Because we believe that Muhammad is the prophetic messenger of G-d and we follow the Quran that abrogated the Torah and all that was revealed before it.
How can a book abrogate another book it is supposed to confirm?
Upvote
0
Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Christian Forums is looking to bring on new moderators to the CF Staff Team! If you have been an active member of CF for at least three months with 200 posts during that time, you're eligible to apply! This is a great way to give back to CF and keep the forums running smoothly! If you're interested, you can submit your application here!
Because we believe that Muhammad is the prophetic messenger of G-d and we follow the Quran that abrogated the Torah and all that was revealed before it.
We feel the same way with our NT/NC. I don't think the Orthodox Jews will go along with either one.Because we believe that Muhammad is the prophetic messenger of G-d and we follow the Quran that abrogated the Torah and all that was revealed before it.
How can a book abrogate another book it is supposed to confirm?
Our dear brother Paul had this to say"it confirmed the truth that was originally revealed in the previous books while abrogating the man made doctrines that have crept in it over time.
Oxy2Hydr0 said:Because we believe that Muhammad is the prophetic messenger of G-d and we follow the Quran that abrogated the Torah and all that was revealed before it.
How can a book abrogate another book it is supposed to confirm?
Originally Posted by Oxy2Hydr0
Because we believe that Muhammad is the prophetic messenger of G-d and we follow the Quran that abrogated the Torah and all that was revealed before it.
Are you saying that the Lord Jesus in our NT/NC is a "fraud"? And again you will never convince the Jews that Muhammad or Jesus abrogated the LAW giving by Moses to them. They would have to throw out their "Holy Talmud" in that case. Good luck with that.The Arabic مُصَدِّق used in the Quran means "a truth verifier". Thus the Quran is a truth-verifier or its position is to verify the truth of whatever scripture that came before it. It tells us what is from G-d in your book and what is fraud made up by men.
What the Quran abrogated is the Torah ie The Law, the Sabbath was obrogated with Jumuah, the prohibitation of only eating that which has scales in the ocean was aboragated making all things in the Ocean allowed to eat as long as it is good for you etc etc.
Abrogating and truth verifiering something has its seperate nature.
We feel the same way with our NT/NC. I don't think the Orthodox Jews will go along with either one.
But I still don't get why they care what Jews think or believe...we aren't and never will be Muslims. So not
believing in the virgin birth or in Jesus as a prophet
should not matter to them [\quote] Why not? why always take islam to task and not care what judaism says. Are there truths you are afraid to reveal.
I have revealed them, you just don't pay attention to them.We feel the same way with our NT/NC. I don't think the Orthodox Jews will go along with either one.
But I still don't get why they care what Jews think or believe...we aren't and never will be Muslims. So not
believing in the virgin birth or in Jesus as a prophet
should not matter to them [\quote] Why not? why always take islam to task and not care what judaism says. Are there truths you are afraid to reveal.![]()
1. Isa (pbuh) never claimed to be God, or Son of God, but asked the Jews to pray to the One God that Jews are praying nowRevelation 2:18 " And to the angel of the church in Thyatira write, ' These things says the Son of God, who has eyes like a flame of fire, and His feet like fine brass:
2. Isa (pbuh) asks the Jews to follow the Torah and the Injil, hence a continuation of the revelations from God
3. Isa (pbuh) was not crucified and hence was not accursed
4. Isa (pbuh) never claimed to the Messiah the Jews are waiting for.
5. Isa (pbuh) performed many miracles to show he was the prophet of God.
You would have noticed Prophet Isa (pbuh) was in some ways totally different from the biblical Jesus whom the gospel writers made to be crucified, accursed, made false prophecies of himself.
So again, why cant Jews accept Isa (pbuh)?
LittleLambofJesus said:Are you saying that the Lord Jesus in our NT/NC is a "fraud"?
What the Quran abrogated is the Torah ie The Law, the Sabbath was obrogated with Jumuah, the prohibitation of only eating that which has scales in the ocean was aboragated making all things in the Ocean allowed to eat as long as it is good for you etc etc.
Abrogating and truth verifiering something has its seperate nature.
The Law for the Jews cannot be abrogated until this event so why do you say Muhammad abrogated it?No, by no means, only those that put things into his mouth that he never said that found its way into the Gospels
LittleLambofJesus said:The Law for the Jews cannot be abrogated until this event so why do you say Muhammad abrogated it?
(NKJV) Matthew 5:18 "For assuredly, I say to you, till heaven and earth pass away, one jot or one tittle will by no means pass from the law till all is fulfilled. [Isaiah 65]
Q 5:48
وَأَنزَلْنَا إِلَيْكَ الْكِتَابَ بِالْحَقِّ مُصَدِّقاً لِّمَا بَيْنَ يَدَيْهِ مِنَ الْكِتَابِ وَمُهَيْمِناً عَلَيْهِ
and We sent down to you (Muhammad) the scripture in truth as a truth-verifier for whatever is it at hand from the (former) scripture, and as a superior over it.....
No, by no means, only those that put things into his mouth that he never said that found its way into the Gospels
orion said:How can one prove what Jesus said or did not say?
We cant prove anything to those who dont want to believe. However if you are asking how do muslims know what Jesus said or didnt say we look to the Quran for the answers.
Originally Posted by LittleLambofJesus The Law for the Jews cannot be abrogated until this event so why do you say Muhammad abrogated it?
(NKJV) Matthew 5:18 "For assuredly, I say to you, till heaven and earth pass away, one jot or one tittle will by no means pass from the law till all is fulfilled. [Isaiah 65]
Ah, but then that is just begging the question.
You are presupposing that the Quran abrogates all the other scriptures and use the Quran to prove what Jesus said or did not say.
AlHannah said:Is Allah then Yahweh? If not, then Christians and Jews do not worship the same
God as Muslims.
Oxy2Hydro said:For Muslims, yes Alllah is YHWH
Oxy2Hydro said:Now I am going to show people how misleading of a person you are. This is a photo copy of E.W. Lanes Lexicon; The intro starts from the right :
Oxy2Hydro said:As everyone can see Lane is quoting other sources( Lth, Msb, K ) stating "OR it is originally ilaah" on line 12 and 13 of the begining. Lane does not make a stament of fact to which Liberate is falsely propagating about Lane.
When did you see me dismiss someone in authority? And tell me, Who are the people of authority that I am suppose to submit to??This is the problem I find with many westernized muslims, the quick dismissal
of authority, and the onus to interprete the quran and sunnah as they personally see fit,
when islam has not given them the authority to do this. Who decides what is an
authentic hadith? You? If you are the one dismissing what is authentic or not,
how do you reconcile your earlier statement that you do not water down islam?
Yes, I do believe it and accept it. Why because Allaah & His Messenger said so and because the hadeeth has been authenticated.Read the above sahih(authentic) hadith, far from contradicting the quran,
it
states this is the reason for sura 33:69, but what are you to do
with the above
hadith? Do you claim it contradicts the quran to save face, or do you reject it
because of the ridiculous story of a stone running away with someone's clothes
and having the sensory neurones to take a beating. If you reject it on whose
authority do you reject it? Have you studied under the tutelage of a mufti for
several years to issue rulings? I am curious to your
response?
yes, and I still do.Recall also you stated the good deeds of non-muslims mean nothing in the
afterlife.
How can suicide bombers go to Jannah when suicide is forbidden and a major sin? For doing any good deed (which is anything that is pleasing to Allaah, done for the sake of Allaah and is in accordance to the Sunnah of Muhammad).What other reasons are there in islam for granting jannah? Is it for
sacrifices for islam? Will suicide bombers also get in there? Or is this a
complicated subject as allah will be judging them on their intentions...?
I already answered how punishment is to be determined and given but of course you insist to want to believe your way...whatever. The community is not in charge of enforcing punishment, that is the job of the authorities. I posted all this, plus proofs from your own Book that also believed and enforced the same thing (from the OT and NT, for theose Christians who want to believe GOD is all love) but the thread was deleted. However I still have it so if you want to see it I will be glad to send it to you.I am impressed you understand this christian concept, a Holy and Just God
punishes sin, where islam and christianity differs is how sin is dealt with.
Nothing you will ever do can make you feel good enough for jannah...
Can you show me anywhere of an example in the quran where allah showed mercy,
and the nature of that mercy?
Yes, all because of honey! I see your a big conspiracy theorist aren't you? *smile*All because of honey!?
If anyone notices, you have interjected your own opinions in these ahaadeeth. The first hadeeth (about the honey) says exactly what I said! You are the one who can't (or don't want to, out of hatred for our Messenger & Islaam) believe that his breath smelled bad from the drink of honey, even though this is clearly what the hadeeth says. What does the smell of a woman have to do with the story?? I also said that the Messenger played very close attention to his breath and loved to keep his mouth clean and cleaned his teeth often.You'd be hard pressed to find a more logical story regarding the event, than
this absurd tale of
honey and bad breath! (Recall that the hadiths of Bukhari precede those of Muslim, hence the original Bukhari hadith gives a more rational and truer picture not something that came later.)
First off, the mujaahiddeen did not attack villages simply because they were not Muslims. And if you are speaking of so-called mujaahiddeen that are fighting in various parts of the world today I don't support most of the things they do because they are not doing it according to Qur`aan & Sunnah. As for non-Muslim women being made right hand possessions and me supporting that, yes I do. As long as it is done according to Islaamic law I don't have a problem with it at all. Funny you didn't mention that some of these women taken as right hand possessions (in the past) decided to accept Islaam, like Safiyyah, Mother of the Believers. There is also an account of woman woman being sent back to her family.Do you as a woman not feel a little disturbed that non-muslims can be made right
hand possessions by a mujaheddin attacking their town, killing their husbands,
for the sole reason that they are non muslims?
I'm not going to speak too much on this hadeeth because I don't anything about or its explanation. However, the chapter title states: "Chapter: Regarding permission to make a raid, without an ultimatum, upon the disbelievers who have already been invited to accept Islaam" It also does not say alot and probably had other hadeeth that goes with it to support it and further clarify it and Allaah knows best. But either way your point is exactly what?? It should be deemed a courtesy that he did notify them ahead of time to begin with. That is usually, if ever done, in war now is it? The whole point is to catch the enemy off guard... Now please tell me something. Why is there always such an issue about Jihaad like the Muslims do not have a right to fight, whether offensive or defensive. The USA has attacked many nations, offensively, in the name of democracy. But thats a ok right?Ibn 'Aun reported: I wrote to Nafi' inquiring from him
whether it was necessary to extend (to the disbelievers) an invitation to accept
(Islam) before meeting them in fight...Sahih Muslim Book 019, Number 4292
Do you know how Maryam became a gift
?
Are you aware that Mohammed threatened the Egyptian copts to accept islam or
else he would wage jihad on them, and the Vice regent, Al Mauqauqis sent two maids one of them Mariah
as a gift to appease him, Mohammed duly accepted the two maids; and did not wage
jihad on the Egyptian copts, distributing the other maid to a fellow muslim.
What kind of a man would set aside his morals for sex
(let's be honest here, this is what is stated happened)
Hey Matti are you giving us some pseudo algebra and quasi chemistry lessons here, mate?The Genetics of The Genesis
A is the first character of the Alphabet. It's the "image of The Creator". The Name of The Creator is secret, only known by people who know The Book of Life.
A created A Female and A male: A = A A
ALA (ALLA, ALLAH) is the Fisrt Genetic Sequence and it's not Eartly, but Spiritual.
A +
ALA and ADA are same by history.
In ADA, the left A is A Female, right A is A Male.
D is "scale, of eqal value", "half", 15'th of a month, "half (of something)"
In the eyes of The Kingdom of Heaven A Female and A Male are eqal. When A Female and A Male merge, the A -letters are merged AA forming an M: A Child that can be A Boy or A Girl. The whole seqence: A (Creator) A A ADA A+A=M = A ADAM.
In conclusion regarding the modern name ALLAH, beside the H, it's the closest possible original name used in The Ancient Dialect of Language A. A+ ADAM MADA +A : A+ ALAH HALA A.
GOD in turn is gothic blasphemy of the name ISA (modern Jesus) - after 325 AD. All that mess is because of the blasphemy.
Source: http://www.suomalaiset.org