I think it's wise to be skeptical of all politicians, especially when you begin to think they're men (or women) of God. Politicians have and respond to incentives just like everyone else, and their most obvious incentive is to garner and maintain votes/support. Mike Pence may in fact be a decent guy, but you don't know. You know only what's displayed publicly, which really isn't much and which may not reveal too much about the actual person. It's quite often hard to differential between real character/actual personality and response to incentives. So I recommend cautious skepticism.
I guess there's an actual chance that you personally know the guy, but I doubt it.