A black hole does not exist...if you're near it.

timewerx

the village i--o--t--
Aug 31, 2012
15,280
5,908
✟300,088.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Single
I've been thinking again.

If objects contract in length near a black hole due to change in space-time curvature (General Relativity) as seen by a far far away observer, then the far away observer would also see the object had increased density due to contraction.

The outside observer would also see the same thing happening to the black hole itself. The radius contracted due to space-time curvature and would see the Black Hole completely inside the Event Horizon.

However, a "local observer" or someone much closer to the black hole experiencing well inside the extreme space-time curvature conditions would not observe the same extent of contraction and whatever mass there is inside the "Event Horizon" (being seen or calculated by the far away observer) would be well outside of it.

The "uncontracted" collection of mass from a local observer is not dense enough to form an Event Horizon or a Black Hole. Far from it. The density may even be low. Due to this space time curvature, it would be impossible for any object to keep on collapsing until it becomes a black hole.

No Event Horizon, no Black Hole. Of course, this doesn't meant light or photons "can" escape that region of space outsiders see as a black hole. Light could escape but due to extreme time dilation, no one would be around alive to observe light finally escape a black hole. It's just like winning a race only nobody's around to acknowledge your victory!^_^

So it would seem black hole only exists if you're far away. Get close enough and the Event Horizon is gone, no black hole and you can clearly see what's in the middle! And there would be no singularity either. In a stellar size black hole, you'll probably see a glowing nebula at the center with a dense, compact, luminous object at the middle of it, probably a neutron star and even condensed matter like brown dwarfs and even planets. For supermassive black holes, you may even see a handful of stars with possibly habitable planets thriving in this isolated world that had condensed from the matter consumed by black holes. For the really big ones, it may even be possible see a few small galaxies inside.

This may yet be the best evidence that our Universe itself may be one giant black hole we live in. Notice the line outlining the higher intensity cosmic background radiation. That could as well be the matter/radiation accreting into our own "Universe Black Hole" from an outside, even much bigger "Macro Universe" and it would be wise to train our most powerful telescopes in that region of space!

Planck-satellite--enhance-004.jpg
 

Petros2015

Well-Known Member
Jun 23, 2016
5,097
4,328
52
undisclosed Bunker
✟290,062.00
Country
United States
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
So it would seem black hole only exists if you're far away. Get close enough and the Event Horizon is gone, no black hole and you can clearly see what's in the middle!

Sounds similar to Death.

"So it would seem death only exists if you're far away. Get close enough and the threshold is gone, no Death and you can clearly see what's beyond it."

But in both cases, you ain't coming back again ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: timewerx
Upvote 0

FrumiousBandersnatch

Well-Known Member
Mar 20, 2009
15,264
8,058
✟326,861.00
Faith
Atheist
I've been thinking again.

If objects contract in length near a black hole due to change in space-time curvature (General Relativity) as seen by a far far away observer, then the far away observer would also see the object had increased density due to contraction.

The outside observer would also see the same thing happening to the black hole itself. The radius contracted due to space-time curvature and would see the Black Hole completely inside the Event Horizon.

However, a "local observer" or someone much closer to the black hole experiencing well inside the extreme space-time curvature conditions would not observe the same extent of contraction and whatever mass there is inside the "Event Horizon" (being seen or calculated by the far away observer) would be well outside of it.

The "uncontracted" collection of mass from a local observer is not dense enough to form an Event Horizon or a Black Hole. Far from it. The density may even be low. Due to this space time curvature, it would be impossible for any object to keep on collapsing until it becomes a black hole.

No Event Horizon, no Black Hole. Of course, this doesn't meant light or photons "can" escape that region of space outsiders see as a black hole. Light could escape but due to extreme time dilation, no one would be around alive to observe light finally escape a black hole. It's just like winning a race only nobody's around to acknowledge your victory!^_^

So it would seem black hole only exists if you're far away. Get close enough and the Event Horizon is gone, no black hole and you can clearly see what's in the middle! And there would be no singularity either. In a stellar size black hole, you'll probably see a glowing nebula at the center with a dense, compact, luminous object at the middle of it, probably a neutron star and even condensed matter like brown dwarfs and even planets. For supermassive black holes, you may even see a handful of stars with possibly habitable planets thriving in this isolated world that had condensed from the matter consumed by black holes. For the really big ones, it may even be possible see a few small galaxies inside.

This may yet be the best evidence that our Universe itself may be one giant black hole we live in. Notice the line outlining the higher intensity cosmic background radiation. That could as well be the matter/radiation accreting into our own "Universe Black Hole" from an outside, even much bigger "Macro Universe" and it would be wise to train our most powerful telescopes in that region of space!

Planck-satellite--enhance-004.jpg
An infalling observer won't "clearly see what's in the middle" because there is no 'middle', and inside the EH, all light paths are towards the future 'singularity', i.e. away from you.
 
Upvote 0