- Jan 12, 2014
- 7,222
- 5,564
- Country
- United States
- Gender
- Male
- Faith
- Non-Denom
- Marital Status
- Married
The argument is circumcision unto salvation... or circumcision unto joining the family of God. This was a well known argument in that day, Acts 15:1-2 begin with it... and the decision by the Acts 15 Council @Radagast was turning back a 50 year old argument between Hillel and Shammai. Hillel (whose school taught "Spirit of the law" )believed that a new convert should only have the 4 things mentioned in the Acts 15 letter... the same 4 things. Shammai (whose school taught "letter of the law") accepted those 4 things but ADDED the need to recite all 613 commands AND be circumcised immediately. Shammai's position was accepted by the Jews at that time (between 10-20BC) and that was halacha... Jewish law at that time. Paul and the rest of the Jerusalem Council, took the softer position with the understanding that this was simply a starting point and that one would learn as they continued on their journey. This is why at the end of the Acts 15 letter it says, "And Moses (an idiomatic reference to God's Law) is read in the synagogues every Shabbat." In other words... start with these 4 things and go learn the rest.Men are NOT circumcised unless they are not Jewish and are converting to Judaism. So he is telling GENTILES not to get circumcised and the belief that converting to Judaism will bring salvation.
There is no historical argument for the dispensational position of today. You (Radagast) are welcome to believe whatever you want, but historically, the first Christians (who were Jews, the message went into the nations after Yeshua's death and of course by foot so SLOWLY at first) believed in Yeshua as messiah AND remained zealous for the law (Acts 21:20). In fact, the word for "many thousands" in Acts 21:20 is murias which is the Greek word for 10,000 and it is in PLURAL which means AT LEAST 20,000 of the 80,000 Jews in and around Jerusalem accepted Yeshua as Messiah AND continued walking in Torah. That isn't how it is taught today, but that is the truth.
Upvote
0