Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
It depends on how you look at it. There is the difference between potential and actual. If the potential for using any of the ministries and gifts that come with the Holy Spirit is there, then God is not limited in how He wants to use us at any time. Perhaps the word "any" is a better way of explaining it than "all".So I take it you've changed your mind with regard to your statement that every believer has all the spiritual gifts already given to him, and just needs to have sufficient faith to activate them?
division results in the quenching of the Holy Spirit every time......What does it mean when you say....."Power had left the church"?
The power of the Holy Spirit dwells in the hearts of believers and not in the concrete building. How could ALL the believers in a church have lost the power of the Holy Spirit as He is the "Seal of approval of God to believers"
doctrinally...yes
but what really convinced me was going to charismatic churches and seeing these gifts operate then going back to the scriptures...
acts 19:1-20
paul came into a church full of believers but cesationist(in our terms)
as Apollos had started the church and had not been babtized in the HS.....we can see that from
acts 19:26...had to be taught more correctly
and in acts 19:2....his converts had not been babtized in the HS....
and asked them, "Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you believed?" They answered, "No, we have not even heard that there is a Holy Spirit.
so here was a non charismatic church in the NT that had little power...
after Paul taught them the way correctly they spoke in tongues and prophesised
acts 18:6
then signs wonders, miracles healings, deliverence....
and many believed....
acts 19:18
broWelcome to the thread.
I can appreciate your perspective.
We have mostly been wrestling with this as a doctrinal issue.
Thanks for sharing your personal testimony. Can you add anything from a doctrinal perspective?
The Cessationist position that has come up time and time again is that:
The charismatic gifts came only through the two outpourings and through the apostle's hands.
However, they keep expanding the definition of "apostles" to include more and more events. For example, they have given Ananias apostleship due to him being called by Christ to pray for the apostle Paul.
It depends on how you look at it. There is the difference between potential and actual. If the potential for using any of the ministries and gifts that come with the Holy Spirit is there, then God is not limited in how He wants to use us at any time. Perhaps the word "any" is a better way of explaining it than "all".
All gifts and ministries are resident in the Holy Spirit with in us. It doesn't mean that all are instantly available to us on demand. But if God leads us into a particular ministry, and the particular gifts for that ministry will be available to us. Therefore it is quite true and not all are apostles, prophets, teachers, or evangelists, or have the ability to speak in interpreted tongues and not all are able to interpret those tongues. If the whole toolbox is not there, then we have an incomplete Holy Spirit in us.
Now, we may be used in a particular ministry at a time in our life, and then God can say, "Stop doing that because I want you to do something different." So a travelling evangelist, Like Aimee Macpherson, can get to a stage of life where the demands of being on the road are too great and her children need stable schooling, so God may say, "Your time of itinerant evangelism is over, and now I want you to plant and church and be the pastor of it (as He did with Aimee Macpherson).
I have felt called to be a preacher, but when I joined my present church, He said, "Join the choir and teach Sunday School." That was it for some years. Then, I was invited to be a member of our Board of Managers (a deacon), then a couple of years later I became an elder. For the first fifteen years of being in that church I had really no opportunities to preach at all. Then, because I have accounting training, God told me to become the church treasurer. That meant number crunching and paper work. It has been only in the last five years that because we no longer have a minister, and a preaching team was formed, that I was invited on it, and preach just once a month. Then the "Session Clerk" (senior elder) stood down and I took his place. So I have adopted a pastoral role in the church. So, now I am the senior elder, part of the preaching team, and treasurer. I have to attend two meetings a month, and because we now have a "mission enabler" which we employ, I have to do the payroll and the tax payments, which is extra work. And all I wanted to do is be a preacher! So, I have entered into a pastoral/helps ministry. So I cannot be an apostle, prophet, teacher, tongues speaker and interpreter because I have not been equipped to perform those ministries in my present church.
But what if God said, "Now stop doing all that and became the church janitor and clean the toilets"? I'd have to do that, because God said so. But if I tried to continue doing all the other things, they would all fall on their sides, because God would no longer be equipping me for those roles and I would burn out, lose my health through stress and the burden of doing things in the flesh and not the Spirit; but I would be cleaning the toilets in the Spirit because the ministry of helps is just as much a spiritual service as all the rest.
Now that takes faith to do that, because faith is basically trusting God that this is what He wants me to do and He will be happy with me doing it, and will equip me, mentally, spiritual, humility-wide, and tool-wise to do the job well.
OK - it's not kosher and against the rules to say another poster is not a Christian - so now -- as Don Pardo on the old Jeapardy show would say :
Let us pause to collect our thoughts.
I am going to post some disparaging statements about charismatics which were said by Cessationists in the first TWENTY PAGES of this thread, and include some of my own comments about them which were never in the thread.
*********
Cessationist - 'Many cultures speak in tongues and receive a "high" from it.'
http://www.dana.org/News/Speaking_in_Tongues__Glossalalia_and_Stress_Reduction/
From that article above:
" But Lynn and others theorize that a proclivity for glossolalia may involve variability in dopaminergic genes believed to also mediate susceptibility to hypnosis. "
Cessationist - "I think the experiment will show that your best friend is just jibbering"
Cessationist - "But I do agree Dave that people do the tongues for the "high", which it is, if you ask them it is physically pleasing and overwhelming. It is more relatable to sex then to Holy works, because that is all it is. People seek this "pleasure", and by doing so they are inviting evil spirits to enter them."
Anto9us said:
"Tongues have indeed NOT CEASED. People do indeed speak in Tongues today."
Dave L. responded:
"They only think they do."
Cessationist - "What people do today is not speaking in tongues as scripture describes it, but rather they have discovered the natural phenomenon of the flesh known to linguists as free vocalization or glossolalia, where the human speech organs go into 'autopilot' and produce strings of random syllables."
---------
Me -- When I described my experience in college in early 70's and the many people who got the Baptism in the Holy Ghost all around me, it was responded:
Cessationist - You and your fellow students 'got' something, but I'm afraid it wasn't the Baptism of the Spirit nor was it the gift of tongues - according to the biblical descriptions of those things.
----------
-----
Cessationist - "Tongues were a warning sign of doom to the wicked Jews. After 70 AD they no longer had a purpose."
Me - Wha?? warning sign of doom? Here is what the visiting Jews said:
Act 2:8
And how hear we every man in our own tongue, wherein we were born?
Box Act 2:9
Parthians, and Medes, and Elamites, and the dwellers in Mesopotamia, and in Judaea, and Cappadocia, in Pontus, and Asia,
Act 2:10
Phrygia, and Pamphylia, in Egypt, and in the parts of Libya about Cyrene, and strangers of Rome, Jews and proselytes,
Act 2:11
Cretes and Arabians, we do hear them speak in our tongues the wonderful works of God.
wonderful works of God doesn't sound like a warning sign of doom
-----
Cessationist - "How about this? The whole of Revelation is the record of a VISION. It is not meant literally. The Angels were seen by John to be doing X and Y; but to say, then, that they spoke languages as we understand them, especially since Angels do not have voice boxes, is silly (or at least presumptuous)."
Cessationist - "The gifts ceased with the Apostles. You do not have the real thing. Example: Those who spoke in tongues in Acts did so spontaneously. You had to be coached and told what to do. Those who spoke knew what they said. You do not. You just make noise."
Cessationist - "We have many claiming the same bogus gifts today."
****
Me -- IN OUR EVER-SHIFTING GOALPOSTS of WHEN tongues 'ceased' -- we have yet other different views than heavenly-language-Dave and human-language-Swordsman...
Cessationist - "I agree that they gradually disappeared. I have not sided with the claim that they ceased upon the passing of the last Apostle or that it happened for that reason."
Cessationist - "It was at about that time that the church finalized and consolidated its beliefs, became the established church of the Roman Empire, and disposed of the greatest heresy or rival Christian movement of the ancient period, Arianism."
Me - A hard blow to Arianism was indeed struck in 381 with final version of Nicene Creed, but those who know church history know that in some parts of Europe, Arian Christianity went on for centuries more! The ever-shifting goalposts, or 'ever-widening circle' as Steve calls it, is a shifty target indeed:
death of last apostle
completion of New Testament/penning of Revelation
disposition of Arianism
this really NAILS IT DOWN to somewhere between 66 AD (if the minority view of Revelation's date is true) and 7th century AD, when last Arians died out and last resistance to Revelation's canonization were about over
****
This excerpt from the first 20 pages of this thread is for the viewing pleasure of those recently coming into the thread, and also serves as a summary of Cessationist mishmash for those who have been in the thread from the beginning. A similar compendium will be forthcoming for statements from pg 21 on.
No I'm not, because the Scripture is quite about that. This is why some pastors end up with burnout, because they are trying to do all the five fold ministries at once, instead of having a ministry team in their churches. William Seymour, the man in charge of the Azusa Street revival church (let's put aside any disagreements about that church for the moment mOk. So long as you're not saying that all beleivers have the same gift, let alone every gift.
I don't think he was hypnotized at all. He was emphasing that the "unknown God" they knew existed, and that their own poets acknowledged His existence, thereby giving reinforcement that their "unknown God" was the God of the Bible who raised Jesus from the dead.The demonic Greeks must have hypnotized the Apostle Paul when he was in Athens, he quoted "certain of your own poets" in the passage about "in Him we live and move and have our being".
I don't know if it was Aratus, Menander or Epimenides he was quoting, but good ole Paul was determined to be "all things to all men" -- and the Mars Hill effort was NOT a flop - some of his hearers became believers, and these were tough nuts to crack.
The unsuccessful Scottish hunter went out into the fog and mist. Now THAT is a joke!Oscarr, I was just JOKING that Paul was hypnotized - it was a joke about him speaking in tongues more than ye all and his proclivity for glossolalia involving variability in dopaminergic genes causing susceptibility to hypnosis...
I know it was very clever of Paul to pick up the "unknown god" theme and quote their own poets, theologians at one time talked about what a MISTAKE Paul's Mars Hill episode was - I call it a success, like he had gone to an atheists' convention and made several converts.
Don't mind my bizarre sarcasm.
so then we agreeOn Vulcan, Leonard Nimoy STILL LIVES!!
What proof do you have that Ananias of Damascus ever saw the Lord personally?But Jesus personally appointed Ananias to minister the Holy Spirit to Paul. And one of the requirements for Apostleship was seeing the Lord personally. Paul calls Barnabas an Apostle. The elders laid hands on Timothy who already had the gifts imparted to him by Paul. And Paul was an Apostle who distributed the gifts through his hands.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?