The "other sheep" could simply be the Gentiles, Jesus did not preach to them in His ministry, save one incident of some Greeks who came to Jesus.
The Bible records only that Jesus appears in Jerusalem and Gallilee after resurrection.
Whether road to Damascus appearance to Paul was simply in vision is sort of vague; Paul's companions heard a voice but didn't see a light, or vice-versa, or heard but didn't understand...
That Jesus appeared in America is speculation - He COULD HAVE appeared in Tokyo and preached to Godzilla, He might have appeared on Venus and preached to extraterrestials - where does it all end?
C. S. Lewis wrote in Perelandra of the unfallen "Adam and Eve" on Venus - but that was science fiction.
And so does some JS WRITINGS seem to be to me.
The Bible does not say that Jesus DID NOT appear all over the world to Toltecs and Mayans and Siberians; but it does say that Heaven has received Him until the restitution of all things, which I feel has not happened yet.[/QUOTE]
The "other sheep" could simply be the Gentiles, Jesus did not preach to them in His ministry, save one incident of some Greeks who came to Jesus.
John 10:16 King James Version (KJV)
16 And other sheep I have, which are not of this fold: them also I must bring, and they shall hear my voice; and there shall be one fold, and one shepherd.
Key words for our discussion is "they shall hear my voice". Yes there were a couple of special incidents inn the bible that Jesus talked with gentiles, but "they" collectively did not hear his voice. Another reason that the gentiles did not "hear his voice", is because Jesus was sent to the House of Israel, and from that people should the gentiles be taught the gospel, but not Jesus particularly.
Interestingly enought, and think about this, the people of the BOM were of the House of Israel. They were not from Judah (Jews), but they were from Joseph. So Jesus had an interest in them as well as the House of Israel in Jerusalem.
There are other places were his sheep are too, and it is plausible that he visited other places on the earth that have not come to our knowledge yet. Remember the lost tribes of the House of Israel.
The key is: they, the House of Israel, his sheep in several folds, will hear his voice and they shall evetually be one fold with one shepherd.
So the other sheep are not gentiles or Tokyo or Venus, because they are not of the House of Israel, but the BOM people in the America's, yes, they are of the House of Israel.