Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
No it doesn't. Again, slaves in Egypt...Again, Shabbat was NOT created at Sinai. Actually Ezekiel 20:12 proves my point!
LOL no it is not a lie! Have you never read Bereshit? Genesis. IT WAS GIVEN AS A SIGN AT SINAI! HOW MANY TIMES MUST I REPEAT THIS TO YOU????? AGAIN, it was made for MAN. He did not specifically say is was made for JEWS, did he... OY VEY!
What does them being slaves in Egypt have to do with them not knowing about the sabbath? Were they not circumcised? Didn’t Abraham keep God’s commandments? So how did the commandment to be circumcised get passed on but not the commandment to observe the sabbath?
So you’re saying that they already knew about the sabbath before their exodus? Nehemiah said they didn’t know about it. How can God make it known to them if they already knew about it and why is God testing them to see whether or not they will keep it if they were already supposed to be keeping it?
Actually the repeating record was you and until now you have not posted a cohesive argument. As I stated before opinion is not evidence.
The question is was work done as slaves on the Sabbath? Yes? There is your answer. No? There is your answer..
Did I say that? I said they were slaves in Egypt. For 400 years! How many generations is that? Did the Egyptians keep the Sabbath? No? So then what about the Hebrews? No? Did Moshe know he was a Hebrew or did he think he was an Egyptian?
Ok I have another question, what were the animals made for? They were made at creation yet man wasn’t allowed to eat them until Noah.
Abel was a shepherd....Noah was allowed to eat EVERY moving thing that lives (clean and unclean)...likely because he saved all animals. Can't eat blood though. Wow that was before Sinai! Noahide Torah! I don't see the relevance of your logic (or lack thereof) and how this relates to the Sabbath. The Sabbath was not created at Sinai. It was given as a SIGN at Sinai. And as SabbathBlessings said, and I have multiple times before, the Sabbath was practiced before ever setting foot at Sinai...(Exodus 16:23)
What verse did you read that told you that Noah was allowed to eat everything that moves? Was it this verse?
Jesus never said the animals were made for mankind to eat.
Not knowing something and not being allowed to do it are two completely different things. They were only slaves for one generation, it’s not as if this was going on for thousands of years.
Jesus is referring back to Creation when mankind Gen1:26 and the Sabbath Mark2:27 Exo20:11 and was made. At Creation before the fall, it doesn't say animals was made to be eaten at Creation. This was only a result of sin.
They were not slaves for 400 years you need to read Exodus again. They lived in Egypt as guests until the Pharaoh that Joseph served died then a new Pharaoh took over and enslaved the Jews. Then when that Pharaoh died and the next Pharaoh took over that’s when God used Moses to take them out of Egypt. Moses was born during the reign of the Pharaoh that enslaved the Israelites and found the burning bush when he was 80 years old. What you’re referring to is the sojourning that took place after Abraham when Issac and Jacob were sojourning in foreign lands as well as the enslavement of the Jews by the Egyptians. All of those are added together in Genesis 15:13.
No Jesus is referring to why the sabbath was created not when it was given to man. In the discussion, when the sabbath was created doesn’t answer the question why his disciples were breaking it. Why the sabbath was created does answer the question why his disciples were breaking it. When God made the sabbath is irrelevant if He hadn’t made it known to man yet.
You’re arguing that the animals were created apart from God’s omniscience and omnipresence. God NEVER intended for man to continue to live in the garden of Eden, that’s why the book of life was written BEFORE creation because Christ’s redemptive plan existed before creation which obviously involved the fall.
I would also point out that His plans never change either.
I don’t know why you’re bringing up Exodus 16 as if I was unaware of it while I’ve been asking you over and over why God was testing them in Exodus 16 to see whether or not they would obey the sabbath command if they were already supposed to be observing before chapter 16. I still don’t recall you answering that question other than claiming that they somehow forgot yet they didn’t seem to forget any of God’s other commandments like circumcision or murder.
You are assuming God giving commandments means people automatically are keeping them. It was answered The Sabbath, Worship and the End Time
