- Jul 22, 2014
- 41,685
- 7,904
- Country
- United States
- Gender
- Male
- Faith
- Non-Denom
- Marital Status
- Married
I will not address everything you've written as I need to meditate on them. I will address some off the bat however. The first one is above:
There are several verses that seem to imply doing them will send you to hell. But I notice that at the end of these verses is almost always tacked on something like "but the righteous into life eternal" - OSAS believers believe that these verses mean "by the way, you think you're righteous, you're not because all these stuff that most people do are sinful too. But accepting Jesus as Lord and Savior will make you righteous in spite of those things"
Another thing I've noticed is that there seems to be a difference in the verses that say what you must do to be saved, and the verses that indicate that you go to hell for certain sins. The verses that say how you must be saved clearly indicate that salvation comes by faith alone. The verses that indicate you to go to hell seem to say that certain works send you to hell.
The two seem to be contradictory in message. OSAS believers address this contradiction by interpreting that the verses that indicate you go to hell are talking about non-Christians and are to emphasize that everyone is condemned because everyone is a sinner which is why you cannot depend on your own righteousness (because the standard for holiness is impossible for man). CS believers address the contradiction by interpreting the verses about hell talk about post-acceptance Christian living (aka 'sanctification').
No. I am sorry, my friend. But you are not reading the full context in Matthew 25, and you are making stuff up that you want to see. Christ divides the sheep from the goats. Jesus puts the sheep on His RIGHT HAND and the goats He puts on His LEFT.
"And he shall set the sheep on his right hand, but the goats on the left." (Matthew 25:33).
What does Jesus (i.e. the King) say to those on His RIGHT HAND?
"Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world:" (Matthew 25:34).
These are believers because Jesus says they are:
(a) Sheep (of which Jesus refers to believers as Sheep in other verses).
(b) Ye are blessed by my Father.
(c) Inherit the Kingdom prepared for you since the foundation of the world.
How does Jesus describe these believers or sheep who inherit the Kingdom and who are blessed by the Father?
35 "For I was an hungred, and ye gave me meat: I was thirsty, and ye gave me drink: I was a stranger, and ye took me in:
36 Naked, and ye clothed me: I was sick, and ye visited me: I was in prison, and ye came unto me." (Matthew 25:36).
What is interesting is that the first group who helped the poor is said to be "righteous" (Matthew 25:37) and the second group who did not help the poor is simply called "they" (Matthew 25:44).
The matter is concluded in verse 46 when Jesus says,
"And these [i.e. "they" or the second group who did not help the poor] shall go away into everlasting punishment: but the righteous [i.e. the first group who helped the poor] into life eternal." (Matthew 25:46).
It's why Jesus divided them in the first place. He separated them so as to cast one group into everlasting punishment and another group so as to go into life eternal.
Note: Brackets in blue are my commentaries to the text.
Superscritter said:I don't see that this is clearly defined. You are making a very strong conclusion about something that I see as an assumption. The "God Directed Works" in the NT don't read much differently from the "Man Directed Works" (and I don't know how you can conclusively make this distinction since both come from the Bible), except that "God directed works" are much much harder to follow because Jesus said that the mere thought of sin condemns you. The "God directed works" as you have labelled them are much much harder to follow than the OT because thought-crime condemns us all.
First, thought crime also existed in the OT, as well.
To desire another man's wife (adultery) is coveting according to the 10 Commandments.
"You shall not covet your neighbor's house; you shall not covet your neighbor's wife, or his male servant, or his female servant, or his ox, or his donkey, or anything that is your neighbor's.” (Exodus 20:17).
Second, I already provided to you a good list of verses for you to check out before that shows how it is God who ultimately does the good work within a believer's life. Click on the spoiler button to check them out again.
For who ultimately does the "good work" in a believer's life?
Is it God?
Or is it the believer?
Well, Scripture tells us that God (Christ) is the One who ultimately does the work within a believer.
Philippians 1:6
Philippians 1:11
Philippians 2:13
Philippians 4:13
1 Corinthians 15:10
Hebrews 12:1-2
Hebrews 13:21
Isaiah 26:12
1 John 4:12
Galatians 5:22-24 (cf. Matthew 7:16-18, Matthew 19:17)
John 15:5
Ezekiel 36:26-27
For that is why the 24 elders cast their crowns down before Jesus (Revelation 4:10). For the crowns they received for their good work was all the result of Christ working in them.
Yeah, but doesn't a believer do the work, too? Now, yes, it is true; A believer is created unto Christ Jesus for good works (Ephesians 2:10); And a believer is indeed held accountable by their "good works" here upon this Earth at a Judgment. But we must also realize that true believers are not ultimately doing these "good works" alone or of their own power, though. For in 1 Corinthians 15:10 Paul said that he labored more than all of his brethren, yet he said it was not him that labored but it was the grace of God that was within him. So true believer's are just choosing to allow God's "good work" to flow within them or not.
Is it God?
Or is it the believer?
Well, Scripture tells us that God (Christ) is the One who ultimately does the work within a believer.
Philippians 1:6
Philippians 1:11
Philippians 2:13
Philippians 4:13
1 Corinthians 15:10
Hebrews 12:1-2
Hebrews 13:21
Isaiah 26:12
1 John 4:12
Galatians 5:22-24 (cf. Matthew 7:16-18, Matthew 19:17)
John 15:5
Ezekiel 36:26-27
For that is why the 24 elders cast their crowns down before Jesus (Revelation 4:10). For the crowns they received for their good work was all the result of Christ working in them.
Yeah, but doesn't a believer do the work, too? Now, yes, it is true; A believer is created unto Christ Jesus for good works (Ephesians 2:10); And a believer is indeed held accountable by their "good works" here upon this Earth at a Judgment. But we must also realize that true believers are not ultimately doing these "good works" alone or of their own power, though. For in 1 Corinthians 15:10 Paul said that he labored more than all of his brethren, yet he said it was not him that labored but it was the grace of God that was within him. So true believer's are just choosing to allow God's "good work" to flow within them or not.
When the Bible says we are not saved of works it is talking about the works of the Law of Moses or man directed works. This evident if you were to look at verses 11-16 (Ephesians 2:11-16) and it is evident if you were to look at Romans and Galatians where the variation of the word "circumcision" appears several times (Which was mentioned so as to address the heresy of trying to be circumcised so as to be saved). I believe the saint today is to obey the Commands only in the New Testament (or New Covenant).
Anyways, the Scriptures say the Law has changed (Hebrews 7:12). So when Paul says, "you are not under the law, but under grace.", he was talking about the Old Law and not the New Law. For if one broke the Old Law, they could be put to death instead of going to Christ and seeking forgiveness by confessing their sins to Him under the New Covenant so as to be forgiven of sin. "For if we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness" (1 John 1:9).
For God is not against His believers obeying Him; And God does not consider those who obey Him out of fear in being punished by the Lord in the after-life to be a wrong thing, either. "For the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom" (Proverbs 9:10). "Behold, the fear of the Lord, that is wisdom; and to depart from evil is understanding." (Job 28:28, - Cross reference with James 3:13). "Wherefore, my beloved, as ye have always obeyed, not as in my presence only, but now much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling" (Philippians 2:12). Also, the body of believers throughout all Judaea and Galilee and Samaria walked in fear of the Lord (Acts 9:31).
But in Eternal Security, there is no reason to fear God.
One can have their cake and eat it, too.
For example: In the most extreme version of Eternal Security, they could say something like,
"Keep on sinning boy, there is no need to worry, you have no control over your body of sin. Therefore, God is not going to blame you. You also got your guaranteed ticket to enter through the gates of Heaven because of your belief on Jesus, too. In fact, nobody's perfect, everybody sins, so just keep on doing the sins that you really like to do. God has forgiven you past, present, and future."
Now, some here may object to the Eternal Security statement above (As they most definitely should); And that is a good thing. In fact, there are Eternal Security Proponents who actually do think they love God and that they are truly serving Him and that they will sin less and less in this life as a part of the Sanctification Process. But will they ever stop sinning in this life? Never. That's the problem. For you can still have your sin and also serve God with even this version of Eternal Security (Which is still wrong). For God cannot agree with saving someone who wants to continue to remain in their evil because that would mean He would have to agree with their willful choice to do evil at some point in the future (Which is not possible because God is good and God is Holy and righteous and there is no darkness within Him).
Sin is merely transgression of the Law (1 John 3:4). So that means, there is some kind of Law of God in existence that believers can still break today.
In fact, today, under the New Covenant, there is:
(a) The Law of Christ (Galatians 6:2).
(b) The Law of Liberty (James 1:25) (James 2:12).
(c) The Royal Law (James 2:8).
(d) The Law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus (Romans 8:2).
(b) The Law of Liberty (James 1:25) (James 2:12).
(c) The Royal Law (James 2:8).
(d) The Law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus (Romans 8:2).
None of these laws were a part of the Old Covenant.
They are laws that are a part of the New Covenant (i.e. the New Testament).
I mean, do you not know that one of the Commandments in the New Testament tells us this?
"Believe on the name of his Son Jesus Christ,." (1 John 3:23).
Here is the entire verse:
"And this is his commandment, That we should believe on the name of his Son Jesus Christ, and love one another, as he gave us commandment" (1 John 3:23).
Are you not justified by keeping the Law or Commandment that says,
"Believe on the name of his Son Jesus Christ,"?
Are you not justified by keeping this Law or Commandment?
In other words, this means you are under some kind of Law.
Paul was not talking about all Law whatsoever (or the Commands given to us in the New Testament). For Jesus says, "Why do you call me Lord, Lord, and do not the things that I say?" (Luke 6:46). To put it to you another way, God is not lawless; And neither are God's people lawless, either.
Superscritter said:OSAS believers believe that the point Jesus was making about thought-crime is that NO MAN can achieve God's standard for holiness, which is why we need Jesus. It was not to imply that after salvation, we are to feel condemned every second of the day because our thoughts betray us.
Well, you are going off your own life experience. But believers walk by faith and not by sight. You cannot go off of what you see. For again, your struggle is not normal for seasoned believers. For your situation is simply not true for many believers who walk uprightly in Jesus Christ thru out history and today. There are many days where I have not struggled with lustful or hateful thoughts. However, it is not something that just comes to you. You have to apply the methods within God's Word and ask for Jesus's help to overcome sin in your life. There are many verses that talk about such a thing. Such verses would not exist if a Sin and Still Be Saved Gospel was true. On the contrary, the Scriptures teach against Easy Believism (See James 2:17-24).
Superscritter said:I am struggling to understand why God will supposedly take away the burden of the Mosaic law only to give us "God directed works" that are substantially harder to follow and are therefore a greater burden.
Then you obviously have never looked at all 613 Commands in the Old Testament and carefully considered in doing them. Nobody can be honest with themselves and say that following all those rituals are easier to accomplish than the Commands in the New Testament. The New Testament Commands are based on God's Eternal Moral Law of Love.
Superscritter said:Outward works are much much easier to achieve than being perfect in thought. You have implied before that you think that thought-perfection is in fact easier to follow than OT laws, but I assure you 99% of people find it much more difficult.
No. Read the 613 Commands and then get back to me.
Also, a person can easily overcome sinful thoughts by the power of Jesus and by employing the methods of overcoming sin within His Word.
Seeing you never tried to do so seriously because you are on the fence (with a strong leaning into the OSAS camp), I am afraid this is not possible for you. You have to first establish the goodness (or the morality) of God within His Word.
Superscritter said:This is another difference in definition. OSAS believers believe the "Jesus is doing the good work through you" is meaning that (for example), you can preach till you're blue in the face, but it is Jesus who will convict men's hearts about their need for salvation - it is the work of the Holy Spirit that will convict men. OSAS believers do not believe that "Jesus is doing the good work through you" means that when you attempt to stop sinning, it is actually Jesus that is doing it on your behalf.
Then why pray to Jesus so as not to be led into temptation?
(See Matthew 26:41).
Why do the Scriptures say the following?
"Now to him who is able to keep you from stumbling, and to present you faultless before the presence of his glory in great joy," (Jude 1:24 NHEB).
"For this purpose the Son of God was manifested, that he might destroy the works of the devil." (1 John 3:8).
"And the Lord shall deliver me from every evil work, and will preserve me unto his heavenly kingdom: to whom be glory for ever and ever. Amen." (2 Timothy 4:18).
Superscritter said:I never said "fear of hell" is the sole purpose of the CS believer for obedience. I said "to please God" is the sole purpose for the OSAS believer to obey God, and that the CS believer is at least in part motivated by a "fear of hell". If you look at what I wrote, I clearly stated "at least in part".
To put the greatest punishment as a motivator for not sinning necessitates that at the back of a Christian's mind, his motivation for obeying God can never be solely to please God. That perfection that I believed God created: that he created a means for us to live in relation with him based purely on pleasing him without any fear of hell will be robbed from me if I accept CS theology. A fact is a fact. I am not saying that CS is false, I am just saying it how it is. Accepting CS theology means I have to accept that my motivations for obedience to God is no longer purely because I want to please him. It will turn from a Godly marriage where divorce is not an option, to a secular marriage where disobedience to a spouse results in total abandonment.
No. You got things backwards. The OSAS belief is that not a selfless type belief because the OSAS Proponent's motivations are not set out to please God for it makes an allowance for serving oneself or sin (of which God cannot agree with because He is holy and righteous); For the OSAS belief says you can sin and still be saved. This is selfish and not selfless. While fear can be a motivator, it is not always the case for the Conditonal Salvationist because perfect love casts out fear. Also, Eternal Torment is not Biblical. So the fear of God torturing a person in flames for all eternity is not true.
...
Last edited:
Upvote
0