Islam is better than its adherents

[Islam_mulia]

Oh...please spare me the "investigation" ... according to who? which manuscripts?

A good response from a Christian who would not make an effort to know the truth.

 

[Montalban]

A good response from a Christian who would not make an effort to know the truth.

Ye olde "I can't prove a thing... you should" evasion!

 

[Montalban]

Most ancient manuscripts do not have this story. It is possibly a late interpolation.

Are you saying that adulteresses shouldn't be stoned?

 

[Islam_mulia]

Are you saying that adulteresses shouldn't be stoned?

Irrelevant question. I wanted to know if Christians agree the story about the adultress was a late interpolation.

 

[Montalban]

Irrelevant question. I wanted to know if Christians agree the story about the adultress was a late interpolation.

That's irrelevant to this thread

 

[Islam_mulia]

That's irrelevant to this thread

I agree. Philothei brought up the topic so I played along.

 

[Montalban]

I agree. Philothei brought up the topic so I played along.

It being an novel addition IN CHRISITIANITY is irrelevant.

The issue of stoning, per se, has relevance to Islam, unless you can answer my question I put to you about it.

 

[Islam_mulia]

It being an novel addition IN CHRISITIANITY is irrelevant.

The issue of stoning, per se, has relevance to Islam, unless you can answer my question I put to you about it.

You are trying to be fair in our discussion, aren't you? "Dont question Christianity, ask only Islam question".

Most of your Islam questions have been answered by Muslims here. Since most questions are asked by yourself and other Christians, Muslims would like to know your opinion, or rather what your religion, taught about the same issues you asked.

I thought that would open up a nice dialogue session between Christians and Muslims. Or are you only comfortable with a one-way Islam question?

 

[Montalban]

You are trying to be fair in our discussion, aren't you? "Dont question Christianity, ask only Islam question".

The threads about Islam. I'd have the same reaction if you asked me to examin Judaism, Hinduism, or any other ideology

Most of your Islam questions have been answered by Muslims here. Since most questions are asked by yourself and other Christians, Muslims would like to know your opinion, or rather what your religion, taught about the same issues you asked.

Start a thread. Preferrably not one directed at me personally.

I thought that would open up a nice dialogue session between Christians and Muslims. Or are you only comfortable with a one-way Islam question?

Considering I started a thread on comparing Islam to Chrisitanity on the status of women I must say that your appeal here must be based on your own lack of eye-sight - for you must have seen that thread.

 

[Islam_mulia]

The threads about Islam. I'd have the same reaction if you asked me to examin Judaism, Hinduism, or any other ideology

Start a thread. Preferrably not one directed at me personally.

If I were to start a thread on Chrsitianity, that would violate the rule of NCR, wouldn't it?

Why not use the current thread, and discuss what Christians and Muslims believe - that way we can have a much fairer discussion.

 

[Montalban]

If I were to start a thread on Chrsitianity, that would violate the rule of NCR, wouldn't it?

So you're not aware of any other areas on this forum where you can ask Christians questions?

 

[Islam_mulia]

So you're not aware of any other areas on this forum where you can ask Christians questions?

I am not asking for anything difficult.

I just ask that both Muslims and Christians share their belief in the same thread. It seems that Muslims have been answering most of the questions raised by Christians and when we asked Christians in return of what they believe, I have encountered Christians saying "open a new thread".