- Feb 5, 2002
- 180,487
- 65,038
- Country
- United States
- Gender
- Female
- Faith
- Catholic
- Marital Status
- Married
- Politics
- US-Others
A month or two ago, a pro-choice classmate of mine decided to put words in my mouth. In a friendly discussion about abortion in America, he responded to me with, “Well, you’re just anti-abortion because you’re Catholic.”
My jaw dropped. “But I’m not,” I said. “I’m pro-life because life begins at conception.”
He did not like this response.
I couldn’t stop thinking about his statement for weeks afterward. I was annoyed that he seemed to think I could have no scientific or philosophical justification for my convictions. It’s true that I am pro-life because science affirms that fetuses are living human beings. But I also believe that the extermination of these human beings is wrong because of my religion, which always has and always will inform my sense of right and wrong.
I think that if I encountered the same accusation today, I would say, “Yes. So?”
Continued below.
intellectualtakeout.org
My jaw dropped. “But I’m not,” I said. “I’m pro-life because life begins at conception.”
He did not like this response.
I couldn’t stop thinking about his statement for weeks afterward. I was annoyed that he seemed to think I could have no scientific or philosophical justification for my convictions. It’s true that I am pro-life because science affirms that fetuses are living human beings. But I also believe that the extermination of these human beings is wrong because of my religion, which always has and always will inform my sense of right and wrong.
I think that if I encountered the same accusation today, I would say, “Yes. So?”
Continued below.

Yes, My Religion Informs How I Vote - Intellectual Takeout
One common argument against letting religion influence your political decisions suggests that it is wrong to impose your moral beliefs on others.
