• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

WMA vs. MP3

Western Deity

you know how it is
Feb 22, 2004
4,197
137
35
✟5,081.00
Faith
Seeker
A year ago my music folder (I don't index things, I just have everything in one big folder :D) would have been strictly MP3-laden (sp?). Today, my music files are WMA/MP3 in a 50:50 or so ratio.

Have any of you noticed that the WMA format is becoming a lot more prevalent, and what do you think of it as a format?
 

Qyöt27

AMV Editor At Large
Apr 2, 2004
7,879
573
39
St. Petersburg, Florida
✟89,359.00
Faith
Methodist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
/rant

I personally can't stand WMA, it's a nasty nasty format, even if the audio quality of WMA9 is better than MP3 at a comparable bitrate. I'd much rather go for MP4/AAC or Vorbis (which are on par with or better than WMA9) before letting WMA have it.

Out of all the songs in my digital collection (which is in upwards of 3000 or so), I think only two or three of them are/were WMA at some time. I avoid that format like the plague (I also generally avoid WMVs like the plague, too, and logically, WMA is the only audio format compatible with WMV).

The thing that annoys me the most about WMA (aside from the über-invasive DRM), is the noise that the thing generates. Hit a really high pitch, and the thing squeals like a pig (even at a higher bitrate; at least MPEG Audio has some type of noise dampening system in place, sheesh). I also never bought that claim Microsoft was putting out that a 64kbps WMA (at that point, it was WMA8) is equal in quality to a 128kbps MP3...I tried that comparison for myself, they lie through their teeth to make their format look good.

As for it becoming prevalent...unfortunately, yes, I do see it becoming more prevalent online. I have a simple explanation of it too: people are becoming lazy and don't know p's from q's about encoding audio or video (for those that default to WMV instead of using DivX, XviD or MPEG-1 simply because Windows Movie Maker exports WMV by default - no matter that it has a DV export function *rollseyes*). Not to mention that (as I saw in an article), most non-tech-savvy consumers simply rip their CDs to their hard drive in the native format the player uses (WMA for Windows Media Player 7+, MP4/AAC for iTunes, Vorbis depending on what version of Winamp you use, etc.), and often times think they are ripping to MP3. Even more annoying is that those who do rip to WMA (knowingly or not), often forget (or don't know about it at all) that they didn't disable the DRM option and then wonder why their music won't play when they put it on a different computer.

As a general rule of thumb, I don't even use Windows Media Player 7+. I stick to mplayer2 (Windows Media Player 6.5; you know, the simple interface - comes packaged with all Windows platforms since the mid-90s) and Media Player Classic for my video needs, and Winamp 2.95 (just recently upgraded from 2.81) to play all my audio. I do keep the newest set of Windows Media codecs on my system though, just for the sake of being able to play newer files. I just don't let the defaults take over.

/rant

Whew. I feel so much better now that that's off my chest.
 
Upvote 0

Alice the Sister

optimize
Jun 30, 2003
7,726
428
38
seattle, washington
✟27,158.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Other Religion
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Libertarian
both are pretty bad.


the only thing good about mp3 is the portability.

there are only two good things about WMA. The fact you can attach a picture in tag and lyrics, and everything. and the lossless format.

Personally, I prefer FLAC and Oggvorbis. I use linux mainly at home, and it doesn't play my wma files (yet...i'm working on something hee hee) I don't have an mp3 ripper besides the twenty use only Nero version. When I download stuff, it's usually in mp3 format just because of the portabilty. Oggvorbis is much better quality than mp3 or even wma, although wma has more 'protection' policies and whatnot, i think oggvorbis is better.

FLAC is Full Lossless Audio Codec. Lossless refers the compression of a song and the bitrates. Basically, it's the same thing as listening to the CD on a CD player, but sometimes it sounds better solely because you use different drivers than CD Audio for audio on your machine. *mathmatically, at least*

Yeah.

Thanks for your time. I vote indy on music too. ^_^

I try to keep up on file compression, because I want the best....but not having the internet kind of takes that away. :(


By the way, there's a program called mplayer..it's a lot like mplayer2, but it's not made by microsoft and it can play any file you can think of.
 
Upvote 0

KristianJ

What's in a name? Letters...
Feb 9, 2004
15,443
663
42
Sydney, Australia
✟43,288.00
Faith
Christian
Golden Calf Disco said:
By the way, there's a program called mplayer..it's a lot like mplayer2, but it's not made by microsoft and it can play any file you can think of.
That could be very handy if it plays both mp3 and .ra files - I've been looking everywhere for a player that'll do both. :)
 
Upvote 0

Anthony_85

Member
Dec 29, 2004
9
0
40
Brisbane, QLD
✟22,629.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
I'm too lazy to make Mp3s of my music CD's so I've been using WMA. However, I think the sound quality of WMA is utterly appauling. Below 192kb sampling rates WMA is very muddy and really poor quality. However, at 192kn sampling rates played in Winamp 5 the quality is superb, Winamp actually decodes WMA better the Windows Media Player 8 and 9.

MP3 > WMA
 
Upvote 0

Qyöt27

AMV Editor At Large
Apr 2, 2004
7,879
573
39
St. Petersburg, Florida
✟89,359.00
Faith
Methodist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
KristianJ said:
Ah, just found out it's Linux...never mind :) But if anyone knows of a player that can play both .ra files and mp3's besides RealPlayer, then please drop me a PM :thumbsup:
dBPowerAmp Player can do it, if you have the RealAudio plugin for it. I don't use that player, though. I stick to the dBPowerAmp Music Converter, which still uses the same plugins, and can convert the RealAudio files to Wave, MP3, etc. (granted, of course, that the files aren't protected). Then I can play them in any player (even though I use WMP 6.5 for RealMedia, but meh).

Another option to play RealMedia (.rm, .ra, etc.), is installing Matroska container support. There's a Windows DirectShow codec for RealMedia installed with it. As long as RealPlayer (or RealAlternative) is on the computer, it can play the RealAudio/Video files through Windows Media Player/any DirectShow-based player.
 
Upvote 0