ABlessedAnomaly
Teacher of the Word
Dan, I fought so hard not to post a first impression answer after reading half of the first paragraph....for it is here that I think you make a mistake in definition. The rest of the post hinges on this definition that you have, IMHO, forced upon this text. And perhaps you do this because of Romans 8:24-25, I don't know (it does seem likely though). Let's see...
Ok.
"Manifestation" - this is the visible thing that comes by faith of our desired, hoped for ... um, hope. It is what faith brings about ultimately if our faith is real, if it is the evidence and substance of something that we once did not see. The "manifestation" is what we ultimately want. Could be healing, could be joy, could be salvation.
"Hope," as a noun is a desire. It is not a thing.
"Hope" (or hoping) as a verb is the action of wanting.
"Invisible thing" (or as you rightly say later that we must agree on, the unseen thing) is what we are at odds over herein.
So to your quote above: You are correct, the manifestation is not the invisible, or unseen, thing. The manifestation is when the unseen becomes seen...it is when we achieve that for which we have faith. The manifestation is the reality realized in this visible world.
So in this, I have issue with what I put in blue above. You repeated it in the next example, so I'll deal with it below.
But the blue above. It is wrong.
Faith is the substance of things. Stop. This tells you what faith is: substance. This tells you what we have faith for: the things. We don't have faith for the hope -- we already have the hope. It is tangible to a point, although it is a concept, an idea. We have it already: we started there -- in hope.
We hope for the invisible thing. The thing (remember, let's assume healing) is not in our grasp yet. It is unseen. It is invisible. But our hope is ours; it is something we are embracing. It is something that we already have a hold of. We want the hoped for thing to manifest. The thing will (if faith is present and excercised) move from the unseen to the seen. The thing is the invisible thing. The hope is what we have and we are hoping for the unseen thing.
If God gives faith for the thing we hope for it means that the thing is promised of God (or allowed of God). The thing exists in the spirit realm. Very, very real -- just not in our physical world. It is far from just a "thought form." In our example, healing, Jesus provided healing in the atonement. It is already in the spirit world awaiting us to manifest it (bring it into existence) through faith. Far from just a thought. It is very, very real.
The reason this is a big thing is that the hope is man-created. We have the ability to hope. And we can certainly hope for things that are contrary to God's will. A woman hoped for Kenneth Copeland in marriage. There will be no true faith for that. There will be no manifestation. The "thing" (marriage to Cope) is simply not on God's table in the spiritual realm.
Confusing "hope" as the "thing" allows faith to be the substance of something that might not even be God's will. And this simply does not hold water.
Here is my quote that you refer to:This is kinda the crux of the point. You actually said it yourself in the above statement, then went one to explain it differently.
Originally Posted by ABlessedMan
Hmm. In Hebrews 11:1 there is one thing that is said to be invisible: the thing. It is the thing that we hope for. It is our desire. We do not have it yet, so it is invisible to us.

Hmm. In Hebrews 11:1 there is one thing that is said to be invisible: the thing. It is the thing that we hope for. It is our desire. We do not have it yet, so it is invisible to us.
Yes, agreed.Our hope (noun) is "our desire".
(I capped Wonder Woman, as the first read for me I somhow missed it)The manifestation of our hope (noun) that we are hoping (verb) for is not the invisible thing, in the sense that it exists like Wonder Woman's invisible plane, we just cant see it or touch it.
Ok.
"Manifestation" - this is the visible thing that comes by faith of our desired, hoped for ... um, hope. It is what faith brings about ultimately if our faith is real, if it is the evidence and substance of something that we once did not see. The "manifestation" is what we ultimately want. Could be healing, could be joy, could be salvation.
"Hope," as a noun is a desire. It is not a thing.
"Hope" (or hoping) as a verb is the action of wanting.
"Invisible thing" (or as you rightly say later that we must agree on, the unseen thing) is what we are at odds over herein.
So to your quote above: You are correct, the manifestation is not the invisible, or unseen, thing. The manifestation is when the unseen becomes seen...it is when we achieve that for which we have faith. The manifestation is the reality realized in this visible world.
If you would have stopped here, we would be in perfect agreement. But alas, this is where we diverge.The thing that we are hoping for is an invisible thing...
As you flesh out this definition below, it becomes apparent we don't define things the same. Let's continue below....in the sense that it exists only as a hope; that is, as a picture in our mind, a concept, an idea, a blueprint; or, as you said, desire. And that is the definition of hope.
This, while perfectly true, is another aspect of the faith discussion. This is getting something that exists already but isn't fully yours -- such as the wealth of the wicked laid up for the just. We can have faith for such wealth, but it isn't ours. I could argue that the manifestation would be when it actually becomes ours (rather than defining manifestation strictly as what is visible somewhere). But let's not muddy this discussion with other aspects of this topic. Let's keep it on something that we don't have that isn't here in this world (like a healing, for instance).In fact, usually the manifestation of what we are hoping for already exists in the natural world, we simply do not yet have possession or ownership of it, therefore it cannot be invisible.
(Yes, I know your just having fun there.) But in the fun there is some misconceptions. For when we believe God for finances, we are not believing for the "dollar bills" but rather the "bill paid" (or whatever we need the finances for). I'm sure you agree with this, but I felt it important to put it down in writing.Let me give an example to clarify what I mean. If we are believing God for finances, there are not invisible dollar bills floating around that we are trying to use our faith to manifest. I'm sure we have all heard the analogy that God is not a counterfeiter. He is not printing faith dollars for us. If He did, what serial numbers would He put on them? Would that be like the Fed printing money? Can we blame Him then for the devaluation of the dollar? (I know that you don't believe that, just having some fun!) No, faith isn't the substance of some invisible dollars bills. Faith is the substance of our HOPE; that is, the idea, concept, picture or desire to have enough money to pay our bills.
So in this, I have issue with what I put in blue above. You repeated it in the next example, so I'll deal with it below.
Ok, same thing. Daily bread is our sustinence, not a physical loaf of bread.If we are believing God for our daily bread, are their invisible loaves of bread floating around, that we cannot see, just waiting for our faith to manifest? No, faith isn't the substance of some invisible loaves of bread floating around. Faith is the substance of our HOPE; that is, the idea, concept, picture or desire that we have of our hunger being filled.
But the blue above. It is wrong.
Hebrews 11:1
Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
"Hoped for" is an adjectival phrase for the object of the prepostion "things." Faith is the substance. What is the substance? Substance of things. Anything else here is descriptive. "Hoped for" defines what the things are; the things are hoped for. The things are not hope. Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
Faith is the substance of things. Stop. This tells you what faith is: substance. This tells you what we have faith for: the things. We don't have faith for the hope -- we already have the hope. It is tangible to a point, although it is a concept, an idea. We have it already: we started there -- in hope.
We hope for the invisible thing. The thing (remember, let's assume healing) is not in our grasp yet. It is unseen. It is invisible. But our hope is ours; it is something we are embracing. It is something that we already have a hold of. We want the hoped for thing to manifest. The thing will (if faith is present and excercised) move from the unseen to the seen. The thing is the invisible thing. The hope is what we have and we are hoping for the unseen thing.
Absolutely not!! Not biblically (when it speaks of 'not seen').No, these things that we are believing God for are invisible because they exist only in thought form.
If God gives faith for the thing we hope for it means that the thing is promised of God (or allowed of God). The thing exists in the spirit realm. Very, very real -- just not in our physical world. It is far from just a "thought form." In our example, healing, Jesus provided healing in the atonement. It is already in the spirit world awaiting us to manifest it (bring it into existence) through faith. Far from just a thought. It is very, very real.
Hope, sure, is ours and is our idea of what we want, our concept. Yes. But hope is not the thing that hopefully will manifest if we have faith and excercise our faith for it to move from the unseen to the seen.They exist in our mind, in the form of ideas, concepts, pictures, or blueprints; what we call hope. These invisible things are our HOPE.
I don't agree with your (1)/(2) analysis. Those are different phrases in the verse. They are not meant (not is it logical) to set them side by side as you did and then say that one adverbal phrase is meaningfully equal to the other. Likewise, substance is not evidence, although both are what faith is.(The Bible also calls this light. Light and Hope are synonyms in the Bible, because it is light that gives us direction, shows us where we are going.) Now, the term things not seen is used in Hebrews 11:1 as a synonym for what HOPE does:
1 Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
-Hebrews 11:1
Let me break it down this way so that you can get a clearer idea of what I am saying:
Here, the phrase not seen, or invisible (I think we are in agreement that what is not seen is invisible) is used as a synonym for the phrase hoped for.
- Faith is the substance..........of things..........hoped for...
- Faith is the evidence............of things..........not seen...
So again, I disagree with this. The thing hoped for is the manifestation of (in this example I've injected) our healing. But the thing is the thing. The hope is our hope for the thing.The thing that is hoped for is our HOPE.
The reason this is a big thing is that the hope is man-created. We have the ability to hope. And we can certainly hope for things that are contrary to God's will. A woman hoped for Kenneth Copeland in marriage. There will be no true faith for that. There will be no manifestation. The "thing" (marriage to Cope) is simply not on God's table in the spiritual realm.
Confusing "hope" as the "thing" allows faith to be the substance of something that might not even be God's will. And this simply does not hold water.
Upvote
0