The Arrogance Of Religion
Picking up my copy of Karl Barth’s Commentary on Romans, as I often do, I just opened it up at random, and began to read when the phrase, “the arrogance of religion” caught my attention. I believe, from my recollection of that moment, Barth repeated himself in a short context. Whatever one might think of the man who was considered the greatest theologian of the twentieth century, one would have to admit from even a cursory reading of Barth, that he, in the strongest language, exposed the difference between God and what religion presumes to know and declare of Him. According to Barth, there is between the two a vast and deep chasm.
Sometimes the arrogance of religion is just plain out-in-the-open apparent.
J. B. Phillips took that arrogance to task noting that God doesn’t not fit in our conceptual box(es), declaring appropriately, that our God (the God according to us) is too small. Yes, I’m generalizing when I say, “our” and “us,” because the indictment is applicable to all in some measure or another since we all have an inclination toward the kind of presumption, as the story goes, of a child telling her teacher that she was drawing a picture of God. “But, no one knows what God looks like,” explained the teacher.
Nonplused at that claim, the child said, “well they will when I’m through.” Yep, that sums up the arrogance of religion.
But it’s not always just plain out-in-the-open apparent; it’s more, as the saying goes, hidden in plain sight… -John Gavazzoni
-Continued below-
The Arrogance of Religion