingo! Your position revealed to the whole point of the matter.
We now have to do our part and not sin to be saved.
There again; there are many applications in scripture per individual men.
Some....
will not be saved, are not saved, can be saved, will be saved, might be saved, etc.
You project for yourself "to be saved" and hinge it on you doing your part, by not sinning.
However for me; I did my part, in submitting in true faithfulness unto God.
And God did His part, forgiving me of all my sins, and washed me from all my sins, and imparted His power in me, to keep me from sinning.
So WHAT applies to me is; I am ALREADY SAVED.
And the scriptures that speak of ...will not, are not, can be, will be, might be saved, do not apply to me.
But the following scriptures DO APPLY;
1Cor.1
- [18] For the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are saved it is the power of God.
1Cor.15
- [2] By which also ye are saved, if ye keep in memory what I preached unto you, unless ye have believed in vain.
2Cor.2
- [15] For we are unto God a sweet savour of Christ, in them that are saved, and in them that perish:
Eph.2
- [5] Even when we were dead in sins, hath quickened us together with Christ, (by grace ye are saved
- [8] For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:
God Bless,
SBC