- Apr 18, 2020
- 2,972
- 913
- Country
- South Africa
- Faith
- Christian
- Marital Status
- Married
I understand what you are saying. As you know I do not believe and have never believed that Satan was bound at Calvary. He was utterly and totally defeated at Calvary, but he has been deceiving the nations ever since (and even the church where he can), so his binding is not yet.You were saying something about this in an earlier post as well. What I would point out here, is this. The NHNE is what contains the new Jerusalem and not, they are one and the same. The reason I mention this, it would be the NJ that resembles the garden of Eden. In the garden of Eden the fall took place inside. satan was inside the garden of Eden. Per what Revelation 20 records, satan and those he deceives, are not anyone in the NJ nor is satan or anyone he deceives, inside of the NJ at the time. They are outside of it, thus it is an attack from the outside and not from within instead.
In the garden of Eden it was the ones inside that were being deceived. Currently pretty much everyone on the planet, except for saved Christians, are deceived and have continued to be deceived for the past 2000 years. This alone has Amil making no sense, as if satan is going to deceive the already deceived once he is loosed, as if that is supposed to make sense. Per Premil not one single person will be deceived during the thousand years, thus plenty of ppl for satan to deceive after the thousand years who are not deceived during the thousand years. Per Premil then, the logic is that satan deceives those no longer deceived. Per Amil, the logic is that satan deceives those already deceived. Are Amils instead going to argue that satan deceives the already saved when he is loosed? Are Amils going to argue that anyone who is not saved, that they are not deceived?
Revelation 20:7 And when the thousand years are expired, Satan shall be loosed out of his prison,
8 And shall go out to deceive the nations which are in the four quarters of the earth, Gog and Magog, to gather them together to battle: the number of whom is as the sand of the sea.
You don't deceive someone already deceived, you deceive someone not deceived. Only per Premil are these in verse 8 not deceived during the thousand years. The reason they are not deceived is because Christ and His saints are ruling over the entire planet during the thousand years, thus no deceivers trying to deceive them any longer, not until satan is loosed. During Amils' proposed thousand years there are deceivers throughout the entire thousand years. Even Amils can't deny this. Or if they do they shouldn't be.
The problem comes with this:
You admitted that you also see the NHNE as immediately following the return of Christ when I mentioned what I saw in the Revelation which suggests that it does.
But here's the problem: If the "thousand years" (+ its close) takes place in the NHNE (i.e if the NHNE and the "thousand years" follows immediately after the return of Christ), then the thousand years cannot be literal, because such a thing as a thousand literal years is impossible in eternity (How long is "a thousand years" in eternity, or what percentage of eternity is it? Is it 0.00000000........000000000000001% of eternity? If not, then what fraction of eternity is it?)
"A fraction of eternity" is meaningless, because it cannot be measured and the moment you divide eternity into "a fraction of eternity" + "the rest of eternity" you no longer have eternity, but time.
So if the NHNE follows immediately after the return of Christ and the "thousand years" follows the return of Christ, then the "thousand years" cannot be literal.
All this is a big problem if our theory (regarding the NHNE and the thousand years both following immediately after the return of Christ) were true, because then we will have Satan deceiving the nations in eternity after having been bound for a symbolic "thousand years" in eternity (because a literal "thousand years" in eternity is an oxymoron).
Upvote
0