I'm basing that off of what the LA Times is saying are the main points of the report. The report isn't out yet, so that is yet to be confirmed, but I'm pretty sure they have it right.
Okay- Hold the phone. You're going to believe the LA Times, who apparently has NOT been given a copy of the report but is instead going off of what someone else has told them, is accurate on what they're reporting??
You realize that at this point, with that report as yet unreleased, you are getting things third and fourth hand, right? And you have played the game of Telephone, right?
Not so fast -- where is the email correspondence from Eric Holder to the ATF bosses, directing traffic on this?
You do realize people erase their emails, especially when they don't want nosy congressmen and senators looking through them, right?
They were insubordinate, calling their own shots, and I'm tellin' ya, Holder had nothing to do with it. I would put money on it, and I would win.
Strong assertion for someone who, as of yet, does not even know whether or not Holder is guilty.
I think there was probably serious hostility to Holder's leadership when the Bush administration became the Obama administration, and furthermore I don't think Holder had a lot of time and energy to reconfigure the ATF's operations to this kind of strategy.
Once more we come to the simple fact that
he would have had to do just that. Requirement of office.
The heads in charge of the operation have rolled, and believe me, any number of people would be screaming right now, if Holder was firing, or allowing to be fired, people who were following his orders.
They have been; and what's more, this happens
all the time.
Did Holder order you to do something illegal, and now you're in trouble? Save a copy of that email, and start saying something about it. See what I mean? Didn't happen.
Again, not so.
I once worked at a company where I was told to do something against company policy. I personally did not realize it was against policy, so I naturally did it. When it all came out, I pointed to the message I had received. The boss didn't have such a message on his computer- So I was the one lying, apparently.
I got fired by the same guy who told me to do the thing he was firing me for.
So, in light of personal experience, your hypothetical situation and resulting conclusion means bupkiss.