Why wouldn't God just predestine everyone? How could it possibly be for His greater glory to only choose some, rather than all? Wouldn't He be most glorified if everyone loves Him?
It doesn't make sense...
It doesn't make sense...
Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
HeDied4Me said:Why wouldn't God just predestine everyone? How could it possibly be for His greater glory to only choose some, rather than all? Wouldn't He be most glorified if everyone loves Him?
It doesn't make sense...
littleapologist said:I think these questions have stemmed out of a false understanding of God's attributes (not saying that you have a false understanding). To be sure, God is a God of love. Yet, God is also a God of Wrath. God is infinite in His being, which (I think would) means that God is infinite in his attributes. God is not "more love" than He is "wrath." He is equal in His love as He is in His wrath. This means God is glorified when he demonstrates all of His attributes. So, to rephrase, Gos is glorified in His Wrath and in His Love, and not glorified in His love to the neglect of His other attributes.
Also, God is most glorified because he says he is most Glorified in what He has decided to do.
HeDied4Me said:Why wouldn't God just predestine everyone? How could it possibly be for His greater glory to only choose some, rather than all? Wouldn't He be most glorified if everyone loves Him?
It doesn't make sense...
Rick Otto said:But He DID predestine everyone!
Try to imagine how mercy could exist if there was no justice?
The cross wouldn't have happened if not for predestination.
It isn't about God being a control-freak, tho.
He's omniscient & omnipotent, so it's natural for Him to know everything before it happens, and not simply clairvoyantly, rather He knows because He created, & did so with purpose.
Ours is simply a problem of perspective.
arunma said:Keep in mind that human logic fails when attempting to understand God. The Apostles teach us that God prepared some vessels for destruction, in order to show his glory. At the same time, it says that God desires for everyone to come to repentence. Yet,
And the Lord's servant must not be quarrelsome but kind to everyone, able to teach, patiently enduring evil, correcting his opponents with gentleness. God may perhaps grant them repentance leading to a knowledge of the truth. (2 Timothy 2:24-25)The "may perhaps" certainly stuck out to me. Why does God do things this way? I don't know, "But who are you, O man, to answer back to God?" (Romans 9:20). It isn't my place to question why God works in certain ways, only to understand to the best of my abilities how he works.
HeDied4Me said:Yes, but when our understanding of the way God works seems to contradict what He said (He desires for everyone to come to repentance) then it's very important to question it... I'm a Calvinist, but this question has been bothering me for a long time.
If God really wants everyone to come to repentance, and He changes people's hearts, then why would He not cause everyone to come to repentance? He certainly could... Jesus's death was sufficient for all...
(I'm not trying to debate... Just trying to understand this a little better...)
bradfordl said:The Lord is not slack concerning his promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance.
(2Pe 3:9)
"To us-ward" is the key phrase here. He is not addressing the whole of mankind, but the church. He is not willing that any of His own should perish, and they will not. What God wills He performs perfectly and precisely, and nothing exists that can change that.
Imblessed said:arielle,
I think you aren't the only one who tries, and fails to understand it. The simple (even if it's not enough for us humans) fact is that that's the way God decided to do it, and I don't think it's a coincidence that Paul spoke specifically to that point in Romans 9.
Life would be ever so much easier if God had decided to save everyone wouldn't it? But I honestly don't think that God could be fully glorified if He had chose to do it that way. It's kind of hard to Glorify God's Grace when you don't see His Wrath.
I think littleapologist put it quite well actually........
I think it is important to note that Calvinists don't dispute the infinite value of Christ's death - but we understand that value is not the same as the intent. If God intended to throw all of His wrath for each and every person on Christ - then what would be left for them to be judged for? But since we know all are not saved, then obviously God's wrath still burns against the non-elect.HeDied4Me said:But that implies that Jesus's death on the cross was not sufficient for all of mankind... God already showed us His wrath, when His own son took what we deserved.
Defcon said:I think it is important to note that Calvinists don't dispute the infinite value of Christ's death - but we understand that value is not the same as the intent. If God intended to throw all of His wrath for each and every person on Christ - then what would be left for them to be judged for? But since we know all are not saved, then obviously God's wrath still burns against the non-elect.
There are Scripture references to point to this limited intent; His sacrifice being a ransom for many (Matthew 20:28, Mark 10:45), dying specifically for the Church (for her - not each and every individual) Ephesians 5:25, these are just a few....
I'm sorry, dear, but Scripture doesn't provide an answer to this question. In fact, Paul rebukes those who ask it (Rom. 9:20). Better to be fearfully thankful than full of fruitless inquiries.HeDied4Me said:Why wouldn't God just predestine everyone? How could it possibly be for His greater glory to only choose some, rather than all? Wouldn't He be most glorified if everyone loves Him?
It doesn't make sense...
Jon_ said:I'm sorry, dear, but Scripture doesn't provide an answer to this question. In fact, Paul rebukes those who ask it (Rom. 9:20). Better to be fearfully thankful than full of fruitless inquiries.
Soli Deo Gloria
Jon
Sorry, didn't mean to imply that at all. I definately think the death was sufficient for all, I just don't think He actually died for everyone. Only the Church, His bride.HeDied4Me said:Okay, Romans 9... I'll have to read that again and see what it says. Thanks.
But that implies that Jesus's death on the cross was not sufficient for all of mankind... God already showed us His wrath, when His own son took what we deserved.
Imblessed said:Sorry, didn't mean to imply that at all. I definately think the death was sufficient for all, I just don't think He actually died for everyone. Only the Church, His bride.
Take solace in his grace and love for you. So great is his love that he sent Jesus Christ to bear the punishment that you had earned. Thank him for his wonderful mercy and love, that he chose you, one of the few among the many, to be adopted as his child and made heir with Christ to his Kingdom. Put your confidence, glory, and trust in him. Delight yourself in his ways and he will poor out untold blessings upon you.HeDied4Me said:Yes, I guess that's true.
Jon_ said:Take solace in his grace and love for you. So great is his love that he sent Jesus Christ to bear the punishment that you had earned. Thank him for his wonderful mercy and love, that he chose you, one of the few among the many, to be adopted as his child and made heir with Christ to his Kingdom. Put your confidence, glory, and trust in him. Delight yourself in his ways and he will poor out untold blessings upon you.
Soli Deo Gloria
Jon
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?