Antisemetism

[Chesterton]

Right, it had to do with them being labelled antisemitic. Naturally, Israel tends to come up, especially these days in a conversation involving that word.

It did not come up "naturally". You just inserted it where it didn't belong.

 

[truthpls]

It did not come up "naturally". You just inserted it where it didn't belong.

I disagree. In the case of the US leader, for example in the article, she was called antisemetic because of her reaction to Gaza protests. Sorry you seek to divorce the issue.

 

[Yeshua HaDerekh]

Is it supposed to be some negative thing? Relevant thing? Or just some random words?

I thought it might be relevant...

 

[truthpls]

I thought it might be relevant...

Some people were basically calling the Palestinians, or many of them savages here. Then we saw Gen brought up. Is there some connection? What would be the point of looking at Gen, who exactly does it apply to in the situation at hand here, and how? If you have some valid point, make it.

 

[Yeshua HaDerekh]

Some people were basically calling the Palestinians, or many of them savages here. Then we saw Gen brought up. Is there some connection? What would be the point of looking at Gen, who exactly does it apply to in the situation at hand here, and how? If you have some valid point, make it.

I think the scripture and 10/7 speaks for themselves..

 

[truthpls]

I think the scripture and 10/7 speaks for themselves..

No point then. OK

 

[ozso]

Americans and others face abuse also. They are partners in crime with the state of Israel. Now if some Canadian or American or other westerners make it clear they do not agree with what their nations support, I would guess they could face less abuse.

No. Jews are being bullied and marginalized because they are Jews.

 

[truthpls]

No Jews are being bullied and marginalized because they are Jews.

So is that what we should call decimating a prison camp city, bullying it? Or are only one race bullied? Would it be antisemetic to acknowledge that masses are being slaughtered? Do you think the world should hold up such mass murder of children as honourable and noble?

 

[ozso]

So is that what we should call decimating a prison camp city, bullying it? Or are only one race bullied? Would it be antisemetic to acknowledge that masses are being slaughtered? Do you think the world should hold up such mass murder of children as honourable and noble?

Jewish citizens of the Western world who are being bullied and marginalized have absolutely nothing to do with what's going on in the Middle-East.

 

[truthpls]

Jewish citizens of the Western world who are being bullied and marginalized have absolutely nothing to do with what's going on in the Middle-East.

The children being mass murdered in Palestine have absolutely nothing to do with what's going on in the Middle-East. You have not posted the example of "Jewish citizens of the Western world who are being bullied"? If a protest of the slaughter gets shut down would that be getting bullied? If someone lost their position due to some phony two bit antisemitism false charge is that being bullied? If people who support the genocide really were getting bullied, would you say it is disproportionate to the number of people getting bullied who are against the slaughter? Perhaps you think everyone against seeing children be killed and mutilated is 'antisemetic'?

 

[ozso]

The children being mass murdered in Palestine have absolutely nothing to do with what's going on in the Middle-East. You have not posted the example of "Jewish citizens of the Western world who are being bullied"?

The situation going on in the US, UK, Canada and elsewhere has been widely reported in the news for a long time. If you're completely unaware of what's going on then I'm not going to keep going over this with you until I have you up to speed.

 

[ozso]

Some people were basically calling the Palestinians, or many of them savages here.

Terrorist organizations like Hamas are being called savage.

 

[truthpls]

The situation going on in the US, UK, Canada and elsewhere has been widely reported in the news for a long time. If you're completely unaware of what's going on then I'm not going to keep going over this with you until I have you up to speed.

It seems to loom large in your head. Have you seen this firsthand? I think for the groups protesting the slaughter, they have experienced firsthand in many cases being silenced or called slanderous names like antisemitic. I know Jewish people and have not heard of some bullying going on?

 

[truthpls]

Terrorist organizations like Hamas are being called savage.

Because they kill civilians. So if the shoe fits I guess the people killing civilians in great numbers need to wear it right? Or would that be 'antisemitic' to imagine?

 

[ozso]

It seems to loom large in your head.

No. It's just something I see in the news. There's no need for ad hominem histrionics.

Have you seen this firsthand?

I've seen firsthand news reports. Are you seeing what's going on in the Middle-East firsthand? Are you there seeing it for yourself? If not then don't use firsthand experience as a qualifier for being aware.

I think for the groups protesting the slaughter, they have experienced firsthand in many cases being silenced or called slanderous names like antisemitic.

You're saying Palestinians from Palestine are coming over to the US, UK, Canada etc to protest? Most of the bullying and marginalizing of Jews in the West is being done by non-Palestinian non-Muslim leftists.

I know Jewish people and have not heard of some bullying going on?

That question doesn't make any sense to me.

 

[Tinker Grey]

No Jews are being bullied and marginalized because they are Jews.

Did you mean that? Or did you mean: "No, Jews are being bullied and marginalized because they are Jews."

Punctuation is important.

 

[ozso]

Because they kill civilians. So if the shoe fits I guess the people killing civilians in great numbers need to wear it right? Or would that be 'antisemitic' to imagine?

Again, Jews living in the West are not citizens of Israel. It's the same thing as the the Islamophobic practice of blaming Muslims living in the West for the 9/11 attacks.

 

[ozso]

Did you mean that? Or did you mean: "No, Jews are being bullied and marginalized because they are Jews."

Punctuation is important.

 

[Robban]

Did you mean that? Or did you mean: "No, Jews are being bullied and marginalized because they are Jews."

Punctuation is important.

Clearly, as your example shows.

 

[Tinker Grey]

Clearly, as your example shows.

Or,

1. It's hot, Tinker
   vs.
2. It's hot Tinker.

I'd like to think #2 is true, but alas ...