I believe all primordial soup theory is based on the miller urey experiment which I believe created some primitive amino acids. However there are many sources as to the fact that this experiment is overrated and by and large "old news"
here are some of the more obvious problems with the primordial soup theory and the miller urey experiment:
- law of mass action:in a watery environment a water molecule will break up a protein into amino acids, and will break up a DNA into respective nucleotides. not the other way around. So this law of mass action proves evolution cannot happen on a chemical level as evolutionary laws of abiogenesis and laws of primordial soup theories suggest.
- water is a solvent of course it breaks things down. Thats not the interesting part. lets start with endothermic reactions, do you know what they are?They are reactions that bond elements. Like when you drop a red die inwater, you don't expect to see a little drop still in the water, it bonds to it. nucleotides don't bond well other nucleotides to make DNA, but they do bond well with the toxic elements produced in the miller urey experiment. So no primordial soup will suffice because the nucleotides will bond to the toxins and be wiped out. They need an endothermic reaction which does not come cheaply, as it requires much needed energy (that would not be there in a primitive soup).
- not to mention the fact that proteins are made of 100% left handed amino acids. Miller Urey produced 50/50. So no proteins evolved in miller urey.
- nucleotides are made of 100% right handed nucleotides. Miller urey produced none, but if possible it would have produced 50/50. So another limitation of primitive soup theory.
- ammonia and methane: in 70's scientist realized: but ammonia would
only last a few thousand years due to ultra violet radiation. And Methane would produce 10 meters of oil due to ultra violet radiation. so no methane, and no ammonia after a few thousand years. so there would be no necessary chemicals in early biospheres to evolve any life out of primitive soup without the chemicals necessary to reproduce miller urey. Other than this: miller urey no studies have been shown to produce abiogenesis or chemical evolution
evolution fails
I hope this answers your posts.
Sorry if I don't reply soon as I am busy with work right now. Thanks for this thread btw.