• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

  • CF has always been a site that welcomes people from different backgrounds and beliefs to participate in discussion and even debate. That is the nature of its ministry. In view of recent events emotions are running very high. We need to remind people of some basic principles in debating on this site. We need to be civil when we express differences in opinion. No personal attacks. Avoid you, your statements. Don't characterize an entire political party with comparisons to Fascism or Communism or other extreme movements that committed atrocities. CF is not the place for broad brush or blanket statements about groups and political parties. Put the broad brushes and blankets away when you come to CF, better yet, put them in the incinerator. Debate had no place for them. We need to remember that people that commit acts of violence represent themselves or a small extreme faction.

How could you tell?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Yamaha06R6Guy

Junior Member
Jul 29, 2013
124
0
✟327.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Well, she could have never lied to you, that you know of. Now, if you said she couldn't lie, because her inherent property is the inability to lie (that you arrived because she told you, others, etc), then that would be circular reasoning.

Can you use the same methods to determine if your girlfriend was lying as you could a deity? If so, then your analogy stands and is logical.

How could you tell if that God was lying to you, in those personal experiences?

I use several means when determining if someone is lying to me or being truthful.

1. I examine what they say
2. I judge what they say by what I know to be true
3. I take into account the character of the person talking to me.

In the case of God, I examine what He says, I judge it by what I know to be true and I take into account His character.

In considering these three together, I have good reasons to believe that God is not lying to me when we communicate.
 
Upvote 0

Non sequitur

Wokest Bae Of The Forum
Jul 2, 2011
4,532
541
Oklahoma City, OK
✟53,280.00
Country
United States
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Constitution
I use several means when determining if someone is lying to me or being truthful.

1. I examine what they say
2. I judge what they say by what I know to be true
3. I take into account the character of the person talking to me.

In the case of God, I examine what He says, I judge it by what I know to be true and I take into account His character.

In considering these three together, I have good reasons to believe that God is not lying to me when we communicate.

How did you arrive at his character?
 
Upvote 0

Non sequitur

Wokest Bae Of The Forum
Jul 2, 2011
4,532
541
Oklahoma City, OK
✟53,280.00
Country
United States
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Constitution
His character is not a location or destination to be arrived at.

Restate the question.

You said, "I take into account His character."

How did you arrive at what you think his character is?
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
Err.....no

It is not circular because I am concluding she is trustworthy by virtue of experiencing her faithfulness over time not because she says she is trustworthy.
You said:

"If you told me you know your girlfriend is an honest woman and that she has never lied to you and that is how you know she is trustworthy, you would think me quite mad if I said that conclusion was arrived at via circular reasoning.

Quite clearly, "she has never lied to me" is a claim subject to the evidence she presents: her partner believe she has never lied to them, but how do you know?
 
Upvote 0

Yamaha06R6Guy

Junior Member
Jul 29, 2013
124
0
✟327.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
You said:

"If you told me you know your girlfriend is an honest woman and that she has never lied to you and that is how you know she is trustworthy, you would think me quite mad if I said that conclusion was arrived at via circular reasoning.

Quite clearly, "she has never lied to me" is a claim subject to the evidence she presents: her partner believe she has never lied to them, but how do you know?

You know because you judge what she says by taking into account the three things I listed.
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
You know because you judge what she says by taking into account the three things I listed.
What things? Honesty, trustworthiness, and not lying? The problem is how to gauge these things.

With a human girlfriend, her actions are limited, so her honesty can be gauged. But how does one gauge the honesty of a powerful being? How does one know that when God says "I created the universe" that he's telling the truth?

'Trust' doesn't quite cut it, of course, as any sufficiently powerful trickster can replicate all the things an honesty deity can do.

Remember the OP: How does one know God is who he says he is, and isn't just a sufficiently powerful trickster? For instance, how do you know the being who purports to be 'God' isn't actually a malicious spirit who desires nothing more than to tempt people away from the one true faith of Hinduism?
 
Upvote 0

Non sequitur

Wokest Bae Of The Forum
Jul 2, 2011
4,532
541
Oklahoma City, OK
✟53,280.00
Country
United States
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Constitution
How do you arrive at what you think is the character of someone who you consider to be trustworthy?

Irrelevant. We are talking about your god.

How did you arrive at what you think His character is?
 
Upvote 0

HitchSlap

PROUDLY PRIMATE
Aug 6, 2012
14,723
5,468
✟288,596.00
Country
United States
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
I use several means when determining if someone is lying to me or being truthful.

1. I examine what they say
2. I judge what they say by what I know to be true
3. I take into account the character of the person talking to me.

In the case of God, I examine what He says, I judge it by what I know to be true and I take into account His character.

In considering these three together, I have good reasons to believe that God is not lying to me when we communicate.

What does god sound like?
 
Upvote 0

KTatis

Well-Known Member
Mar 17, 2007
1,302
27
The Heavenly Abode
✟1,923.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
What does god sound like?
This is an interesting conversation. Nice rebuttals on both sides! But i cannot sit by any longer and watch yamaha get double teamed. Its time for me to testify. I also have conversations with God. He talks to you in a way. That would be most pleasant to you. So ergo he could sound like anything or anyone. When i here him talk he sounds like the God in the movie "The Prince of Egypt" and inretrospective you connot know for sure who is lying or not you will have to simply trust them and put your faith in something positive. Believe there us good out there. When you grow to love and trust you will know God isnt a liar. And we know this because the adversary claims the one who speaks the truth is a liar. If everything i told you was the truth and you knew this a man came and said oh he is just a liar dont believe him you are just being brainwashed and blah blah blah. But you know im a man of my word cause i keep my promises. Other people came to you and said yes he is a good man he paid my rent gave me money and expect nothing in return but honesty and loyalty. You messure a man not by the truths and promises but by his faults and when you measure Gods faults and flaws you will not find any this is how you know someone has good intentions. The same can be applied to people good morals and ethics is proof of a good heart.
 
Upvote 0

Non sequitur

Wokest Bae Of The Forum
Jul 2, 2011
4,532
541
Oklahoma City, OK
✟53,280.00
Country
United States
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Constitution
This is an interesting conversation. Nice rebuttals on both sides! But i cannot sit by any longer and watch yamaha get double teamed. Its time for me to testify. I also have conversations with God. He talks to you in a way. That would be most pleasant to you. So ergo he could sound like anything or anyone. When i here him talk he sounds like the God in the movie "The Prince of Egypt" and inretrospective you connot know for sure who is lying or not you will have to simply trust them and put your faith in something positive. Believe there us good out there. When you grow to love and trust you will know God isnt a liar. And we know this because the adversary claims the one who speaks the truth is a liar. If everything i told you was the truth and you knew this a man came and said oh he is just a liar dont believe him you are just being brainwashed and blah blah blah. But you know im a man of my word cause i keep my promises. Other people came to you and said yes he is a good man he paid my rent gave me money and expect nothing in return but honesty and loyalty. You messure a man not by the truths and promises but by his faults and when you measure Gods faults and flaws you will not find any this is how you know someone has good intentions. The same can be applied to people good morals and ethics is proof of a good heart.

Love and trust cannot tell if a deity is lying.

The question is, how could you tell? The foundation used to being able to discern truth from falsehoods cannot start with predefined traits.

"History", "nature" and "experience" cannot be used. Lying and decent can circumvent those by superseding it; one can show a record/history of honestly, yet not be honest. This is your problem.
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
This is an interesting conversation. Nice rebuttals on both sides! But i cannot sit by any longer and watch yamaha get double teamed. Its time for me to testify. I also have conversations with God. He talks to you in a way. That would be most pleasant to you. So ergo he could sound like anything or anyone. When i here him talk he sounds like the God in the movie "The Prince of Egypt" and inretrospective you connot know for sure who is lying or not you will have to simply trust them and put your faith in something positive.
I find this interesting. Why do you have to put your trust and faith in God? If he cannot vindicate himself, even his existence, isn't it more rational to withhold belief?

Believe there us good out there. When you grow to love and trust you will know God isnt a liar. And we know this because the adversary claims the one who speaks the truth is a liar. If everything i told you was the truth and you knew this a man came and said oh he is just a liar dont believe him you are just being brainwashed and blah blah blah. But you know im a man of my word cause i keep my promises. Other people came to you and said yes he is a good man he paid my rent gave me money and expect nothing in return but honesty and loyalty.
That would be grand - we'd have you, a physical person here in front of us, and we'd have testimony arguing for and against your truthfulness. More importantly, we could quantify whether you did, indeed, pay people's rent - a simple bank statement would suffice.

How can we do that with God? When God says "I made the universe", why should we believe him? When God says "Abraham, kill you son", why should we listen?

You messure a man not by the truths and promises but by his faults and when you measure Gods faults and flaws you will not find any
I disagree. God is at fault when he killed all the first-born sons of Egypt, and when he killed all humanity, save eight, in the Flood.

this is how you know someone has good intentions. The same can be applied to people good morals and ethics is proof of a good heart.
What if God lied about being the creator of the universe, but he did it so that people would follow his benevolent laws and guidelines? Unwavering honesty is not always a sign of benevolence, and vice versa.
 
Upvote 0

KTatis

Well-Known Member
Mar 17, 2007
1,302
27
The Heavenly Abode
✟1,923.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Love and trust cannot tell if a deity is lying.

The question is, how could you tell? The foundation used to being able to discern truth from falsehoods cannot start with predefined traits.

"History", "nature" and "experience" cannot be used. Lying and decent can circumvent those by superseding it; one can show a record/history of honestly, yet not be honest. This is your problem.

Yeah youre right but love and trust will guide you. And like i said no one knows who is lying nor being honest thats why you must have faith in something positive. By your logic everyone is a liar therefore trust no one not even God himself. Put your faith in something positive. And yes a record history can determine one is telling the truth if they arr currently being honest at the moment what they are presenting you! and someones nature as well can determine if they are honest cause many peoples nature will not allow them to lie. God dosent lie and "experience" shows us this. He is a loving and caring God he is the creator of all things. He said do himself. Your problem is how do we know this? Well thats the thing no one can know for sure thats why we put our faith in him regardless its true love. You dont know if your parents are actually aliens or robots. Do you know if their actually your parents? Do you know when your real birthday is? You onlu believe what you were told. Do you know your original birth city? Did Charles Darwin exist or was he a mad man apart of a secret society that wanted to lead many people astray and divide the world? Like i said you dont know but you put faith in all these things hoping that they are true. And we do the same but on a grander scale. We put faith in God hoping and praying he will be there for us!


Psalms 14:1 -- The fool[a][bless and do not curse]says in his heart,[bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse]“There is no God.”They are corrupt, their deeds are vile;[bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse]there is no one who does good.
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
Yeah youre right but love and trust will guide you. And like i said no one knows who is lying nor being honest thats why you must have faith in something positive.
I'd prefer to put reasoned belief in something positive - science and medicine, human ingenuity and bravery, etc.

By your logic everyone is a liar therefore trust no one not even God himself.
That's exactly the opposite of what we've said. No one said "everyone is a liar", merely that no one can prove that God always tells the truth (despite the fact that this claim is often made).

Put your faith in something positive. And yes a record history can determine one is telling the truth if they arr currently being honest at the moment what they are presenting you! and someones nature as well can determine if they are honest cause many peoples nature will not allow them to lie. God dosent lie and "experience" shows us this. He is a loving and caring God he is the creator of all things. He said do himself.
Well, that's just he: we have only God's word about this, and God's word, when taken literally, doesn't correlate with what we see.

Your problem is how do we know this? Well thats the thing no one can know for sure thats why we put our faith in him regardless its true love.
But why? I get that you believe in these things by faith, but why do you believe by faith? If there's no reason to believe in something, I simply don't believe in it. I don't understand why anyone would want to believe in something by faith.

You dont know if your parents are actually aliens or robots. Do you know if their actually your parents? Do you know when your real birthday is? You onlu believe what you were told. Do you know your original birth city? Did Charles Darwin exist or was he a mad man apart of a secret society that wanted to lead many people astray and divide the world? Like i said you dont know but you put faith in all these things hoping that they are true. And we do the same but on a grander scale. We put faith in God hoping and praying he will be there for us!
I disagree, and your error is in the difference between certainty beyond all doubt and certainty beyond all reasonable doubt. We do not have 100% certainty beyond all doubt, no, but we do have 99% certainty, which is good enough.

I know beyond all reasonable doubt that I was born in Kent, because there is a consilience of evidence.

Can you say the same for God's claim that he created the universe?
 
Upvote 0

Non sequitur

Wokest Bae Of The Forum
Jul 2, 2011
4,532
541
Oklahoma City, OK
✟53,280.00
Country
United States
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Constitution
Yeah youre right but love and trust will guide you. And like i said no one knows who is lying nor being honest thats why you must have faith in something positive. By your logic everyone is a liar therefore trust no one not even God himself. Put your faith in something positive. And yes a record history can determine one is telling the truth if they arr currently being honest at the moment what they are presenting you! and someones nature as well can determine if they are honest cause many peoples nature will not allow them to lie. God dosent lie and "experience" shows us this. He is a loving and caring God he is the creator of all things. He said do himself. Your problem is how do we know this? Well thats the thing no one can know for sure thats why we put our faith in him regardless its true love. You dont know if your parents are actually aliens or robots. Do you know if their actually your parents? Do you know when your real birthday is? You onlu believe what you were told. Do you know your original birth city? Did Charles Darwin exist or was he a mad man apart of a secret society that wanted to lead many people astray and divide the world? Like i said you dont know but you put faith in all these things hoping that they are true. And we do the same but on a grander scale. We put faith in God hoping and praying he will be there for us!


Psalms 14:1 -- The fool[a][bless and do not curse]says in his heart,[bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse]“There is no God.”They are corrupt, their deeds are vile;[bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse][bless and do not curse]there is no one who does good.

You are kinda shifting the burden of proof and moving the goal posts there.

"God dosent lie and "experience" shows us this. He is a loving and caring God he is the creator of all things. He said do himself"

Well, "he said so himself" is circular reasoning. That's the first problem.

Let me ask it to you this way, how could you tell he is telling the truth?

(Please, no logical fallacies. As you have made many previously, if you do not understand what they are or why they are, I will be happy to tell you.)
 
Upvote 0

Yamaha06R6Guy

Junior Member
Jul 29, 2013
124
0
✟327.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
You are kinda shifting the burden of proof and moving the goal posts there.

"God dosent lie and "experience" shows us this. He is a loving and caring God he is the creator of all things. He said do himself"

Well, "he said so himself" is circular reasoning. That's the first problem.

Let me ask it to you this way, how could you tell he is telling the truth?

(Please, no logical fallacies. As you have made many previously, if you do not understand what they are or why they are, I will be happy to tell you.)


Saying:

I know God is telling the truth because I took Him at His word, trusted Him, asked Him to forgive me of my sins and come into my heart to cleanse me of all unrightesousness and then He did and now I have a personal relationship with Him which grows day by day and each new day I experience His faithfulness in fresh new ways and thus far He has never lied to me but everything He has told me about Himself has been proven true....

Is not arguing in a circle.

It is stating what one has experienced personally as their reason for maintaining God is trustworthy.

It is explaining something that you cannot even begin to understand being the natural man that you are.

If you really are interested in knowing God personally, simply pray that He reveal Himself to you and He will.

But if you are just interested in trying to prove a point, you are going to be sorely disappointed and on top of that, you will be missing the great truth that God Himself wants you to know Him in a special, personal way.
 
Upvote 0

Non sequitur

Wokest Bae Of The Forum
Jul 2, 2011
4,532
541
Oklahoma City, OK
✟53,280.00
Country
United States
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Constitution
Saying:

I know God is telling the truth because I took Him at His word, trusted Him, asked Him to forgive me of my sins and come into my heart to cleanse me of all unrightesousness and then He did and now I have a personal relationship with Him which grows day by day and each new day I experience His faithfulness in fresh new ways and thus far He has never lied to me but everything He has told me about Himself has been proven true....

Is not arguing in a circle.

It is stating what one has experienced personally as their reason for maintaining God is trustworthy.

It is explaining something that you cannot even begin to understand being the natural man that you are.

If you really are interested in knowing God personally, simply pray that He reveal Himself to you and He will.

But if you are just interested in trying to prove a point, you are going to be sorely disappointed and on top of that, you will be missing the great truth that God Himself wants you to know Him in a special, personal way.

No, it is. You just don't see it or won't admit it.

Ok, how's this: Could a god have lied and done all that you mentioned under the pretense of being a good god?

Yes or no.
 
Upvote 0

juvenissun

... and God saw that it was good.
Apr 5, 2007
25,452
805
73
Chicago
✟138,626.00
Country
United States
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Married
You see no dilemma in not being able to tell if a deity was lying?

My decision is irrelevant (although there seems to be a big problem with me not giving mine). I asked a question.

Your solution of how you could tell was convincing yourself. That doesn't answer how you could tell, just how you did.

What tools could you use that could tell if a deity was lying?

Time. That is the only thing you need.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.