Greetings, sad clown.....
I had some crises of faith and to be honest some serious rebellion-against-God issues when I was in my twenties, and the path back to fellowship with Him was a broken one. The consistent things were crying out for him to change me - my thoughts, my beliefs, my emotions, etc. - because I knew I couldn't do it myself, reading the Bible (mainly at that point in the Psalms), and being obedient to anything I felt he was leading me to do, even if it didn't make sense to me (for example, recording sermons over my dark-music tapes - that definitely makes sense now, years later).
My husband's path back to that fellowship with God began, I think, like yours, with a desire for harmony between himself and me. It may not seem valid at first blush - it didn't to me at the time, really - but God can change our motivations!! And He has changed my husband's motivations, after several years. Now we are both serving God and walking in much greater harmony with each other.
I encourage you to just keep moving toward the Lord. I think He will meet you!!!
blessings
tal