Piccard or Kirk?

[MidnightCandel777]

HAHAHAHAHAH!!!


Piccard could kick Kirk's butt anyday of the week!!!!!!

 

[LovesToRead]

Hmm, how to pick???

I love them both in their own way...I'm just too sentimental.

I know, I know, this IS NOT what you're looking for!

 

[JTM3]

Jean-Luc Picard for the record..........

They each have their own styles; Kirk is shoot and ask questions later; Picard, although a great captain too, maybe relies on diplomacy a little too much........

 

[maniaco]

Picard aaaaaall the way but its mainly just cuz i love patrick stewart

 

[maxmerc]

John Sheridan, from Babylon 5. He kicked the Shadows' behinds all the way outta the GALAXY.

AIN'T nobody better.

 

[Jebediah]

Khaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan!

 

[moicherie]

Neither Sisko! -

 

[Lycana]

Kirk- he's classic

 

[LovesToRead]

John Sheridan, from Babylon 5. He kicked the Shadows' behinds all the way outta the GALAXY.

AIN'T nobody better.

THIS IS SO FUNNY!

But, that's a different show! :o

*Mutters to self, now I must know who the Shadow are? Surely this can't mean my all black kitty? No, it can't mean her...although...No, I'm sure now, its not about her. *

 

[LovesToRead]

Khaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan!

WOW!

What a movie that was! I loved it!

 

[Dust and Ashes]

I have to admit I would have voted Sheridan if there had been an option. But I voted for Picard, though I like them both.

 

[Nachtjager]

Please! Kirk was a walkin, talkin, overacting all-around interplanetary Billy Jack. While Piccard would try to reason with aliens and understand them, maybe get them into group therapy or something like that, maybe get them on the Federation's medical perscription assistance plan to deal with their issues. Kirk would blast 'em full of holes and then win the hearts of every woman on the planet as well as those of every girl on the ship - it's no contest. If you want Dr. Phil as a starship commander, it's Piccard. Kirk was kinda' corny at times, but at least they knew what weapons were for. And this whole "borg" thing? ARRRGGHHH! How boring is that? Again, blast 'em and be done with it. Later and God bless!

 

[LovesToRead]

Please! Kirk was a walkin, talkin, overacting all-around interplanetary Billy Jack. While Piccard would try to reason with aliens and understand them, maybe get them into group therapy or something like that, maybe get them on the Federation's medical perscription assistance plan to deal with their issues. Kirk would blast 'em full of holes and then win the hearts of every woman on the planet as well as those of every girl on the ship - it's no contest. If you want Dr. Phil as a starship commander, it's Piccard. Kirk was kinda' corny at times, but at least they knew what weapons were for. And this whole "borg" thing? ARRRGGHHH! How boring is that? Again, blast 'em and be done with it. Later and God bless!

Gee, umm, could you share your thoughts with us!


This thread brings out the most interesting points about these shows and movies.


Oh, you forgot - Kirk always ended up with either a ripped shirt or no shirt at all.

Gotta love him!

 

[eaglex]

I happened to like both of them. They are both special in their own ways. Why chose between them.

 

[searchingforGodlyanswers]

He's kewl and level-headed.
I also liked NG better than the original.

 

[Goatboy]

Damn that’s a hard one.

Kirk.

Got to be Kirk, for Space Seed, Arena, Enemy Within, and especially, Search For Spock.

Kirk takes it.
(“I. Have. Had. Enough. Of. You!”)

[mode=pedant] That would be Jean-Luc Picard (not Luke) and James Tiberius Kirk[/mode]

 

[WalksWithChrist]

Damn that’s a hard one.

Kirk.

Got to be Kirk, for Space Seed, Arena, Enemy Within, and especially, Search For Spock.

Kirk takes it.
(“I. Have. Had. Enough. Of. You!”)

[mode=pedant] That would be Jean-Luc Picard (not Luke) and James Tiberius Kirk[/mode]

Nice quote! Kirk got a good use out of his boot heel in that scene.

I voted Picard. Kirk being a hyper-cheezy individual off-camera has just a *little* to do with it...I still love him tho!!

 

[searchingforGodlyanswers]

My hubby has been watching on the Spike channel mostly ST:NG in the afternoons
and whenever he can I think deep space and voyager (with Sisko and Kira)
Now if only I could get him into soaps and Lost!

 

[WalksWithChrist]

My hubby has been watching on the Spike channel mostly ST:NG in the afternoons
and whenever he can I think deep space and voyager (with Sisko and Kira)
Now if only I could get him into soaps and Lost!

 

[MichaelFJF]

James T. Kirk. No question. Ya gotta go with the original. The only reason Picard COULD be more diplomatic is due to the groundwork laid by Kirk and Spock.

Sisco??? Was there a Sisco??? Ohhhhh - you mean the guy in charge of that total waste of a series. Bleh.

No Janeway option? Women libbers aren't gonna like you very much.