Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Originally Posted by brinny
And this was so before the fall? How would one test it or what would one compare it to? Our only basis for testing is what is present now.
To test it, one has first to test there was a Fall.
Originally Posted by brinny
And this was so before the fall? How would one test it or what would one compare it to? Our only basis for testing is what is present now.
I don't believe in a fall. But you do. So if you believe Adam and Eve were humans, they would have needed Vitamin B12. Not to mention the fact that every ecosystem known on this planet requires bacteria (they decompose, after all).
If your theology insists that bacteria were not there before the fall, you have to believe some increasingly absurd things. Maybe God personally supplied the B12? Well, then he must have envisioned that the fall was going to happen and bacteria were magically going to appear. Or before the fall could humans synthesize B12? Well, why not now? Did God personally shut down that gene so we'd be reliant on bacterial byproducts? Plants also need B12, so did he do something similar for them? Or maybe they didn't need B12? So why do we need it now? People with B12 deficiencies in diseases such as Pernicious Anemia have a terrible time with it, but if humans used to not need B12 before the fall, why do we need it now? God apparently likes to micro-manage his punishments on the molecular level.
If you also believe there was no such thing as death before the fall, wow, well, that has even more problems.
My point is this -- the people who wrote Genesis and the rest of the Bible were not as informed about the nature of biology and reality for the most part. They didn't know what bacteria are. They didn't know what cells are. Maybe the moral of the Garden story is more important than insisting that it actually happened like that.
If there WAS a time before the fall, there was no decay. In that present state there was no need for anything to balance anything else. It was perfect, and all worked perfectly. No decay, no disease, no death. The question then becomes, why would any bacteria be necessary?
I'm sorry, but this is a very ignorant idea. Death and decay are 100% necessary and required for living things.
We are organisms that cannot produce our own energy from sunlight, thus we require plants to convert the sun's energy into compounds that we can break down to get our own energy. We piggy-back on plants and need them. Plants also piggy-back on bacteria, as we do as well.
Cellular death is essential to our survival. Here are some basic examples:
We do need bacteria for more than just Vitamin B12. Here are more reasons:
- The way we excrete iron is by exfoliating the cells in our gut lining. These cells die with excess iron so the body does not become iron overloaded (which leads to liver and heart failure).
- In embryonic development, the process of cellular apoptosis (programmed cell death) is utilized in forming many organs, and that is why we aren't born with webbed fingers.
- Apoptosis checks unnecessary cell growth. If you don't have apoptosis, you will develop cancer because DNA mutations occur at random, and apoptosis helps combat this.
The moral of the story is this: when we actually look at the biochemistry, genetics, and physiology of human life it becomes abundantly clear that we are fine-tuned for the environment that we live in. This is, of course, because we evolved in this environment. We depend heavily on bacteria, plants, and other animals in this world because we are part of this world and nothing else.
- Vitamin K is not produced by humans, and our gut flora (bacteria) makes it for us. Our coagulation system absolutely requires Vitamin K for the synthesis of factors 2, 7, 9, 10, C, and S. Hard to see how you would be able to live if you were bleeding into every joint and muscle in our body because you couldn't form blood clots.
- Bacteria in the gut break down a lot of complex polysaccharides that our enzymes cannot, freeing metabolites for us to absorb that we otherwise couldn't.
- Bacteria detoxify micronutrient carcinogens that are ingested in the everyday diet.
- Small molecules secreted by bacteria help in the absorption of cations necessary for life.
- The interplay between bacteria and the immune system is extremely complex and could fill the dissertations of hundreds of PhD students.
Frankly, I find your argument about the Fall to be rather infantile and ignorant. You clearly don't know anything about human biology, and seek to make your theology trump it.
Sounds like a judgement from God.I'm sorry, but this is a very ignorant idea. Death and decay are 100% necessary and required for living things.
Sounds like a judgement from God.
Genesis 2:17 But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die.
You say "necessary", but God says "surely".
You are right. It's not complicated at all. If there was such a thing as "before the fall", none of what you can test, observe in this present state of decay, disease, and death, applies to a state of perfection.
Originally Posted by brinny
You are right. It's not complicated at all. If there was such a thing as "before the fall", none of what you can test, observe in this present state of decay, disease, and death, applies to a state of perfection.
I'm saying that the whole notion of a "state of perfection" before "the Fall" runs counter to everything we know about our own existence and is a rather ignorant idea that was made up by people who don't know how reality actually works.
No Christian that I know who actually has had a decent education would ever put forth the idea that there was no death or decay before "the Fall". Most of them consider the idea of the Fall allegorical anyway.
?
Deshe = "the FIRST sprouts of life" on the planet earth?"
But not before the Fall.The idea that we must consume to survive has been around way before your scriptures were penned.
You'd be impressed alright. You'd be whining that it was inserted after-the-fact, retconned, or an anachronism, or too vague to be useful, or whatever you guys do concerning the prophecies about the Jews returning to the Promised Land.Now if your scriptures said "microscopic creatures smaller than you can see live in your colon usually harmoniously, helping you digest food and making nutrients for you, but they can sometimes cause disease" I'd be far more impressed.
Is that why Israel burned their utensils in fire and scrapped their walls when leprosy was involved?Took the human race a loooong time to formulate the germ theory of disease, and we'd have been better off with it the earlier we'd had it.
Yup --A "Christian's" education in the gifts of wisdom and discernment are from God, imparted by the Holy Spirit. Education by man is limited.
A "Christian's" education in the gifts of wisdom and discernment are from God, imparted by the Holy Spirit. Education by man is limited. It does not answer all questions, for it is limited, finite, based on this present dimension, this present state. "Christians" are flawed, prone to be as human as anyone else. God is not flawed. It is HE a Christian should be looking to, not man. God has the bigger, infinately larger picture. Man does not. Man lives and dies. *Poof* he is gone. God does not die. He is not gone. It's simple, really. Man is flawed, and his studies, and tests, research, observations are limited, and over time crumble, get corrected because they were flawed, and disappear with man, who is here one day and gone the next.
You'd be impressed alright. You'd be whining that it was inserted after-the-fact, retconned, or an anachronism, or too vague to be useful, or whatever you guys do concerning the prophecies about the Jews returning to the Promised Land.
Is that why Israel burned their utensils in fire and scrapped their walls when leprosy was involved?
Go AV! You tell him his opinion.You'd be impressed alright. You'd be whining that it was inserted after-the-fact, retconned, or an anachronism, or too vague to be useful, or whatever you guys do concerning the prophecies about the Jews returning to the Promised Land.
Well, is it?Is that why Israel burned their utensils in fire and scrapped their walls when leprosy was involved?
They are making progress, they are not killing people off nearly as fast as they use to. If WW3 comes around they may make up for it though.At least the scientific method improves quality of life and life expectancy
And evolution did not invent eternal life, did it?
Leprosy was a judgment against man for his sin. God did cause death to enter his creation because of mans disobedience, which no man will be allowed to live for eternity in his sin. Will God remove the curse of death? No law or ritual will save a man or cleanse him. This marvelous creation is Gods so is the atonement; can you live forever? Yes on his terms not mans; accept his atonement for sin Jesus Christ. Go ahead and say that God should have given us medicine instead of forgiveness but we shall surly still die because we cannot live for eternity in our sin Gods discussion not ours.
They are making progress, they are not killing people off nearly as fast as they use to. If WW3 comes around they may make up for it though.
Science and technology are the only reasons you've lived to 59.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?