• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

  • CF has always been a site that welcomes people from different backgrounds and beliefs to participate in discussion and even debate. That is the nature of its ministry. In view of recent events emotions are running very high. We need to remind people of some basic principles in debating on this site. We need to be civil when we express differences in opinion. No personal attacks. Avoid you, your statements. Don't characterize an entire political party with comparisons to Fascism or Communism or other extreme movements that committed atrocities. CF is not the place for broad brush or blanket statements about groups and political parties. Put the broad brushes and blankets away when you come to CF, better yet, put them in the incinerator. Debate had no place for them. We need to remember that people that commit acts of violence represent themselves or a small extreme faction.

North Korean SF Insurgency In The South

Verv

Senior Veteran
Apr 17, 2005
7,277
672
Gyeonggido
✟40,959.00
Country
Korea, Republic Of
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
An inside look of what happened during the May 18th 1980 uprising in Kwangju, South Korea, commonly known as the ‘Kwangju Massacre.’ Public information has finally come to that at the time North Korea was ready for full scale invasion and even had special forces members amongst the rebel crowd of Kwangju:
&#48513;&#54620;&#44400; &#53945;&#49688;&#48512;&#45824; &#52636;&#49888;&#51032; &#53448;&#48513;&#51088; &#47784;&#51076;&#51064; ‘&#51088;&#50976;&#48513;&#54620;&#44400;&#51064;&#50672;&#54633;’(&#45824;&#54364; &#51076;&#52380;&#50857;·&#51204; &#44368;&#46020;&#51648;&#46020;&#44397; 19&#50668;&#45800; 2&#45824;&#45824;· &#44228;&#44553; &#49345;&#50948;)&#51008; 20&#51068; &#50724;&#51204; &#49436;&#50872; &#51221;&#46041; &#49464;&#49892;&#47112;&#49828;&#53664;&#46993;&#50640;&#49436; &#44592;&#51088;&#54924;&#44204;&#51012; &#44054;&#44256; &#51648;&#45212; 80&#45380; &#48156;&#49373;&#54620; 5.18 &#44305;&#51452;&#49324;&#53468; &#45817;&#49884; &#48513;&#54620;&#44400; &#44060;&#51077;&#51032; &#49892;&#49345;&#51012; &#45233;&#45233;&#51060; &#44277;&#44060;&#54664;&#45796;. &#50500;&#47000;&#45716; &#51060;&#45216; &#44592;&#51088;&#54924;&#44204;&#51012; &#51452;&#52572;&#54620; &#51076;&#52380;&#50857; &#50472;&#51032; &#51613;&#50616;&#51012; &#50836;&#50557;&#54620; &#44163;&#51060;&#45796;. <&#54200;&#51665;&#51088; &#51452;>


(A North Korean refugee who was in a Special Forces unit recently came out and talked about the ‘Free North Korean Soldiers’ participated. The representative who confirmed it was Yim Cheonyong, former member of the 19th Brigade, 2nd Battalion, a high ranking officer) announced on the 20th in Seoul at a meeting at the Saehil Press Meeting that in the May 18th, 1980 Gwangju uprising North Korean special forces participated, revealing details of the incident.)


&#44608;&#51068;&#49457;, &#44608;&#51221;&#51068;&#51008; &#44592;&#54924;&#44032; &#51080;&#51012; &#46412;&#47560;&#45796; &#49900;&#48373;&#46308;&#50640;&#44172; “&#50672;&#48169;&#51228; &#53685;&#51068;&#51008; &#54217;&#54868;&#51201; &#48169;&#48277;&#51004;&#47196; &#44032;&#45733;&#54624;&#51648; &#47784;&#47476;&#45208; &#45224;&#51312;&#49440; &#54785;&#47749;&#51008; &#54253;&#47141;&#51201; &#48169;&#48277;&#51060; &#50500;&#45768;&#44256;&#45716; &#48520;&#44032;&#45733;&#54616;&#45796;. &#54217;&#54868;&#51201; &#48169;&#48277;&#51008; &#54872;&#49345;&#50640; &#51648;&#45208;&#51648; &#50506;&#45716;&#45796;”&#44256; &#44053;&#51312;&#54644;&#50772;&#45796;.


(Kim Il-sung and Kim Jong-il, whenever they had free moments, would tell to their admirers that ‘Federal, peaceful reunification of Korea may not be possible and reunification without a violent South Korean revolution may be impossible. Let’s not hallucinate that peaceful revolution will lead to reunification.’)


&#45224;&#54620; &#45236; &#52828;&#48513;&#49464;&#47141;&#46308;&#51060; &#48120;&#44400; &#44592;&#51648;&#47484; &#44277;&#44201;&#54616;&#47728; &#48120;&#44400;&#52384;&#49688;&#47484; &#51452;&#51109;&#54616;&#45716; &#51665;&#54924;&#45208; 4.19&#45208; &#44305;&#51452;&#48393;&#44592;&#52376;&#47100; &#48124;&#51452;·&#54217;&#54868;·&#51088;&#51452;&#47484; &#50808;&#52824;&#45716; &#44201;&#47148;&#54620; &#49884;&#50948;&#44032; &#51204;&#44397;&#51012; &#46244; &#45934;&#51012; &#46412; &#48124;&#51452;·&#50528;&#44397;&#53804;&#49324;&#46308;&#51012; &#44396;&#54620;&#45796;&#45716; &#47749;&#48516;&#51004;&#47196; &#47924;&#47141; &#44060;&#51077;&#54620;&#45796;&#45716; &#51204;&#47029;&#51060;&#45796;.


(If the North Korean sympathizers in South Korea were to attack American bases while insisting on an American withdrawal in various gathering, it would be like the 4.19 (1960) uprising of Gwangju where the people filled the streets screaming for democracy, peace, and autonomy; the entire nation would be thrown into a wave of protests and during this time the North Korean military forces would tactically intervene and seek out the Democratic and P
atriotic [south Korean loyalist] fighters.)


&#50669;&#45824; &#45224;&#54620;&#50640;&#49436; &#48268;&#50612;&#51652; &#53356;&#44256; &#51089;&#51008; &#48520;&#54665;&#54620; &#49324;&#44148;&#46308;&#50640;&#45716; &#48736;&#51664;&#50630;&#51060; &#48513;&#54620;&#51060; &#51649;·&#44036;&#51217;&#51201;&#51004;&#47196; &#44060;&#51077;&#54644;&#50772;&#45796;.


(Generation after generation of large and small incidences and the complete and thorough presence of North Korean worker-spies would lead to these goals.)


“&#48513;&#54620;&#44400; &#53945;&#49688;&#48512;&#45824; &#44305;&#51452;&#49324;&#53468; &#44060;&#51077; &#44277;&#44277;&#50672;&#54620; &#48708;&#48128;”

(”The North Korean Special Forces presence was a publicly known secret”)


&#45796; &#47480; &#44163;&#51008; &#51217;&#50612; &#46160;&#44256;&#46972;&#46020; &#54620;&#44397; &#48124;&#51452;&#54868;&#50868;&#46041;&#51032; &#49345;&#51669;&#51064; 5.18&#44305;&#51452;&#48124;&#51473;&#54637;&#51137;&#51032; &#44221;&#50864;&#50640;&#46020; &#54788;&#50669; &#48513;&#54620;&#44400; &#52636;&#49888;&#46308;, &#53945;&#55176; &#53945;&#49688;&#48512;&#45824; &#52636;&#49888;&#46308;&#51008; &#48513;&#54620;&#44400; &#51221;&#50696; &#53945;&#49688;&#48512;&#45824;&#44032; &#53804;&#51077;&#46096;&#45796;&#45716; &#51221;&#46020;&#45716; &#45796; &#50508;&#44256; &#51080;&#45716; &#49324;&#49892;&#51060;&#45796;. &#45796;&#51020;&#51008; &#44608;&#51068;&#49457;&#51060; 76&#45380; 8&#50900;, &#44536;&#47532;&#44256; 80&#45380; 5&#50900; &#45824;&#45224;&#44277;&#51089;&#50896;&#46308;&#50640;&#44172; &#45236;&#47536; &#48708;&#48128;&#51648;&#47161;&#51032; &#51204;&#47928;&#51060;&#45796;.


(If you look at what happened in the 5.18 incident in Kwangju, amongst the citizens protesting there were paid North Korean soldiers, particularly those from Special Forces and even the most elite Special Forces units, as you all know. During this time Kim Il-sung in August of 1976 [August 18th, 1976 was the famous Panmunjeom Axe incident] and also in May of 1980 [Gwangju Massacre] gave secret orders to all of the agents involved in trying to construct the revolution in the South, which were: [NOTE: this is only a copy of the 1980 orders])


[&#48708;&#48128;&#51648;&#47161;1] “&#45224; &#51312;&#49440;&#50640;&#49436; &#45432;&#46041;&#51088;&#46308;&#51060; &#46300;&#46356;&#50612; &#46308;&#44256; &#51068;&#50612;&#45228;&#49845;&#45768;&#45796;. &#49324;&#48513; &#53444;&#44305;&#51032; &#50976;&#54792;&#49324;&#53468;&#45716; &#48152;&#49464;&#44592;&#50640; &#44152;&#52828; &#49885;&#48124;&#51648; &#53685;&#52824;&#51032; &#54596;&#50672;&#51201; &#49328;&#47932;&#51060;&#47728; &#51064;&#44036; &#51060;&#54616;&#51032; &#52380;&#45824;&#50752; &#47736;&#49884; &#49549;&#50640;&#49436; &#49888;&#51020;&#54616;&#45912; &#45432;&#46041;&#51088;&#46308;&#51032; &#49939;&#51060;&#44256; &#49939;&#51064; &#50872;&#48516;&#51032; &#54253;&#48156;&#51077;&#45768;&#45796;. &#45224;&#51312;&#49440; &#54785;&#47749;&#44032;&#46308;&#44284; &#51648;&#54616;&#54785;&#47749; &#51312;&#51649;&#46308;&#51008; &#51060;&#48264; &#49324;&#48513; &#49324;&#53468;&#44032; &#51204;&#44397;&#51004;&#47196; &#54869;&#49328;&#46104;&#46020;&#47197; &#51201;&#44537; &#48520;&#51012; &#48537;&#51060;&#44256; &#52397;&#45380;&#54617;&#49373;&#46308;&#44284; &#46020;&#49884; &#48712;&#48124; &#46321; &#44033;&#44228;&#44033;&#52789;&#51032; &#44305;&#48276;&#54620; &#48124;&#51473;&#46308;&#51032; &#50672;&#45824; &#53804;&#51137;&#51012; &#51312;&#51649; &#51204;&#44060;&#54644; &#45908; &#44201;&#47148;&#54620; &#51204;&#48124; &#54637;&#51137;&#51004;&#47196; &#45132;&#50612;&#50732;&#47140;&#50556; &#54633;&#45768;&#45796;.”


(Secret Order #1: At last the South Korean proletariat is waking up. The pivotal point was the bloody coal miner’s protest (April 1980), in which the fifty years of pent up rage produced from the colonial oppression, from which the contempt and scorn of the worker the belief of the proletariat piled up and so did the righteous indignation of the proletariat explode. And now, we must take the incidences from the Coal Mine strike and increase them to every level of the nation, with the South Korean revolutionaries and underground revolutionary network, bringing it forth to the youthful students, the impoverished of the city and to every single industry and class, bringing forth all of the people en masse with the Brigades entering war alongside them until the entire populace is absorbed.)


(NOTE: the April, 1980 Coal Miners incident involved a violent protest which sent 91 different people to the courts, most ending up with substantial jail time that ruined their family’s livelihood )

[&#48708;&#48128;&#51648;&#47161;2] “&#44208; &#51221;&#51201; &#49884;&#44592;&#44032; &#54252;&#52265;&#46104;&#47732; &#51648;&#52404; &#50630;&#51060; &#52509; &#44277;&#44201;&#51012; &#44060;&#49884;&#54644;&#50556; &#54633;&#45768;&#45796;. &#51204;&#44397;&#51201;&#51064; &#52509;&#54028;&#50629;&#44284; &#46041;&#49884;&#50640; &#51204;&#47029;&#51201; &#50836;&#52649;&#51648;&#45824; &#44275;&#44275;&#50640;&#49436; &#47924;&#51109;&#48393;&#44592;&#47484; &#51068;&#51004;&#53020; &#51204;&#49888; &#51204;&#54868;&#44397;, &#48320;&#51204;&#49548;, &#48169;&#49569;&#44397; &#46321; &#51473;&#50836; &#44277;&#44277;&#49884;&#49444;&#46308;&#51012; &#51216;&#44144;&#54616;&#45716; &#46041;&#49884;&#50640; &#45800;&#51204;&#44284; &#54632;&#44760; &#53685;&#49888; &#44368;&#53685;&#47581;&#51012; &#47560;&#48708;&#49884;&#53412;&#44256; &#51076;&#49884;&#54785;&#47749;&#51221;&#48512;&#51032; &#51060;&#47492;&#51004;&#47196; &#48513;&#50640; &#51648;&#50896;&#51012; &#50836;&#52397;&#54616;&#45716; &#51204;&#54028;&#47484; &#45216;&#47140;&#50556; &#54633;&#45768;&#45796;. &#44536;&#47000;&#50556; &#45224;&#44284; &#48513;&#51032; &#51204;&#47029;&#51201; &#48176;&#54633;&#51004;&#47196; &#54785;&#47749;&#51201; &#45824; &#49324;&#48320;&#51012; &#51452;&#46041;&#51201;&#51004;&#47196; &#50526;&#45817;&#44600; &#49688; &#51080;&#49845;&#45768;&#45796;.”


(Secret Order #2: Seize the moment and without delay begin the attacks. A national general strike must begin and alongside it an armed insurrection attacking communications, electric transformers, and broadcasting centers, without exception attacking the public facilities, creating a paralysis of communications. At the same time, under the name of the new revolution, diffuse the notion that the North must come down to provide support. It is through this means that a strategic group made up of north and south Korean revolutionary forces will attain control of the nation.)


&#48513;&#54620;&#44400; &#53945;&#49688;&#48512;&#45824; 5.18 &#45817;&#49884; ‘&#50756;&#51204; &#47924;&#51109;’ &#49345;&#53468;&#47196; &#45824;&#44592;”

(North Korean Special Forces units were waiting for complete insurrection at the time of the 5.18 uprising)


&#44608;&#51068;&#49457;&#51032; &#51060; &#44057;&#51008; &#48708;&#48128;&#51648;&#47161;&#44284; 80&#45380; 5&#50900;&#51012; &#51204;&#54980;&#54620; &#48513;&#54620;&#44400;&#51032; &#50880;&#51649;&#51076; &#46321; &#51228;&#48152; &#49345;&#54889;&#51008; &#44305;&#51452;&#49324;&#53468;&#50640; &#48516;&#47749;&#55176; &#48513;&#54620;&#44400;&#51060; &#44060;&#51077;&#46096;&#51020;&#51012; &#48372;&#50668;&#51456;&#45796;.


(Kim Il-sung conveyed orders just like these in May of 1980, making it clear that we were to move and that this situation was the one that would clearly bring the North Koreans in [to aid the South Korean revolution].)


5.18 &#49324;&#53468; &#45817;&#49884; &#54632;&#44221;&#45224;&#46020;&#50640; &#50948;&#52824;&#54644; &#51080;&#45912; &#50864;&#47532; &#48512;&#45824;&#45716; &#51204;&#53804;&#46041;&#50896;&#49345;&#53468;&#50640; &#51652;&#51077;&#54616;&#46972;&#45716; &#52280;&#47784;&#48512;&#51032; &#47749;&#47161;&#51012; &#48155;&#44256; &#50756;&#51204; &#47924;&#51109;&#54620; &#49345;&#53468;&#50640;&#49436; &#49888;&#48156;&#46020; &#48279;&#51648; &#47803;&#54620; &#52292; 24&#49884;&#44036; &#51652;&#51648;&#47484; &#52264;&#51648;&#54616;&#44256; &#44305;&#51452;&#49324;&#53468;&#50640; &#45824;&#54644; &#44596;&#44553;&#49549;&#48372;&#47196; &#51204;&#54644; &#46308;&#51004;&#47732;&#49436; 20&#50668;&#51068; &#51060;&#49345; &#52636;&#51204; &#47749;&#47161;&#51012; &#44592;&#45796;&#47532;&#44256; &#51080;&#50632;&#45796;.


(At the time of the May 18th uprising our unit in North Hamgyeong province (North Korea) issued orders to us to accomplish complete insurrection, ordering us to not remove our shoes and to maintain operations 24 hours a day and up until the 20th we were waiting for orders to officially go to war.)
…
&#46608; &#48513;&#54620;&#44400; 4&#44400;&#45800; 70&#51221;&#52272;&#45824;&#45824; &#51204;&#53804;&#50896;&#51004;&#47196; &#48373;&#47924;&#54664;&#45912; &#51060;&#45909;&#49440; &#50472;&#47196;&#48512;&#53552; &#45817;&#49884; &#51221;&#52272;&#44397; &#49548;&#49549; &#51221;&#52272;&#45824;&#45824;&#50896;&#46308;&#51032; &#44305;&#51452; &#52840;&#53804; &#49345;&#54889;&#50640; &#45824;&#54644; &#48708;&#44368;&#51201; &#49345;&#49464;&#54620; &#50584;&#44592;&#47484; &#46308;&#51012; &#49688; &#51080;&#50632;&#45796;.


(At the same time the 4th Corps, 70th Reconnaissance Battalion had entered Gwangju. At the time Yi Deokseon was working for the unit and has provided minute details of what occurred.)
The article now talks in mundane details about which units participated, but it says that 2 out of 3 north Korean insurgents died during the uprising and the remaining returned to their units in North Korea.
&#51060;&#45909;&#49440; &#50472;&#50640; &#46384;&#47476;&#47732; 80&#45380;&#50640; 2&#44400;&#45800; 75&#51221;&#52272;&#45824;&#45824;&#50640;&#49436;&#47564; 41&#47749;&#51032; &#44277;&#54868;&#44397; &#50689;&#50885;&#51060; &#48176;&#52636;&#46096;&#44256; &#53440; &#48512;&#45824;&#46308;&#50640;&#49436; 21&#47749;, &#46020;&#54633; 62&#47749;&#51032; &#50689;&#50885;&#51060; &#45208;&#50772;&#45796;&#44256; &#54620;&#45796;. &#48513;&#54620;&#51032; &#44221;&#50864; &#54217;&#54868;&#49884;&#44592;&#50640;&#45716; &#45224;&#54028;&#44036;&#52393;&#51060;&#45208; &#51204;&#53804;&#50896;&#51060; &#50500;&#45768;&#47732; &#44277;&#54868;&#44397; &#50689;&#50885; &#52845;&#54840;&#47484; &#48155;&#45716; &#51068;&#51060; &#44144;&#51032; &#50630;&#51020;&#51012; &#44048;&#50504;&#54624; &#46412; &#54620; &#54644; &#46041;&#50504;&#50640; 62&#47749;&#51032; &#51204;&#53804;&#50689;&#50885;&#51060; &#53444;&#49373;&#54664;&#45796;&#45716; &#44163;&#51008; &#45824;&#45224;&#52840;&#53804;&#44288;&#47144; &#44144;&#45824; &#51089;&#51204;&#51060; &#51080;&#50632;&#51020;&#51012; &#48372;&#50668;&#51452;&#45716; &#44163;&#51060;&#45796;.


(According to Yi Deokseon, of the 75th Reconnaissance Battalion 41 “Republican Heroes,”other units 21 “Republican Heroes,” making a total of 62 people who participated in the Gwangju uprising to have gained the honor of being called as much. At this time, it was almost impossible in North Korea for spies or military combatants to receive the title of Republican Hero and so it really shows just how massive of an operation this was and how many honors were bestowed.
Freezone, by Kim Pilhae


This was a really tremendous read that showed just what circumstances the governments of Korea in the 70s and 80s were facing against the North Koreans who were actively agitating revolution.


As it comes out more and more, we are looking at a situation where south Korea was gravely threatened. The North was constantly monitoring for strife and trying to incite as much; they were primary instigators behind the Gwangju Massacre, it was apparent that they were preparing for it as soon as the Coal Miners strike occurred.
What is startling to note about the Gwangju massacre was that it began with student protests at a university and culminated in live gunfire upon the protesters by May 20th. A bit over 140 or 150 people died though nobody can ever know for sure, being that much was covered up.


That is why the heavy hands of men like Park Chunghee were necessary: they controlled the country from the relentless North Korean attempts to undermine it, and while north Korea retained total and absolute control over every aspect of their lives in the North, the South which allowed personal freedoms had to resist by all means necessary from such grave situations that they faced.
 

Voegelin

Reactionary
Aug 18, 2003
20,145
1,430
Connecticut
✟26,726.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Republican
That is why the heavy hands of men like Park Chunghee were necessary: they controlled the country from the relentless North Korean attempts to undermine it, and while north Korea retained total and absolute control over every aspect of their lives in the North, the South which allowed personal freedoms had to resist by all means necessary from such grave situations that they faced.

Clearly it was needed. By its hopeless to try to convince many in the west of that. They believe those who were forced to take unpleasant actions to prevent totalitarian regimes from expanding were worse than the regimes they resisted.
 
Upvote 0

OttovonBismarck

Iron Chancellor
Apr 22, 2004
302
30
38
✟15,602.00
Faith
Lutheran
Clearly it was needed. By its hopeless to try to convince many in the west of that. They believe those who were forced to take unpleasant actions to prevent totalitarian regimes from expanding were worse than the regimes they resisted.

Hah, use Stalinist logic to beat...Stalinism? Good job.
 
Upvote 0

Voegelin

Reactionary
Aug 18, 2003
20,145
1,430
Connecticut
✟26,726.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Republican
Hah, use Stalinist logic to beat...Stalinism? Good job.

No. American policy was to support, if necessary, authoritarian regimes in order to defeat totalitarian regimes. We even gave aid to a totalitarian regime,the USSR, in order to defeat another totalitarian regime--Nazi Germany.

There is a enormous difference between totalitarian and authoritarian regimes; between the Shah and Pol Pot, between Marcos and Ho Chi Minh, between Allende and Pinochet. One can survive under authoritarianism. Civil society exists. Under Stalinism, under Maoism, under Fidelism, under Allende had he continued on his path, all--the family, the church, all property-- is consumed by the state.

Liberal Democrats once saw the difference as the Truman administration developed the policy. The far left in America saw it as, time after time, it apologized, supported or minimized the crimes of totalitarian regimes while it fought authoritarian regimes which were reacting to the threat of totalitarianism.
 
Upvote 0

Voegelin

Reactionary
Aug 18, 2003
20,145
1,430
Connecticut
✟26,726.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Republican
Right on, Voeg, people do not realize that life is rarely a choice between good and evil but almost always a choice between the lesser of two evils.

Or one could view it as the better of two choices.

There is some interesting testimony --sealed for 50 years--in the Executive Sessions of the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations of the Committee on Government Operations (McCarthy Hearings 1953-54) which relates to your OP.

The Senate called Korean war POWs to testify. Several of them recounted how, when they were captured by North Koreans, their families received harassing phone calls and mail before the U.S. Military knew what had happened to them.

North Korea had activists in America all during the Korean war which were in contact with the regime in Pyongyang. David Horowitz touched on this subject in Radical Son and names some names of the Americans who wanted a North Korean victory.
 
Upvote 0

OttovonBismarck

Iron Chancellor
Apr 22, 2004
302
30
38
✟15,602.00
Faith
Lutheran
No. American policy was to support, if necessary, authoritarian regimes in order to defeat totalitarian regimes. We even gave aid to a totalitarian regime,the USSR, in order to defeat another totalitarian regime--Nazi Germany.

There is a enormous difference between totalitarian and authoritarian regimes; between the Shah and Pol Pot, between Marcos and Ho Chi Minh, between Allende and Pinochet. One can survive under authoritarianism. Civil society exists. Under Stalinism, under Maoism, under Fidelism, under Allende had he continued on his path, all--the family, the church, all property-- is consumed by the state.

Liberal Democrats once saw the difference as the Truman administration developed the policy. The far left in America saw it as, time after time, it apologized, supported or minimized the crimes of totalitarian regimes while it fought authoritarian regimes which were reacting to the threat of totalitarianism.

The United States supported the USSR over Nazi Germany because there's a drastic, drastic, difference between Stalinism and Nazism. One is cold and systematic while the other is evil and dehumanizing.


For the most part you're using one tame example versus one extreme example. For example: Pol Pot was an evil man. His being "communist" had nothing to do with the fact that he was deranged. But let's not forget the USA was one of the Khmer Rouge's biggest supporters. Now, for some reason you contrast him with the Shah. The Shah was just a corrupt Autocrat, not a mass-murdering psycho. You only make comparison to slant the argument. It would've been more honest to say, oh, I dunno, "the Shah and Mosseddeg" or "Pol Pot and ...". Y'know, there's no one you can honestly compare Pol Pot to. Maybe Hitler.

Truman's administration developed its foreign policy not on a logical doctrine or ideology, but simple on the stance "We need to justify keeping military spending high so we don't go back into depression."
 
Upvote 0

Verv

Senior Veteran
Apr 17, 2005
7,277
672
Gyeonggido
✟40,959.00
Country
Korea, Republic Of
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
The US supported other Cambodian rebel groups as well simply to fight a communist Vietnamese occupation; never was the regime of Pol Pot supported but only a ragged rebel army that waged war against an occupying force. Other groups were also funded and all of it was an effort to curb Vietnamese influence on the Siamese peninsula, Otto.
 
Upvote 0

OttovonBismarck

Iron Chancellor
Apr 22, 2004
302
30
38
✟15,602.00
Faith
Lutheran
The US supported other Cambodian rebel groups as well simply to fight a communist Vietnamese occupation; never was the regime of Pol Pot supported but only a ragged rebel army that waged war against an occupying force. Other groups were also funded and all of it was an effort to curb Vietnamese influence on the Siamese peninsula, Otto.

So supporting a genocidal regime to overthrow one we have an ideological disagreement with is okay?

We supported the Khmer Rouge for these reasons: China supported the Khmer Rouge and we wanted China on our side. The USSR supported Vietnam and we hated those stinking Soviets.
 
Upvote 0