Yesterday at 04:45 PM Lotar said this in Post #86
I am saved because of what Christ has done for me. But I must make the choice to recieve this gift.
So are you saved because Christ died for you or are you saved because you "make the choice to receive this gift?" I'm not asking you if your choice saves you. I'm asking if you feel that His sacrifice saved you or do you believe that His sacrifice wasn't implemented in your case until you added to His perfect (which means complete, by the way) sacrifice by "making the choice to receive the gift."
The problem with predestination is that it contradicts the concept of free will.
I'd say, first off, you have an errant view of predestination. Second, you're right. It does contradict the
biblically unsupported concept of free will.
If you have free will, which the bible clearly preaches, God cannot force salvation on you, or prevent you from choosing it.
[bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse]!! You're right! It's so clear now.
What the Bible clearly teaches is that man, after the Fall, is depraved, evil, an enemy of God, at war with God, dead in their trespasses, unable to reconcile with God, unrighteous, does not desire the things of God, is not thankful to God nor does he glorify God, does not seek after God, and destined to hell. I don't know what Bible you use but if that's what you got from the Bible you might really want to do a bit more research.
Why? Because then it would no longer be free will, and God does not contradict Himself.
I'm really curious to read Scripture that says unregenerate man loves God and seeks Him freely. I could show you a ton of Scripture that
clearly shows that man does not seek God. Yet you think that not only does man seek God, fallen man loves God.
Can you resist God's will, yes, and the bible teaches this.
God's Will is not summed up as "God's Will," at least not in the Bible. God's Will is not as simple as "all men being saved." God has a permissive Will. God has a decreed Will.
Let me ask you something, do you believe you can stop God's
decreed Will from coming to pass?
Am I saying that God is not all powerful? No, but I am saying that He does not force His will on us. God wants us to gennuinly love and praise Him. In order to do this, we must have a choice in the matter.
Do you think anything happened to man's nature when he fell from grace? I am lost as to how someone can say that Jesus "saved them" but then say that they "freely chose to love and praise God." Look man,
REGENERATE MAN struggles with his old
FALLEN nature but has the desire and ability to do for God's good pleasure. Unregenerate man is unrighteous. Loving God is a righteous action. An unrighteous creation cannot make a righteous dicision. Yet, according to you, it's clearly preached in the Bible that fallen, unrighteous man does make the righteous choice to freely serve God. Yeah. Don't see. Maybe you could point it out.
Lets say your married (I assume you are because of the baby picture). Does it make you happy when she compliments you and tells you she loves you? I assume so. Now, would it feel the same if you knew she had no choice in the matter, she had to say those things? Even if she thought it was her choice? I doubt it. Why? Because the option to choose otherwise is what makes it so valuable. Otherwise God might as well have made robots.
Lotar, do yourself a favor and read a few books on predestination. I recommend anything by R.C. Sproul. There are many great reformed authors but Dr. Sproul is very easy to follow. Being made into robots is the common view of predestination for people who don't understand anything about predestination. Also, and this is really relavent, I'm not God. My wife is not evil. We are not enemies. I am not sovereign. So comparing the interaction of my wife and I to the interaction of God and fallen man shows not only your ignorance of the nature of fallen man but your desire to elevate fallen man and perpetuate the unbiblical idea that man retains some measure of righteousness after the Fall.
God says that He wants everyone to be saved. Well if this is what He wants, and he chooses how is saved and who is not, why isn't everyone saved?
This is actually a great question and one that I would be happy to answer. I don't think you have a genuine desire to know but I'll enlighten you anway. The verses that deal with it being "God's Will" that everyone be saved and that none should perish are speaking of the permissive Will of God and His nature. God is benevolent and does not delight in the necessary eternal death of the unregenerate but, believe me, it is His decreed Will that it come to pass.
Why does the bible tell us to spread the word, if God has already chosen who will and will not be saved? I mean, they'll be saved no matter what anyways, so why bother?
Evangelism is one of the methods that God uses to enlighten and gather His flock. This flock isn't random in size. God knows who are His. A person's ability to convincingly deliver the Truth of the Gospel never has been, nor will it ever be, the reason someone comes to faith. That is a gift of God's grace which He bestows upon whomever is so pleases Him to do so. You could be the best preacher in the world but if you are talking to someone who has not been given ears to hear you are wasting your time. God uses His children to spread His Word. It's not an issue of someone being saved "no matter what." What did you think, that
we "win souls for the Lord?" God gathers His flock. You don't gather it for Him. He just uses us to bring about His Will. I have yet to understand people incessant need to be autonomous. I think it stems from our fallen nature that desires to credit ourselves with "seeing the Truth and making the right decision" rather than "being enlightened to the Truth by the Divine intervention of God and being brought to the Truth because it pleased God to do so."
If this is taught in the Bible, please quote it.
If what is taught in the Bible, predestination? Lotar, either you don't read the Bible or you don't know what Calvary Chapel teaches.
ALL CHRISTIAN CHURCHES teach a doctrine of predestination, yes, even Calvary Chapel churches. The difference is what that their view on it is, not whether it is a valid biblical theme.
Someone said something about being saved before they said any prayer. This is correct, you are saved when you make the decision, not when you say the words. So if you say the words and don't make the decision, you are not saved. God looks at our heart and our motives.
I ask again (though I've yet to get a straight answer to this), are
you saved because
you made the right decision. I
didn't ask if salvation was available because of your decision. You have said that because of Jesus' sacrifice salvation was available to you, right? What I'm asking is, what is it that makes that sacrifice be manifested
in you?
Thanks,
God bless