Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
When one side says your future is preordained, and the other side says our future is up to us, I see no similarities.Then you misunderstand either Calvin or the Bible, for they are the same.
Dispensationalism, really?-This website is defiantly the place to go if you want to find teachings that can help you compare and see Calvinism faults and bad teaching.
Grace Evangelical Society
Here is just few of the many free articles they have on their website and youtube site.
Calvinism Has a Box of Mystery Verses – Grace Evangelical Society
-------------------------
Why Am I a Zero-Point Calvinist? – Grace Evangelical Society
-------------------------
Bible Study Fellowship, Romans, and Calvinism – Grace Evangelical Society
-------------------------
Taking Romans 8:28-30 Back from Calvinism – Grace Evangelical Society
I have looked into Calvinism vs Free Will. The following is a book (now a free online resource) that I wrote backing Free Will. The Way and Free Will You will find many strong arguments against Calvinism come from the Early Church Fathers. I have read word for word most of the Fathers from the first 100 -200 years. They all believed in Free Will salvation, and fought the early Calvinistic belief of Fatalism. ChatGPT assures me that the remaining Church Fathers, up until Augustine, all taught Free Will, or Synergy.Taking a step back from that way of thinking and am looking for different ways of looking at it.
But you believe in open theism so your opinion here is suspect. Do humans have the free will to not sin?I have looked into Calvinism vs Free Will. The following is a book (now a free online resource) that I wrote backing Free Will. The Way and Free Will You will find many strong arguments against Calvinism come from the Early Church Fathers. I have read word for word most of the Fathers from the first 100 -200 years. They all believed in Free Will salvation, and fought the early Calvinistic belief of Fatalism. ChatGPT assures me that the remaining Church Fathers, up until Augustine, all taught Free Will, or Synergy.
If by Open Theism you mean:But you believe in open theism so your opinion here is suspect. Do humans have the free will to not sin?
There's a lot of puffery and weasel words to that. As with other human philosophies that push at the edges of the mystery, you've stumbled into heresy by denying an essential attribute(omniscience).In short, open theism posits that since God and humans are free, God's knowledge is dynamic and God's providence flexible. Whereas several versions of traditional theism picture God's knowledge of the future as a singular, fixed trajectory, open theism sees it as a plurality of branching possibilities, with some possibilities becoming settled as time moves forward.[8][9] Thus, the future, as well as God's knowledge of it, is open (hence, "open" theism).
Open theism is not biblical and can not be discussed in this forum but can only be discussed in the controversial theology room. Open a thread there if you want to discuss it.If by Open Theism you mean:
In short, open theism posits that since God and humans are free, God's knowledge is dynamic and God's providence flexible. Whereas several versions of traditional theism picture God's knowledge of the future as a singular, fixed trajectory, open theism sees it as a plurality of branching possibilities, with some possibilities becoming settled as time moves forward.[8][9] Thus, the future, as well as God's knowledge of it, is open (hence, "open" theism).
A person can not believe in Free Will, unless God's knowledge is open, or God has a mysterious ability to see even future free will choices. Open Theism makes perfect sense for a person who believes in Free Will. It is not some evil doctrine as you suppose it to be.
It is also supported by scripture.
Gen 6:5-7 Then the LORD saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every intent of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually. And the LORD was sorry that He had made man on the earth, and He was grieved in His heart. So the LORD said, "I will destroy man whom I have created from the face of the earth, both man and beast, creeping thing and birds of the air, for I am sorry that I have made them."
I am at work at the moment so don't have the time to reply to the comment about sin. Will do so later.
you've stumbled into heresy by denying an essential attribute (omniscience).
That is just ridiculous, a belief founded on a literal reading of scripture is considered off limits to discussion. I won't be remaining silent in future, just because somebody can't stomach open debate.Open theism is not biblical and can not be discussed in this forum but can only be discussed in the controversial theology room.
From the statement of purpose sticky for general theology.That is just ridiculous, a belief founded on a literal reading of scripture is considered off limits to discussion. I won't be remaining silent in future, just because somebody can't stomach open debate.
Because you are misunderstanding one of them. . .When one side says your future is preordained, and the other side says our future is up to us, I see no similarities.
The fall of Adam was not a neutral event—it was the willful rebellion of man against a holy God.
Did Adam, in your view, have free will in that regards, or was his fall decreed?
Chapter 3 of the Second London Baptist Confession of Faith of 1689 (2LCF) is titled, “Of God’s Decree.” God’s “decree” is His plan or purpose that has existed in His mind from eternity past. Robert Shaw says, “By the decree of God is meant his purpose or determination with respect to future things; or, more fully, his determinate counsel, whereby from all eternity, he fore-ordained whatever he should do, or would permit to be done, in time.”1 The decree is an aspect of God’s internal work, and it therefore precedes any of God’s external works in time and space. God’s external works of creation and providence effectively implement God’s eternal decree.
I really don't understand how someone could possibly find a God who designed atrocities like the holocaust worthy of worship. Your theology turns God into the only sinner, as everyone else does exactly what God intended for them to do.The fall was in God's decree, yes. It was decreed because nothing happens outside of God's decree.
I really don't understand how someone could possibly find a God who designed atrocities like the holocaust worthy of worship. Your theology turns God into the only sinner, as everyone else does exactly what God intended for them to do.
How is something that God designed so that no outher possible thing would happen supposed to reveal why we need such sovereignty? Your twisted view of providence defames the character of God by attributing all sin to Him. You spout off Calvinist proof texts with no concern for the context you rip them out of, and turn God into a moral monster. You speak of humans committing sin and atrocities, but you claim that God has fixed it such that those atrocities were inevitable and somehow His authoring sin, the suffering of innocents, and hell is supposed to bring Him glory? You present Him as worse than the devil.The horror of sin doesn’t disprove God's sovereignty—it reveals why we need it. A theology that only permits a God who never ordains suffering is not biblical; it’s sentimental. The problem isn’t that Reformed theology makes God the "only sinner," but that man refuses to see the depth of his own guilt apart from grace.
Scripture is clear: God is holy, just, and good in all His works—even when He ordains evil for righteous ends. He raised up Pharaoh so that His name would be proclaimed in all the earth (Exodus 9:16, Romans 9:17–18). He predestined the crucifixion of His own Son—“this Jesus, delivered up according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God, you crucified” (Acts 2:23). Do you think the cross was Plan B?
You speak as though God must justify Himself to man. But who are we, O man, to answer back to God? (Romans 9:20). If evil exists apart from God's decree, then it exists outside His control—and that would be a far more terrifying universe.
Yes, humans commit atrocities—and yes, they are morally responsible for them. That’s the point. We’re not good people making mistakes. We are fallen creatures in need of sovereign mercy. The “free will” most appeal to is the very thing enslaved to sin unless God intervenes (John 8:34, Romans 3:10–18). And He has intervened—in Christ, to redeem a people for Himself out of this broken world. A multitude no one can number (Revelation 7:9).
The wonder isn’t that God allows sin and judgment—but that He saves anyone at all.
Ok, I think this will be helpful to understanding where you are coming from. There are actually various views within Calvinism.Adam and Eve were created upright—but mutable (able to fall).
The fall was in God's decree, yes. It was decreed because nothing happens outside of God's decree.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?