I think I just gave my husband an ultimatum...

Femelle

Member
Oct 11, 2021
6
11
Northern Europe
✟15,693.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I wish that wasn't the case, but I sort of did and if there's anytime to ask for Christian input it is now. Thank you for reading my very long post (sorry), whoever you are. <3

Short background. We've been married a little longer than 8 years and from my perspective, the roller coaster started as soon as we got married which we did after nearly four months of dating. We both have a past and we were older when we got married. I come from a broken, quasi Christian home and my husband comes from a broken communist/socialist/feminist home. He became a Christian a few years before we met and I had decided to take my faith seriously a couple of years before we met. And so, we fell madly in love and got married during our honeymoon phase and then we got to know each other as time went on...

Besides being manly, ruggedly handsome and Christian, he courted me intensively and with intent. He is an extraverted extrovert and wants to spend most of his time with me. He can make me laugh like no one else and he enjoys listening to how my days have been and about what my colleagues or friends are up to/how they live their lives. We enjoy dancing together at home every now and again, we read books out loud for each other, watch movies, go for walks hand in hand, travel and he rarely, if ever, rejects me. We sometimes pray together and go to church. So... how in the world can I give my seemingly perfect husband an ultimatum, being a Christian and all?

While we really do have good times together and actually really enjoy each other's company, I have come to a point where I now can verbalise that I don't trust him. Well, in some respects I do, but in too many I don't. I don't trust his love for me and sometimes I'm not sure of who he is. There have been so many tough and confusing conflicts throughout the years, that I become confused as to what's going on. He is not keen on my story about us, as he says, and he wants me to change it. I'd love to change it and I feel guilty just writing in this forum, like I'm betraying him. But I can't change my story. Not yet. I do hope to be able to change my story, though. So what is my story aside from all that is good?

He has a temper. He doesn't hit me and I don't think he ever would, but he does go at me hard. He is a very sensitive person and when I question him, look at him in a questioning manner or have a tone, he will work up an emotional reaction that will erupt sooner or later. When it does he will go at me, call me names, turn the story around, use my words as his own, interrupt me at my every effort to defend myself. Unfortunately I do not manage well being constantly cut off for hours on end, so I will snap and get back at him which of course works against me because he will walk away as he thinks I am too emotional. If I ever bring to his attention that I was hurt by something that was said, he will get really upset with me and say that I hurt him by saying that I was hurt. If I don't agree with a political thought or any disagrement for that matter, he will get really provoked and start calling me a feminist and start an argument that may last for day. If I ask him to not talk about the devil or push too hard with people who prefer not to talk about God, the night is ruined and when I want to have a say in what kind of car we buy with our money he will go on and on about me having control issues. If I say I think a towel is dry when he thinks it's damp he will go off on me about not agreeing with him and so it goes. Throughout the years, he has yelled at me, made me cry more times than I remember and sometimes mock me for crying. In the beginning, he would come up against me and put his face close to my face and hit his hand in the wall. Once he pushed and held me down on the couch, but I don't remember why. While he praises me and puts me on a pedestal, which he does (too much), he also does the opposite and I can't work out what's going on. Or maybe I can. I'm just not sure I want to.

When it comes to politics there are things we agree on and things we don't and one of our problems is that we express ourselves differently and I don't approve of how he expresses himself and some of his views. He knows this and even when I try to be diplomatic about my disapproval, it is still a disapproval and that will set him off. Perhaps a natural reaction for him since he has a fear of rejection (disorganized attachment). I just don't know though how to start approving contempt and bigotry in order to appease him. I am not the perfect partner. I am critical to quite a few of the things he says and I find it hard to hold my piece when he says outrageous things that also makes for awkward social situations. Sometimes my fears have been just that though - my fears. There are times when he has fantastic conversations about faith and what God has done in his life and I'm really pleased about that. But my fear of awkward moments trigger him and usually lead to an argument. Sometimes we have situations with friends and/or family that ends with people getting really angry with him and walking out and the conflicts are actually severing relationships.

I do try, or I have tried for the past 8 years to appease him when it comes to intimacy which he says will calm him and make him feel both loved by me and also satisfied by the cranial click that sort of resets him. But it doesn't calm him. The first few years I appeased him (well, not just appeasment to be fair) most days of the week and then after four years or so, we agreed on (he hesitantly) an intimacy schedule of 2-4 times per week up until this summer when I said I also wanted to appease myself even if that would mean less some weeks. This in order for me to bloom and for our intimacy to increase. Thing is, after day 2 there is a slight change in his behaviour and from day 3 everything slowly goes south and I end up on those not so lovely egg shells. He stops interacting with me. He doesn't look at me, talk to me much, is cold and distant until I bend and we are close again or until we have a fight. When arguing he will tell me that my body is his body and that according to the Bible a woman should love her husband and meet his demands. I do after all come from his rib and God created woman for man as it is not good for the man to be alone. Also, there should only be a short pause of intimacy for prayer. So he tells me I'm not a good Christian woman (I've stooped and said the same to him) and that my desire is less important than his based on the fact that he is a man and also the one who gives. And I, as a woman, am the receiver. He also does not accept a no to intimacy unless I'm ill, in pain or for some other reason restricted. Not being in the mood is not a valid reason and he simply doesn't understand that. I should meet his needs, just like he will meet my needs with keeping it somewhat tidy in kitchen. He won't force intimacy, but he will stop interacting normally with me for days on end. Not as a punishment, he says, it's just how he deals with being rejected. Cuddles as substitute will not do.

So I have initiated Christian counselling. Again. Like the first time, he didn't want to continue seeing our first therapist, but he decided to meet with a male pastor whom my friend recommended. Now we have just started couples' therapy with the pastor and his wife. Only tricky part now is that he wants me to change my narrative about us and he prefers that I don't talk about the past. He won't muzzle me, I think. At least he never has - he believes in talking openly about everything. I'm the one who is more selective with what I say and to whom. It's just that he does not want me to focus on the past which I understand because our way of handling conflicts does not paint a pretty picture. And he keeps saying that I'm the best thing that ever happened to him and does not share my view of the relationship. But not talking about the past seems impossible as I see patterns that needs to be dealt with in order to move forward. As for the first therapist, she is a woman. He struggles with strong women (yet is attracted to the ones with integrity which he equates with strength) and a few times he has said he doesn't think women should have the right to vote. I can simply not even get into that with him since I'm not sure how to deal with it. I think he is playing me saying that, but then I realise he might not be. As for women in church, he does not believe women should preach/lead and I would be ok with his way of interpreting the Bible, but would love to look into the Bible together to understand God's Word deeper. Not in order to change his mind, in order to see what God actually says. So I asked him if we could go to Bible study together or go deeper with someone who has walked a long and stable life with Jesus and who is also older than us. I asked him if he could chose someone he looks up to and initiate contact, to which he said there is no one he looks up to. No one. He knows the Bible and also, women and men should not study, or are not ment to study the Bible together since it is written differently for women and men. So no, he would not go with me to anyone to dwelve deeper into God's word even if our marriage depended on it. That's when I looked at him and said "this is almost a deal breaker for me." Later that night, a week ago, he said he would go with me since I was "holding a gun to his head" but I have yet to see action.

There's more I can write, but I have to stop before it gets too lengthy. I'm confused though. My husband is so eloquent, clear sighted and loving at times, only to say the craziest things, be really needy, mean/hard with little sight of fruit other times. I don't know how to handle the thought of living in this roller coaster with nocturnal panic attacs every now and again for the rest of my life. I also turn into someone I never was before and it's not what I want or expect from myself. I can't put that on him, but I can see that our fantastic moments together do not weigh up the destructiveness of our relationship. What do I do? Pray that things will change? How long do I wait for change? What is too much emotional distress? Is this emotional abuse? Is emotional abuse cause for divorce? Separation? I don't even know if I - the independent woman - can manage to leave him. He's been left before and that devastated him and this year he has, when in affect, twice said he's so fed up that he'll go drown himself/hang himself. Not that I think he would, but it still puts this tiny little worry in the back of my head. What if he would? Up and down we go - life is like a merry-go-round.

/Femelle
 

Sketcher

Born Imperishable
Feb 23, 2004
38,984
9,400
✟380,249.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Republican
He has a temper. He doesn't hit me and I don't think he ever would, but he does go at me hard. He is a very sensitive person and when I question him, look at him in a questioning manner or have a tone, he will work up an emotional reaction that will erupt sooner or later. When it does he will go at me, call me names, turn the story around, use my words as his own, interrupt me at my every effort to defend myself. Unfortunately I do not manage well being constantly cut off for hours on end, so I will snap and get back at him which of course works against me because he will walk away as he thinks I am too emotional. If I ever bring to his attention that I was hurt by something that was said, he will get really upset with me and say that I hurt him by saying that I was hurt. If I don't agree with a political thought or any disagrement for that matter, he will get really provoked and start calling me a feminist and start an argument that may last for day. If I ask him to not talk about the devil or push too hard with people who prefer not to talk about God, the night is ruined and when I want to have a say in what kind of car we buy with our money he will go on and on about me having control issues. If I say I think a towel is dry when he thinks it's damp he will go off on me about not agreeing with him and so it goes. Throughout the years, he has yelled at me, made me cry more times than I remember and sometimes mock me for crying. In the beginning, he would come up against me and put his face close to my face and hit his hand in the wall. Once he pushed and held me down on the couch, but I don't remember why. While he praises me and puts me on a pedestal, which he does (too much), he also does the opposite and I can't work out what's going on. Or maybe I can. I'm just not sure I want to.
He sounds kind of like my dad, only my dad never pushed my mom or hit the wall close to her head. I moved out (again) a few years after he had entered a phase of hitting himself, which I hope is over. I had gotten to see his temper collapse on him, essentially.

Yet, he and my mom are still married. She's quiet, but strong in those times when he acts like that. She does her best to help him discreetly to avoid setting him off and to reduce stressors when she can. But what really is the key here is she knows who she is in Christ and has really internalized God's word in her heart. She really has a steadfast love for him and the rest of the family. He has a short fuse, she has a really, really long one.

a few times he has said he doesn't think women should have the right to vote. I can simply not even get into that with him since I'm not sure how to deal with it. I think he is playing me saying that, but then I realise he might not be.
Well, do you vote? And does he know about it?

As for women in church, he does not believe women should preach/lead and I would be ok with his way of interpreting the Bible, but would love to look into the Bible together to understand God's Word deeper. Not in order to change his mind, in order to see what God actually says. So I asked him if we could go to Bible study together or go deeper with someone who has walked a long and stable life with Jesus and who is also older than us. I asked him if he could chose someone he looks up to and initiate contact, to which he said there is no one he looks up to. No one. He knows the Bible and also, women and men should not study, or are not ment to study the Bible together since it is written differently for women and men. So no, he would not go with me to anyone to dwelve deeper into God's word even if our marriage depended on it.
That's unfortunate. Better spiritual headship would include that, I think.

Is emotional abuse cause for divorce?
No.

I don't even know if I - the independent woman - can manage to leave him. He's been left before and that devastated him and this year he has, when in affect, twice said he's so fed up that he'll go drown himself/hang himself. Not that I think he would, but it still puts this tiny little worry in the back of my head. What if he would? Up and down we go - life is like a merry-go-round.
Leaving him wouldn't fix that. What resources are there in your country for people who are or claim to be suicidal?
 
  • Agree
Reactions: anna ~ grace
Upvote 0

timf

Regular Member
Jun 12, 2011
1,023
368
✟79,640.00
Faith
Non-Denom
In the way you laid out your case against your husband almost like a prosecutor in court and with a degree of intensity that speaks to deep resentment, it sounds like you are fishing for responses that will endorse your accusations.

Even if a chorus is roused to voice support, it will not solve the discontent you feel. Generally such external support tends to drive one party further from the other.

If you read Galatians chapter five you get a picture of the difference between the flesh and the Spirit. Essentially this difference is between selfishness and selflessness. Our society has been guided by the prince of this world to foster historically unprecedented levels of selfishness.

The definition of love (agape) in 1 Corinthians 13:4-7 is essentially selflessness.

Many approach Christianity looking for rules to follow or justification to do what they want. Often what is missed is the supernatural power of God's word to change hearts and the humility and willingness to seek it.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: anna ~ grace
Upvote 0

Femelle

Member
Oct 11, 2021
6
11
Northern Europe
✟15,693.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
He sounds kind of like my dad, only my dad never pushed my mom or hit the wall close to her head. I moved out (again) a few years after he had entered a phase of hitting himself, which I hope is over. I had gotten to see his temper collapse on him, essentially.

- I’m sorry to hear about your father - I do hope he is feeling better. It must’ve been hard seeing your father struggle.

Yet, he and my mom are still married. She's quiet, but strong in those times when he acts like that. She does her best to help him discreetly to avoid setting him off and to reduce stressors when she can. But what really is the key here is she knows who she is in Christ and has really internalized God's word in her heart. She really has a steadfast love for him and the rest of the family. He has a short fuse, she has a really, really long one.

- Your mother sounds like a rock & I do believe that being mild while strong in faith makes all the difference in their relationship. I am not as steadfast and my fuse only seems to get shorter. Perhaps because I’m fighting too much in my flesh…

Well, do you vote? And does he know about it?

- I do and he knows. He never said that I couldn’t vote, only that (liberal) women shouldn’t.

That's unfortunate. Better spiritual headship would include that, I think.

- I agree.

No.

- While I have not come to terms with when/if someone has broken their vows within a marriage by not loving their spouse, I do appreciate your directness.

Leaving him wouldn't fix that. What resources are there in your country for people who are or claim to be suicidal?

- I don’t think he means what he says when angry, but we probably should talk about it.

Thank you for taking time to respond, I really appreciate it.
 
Upvote 0

Femelle

Member
Oct 11, 2021
6
11
Northern Europe
✟15,693.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
In the way you laid out your case against your husband almost like a prosecutor in court and with a degree of intensity that speaks to deep resentment, it sounds like you are fishing for responses that will endorse your accusations.

- Perhaps you are right. Perhaps I have come to resent my husband and have come to the end of the rope. I don’t, however, think I’m looking for endorsement of my accusations (which ones are you referring to?), but I’m probably hoping someone will see my strife and empathize while nudging me in God’s direction as I do love and care for my husband. It’s just that I feel like I’m sinking.

Even if a chorus is roused to voice support, it will not solve the discontent you feel. Generally such external support tends to drive one party further from the other.

- I know you are right about this & it is for this reason I’m in this forum instead of talking to my non-Christian friends who would have told me to leave years ago.

If you read Galatians chapter five you get a picture of the difference between the flesh and the Spirit. Essentially this difference is between selfishness and selflessness. Our society has been guided by the prince of this world to foster historically unprecedented levels of selfishness.

- Thank you, I will read this and pray for guidance.

The definition of love (agape) in 1 Corinthians 13:4-7 is essentially selflessness.

- Yes. It is so difficult when you feel that it’s one sided, but I know that’s besides the point. Through Christ alone…

Many approach Christianity looking for rules to follow or justification to do what they want. Often what is missed is the supernatural power of God's word to change hearts and the humility and willingness to seek it.

❤️
 
Upvote 0

Citizen of the Kingdom

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Jan 31, 2006
44,350
14,508
Vancouver
Visit site
✟335,989.00
Country
Canada
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
People go into marriages with preconceived ideas of expectations according to whatever role model they have boughten into. (AND USUALLY WITHOUT TELLING THE OTHER WHAT TO EXPECT- Hence deception) If they were realistic they would, before marriage, have that list divided into real and unreal expectations, because unreal expectations are already failures waiting to happen and supply a long list of bullets left to the enemies use.
For instance, your best friend is suddenly thrown into a role that someone else has written the dialog to. Boom, a role change and a different person is set to the music, but the fool has never learned to dance, and the former best friend is placed in high heels and expected to move backwards, doesn’t work. (well maybe for ginger and whoever) Seriously, I really wonder who, yah, who, who wrote the book of love. Prayers for yourself and husband. Sounds like you have the right ingredients but the wrong recipe.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

BobRyan

Junior Member
Angels Team
Site Supporter
Nov 21, 2008
51,352
10,607
Georgia
✟912,457.00
Country
United States
Faith
SDA
Marital Status
Married
I wish that wasn't the case, but I sort of did and if there's anytime to ask for Christian input it is now. Thank you for reading my very long post (sorry), whoever you are. <3

A few words of advice

1. Never discuss politics. Spend way more time praying with your husband about issues you both agree on or want Gods help with, salvation for family members and friends, God's healing for our nation etc.

2. "Amp up" - the Gospel in your home. Lot's of good Christian music on internet - let that be 'the sound in our home' - as often as possible.

3. Pray for him when he is gone.

Christians are a sitting duck for the devil if they are "coasting" and seemingly unaware of their danger. That goes double in marriage.

Here is a great read - for you to do as a couple - it is a commentary on the Life of Christ - this is world-class ... it will change your life.

The Desire of Ages

Read a page and half together for your family worship each day.
 
Upvote 0

Sketcher

Born Imperishable
Feb 23, 2004
38,984
9,400
✟380,249.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Republican
- I’m sorry to hear about your father - I do hope he is feeling better. It must’ve been hard seeing your father struggle.
Thank you.
- Your mother sounds like a rock & I do believe that being mild while strong in faith makes all the difference in their relationship. I am not as steadfast and my fuse only seems to get shorter. Perhaps because I’m fighting too much in my flesh…
She is. The only choice as followers of Christ is to grow in our faith, which means you would need to go to God and grow into your own version of someone that strong and that gentile and that loving.

- I do and he knows. He never said that I couldn’t vote, only that (liberal) women shouldn’t.
Makes sense. It's natural for people who are angry about politics to not want people on the other side to vote, or at least not enough of them to vote to actually win and get things done.

- While I have not come to terms with when/if someone has broken their vows within a marriage by not loving their spouse, I do appreciate your directness.
The New Testament doesn't get more liberal on this than Matthew 19:9 and Matthew 5:32 when both are Christians. This is what Paul would have had in mind when he wrote 1 Corinthians 7:10-11 and the rest of that chapter. Now, if your physical safety were to ever be threatened (and these are general instructions) you can escape to safety (Luke 21:20-24, Acts 8:1). But this would never mean marrying or cohabitating with another. It would mean finding an appropriate shelter or safehouse and moving on from there, and not romantically or sexually involving yourself with another as long as your husband lives. I hope it will never get to that point for you, you said you are not in danger.

- I don’t think he means what he says when angry, but we probably should talk about it.
Yeah, sounds familiar. When dad gets angry he says the worst things he can think of, which don't match up with what he says and does otherwise.

Thank you for taking time to respond, I really appreciate it.
You're welcome, I hope what I shared is helpful.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Maria Billingsley

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Oct 7, 2018
9,661
7,880
63
Martinez
✟906,444.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I wish that wasn't the case, but I sort of did and if there's anytime to ask for Christian input it is now. Thank you for reading my very long post (sorry), whoever you are. <3

Short background. We've been married a little longer than 8 years and from my perspective, the roller coaster started as soon as we got married which we did after nearly four months of dating. We both have a past and we were older when we got married. I come from a broken, quasi Christian home and my husband comes from a broken communist/socialist/feminist home. He became a Christian a few years before we met and I had decided to take my faith seriously a couple of years before we met. And so, we fell madly in love and got married during our honeymoon phase and then we got to know each other as time went on...

Besides being manly, ruggedly handsome and Christian, he courted me intensively and with intent. He is an extraverted extrovert and wants to spend most of his time with me. He can make me laugh like no one else and he enjoys listening to how my days have been and about what my colleagues or friends are up to/how they live their lives. We enjoy dancing together at home every now and again, we read books out loud for each other, watch movies, go for walks hand in hand, travel and he rarely, if ever, rejects me. We sometimes pray together and go to church. So... how in the world can I give my seemingly perfect husband an ultimatum, being a Christian and all?

While we really do have good times together and actually really enjoy each other's company, I have come to a point where I now can verbalise that I don't trust him. Well, in some respects I do, but in too many I don't. I don't trust his love for me and sometimes I'm not sure of who he is. There have been so many tough and confusing conflicts throughout the years, that I become confused as to what's going on. He is not keen on my story about us, as he says, and he wants me to change it. I'd love to change it and I feel guilty just writing in this forum, like I'm betraying him. But I can't change my story. Not yet. I do hope to be able to change my story, though. So what is my story aside from all that is good?

He has a temper. He doesn't hit me and I don't think he ever would, but he does go at me hard. He is a very sensitive person and when I question him, look at him in a questioning manner or have a tone, he will work up an emotional reaction that will erupt sooner or later. When it does he will go at me, call me names, turn the story around, use my words as his own, interrupt me at my every effort to defend myself. Unfortunately I do not manage well being constantly cut off for hours on end, so I will snap and get back at him which of course works against me because he will walk away as he thinks I am too emotional. If I ever bring to his attention that I was hurt by something that was said, he will get really upset with me and say that I hurt him by saying that I was hurt. If I don't agree with a political thought or any disagrement for that matter, he will get really provoked and start calling me a feminist and start an argument that may last for day. If I ask him to not talk about the devil or push too hard with people who prefer not to talk about God, the night is ruined and when I want to have a say in what kind of car we buy with our money he will go on and on about me having control issues. If I say I think a towel is dry when he thinks it's damp he will go off on me about not agreeing with him and so it goes. Throughout the years, he has yelled at me, made me cry more times than I remember and sometimes mock me for crying. In the beginning, he would come up against me and put his face close to my face and hit his hand in the wall. Once he pushed and held me down on the couch, but I don't remember why. While he praises me and puts me on a pedestal, which he does (too much), he also does the opposite and I can't work out what's going on. Or maybe I can. I'm just not sure I want to.

When it comes to politics there are things we agree on and things we don't and one of our problems is that we express ourselves differently and I don't approve of how he expresses himself and some of his views. He knows this and even when I try to be diplomatic about my disapproval, it is still a disapproval and that will set him off. Perhaps a natural reaction for him since he has a fear of rejection (disorganized attachment). I just don't know though how to start approving contempt and bigotry in order to appease him. I am not the perfect partner. I am critical to quite a few of the things he says and I find it hard to hold my piece when he says outrageous things that also makes for awkward social situations. Sometimes my fears have been just that though - my fears. There are times when he has fantastic conversations about faith and what God has done in his life and I'm really pleased about that. But my fear of awkward moments trigger him and usually lead to an argument. Sometimes we have situations with friends and/or family that ends with people getting really angry with him and walking out and the conflicts are actually severing relationships.

I do try, or I have tried for the past 8 years to appease him when it comes to intimacy which he says will calm him and make him feel both loved by me and also satisfied by the cranial click that sort of resets him. But it doesn't calm him. The first few years I appeased him (well, not just appeasment to be fair) most days of the week and then after four years or so, we agreed on (he hesitantly) an intimacy schedule of 2-4 times per week up until this summer when I said I also wanted to appease myself even if that would mean less some weeks. This in order for me to bloom and for our intimacy to increase. Thing is, after day 2 there is a slight change in his behaviour and from day 3 everything slowly goes south and I end up on those not so lovely egg shells. He stops interacting with me. He doesn't look at me, talk to me much, is cold and distant until I bend and we are close again or until we have a fight. When arguing he will tell me that my body is his body and that according to the Bible a woman should love her husband and meet his demands. I do after all come from his rib and God created woman for man as it is not good for the man to be alone. Also, there should only be a short pause of intimacy for prayer. So he tells me I'm not a good Christian woman (I've stooped and said the same to him) and that my desire is less important than his based on the fact that he is a man and also the one who gives. And I, as a woman, am the receiver. He also does not accept a no to intimacy unless I'm ill, in pain or for some other reason restricted. Not being in the mood is not a valid reason and he simply doesn't understand that. I should meet his needs, just like he will meet my needs with keeping it somewhat tidy in kitchen. He won't force intimacy, but he will stop interacting normally with me for days on end. Not as a punishment, he says, it's just how he deals with being rejected. Cuddles as substitute will not do.

So I have initiated Christian counselling. Again. Like the first time, he didn't want to continue seeing our first therapist, but he decided to meet with a male pastor whom my friend recommended. Now we have just started couples' therapy with the pastor and his wife. Only tricky part now is that he wants me to change my narrative about us and he prefers that I don't talk about the past. He won't muzzle me, I think. At least he never has - he believes in talking openly about everything. I'm the one who is more selective with what I say and to whom. It's just that he does not want me to focus on the past which I understand because our way of handling conflicts does not paint a pretty picture. And he keeps saying that I'm the best thing that ever happened to him and does not share my view of the relationship. But not talking about the past seems impossible as I see patterns that needs to be dealt with in order to move forward. As for the first therapist, she is a woman. He struggles with strong women (yet is attracted to the ones with integrity which he equates with strength) and a few times he has said he doesn't think women should have the right to vote. I can simply not even get into that with him since I'm not sure how to deal with it. I think he is playing me saying that, but then I realise he might not be. As for women in church, he does not believe women should preach/lead and I would be ok with his way of interpreting the Bible, but would love to look into the Bible together to understand God's Word deeper. Not in order to change his mind, in order to see what God actually says. So I asked him if we could go to Bible study together or go deeper with someone who has walked a long and stable life with Jesus and who is also older than us. I asked him if he could chose someone he looks up to and initiate contact, to which he said there is no one he looks up to. No one. He knows the Bible and also, women and men should not study, or are not ment to study the Bible together since it is written differently for women and men. So no, he would not go with me to anyone to dwelve deeper into God's word even if our marriage depended on it. That's when I looked at him and said "this is almost a deal breaker for me." Later that night, a week ago, he said he would go with me since I was "holding a gun to his head" but I have yet to see action.

There's more I can write, but I have to stop before it gets too lengthy. I'm confused though. My husband is so eloquent, clear sighted and loving at times, only to say the craziest things, be really needy, mean/hard with little sight of fruit other times. I don't know how to handle the thought of living in this roller coaster with nocturnal panic attacs every now and again for the rest of my life. I also turn into someone I never was before and it's not what I want or expect from myself. I can't put that on him, but I can see that our fantastic moments together do not weigh up the destructiveness of our relationship. What do I do? Pray that things will change? How long do I wait for change? What is too much emotional distress? Is this emotional abuse? Is emotional abuse cause for divorce? Separation? I don't even know if I - the independent woman - can manage to leave him. He's been left before and that devastated him and this year he has, when in affect, twice said he's so fed up that he'll go drown himself/hang himself. Not that I think he would, but it still puts this tiny little worry in the back of my head. What if he would? Up and down we go - life is like a merry-go-round.

/Femelle
Welcom to CF. Sorry you are going through a difficult time. Marriage is very difficult especially if there is a lot of emotional baggage. I have no advice other than one. Pray together everyday for your relationship. This will help remind both of you that God's will for both of you is to LOVE
and honor each other.
Blessings.
 
  • Friendly
Reactions: Femelle
Upvote 0

aiki

Regular Member
Feb 16, 2007
10,874
4,349
Winnipeg
✟236,538.00
Country
Canada
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Married
God intends that, in marriage, your husband meets Christ in you and you meet Christ in him. When this happens, your marriage will be the amazing thing God intends it should be. But until this is so, your marriage will continue to be a painful mixed-bag of experiences with your spouse. He isn't - and will never be - perfect. Neither will you. But if Christ anchors and orders your marriage, if pursuit of him, not merely each other, is the goal of your marriage, you will find joy, peace and rest in your marriage, despite the faults of each of you. When both of you resort continually to Christ for your "marching orders" in your marriage, when your chief aim is to be his ambassador to your spouse (and vice versa), your failings and weaknesses as human beings will no longer have the power to threaten or dissolve your marital union.

Christ loved us when we were his enemies, when we were living in open rebellion toward him, despising his truth and light. (John 1:11; Colossians 1:21; Ephesians 2:1-3; Titus 3:3-4) When we submit ourselves entirely to him to do with as he pleases, we are filled with him, with the Spirit of Christ, and overflow with his love and light. And when our spouse meets us in this condition and acts selfishly toward us, instead of responding in kind, looking for the door out of the relationship, our spouse encounters in us the unwavering, holy, brightly-shining love of Christ.

But do you want to be a vessel in and through whom Christ communicates himself? Will you live your life for yourself? Or for the One who gave you life? You were made to do the latter, not the former. And in Christ's power, filled up with him, loving a troublesome spouse is more than possible, it's a joy; for regardless of the response our spouse may have to Christ flowing from us, we have pleased the true Lover of our Soul, the only One who can truly and fully satisfy us, and we move deeper into communion with him as a result.

No human can ever be for you what God intends only He can and should be. Perhaps more than any other relationship, marriage exposes us to this reality - not to hurt us, or make us cynical about humanity, but to crowd us to God in whom true meaning, fulfillment and peace are found.

By the way, God hates divorce. He calls divorcing one's spouse "treachery."

Malachi 2:14-16
14 ...the LORD has been witness between you and the wife of your youth, against whom you have dealt treacherously: yet is she your companion, and the wife of your covenant.
15 And did not he make one? Yet had he the residue of the spirit. And wherefore one? That he might seek a godly seed. Therefore take heed to your spirit, and let none deal treacherously against the wife of his youth.
16 For the LORD, the God of Israel, says that he hates divorce: for one covers violence with his garment, says the LORD of hosts: therefore take heed to your spirit, that you deal not treacherously.


You can be sure that contemplating divorce is not something that originates with God. That should, as His child, quite put you off divorce - especially under the marital circumstances you've described.
 
Upvote 0

Aussie Pete

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Aug 14, 2019
9,081
8,285
Frankston
Visit site
✟727,630.00
Country
Australia
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Divorced
I wish that wasn't the case, but I sort of did and if there's anytime to ask for Christian input it is now. Thank you for reading my very long post (sorry), whoever you are. <3

Short background. We've been married a little longer than 8 years and from my perspective, the roller coaster started as soon as we got married which we did after nearly four months of dating. We both have a past and we were older when we got married. I come from a broken, quasi Christian home and my husband comes from a broken communist/socialist/feminist home. He became a Christian a few years before we met and I had decided to take my faith seriously a couple of years before we met. And so, we fell madly in love and got married during our honeymoon phase and then we got to know each other as time went on...

Besides being manly, ruggedly handsome and Christian, he courted me intensively and with intent. He is an extraverted extrovert and wants to spend most of his time with me. He can make me laugh like no one else and he enjoys listening to how my days have been and about what my colleagues or friends are up to/how they live their lives. We enjoy dancing together at home every now and again, we read books out loud for each other, watch movies, go for walks hand in hand, travel and he rarely, if ever, rejects me. We sometimes pray together and go to church. So... how in the world can I give my seemingly perfect husband an ultimatum, being a Christian and all?

While we really do have good times together and actually really enjoy each other's company, I have come to a point where I now can verbalise that I don't trust him. Well, in some respects I do, but in too many I don't. I don't trust his love for me and sometimes I'm not sure of who he is. There have been so many tough and confusing conflicts throughout the years, that I become confused as to what's going on. He is not keen on my story about us, as he says, and he wants me to change it. I'd love to change it and I feel guilty just writing in this forum, like I'm betraying him. But I can't change my story. Not yet. I do hope to be able to change my story, though. So what is my story aside from all that is good?

He has a temper. He doesn't hit me and I don't think he ever would, but he does go at me hard. He is a very sensitive person and when I question him, look at him in a questioning manner or have a tone, he will work up an emotional reaction that will erupt sooner or later. When it does he will go at me, call me names, turn the story around, use my words as his own, interrupt me at my every effort to defend myself. Unfortunately I do not manage well being constantly cut off for hours on end, so I will snap and get back at him which of course works against me because he will walk away as he thinks I am too emotional. If I ever bring to his attention that I was hurt by something that was said, he will get really upset with me and say that I hurt him by saying that I was hurt. If I don't agree with a political thought or any disagrement for that matter, he will get really provoked and start calling me a feminist and start an argument that may last for day. If I ask him to not talk about the devil or push too hard with people who prefer not to talk about God, the night is ruined and when I want to have a say in what kind of car we buy with our money he will go on and on about me having control issues. If I say I think a towel is dry when he thinks it's damp he will go off on me about not agreeing with him and so it goes. Throughout the years, he has yelled at me, made me cry more times than I remember and sometimes mock me for crying. In the beginning, he would come up against me and put his face close to my face and hit his hand in the wall. Once he pushed and held me down on the couch, but I don't remember why. While he praises me and puts me on a pedestal, which he does (too much), he also does the opposite and I can't work out what's going on. Or maybe I can. I'm just not sure I want to.

When it comes to politics there are things we agree on and things we don't and one of our problems is that we express ourselves differently and I don't approve of how he expresses himself and some of his views. He knows this and even when I try to be diplomatic about my disapproval, it is still a disapproval and that will set him off. Perhaps a natural reaction for him since he has a fear of rejection (disorganized attachment). I just don't know though how to start approving contempt and bigotry in order to appease him. I am not the perfect partner. I am critical to quite a few of the things he says and I find it hard to hold my piece when he says outrageous things that also makes for awkward social situations. Sometimes my fears have been just that though - my fears. There are times when he has fantastic conversations about faith and what God has done in his life and I'm really pleased about that. But my fear of awkward moments trigger him and usually lead to an argument. Sometimes we have situations with friends and/or family that ends with people getting really angry with him and walking out and the conflicts are actually severing relationships.

I do try, or I have tried for the past 8 years to appease him when it comes to intimacy which he says will calm him and make him feel both loved by me and also satisfied by the cranial click that sort of resets him. But it doesn't calm him. The first few years I appeased him (well, not just appeasment to be fair) most days of the week and then after four years or so, we agreed on (he hesitantly) an intimacy schedule of 2-4 times per week up until this summer when I said I also wanted to appease myself even if that would mean less some weeks. This in order for me to bloom and for our intimacy to increase. Thing is, after day 2 there is a slight change in his behaviour and from day 3 everything slowly goes south and I end up on those not so lovely egg shells. He stops interacting with me. He doesn't look at me, talk to me much, is cold and distant until I bend and we are close again or until we have a fight. When arguing he will tell me that my body is his body and that according to the Bible a woman should love her husband and meet his demands. I do after all come from his rib and God created woman for man as it is not good for the man to be alone. Also, there should only be a short pause of intimacy for prayer. So he tells me I'm not a good Christian woman (I've stooped and said the same to him) and that my desire is less important than his based on the fact that he is a man and also the one who gives. And I, as a woman, am the receiver. He also does not accept a no to intimacy unless I'm ill, in pain or for some other reason restricted. Not being in the mood is not a valid reason and he simply doesn't understand that. I should meet his needs, just like he will meet my needs with keeping it somewhat tidy in kitchen. He won't force intimacy, but he will stop interacting normally with me for days on end. Not as a punishment, he says, it's just how he deals with being rejected. Cuddles as substitute will not do.

So I have initiated Christian counselling. Again. Like the first time, he didn't want to continue seeing our first therapist, but he decided to meet with a male pastor whom my friend recommended. Now we have just started couples' therapy with the pastor and his wife. Only tricky part now is that he wants me to change my narrative about us and he prefers that I don't talk about the past. He won't muzzle me, I think. At least he never has - he believes in talking openly about everything. I'm the one who is more selective with what I say and to whom. It's just that he does not want me to focus on the past which I understand because our way of handling conflicts does not paint a pretty picture. And he keeps saying that I'm the best thing that ever happened to him and does not share my view of the relationship. But not talking about the past seems impossible as I see patterns that needs to be dealt with in order to move forward. As for the first therapist, she is a woman. He struggles with strong women (yet is attracted to the ones with integrity which he equates with strength) and a few times he has said he doesn't think women should have the right to vote. I can simply not even get into that with him since I'm not sure how to deal with it. I think he is playing me saying that, but then I realise he might not be. As for women in church, he does not believe women should preach/lead and I would be ok with his way of interpreting the Bible, but would love to look into the Bible together to understand God's Word deeper. Not in order to change his mind, in order to see what God actually says. So I asked him if we could go to Bible study together or go deeper with someone who has walked a long and stable life with Jesus and who is also older than us. I asked him if he could chose someone he looks up to and initiate contact, to which he said there is no one he looks up to. No one. He knows the Bible and also, women and men should not study, or are not ment to study the Bible together since it is written differently for women and men. So no, he would not go with me to anyone to dwelve deeper into God's word even if our marriage depended on it. That's when I looked at him and said "this is almost a deal breaker for me." Later that night, a week ago, he said he would go with me since I was "holding a gun to his head" but I have yet to see action.

There's more I can write, but I have to stop before it gets too lengthy. I'm confused though. My husband is so eloquent, clear sighted and loving at times, only to say the craziest things, be really needy, mean/hard with little sight of fruit other times. I don't know how to handle the thought of living in this roller coaster with nocturnal panic attacs every now and again for the rest of my life. I also turn into someone I never was before and it's not what I want or expect from myself. I can't put that on him, but I can see that our fantastic moments together do not weigh up the destructiveness of our relationship. What do I do? Pray that things will change? How long do I wait for change? What is too much emotional distress? Is this emotional abuse? Is emotional abuse cause for divorce? Separation? I don't even know if I - the independent woman - can manage to leave him. He's been left before and that devastated him and this year he has, when in affect, twice said he's so fed up that he'll go drown himself/hang himself. Not that I think he would, but it still puts this tiny little worry in the back of my head. What if he would? Up and down we go - life is like a merry-go-round.

/Femelle
First up, I suggest that you look up Mark Gungor, the best relationship counselor on the planet. He is also the most entertaining. For example, one of his series is "how to stay married without killing anyone". You and your husband should watch together.

It is almost instinctive for a woman to want to change the man she marries. Bad idea. Either you get your way and "your not the man I married" or you do not and you wear yourself out trying. Ignore this if it does not apply.

Leave him alone! Let God change Him! That's what God says to women married to unbelievers. How easy is it for you to change yourself? Why do you think you can change your husband? Pray for him for sure. Let your own life and demeanor convict him. As long as he is not chasing other women or physically abusing you, you are not that badly off.

Your husband sounds like my son-in-law except more extroverted. My son-in-law has many talents but he's also utterly rebellious. He pretended to be a Christian to win my daughter's heart. She loves him even though she has no illusions about the kind of man he is. They have four children. I don't see them often as they live a long way from me. I saw them in January. My son in law has mellowed considerably. One time I visited, about 8 years ago, he'd just put his fist through a wall. My tiny daughter jumped up on a table and yelled at him. (She's not quite 5 ft). I saw no sign of that temper last visit.

God is well able to change people. We cannot and it is counter productive to try. God may well be working in your life too. Independence is not a blessing, it is a blight. I speak from experience. I was four when I started school. I did not want my mother taking me to school because I was fine on my own. Independence keeps us from trusting God.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: anna ~ grace
Upvote 0

Albion

Facilitator
Dec 8, 2004
111,138
33,258
✟583,842.00
Country
United States
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Married
What do I do? Pray that things will change?
I would not limit myself to doing that.

How long do I wait for change?
Not a minute longer.

What is too much emotional distress?
I think you've arrived at close to the breaking point.

Is this emotional abuse?
Probably, but identifying or labelling it probably isn't going to be very helpful.

My thinking is that you need professional help as soon as possible and that you two are prime candidates for it.

Not everyone who comes here with problems would be answered that way, but I see you two as being perfect candidates for it. However, and although the religious conflicts are part of the issue, I would not favor turning to any more Christian pastors and their wives as counselors. Even if the secular counselors can be insensitive about their clients' religious convictions, your husband's and your own actions towards each other seem to me to be the kind of thing that can be worked out, so long as you both are willing to agree that the blame belongs on both sides and you need to agree to approaching disagreements in a new way.

I'm speaking not as a professional myself and, as always, there are both good and bad counselors, so do be careful if you go this way.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

aiki

Regular Member
Feb 16, 2007
10,874
4,349
Winnipeg
✟236,538.00
Country
Canada
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Married
One wonders what Christians in bad marriages did to resolve the badness in their marriages before modern counselling. How has it come to pass that Christians believe a "professional counsellor" is vital to a couple struggling in their marriage? Were couples in all the centuries prior to modern counselling just out of luck, unavoidably and perennially crippled in their marriages because modern counselling hadn't yet developed? Goodness! What did Paul think he was doing, then, offering marital advice without proper, modern credentialing?! And what a mess God has made of things for the 2000 years prior to today, leaving Christian marriages without the professional means to be all He intended them to be.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: anna ~ grace
Upvote 0

Albion

Facilitator
Dec 8, 2004
111,138
33,258
✟583,842.00
Country
United States
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Married
One wonders what Christians in bad marriages did to resolve the badness in their marriages before modern counselling. How has it come to pass that Christians believe a "professional counsellor" is vital to a couple struggling in their marriage?


Femelle,

Please note that the replies you've received so far advise professional counselling in your case. It is not what would be recommended to everyone having marital difficulties. Also, no one advised against prayer (!) or other approaches that might be undertaken at the same time. Your own situation, as you described it to us, appears to be close to urgent but also capable of resolution if approached in a spirit of cooperation.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

ViaCrucis

Confessional Lutheran
Oct 2, 2011
37,458
26,890
Pacific Northwest
✟732,295.00
Country
United States
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
US-Others
Your situation, as you present it, demonstrates a deeply troubling and toxic relationship. A person doesn't have to hit you to be an abusive person. Abuse can be emotional, psychological, and even spiritual.

A man who tells a woman that women shouldn't have the right to vote is, on its own, one of the biggest red flags I have ever encountered.

Others have recommended the same as I would give: Serious, professional therapy and counseling is necessary. Additional pastoral counseling sounds especially needed--as long as it comes from a good pastor of course. A good pastor will take you seriously, a good pastor will work to help lead you toward what is loving, healthy, and Christian; a bad pastor will manipulate and moralize.

My prayers are with you and your marriage. May God's peace rest upon you, sibling in Christ.

-CryptoLutheran
 
Upvote 0

ViaCrucis

Confessional Lutheran
Oct 2, 2011
37,458
26,890
Pacific Northwest
✟732,295.00
Country
United States
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
US-Others
One wonders what Christians in bad marriages did to resolve the badness in their marriages before modern counselling. How has it come to pass that Christians believe a "professional counsellor" is vital to a couple struggling in their marriage? Were couples in all the centuries prior to modern counselling just out of luck, unavoidably and perennially crippled in their marriages because modern counselling hadn't yet developed? Goodness! What did Paul think he was doing, then, offering marital advice without proper, modern credentialing?! And what a mess God has made of things for the 2000 years prior to today, leaving Christian marriages without the professional means to be all He intended them to be.

I'm confident that the Apostles were good pastors.

-CryptoLutheran
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Avniel

Doing my part each day by being the best me
Jun 11, 2010
7,219
438
Bronx NYC
✟38,941.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Democrat
Is it possible that you might look down on his beliefs. You said he was raised in a socialist and communist household, I never realized that was a bad thing. The free COVID vaccine, is a socialist program. However as someone with a degree in political science, I’ve had Christian back lash for some of my political beliefs while I have scripture that can back as well.

I think that’s a church issue, you can be a democrat and a Christian, you can be a republican and a Christian. The concept of politics is worldly nature, even God warned the Hebrews about it.
 
Upvote 0