Muslims in a public forum

[linchen]

If anyone is killed unjustly.

What does it mean "unjustly"?
And who are according to the Koran the people
who have to judge between the just and the unjust killing?

 

[Bookofknowledge]

I'd say no on both counts - therefore you have no license to comment according to the Quran.

You asked me specific question - don't be a dictator by telling me what I can say and what I can not say after I have said it based on my knowledge.

 

[Bookofknowledge]

What does it mean "unjustly"?
And are is according to the Koran the people
who have to judge between the just and the unjust killing?

If some one kills a person "unjustly" that means they have killed an innocent.

 

[Bookofknowledge]

You asking me what you should believe regarding your religion makes me laugh when I read your name.

I guess I should start asking you to explain your question.

You asked me are you an heir to the ones killed in Iran?

My response was "Can I" be the heir to the one killed in Iran?

 

[Kris_J]

You asked me specific question - don't be a dictator by telling me what I can say and what I can not say after I have said it based on my knowledge.

You have no opinion on whether an execution in Iran is unjust. You are a hypocrite if you have an opinion on whether an execution in Britain is unjust.

 

[linchen]

If some one kills a person "unjustly" that means they have killed an innocent.

Innocent of what?

 

[Kris_J]

I guess I should start asking you to explain your question.

You asked me are you an heir to the ones killed in Iran?

My response was "Can I" be the heir to the one killed in Iran?

If you are asking me it means you do not know.

 

[Bookofknowledge]

You have no opinion on whether an execution in Iran is unjust. You are a hypocrite if you have an opinion on whether an execution in Britain is unjust.

Are you looking forward to call me a hypocrite simply because I didn't told you my opinion with regards to Iran issue? - why do you sound as a dictating individual?

 

[Bookofknowledge]

If you are asking me it means you do not know.

Come on kris how can I be her heir unless I claim myself as her heir through the family tree of Adam or through those people who were in the Ark of Noah.

I am not her immediate heir.

 

[Kris_J]

Are you looking forward to call me a hypocrite simply because I didn't told you my opinion with regards to Iran issue? - why do you sound as a dictating individual?

Oh. Ok I'll just wait for you to respond like you have in gay teens thread... (never! At least Oxyhydro has the guts to make a stand & express his honest opinion).

I suspect you will sit on the fence & keep dodging my questions until you die cos you're scared to make a stand. How sad.

 

[Kris_J]

Come on kris how can I be her heir unless I claim myself as her heir through the family tree of Adam or through those people who were in the Ark of Noah.

I am not her immediate heir.

Thats alright then, so long as the British police do not execute your Muslim father & mother as a racially profiled Muslim terrorist suspect, you have no opinion either.

 

[Bookofknowledge]

Thats alright then, so long as the British police do not execute your Muslim father & mother as a racially profiled Muslim terrorist suspect, you have no opinion either.

those who are being killed by authorities were not born without a father and a mother hence I am sure the world police is keeping the account of how many they have killed so far.

 

[Bookofknowledge]

Oh. Ok I'll just wait for you to respond like you have in gay teens thread... (never! At least Oxyhydro has the guts to make a stand & express his honest opinion).

I suspect you will sit on the fence & keep dodging my questions until you die cos you're scared to make a stand. How sad.

This a nice way of requesting me to respond. You are free to visit my grave when I am dead.

 

[Kris_J]

those who are being killed by authorities were not born without a father and a mother hence I am sure the world police is keeping the account of how many they have killed so far.

make up your mind - are you allowed to have an opinion on the executions that goes on in other countries eg. Iran or Britain - or not? If not then what are you talking about?

 

[Bookofknowledge]

Innocent of what?

Innocent of crime in which a person has been killed or hurt.

 

[Bookofknowledge]

If not then what are you talking about?

I am talking about what is legal according to the law of religion.

 

[Kris_J]

This a nice way of requesting me to respond. You are free to visit my grave when I am dead.

I suppose that is the closest admission of guilt of dodging question I can get out of you. Thanks for letting us know you are a classic Muslim tight-lippedcase the OP was talking about.

Next Muslim!
(lets hope the next Muslim has more courage & honesty - note: Oxyhydro has proven honesty in gay teen thread yet has not proven that he is capable of challenging the beliefs of another Muslim as per OP)

 

[Kris_J]

Is Islam a religion that gags its Muslims from being critical of the Muslim community?

Bookofknowledge does not know this, hence has not lived up to his name otherwise I'd have had a clear answer by now.

Does anyone know the answer to this question? So far the tight-lippedness of our resident NCR Muslims suggest that Islam does gag its Muslims from being critical of the Muslim community.

 

[Bookofknowledge]

I suppose that is the closest admission of guilt of dodging question I can get out of you. Thanks for proving the OP.

I congratulate you for whatever that is you have achieved. You are free to suppose or feel anything you like.

 

[Kris_J]

I am talking about what is legal according to the law of religion.

So? You have no opinion hence nothing to say thus the above means nothing.