Originally Posted by DonaldOrwinRenKern
The topic isn't sex being a dirty word...
Well your the one who first mentioned dealing with the real problem. I'm saying this is part of the real problem therefore it needs to be addressed. Have you changed your mind perhaps and don't want to deal with the entire issue?
I have not run into the issue of sex being a dirty word although I'm sure that is a problem and I do agree that it can be an issue. What I am trying to get to is the fact that there are several cases where I have noticed a man trying to excuse his behavior by hiding behind the label of addiction.
I may not be seeing the whole picture on the dirty sex subject, how does that make porn addiction a valid statement. Actually Dag please elaborate on you opinion, I think I'm missing something?
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonaldOrwinRenKern
The problem is calling something an addiction when it is not. and comparing romance novels to porn, you've gotta be kidding me.
I'm just mentioning the study I once saw. It pointed out that brainwave paterns that are there during sex are also there when reading romance novels. It could be argued that romance novels are a female version of porn. The point being is that there is sufficient doubt in regards to your claim that it is a male only problem. I can also tell you from having worked in a paper shop that there was no shortage of female porn magazines being purchased. So there are females out there interested in this stuff as well. So once again sufficient doubt is cast on your claim it is a male only problem.
I do apologize for making such a black and white comment. I know there are some women who watch porn.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonaldOrwinRenKern
Now listen... I'm sure there are guys out there that have a problem with porn... what I am talking about is the guy that sneaks off to watch porn, the guy that walks into a room and cant keep his eye off of every girl, the guy that needs to pick up the swimsuit issue, the guy that objectifies women, gets off on watching a video on youtube of two women slapping eachother in the face for 45 seconds... and he was laughing his ass off.
So are you suggesting we wait untill it is a huge problem and has a huge hold on the guys life before intervening? Surely we would want to stop it earlier in the process. I mean let's be honest guys don't go from looking at zero porn one day to what you describe here the next. It is a gradual thing just like it tends to be with alcoholics. They only drink on social occasions, then they drink heavily on social occasions, then they drink at other times and so forth. It isn't something that happens overnight.
Ok, I think this is an area where we have a difference of opinion or maybe a misunderstanding... Everyone that I have known that is into porn started it at a very early age. If you mean interviening then, I totally agree... but I think it is more of an issue of teaching respect... This has a lot to do with having respect for women.
You should be able to look at a woman without seeing a piece of meat.
The example I am using is someone who grew up in an environment where the mother is not really treated with utmost respect. This person also verbally abuses, mentally abuses, and has physically abused her.
During which time he demands sex from her. Tells her that it is all her fault, that it is Gods will for her to help him through this addiction...
I'm sorry, but I have a really big problem with that kind of behavior. He is claiming to be an addict... I just see a jerk hiding behind a label to manipulate.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonaldOrwinRenKern
I understand where you are coming from Dag, and I am very familiar with addiction. The problem is, this is a male addiction made up by the church to give men an excuse for thier actions...
Before you wanted me to leave the church out of this now you bring it up. C'mon Dave you can't have it both ways. I would be interested in your proof that it was the church who made it up. I personally in my 30 plus years of church attendance and involvement in a number of mission organisations have not seen any evidence that it was the church. I'm not saying they didn't but I've seen no evidence. If you are indeed right then I would say the fault for that is with the people who listen to them unquestiongly. It would be the same as all those people who just accepted the outspoken people who said AIDS was God's judgement on gay people. The people who are to blame are the ones who followed that line when there was nothing to back it up.
Ok... maybe I spoke alittle soon on this one. It is only at church and in strong Christian circles that I have heard the term porn addiction.
You have a point... We tend to follow things if they sound good, I think that's why I have a problem with the whole porn addiction thing...
Although... Do you think it is possible that someone who doesn't have an addiction or doesn't care to hide behind the label?
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonaldOrwinRenKern
Hold them accountable when they are damaging someone elses selfesteem or turning their world upside down... in the church it should be seen as Adultry cut and dry plain and simple. Just like all the rules we apply for women... I think men should be held accountable in not even more responsible for thier actions..
If you are going to objectify women while you are married to one by watching Leather Angels of Sex and jerking off to every image on the screen....
Then you betray your wifes trust... you should be held accountable...
It is not an addiction. That is absurd!
I agree we should hold them accountable. Regardless of if it is an addiction which is a sin or just a plain sin the person should be held accountable. That should go without saying. What should also go without saying is that in both cases we should not just walk away from the person and leave them to deal with it themselves like you seem to be advocating (or have I misunderstood you when you say the woman should be able to just walk away?). If it is just a sin we have a biblical obligation to help our fellow believer. If it is an addiction then we also should help the person. In both cases helping does not mean taking responsibility for the actions away from the one who did them.
Your talk of keeping guys accountablre like we do women prompts me to say we should also keep women accountable like we keep men accountable. You seem to be thinking of the typical sterotype of women. If you really want I could go on and give a lengthy list of things that women are not held to the same standard as men even though they should. Or in other words it works both ways. I'm not saying that guys are always held accountable when they should be. I know that is not the case but to paint a picture that men can do what they want and excuse it while women can't is not a balanced view.
I agree, I guess you should know where I am coming from... There are a lot of case where the shift in power is a little more male dominated... Not because that is how it should be, but because that seems to be the common view..
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonaldOrwinRenKern
Why is it ever time something bad happens everyone is quick to blame Satan for it...
I never said it was satan. I was simply asking the person to consider if it might not be God bringing these people into her life.. I find it interesting that people so quickly blame God for bad things. They don't acknowledge the rest of it. Satan is real. Sin is real. We live in a fallen world which means bad things can happen to good people. This world is not the way God intended it to be. God intended a world without sin. With sin there were consequences.
ok.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonaldOrwinRenKern
My question is this, if Satan brought him into her life and she married him... She can dump his but to the curb right?
Why are you so quick to reccomend divorce? Surely we should try and fix things. I know of marriages that have survived an affair. It took time. It took hard work. The point being the love was still there. Why write it off so quick?
I also read it a bit different to how you understand it.
You have a point... if it is based on love. I understand mistakes could happen, but I also understand that when you truly love someone you will do everything in your power to not hurt them... Especially if you are hurting them again and again and again...
What if there is no love left and just pain... Should she stay. I have seen women who are living a miserable exsistence because the are afraid to leave their husband because of the way their church family will look at them.