Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Go to the post right above you. I have loads more but I need your help with this illustration problem. Help.ThirdAngel said:I whole heartedly agree with you linssue55 about Jesus paying it all for us, and that it is up to us to accept the sacrifice. Theologically, I have no differences with you as to the end results and the means of being saved. I was trying provoke some thought about was what the bible says about what happens after death (This is in no way an attempt to redefine the protestant understanding of salvation).
The bible speaks of death as a "sleep" 52 times. Many people have said that the sleep referred to is the sleep of the body. But the Hebrew word for soul (Nephesh) is the same used for man as it is for animals, and the bible says that our destination at death is the same as that of the animals. The bible also refers to humans as "dust." Such was the case with Adam at creation. When God breathed the breath (Ruwach; Heb. Spirit, breath, wind) of life into Adam, he "became" a living soul (Nephesh).
The Spirit (Ruwach), or breath is not the soul (Nephesh). It is the breath of life given by God which animates the body and makes man a living soul (Nephesh). At death;
...the dust will return to the earth as it was, And the spirit (Ruwach) will return to God who gave it. Eccl. 12:7.
And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living being. Gen. 2:7
If we look at this verse closely, we can see that it is an equation. Dust (body) + Breath of God (Ruwach) = Soul (Nephesh). Likewise;
Soul (Nephesh) - Breath of God (Ruwach) = Dust. This can be likened to a light bulb. The electricity enters the glass and the bulb becomes a light. The bulb is not the light, niether is the electricity the light. The light is a combination of the electricity and the bulb filament. Does the light continue to exist when the electricity is removed? No. But it can be recreated.
As I see it, both saved and unsaved remain in the grave, until they are resurrected (reanimated with the breath of life).
I noticed your flow chart linssue55 showed a state of torment for the unsaved after death prior to the 2nd death. It also mentions that this occurs at the center of the earth. I do not see any evidence for that in the bible. The parable of the rich man and Lazarus is the only scripture I can see which would lead us to believe in a state of torment immediately after death. But if we take the parable (which is an alegory) as doctrine, then we find Jesus contradicting plain statements made about the real Lazarus (Lazarus sleeps...Lazarus is dead). We would also have to conclude that the rich man in the parable had a physical body in hell immediately after death, which would be impossible if we understand the resurrections correctly. Taking a parable literally can be misleading. If we were to do so, we could also come to the conclusion that trees talk, as in the parable in the book of judges.
Your thoughts on these things? I don't want to get too deep with one post.
God bless
I'm afraid I'm not much good at that sort of thing. I haven't experimented much with uploading images.linssue55 said:Go to the post right above you. I have loads more but I need your help with this illustration problem. Help.
Ok, let's first list what you would like to discuss:ThirdAngel said:I whole heartedly agree with you linssue55 about Jesus paying it all for us, and that it is up to us to accept the sacrifice. Theologically, I have no differences with you as to the end results and the means of being saved. I was trying provoke some thought about was what the bible says about what happens after death (This is in no way an attempt to redefine the protestant understanding of salvation).
The bible speaks of death as a "sleep" 52 times. Many people have said that the sleep referred to is the sleep of the body. But the Hebrew word for soul (Nephesh) is the same used for man as it is for animals, and the bible says that our destination at death is the same as that of the animals. The bible also refers to humans as "dust." Such was the case with Adam at creation. When God breathed the breath (Ruwach; Heb. Spirit, breath, wind) of life into Adam, he "became" a living soul (Nephesh).
The Spirit (Ruwach), or breath is not the soul (Nephesh). It is the breath of life given by God which animates the body and makes man a living soul (Nephesh). At death;
...the dust will return to the earth as it was, And the spirit (Ruwach) will return to God who gave it. Eccl. 12:7.
And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living being. Gen. 2:7
If we look at this verse closely, we can see that it is an equation. Dust (body) + Breath of God (Ruwach) = Soul (Nephesh). Likewise;
Soul (Nephesh) - Breath of God (Ruwach) = Dust. This can be likened to a light bulb. The electricity enters the glass and the bulb becomes a light. The bulb is not the light, niether is the electricity the light. The light is a combination of the electricity and the bulb filament. Does the light continue to exist when the electricity is removed? No. But it can be recreated.
As I see it, both saved and unsaved remain in the grave, until they are resurrected (reanimated with the breath of life).
I noticed your flow chart linssue55 showed a state of torment for the unsaved after death prior to the 2nd death. It also mentions that this occurs at the center of the earth. I do not see any evidence for that in the bible. The parable of the rich man and Lazarus is the only scripture I can see which would lead us to believe in a state of torment immediately after death. But if we take the parable (which is an alegory) as doctrine, then we find Jesus contradicting plain statements made about the real Lazarus (Lazarus sleeps...Lazarus is dead). We would also have to conclude that the rich man in the parable had a physical body in hell immediately after death, which would be impossible if we understand the resurrections correctly. Taking a parable literally can be misleading. If we were to do so, we could also come to the conclusion that trees talk, as in the parable in the book of judges.
Your thoughts on these things? I don't want to get too deep with one post.
God bless
I'll get your PM's in my email. Or I'll PM you my adress. But just look at what I posted and comment on that. My observations about the nature of the soul, breath of God and the biblical references to death as a sleep. etc...linssue55 said:Ok, let's first list what you would like to discuss:
From post #19......
1.....Eternal punishment?
2....Heaven?......
3.....Resurrection?.....
Post #23.....
1....Become a living soul?
2......Returns to dust?.....
3.......Lazarus and the rich man?....
I can get with each one of these.......but as for the illustrations, I can e-mail loads of them to you, but I would need your e-mail address. I can't seem to get them to go on here, the illustrations? I wish I could, they are really neat.
GraceInHim said:linssue55 is correct.. love the image *Thumbs up*
lets not forget, an atheist is no lower then one who believes and keeps sinning.. *wink*
From my teachings.......ThirdAngel said:My observations about the nature of the soul, breath of God and the biblical references to death as a sleep. etc...
linssue55 said:From my teachings.......
THE SOUL
SOUL A living substance, simple, bodiless, and invisible by nature, activating the body to which it brings life, growth, sensation and reproduction. The mind is not distinct from the soul but serves as a window to the soul. The soul is free, endowed with will, and the power to act. Along with the body, the soul is created by God in His image. The soul of man will never die (Gen. 1:26; 2:7; Matt. 10:28).
I'll get back with you on Matt 27:52.ThirdAngel said:Thanks linssue55. Let me take this a little at a time. I don't want to cover too much all at once, otherwise thoughts and communications tend to get scattered.
[/font]
Look at Gen. 1:26, 2:7 and Matt. 10:28. Do these verses really say that the soul of man will never die? Matt. 10:28 says that God can destroy the soul. Ezekiel 18:4 says; "The soul that sins shall die." 1 Tim. 6:15-16 says that Jesus the King of kings ALONE has immortality. Whoa, now you take one at a time.I sent you a salvation package, 40 things. We inherit eternal life a the point of salvation....many, many verses......."The soul that sins shall die." .....this is spiritual death, carnal, out of fellowship.
Your definitions are true to our typical understanding, but are not biblical definitions. If you use a concordance or a lexicon, you will see that the Hebrew word for Soul, is "Nephesh." Do they use Isosgogics? with this interpretation?, is it Exegesis from the original language, NOT from the Hebrew of today?
This same word is used to describe animals as in Gen. 1:20; 21 Then God said; "Let the waters abound with living creatures (nephesh')." So God created great sea creatures (nephesh)....and man became a living soul (nephesh). Gen. 2:7......This is the problem when Isogogics are not used, so much can be misinterpreted. Animals do not have souls as we do, only physical life, nor do they have the knowledge or self-conscienceness to make the decision to believe in the Lord, for the Lord only gives people (believers) eternal life, He only died on the cross for people. The breath of life in the Original Hebrew using Isosgoics and Exegesis is Nashemah. He did not breath the breath of life into animals. This is apples and oranges.![]()
Nowhere in scripture can you find an example of a soul being spoken of as being immortal. Refer to salvation package, and other's I have sent.
linssue55, you have been very good about sticking to the bible, but you are bringing in all sorts of extra biblical definitions and presuppositions. Not at all....I use nothing but biblical.....for I would never put in personal oppinion to the word of God, that would be apostate, and evil, I absolutely will not go there. Remember, we cannot acknowledge what we do not understand. Like I said the bible must be interpreted in the time it was written. I will send you one more thing to aid you in understanding of what I am saying. (ICE)
The only human beings who have not tasted death are Moses, Elijah, Enoch and possibly others who John saw in vision who he called the 24 elders in Revelation. I would speculate that they may have been resurrected when Crist was crucified. Ok, now do you agree that the resurrection body cannot die? If you do (I hope you do), then why aren't these men walking the earth right now?The only person that has ever been resurrected is the Lord, for the resurrection body is not subject to death, once it is given by the Lord, it can never die. There will be 2 exceptions, during the tribulation, Moses, and Elijah (now in heaven with the Lord) will NOT recieve their resurrection bodies at the time of the rapture, instead they will be "Resussitated" to come back during the tribulation, to witness to the world. They will be killed, by the anti-christ. Now, if they (Moses) was now resurrected, how could he die during the tribulation?, how could he die again?. He couldn't. The point is after their death's during the tribulation, they will be on display before the world for 3 day's, and the end of the 3 day's, the Lord Resurrects (never to die again) them, all eye's will see. Just as the Lord's body cannot ever die again, because of the resurrection, WE will recieve the same body. Like Lazarus, he was "resussitated" (in the original), but then later died again, for the last time. If he had recieved his resurrection body then, he would be walking around amongst us right now, a 2,000 year old man. He is now in heaven with the Lord, awaiting his resurrection body as the dead in christ, at the time of the rapture.
Matt. 27:52 says that; the graves were opened; and many bodies of the saints who had fallen asleep were raised.
As I have pointed out, the bible refers to death as a sleep 52 times. That is not just something to be shrugged off in favor of definitions derived from ancient Greek or Roman culture. Yes it does, but NONE of them refer to us, we believers have eternal life, at physical death, our soul, and spirit to go be with the Lord, not lying dead in coffins awaiting the resurrection. I sent info on this.
Anyhow, enough for now. Be back tomorrow.
God bless.
[/size][/font]
:: Starlight :: said:Some forms of Christian theology make God seem like an evil, heartless monster who tortures people for eternity just for not believing in him...![]()
Well, no one is perfect, so we all sin... Christians and non-Christians alike.GraceInHim said:He is not at all.. and Jesus loves to find sinners.. for I was a bad one, no better then an athiest.. he will guide more sheep ..![]()
So sad....BUT SO TRUE. No one should ever blame the Lord!Cause said:Caliban:
The Bible makes it quite clear that the suffering and torment of the wicked will be as eternal as the life of the blessed. Jesus Himself said in Matthew 25:46:
And these shall go away into everlasting punishment: but the righteous into eternal life.
Some find the thought of eternal torment of the wicked harsh, but it is really just. You see, when Adam rebelled against God, in effect he was saying that he wanted life without God. He wanted to decide truth for himself, independent of God. That is what sin is - being self-centred rather than God-centred. Thinking, It's all about me. In a similar way, when we reject Christ and His offer of salvation and cling to our sins we are also in effect saying that we want to live independent of God, without Him. Or put in a different way, when we reject Christ we are saying to Him: "Go away Jesus! Don't come here in my life with that torch of yours telling me how to live! Just leave me alone." And, on Judgment Day, God will sadly grant their wish and depart them from Himself. Obviously, the natural alternative of choosing life independent or apart from the eternal life giving source is eternal death (since the soul is eternal). Also, the Bible tells us that all have sinned and deserve eternal condemnation. But God in His grace, has given us a path out of condemnation and into salvation and become a child of God through faith in His Son who died on the cross and rose again for our sins.
Those who reject Christ on Judgment Day will literally get what they have asked for and what they deserve. That is why our mission to save people is very important, because eternity is a long time and I wouldn't want even Hitler to endure that kind of punishment, even though it is what we all ask for and deserve through our unbelief in Christ.
Many people, sadly even Christians, do not understand this and can't reconcile the punishment with a holy, just, and loving God. God has already given them a way out, and if they reject it, as I explained, they are asking for punishment. They literally have themselves to blame as they send themselves to hell (unfortunately).