It involves more than just a piece of paper. Besides, you're the one who just got done posting to me that we're supposed to obey laws. Now you're saying it's just a piece of paper. If you're going to subscribe to certain logic, then at least use it consistently.
It is spending money and jumping threw hoops to get a document to say you are legal. But sometimes people do not have money and are poor. Are we to exclude people based on wealth? That doesn't sound honorable if you ask me. Yes, it is the reality of our country and I encourage everyone to do the right thing in regards to becoming a citizen. But technically it is not right to deport millions of undocumented people who are productive members of our soceity just because they are not fortunate enough to have money so that they can jump thru the right hoops.
Aldebaran said:
Wrong. It's because they broke the law and entered the country illegally. Doesn't matter what they're called or what they look like.
What moral wrong have they done? How is it morally wrong? If they came here to do harm, that would be a different story. But if they came here to have a good life for their family and to be a citizen, then you are missing the point. For the way you are talking here reminds me of the time of when the Pharisees critized Jesus for healing on the Sabbath. Jesus said it is lawful to do good on the Sabbath. In other words, while obeying the Law of the land is very important, we also have to realize that God is also forgiving and loving, too. He knows a person's heart and does not wish them to perish but to repent. In other words, it is like you are saying we should be thrown in jail if we go 1 mile over the speed limit. There is a point of one being too excessive in their punishment for a particular crime.
I am trying to actually wonder if you have even watched Star Trek.
Here is a scene from the Next Generation so as to refresh your memory:
WORF: No response.
PICARD: Try them again. Boost the signal strength.
WORF: Sheliak Corporate. This is the starship Enterprise. Respond please.
(A vaguely humanoid blob appears, looking like lumps of mud)
SHELIAK [on viewscreen]: Conversation is neither required nor desired.
PICARD: Conversation is necessary if we are to find a solution to our mutual problem.
SHELIAK [on viewscreen]: Our involvement in Federation illegality is not indicated.
PICARD: Both parties are involved, sir.
SHELIAK [on viewscreen]: Remove the humans from the Tau Cygna system. Three Earth days remain.
PICARD: Let us negotiate in good faith.
SHELIAK [on viewscreen]: Negotiate to what purpose? The treaty is signed.
PICARD: There is a thriving colony on that planet. Rather than uproot these people, may I offer a compromise?
SHELIAK [on viewscreen]: Denied.
PICARD: Why?
SHELIAK [on viewscreen]: The law is paramount. We are entitled.
PICARD: This is not a law. It is a treaty. It is designed to smooth relations between peoples. Not to act as a strait
(Transmission ends)
PICARD: Jacket
http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/149.htm
Aldebaran said:
Where do you get the "violence" from? If they desired to be legal, then they could have demonstrated so by entering the country the legal way.
Not everyone has money and sometimes people are forced to feed their family. But the violence? Are you kidding me? What do you think is going to happen when you deport a couple of million people and put up a building high wall (as if to say the people on the other side are really bad criminals)?
...