• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Why this hate for Islam?

Status
Not open for further replies.

GeratTzedek

Meaning Righteous Proselyte to Judaism
Aug 5, 2007
4,213
339
64
Los Angeles area
Visit site
✟6,003.00
Faith
Judaism
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
There is a difference between fear of the stranger and a reputation earned. For example, while I don't condone a blanket hatred of Muslims and see good in Islam, I alsoconcede the Islamic world has earned a bad reputation for itself.

Now, let's look back at the early 20th Century. Did the Jews do anything which warrented such hatred of them that they should be exterminated like bugs from the face of the earth? Were they engaging in terrorist activities that targeted innocents? Did they kill their own women on the mere suspicion of unseemly behavior? Were they planning to dominate the world and impose Judaism on everyone?

There simply is no comparison between bigotry and disliking something or someone for warranted reasons. I hate pedophilia; I want all pedophiles permanently removed from society. That doesn't make me a bigot just because I'm opposed to them acting on their sexual preference. I hope I explained this adequately.
 
Upvote 0

Jebediah

Senior Veteran
Dec 8, 2005
2,639
220
48
✟3,940.00
Faith
Pagan
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
There is a difference between fear of the stranger and a reputation earned. For example, while I don't condone a blanket hatred of Muslims and see good in Islam, I alsoconcede the Islamic world has earned a bad reputation for itself.

Now, let's look back at the early 20th Century. Did the Jews do anything which warrented such hatred of them that they should be exterminated like bugs from the face of the earth? Were they engaging in terrorist activities that targeted innocents? Did they kill their own women on the mere suspicion of unseemly behavior? Were they planning to dominate the world and impose Judaism on everyone?

There simply is no comparison between bigotry and disliking something or someone for warranted reasons. I hate pedophilia; I want all pedophiles permanently removed from society. That doesn't make me a bigot just because I'm opposed to them acting on their sexual preference. I hope I explained this adequately.

The main accusations against the Jews are different in their character, and are cashed out in terms of psychological warfare, social parasitism, and economic manipulation. You take issue with essential character of Islam, that it is violent and repressive. Those who take issue with the Jews are also taking issue with an essential character, just a different one.

Oh yeah, and then there is the whole Israel thing. A lot of people resent the hell out of that.
 
Upvote 0

GeratTzedek

Meaning Righteous Proselyte to Judaism
Aug 5, 2007
4,213
339
64
Los Angeles area
Visit site
✟6,003.00
Faith
Judaism
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
:doh: Jebediah:

Please read what I wrote above regarding distinguishing between genuine actions deserving of judgment, and shere bigotry.

Also, no where in my post did I say that ALL MUSLIMS DESERVE TO BE HATED, or deserve death, or any such nonsense. So puhleeze. We don't throw knives away just because some people misuse them.

Oy Veh.:doh:
 
Upvote 0

Meshavrischika

for Thy greater honor and glory
Jun 12, 2007
20,903
1,566
OK
✟50,603.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
"They just heard you offer the apology for all the monsters of our times."DEATHS-HEAD REVISITED - 11/10/61
[SIZE=-1]Written by: Rod Serling

Not that I disagree. I just think that particular knife cuts both ways, and that plenty of people would say that exact phrase applies to Jews as well.
[/SIZE]
and Christians... don't forget us

(I'm not being sarcastic)
 
Upvote 0

Jebediah

Senior Veteran
Dec 8, 2005
2,639
220
48
✟3,940.00
Faith
Pagan
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
:doh: Jebediah:

Please read what I wrote above regarding distinguishing between genuine actions deserving of judgment, and shere bigotry.

Also, no where in my post did I say that ALL MUSLIMS DESERVE TO BE HATED, or deserve death, or any such nonsense. So puhleeze. We don't throw knives away just because some people misuse them.

Oy Veh.:doh:

I'm not saying you did. I'm merely saying that your statements apply to your own faith, and that to acknowledge that a group can bring a negative opinion on themselves and deserve it is to recognize a valid position in anti-Semitism.
 
Upvote 0

GeratTzedek

Meaning Righteous Proselyte to Judaism
Aug 5, 2007
4,213
339
64
Los Angeles area
Visit site
✟6,003.00
Faith
Judaism
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
The main accusations against the Jews are different in their character, and are cashed out in terms of psychological warfare, social parasitism, and economic manipulation. You take issue with essential character of Islam, that it is violent and repressive. Those who take issue with the Jews are also taking issue with an essential character, just a different one.

Oh yeah, and then there is the whole Israel thing. A lot of people resent the hell out of that.
You are misrepresenting me. I considered reporting this. I very clearly stated from the beginning that this is NOT the view I have of Islam. I consider it a religion with good potential. It need not be either violent nor repressive. That it has become glaringly so is a tragedy not just to the world, but to Islam.

Secondly, the charges against the Jews, such as social parasitism, were and are false. They are largely a result of fear of the stranger, an innate human quality. Observant Jews cannot well assimilate, nor should they. In tolerant societies such as the USA, they can and do become intermingled to a much larger degree. But to the degree that they stand apart, they are feared. When a people is feared, everything they do and say is filtered through that fear, leading to lies.

An example of a lie about Jews: "Jews use the blood of gentile children to make Matzah for Passover." An example of a lie about Muslims: "Muslims worship the moon god." These are the kinds of hateful biggoted statement you hear that originate from fear. They are not based on reality.

Suicide bombings are very real.
 
Upvote 0

GeratTzedek

Meaning Righteous Proselyte to Judaism
Aug 5, 2007
4,213
339
64
Los Angeles area
Visit site
✟6,003.00
Faith
Judaism
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
I'm not saying you did. I'm merely saying that your statements apply to your own faith, and that to acknowledge that a group can bring a negative opinion on themselves and deserve it is to recognize a valid position in anti-Semitism.
No, it is NOT a valid position in anti-semitism, because the "and deserve it" is simply not true.

If Sally sleeps with a different guy every weekend, she deserves her reputation as a ****.
If Jane isn't sleeping with any man, but the rumor is spread that she is a ****, she does NOT deserve it.

This is so incredibly basic, I am baffled why I even need to say it.
 
Upvote 0

Meshavrischika

for Thy greater honor and glory
Jun 12, 2007
20,903
1,566
OK
✟50,603.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
No, it is NOT a valid position in anti-semitism, because the "and deserve it" is simply not true.

If Sally sleeps with a different guy every weekend, she deserves her reputation as a ****.
If Jane isn't sleeping with any man, but the rumor is spread that she is a ****, she does NOT deserve it.

This is so incredibly basic, I am baffled why I even need to say it.
**note: in no way do I support anyone promoting any kind of anti semitism**

the choices aren't so black and white though.
for instance... if sally portrays or presents herself as a ****, whether knowingly or unknowingly, she can be called such, even if she is not... (perception is everything)

this just puts forward to me that we all need to be completely and totally visibly LIVING our calling. Those that do this won't be subject to this type of assumption.
 
Upvote 0

Jebediah

Senior Veteran
Dec 8, 2005
2,639
220
48
✟3,940.00
Faith
Pagan
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
You are misrepresenting me. I considered reporting this. I very clearly stated from the beginning that this is NOT the view I have of Islam. I consider it a religion with good potential. It need not be either violent nor repressive. That it has become glaringly so is a tragedy not just to the world, but to Islam.

Secondly, the charges against the Jews, such as social parasitism, were and are false. They are largely a result of fear of the stranger, an innate human quality. Observant Jews cannot well assimilate, nor should they. In tolerant societies such as the USA, they can and do become intermingled to a much larger degree. But to the degree that they stand apart, they are feared. When a people is feared, everything they do and say is filtered through that fear, leading to lies.

An example of a lie about Jews: "Jews use the blood of gentile children to make Matzah for Passover." An example of a lie about Muslims: "Muslims worship the moon god." These are the kinds of hateful biggoted statement you hear that originate from fear. They are not based on reality.

Suicide bombings are very real.

^_^

Report away. I don't respond well to moral rebuke from people whose values I don't share.

Have you ever considered that for a strong people to function, they must share common values, a way of life, and a common circulation of resources, and that the refusal to assimilate (to the point of terming it a virtue!) and the insistence on insular "nations inside of nations" would be extremely problematic in respect to that? That the problems created by that might be systematic, affecting entire structures of society? Why is it so odd that people would see that as being as much of a problem as violence? Economic sabotage, which is what creating micro-economies is, leads to large scale suffering and problems.

I have never seen the claim from anti-Semites that Jews did anything with blood. Maybe I just missed it, or automatically discounted such silliness. What I have seen is descriptions of sociological problems caused by systematic creation of microeconomies and the refusal to assimilate to the values of parent nations.

Let me ask you this...why does Israel want to only grant citizenship to Jews?

"We have to maintain the state's democratic nature, but also its Jewish nature."- Ze'ev Boim

Now, I think that this is a valid and good choice for a nation, to choose to unify its values under one standard. I also don't see why that desire should not apply to every nation.
 
Upvote 0

Disippelen

Peaceful Crusader
Dec 22, 2005
880
47
41
Oslo, Norway
✟23,775.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
I don't think that there is much hatred of Islam on this site, at least not hatred of Muslim people. Well, that's only what I've observed. People ask questions and often they also make accusations as part of their debates, but I don't think that this equals hatred. Christians have faced the same in Europe through many centuries.

For my own part I have many Muslim friends whom I respect both as persons and as Muslim adherents. Based on my own experience no one should hate Muslims (or persons of other faiths for that matter). I do, however, believe that it is very important to continue debating religion and society. We must never arrive at the conclusion that ideology should be withheld from open discussion, that may potentially be very dangerous indeed.

Basically regarding criticism of religion or ideology, it's best to concentrate on the holy scriptures / manifests etc. as well as the founders (Jesus, Mohammad, Marx, Hitler etc). Looking at those, of course based on the relevance of the founder, would be the most fruitful way of establishing the truthfullness and value of a faith and/or ideology.


Dis :)
 
Upvote 0

GeratTzedek

Meaning Righteous Proselyte to Judaism
Aug 5, 2007
4,213
339
64
Los Angeles area
Visit site
✟6,003.00
Faith
Judaism
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
Jeb:

What value did my post contain which you did not share? I was concerned about your misreprentation of me. Do you not also value people being honest and truthful and representing others fairly? Most of my pagan friends do...

Or are you saying that because we do not share ALL values, that you don't care about anything I say? Please let me know, so that I can choose to ignore you and not respond in the future if such is the case. I hate to spin my wheels.
 
Upvote 0

GeratTzedek

Meaning Righteous Proselyte to Judaism
Aug 5, 2007
4,213
339
64
Los Angeles area
Visit site
✟6,003.00
Faith
Judaism
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
Israel has many non-Jewish citizens. It is the "right of return" , aka automatic citizenship, which is reserved only for Jews. But there are plenty of Christian, Muslim, and secular citizens. Goodness, there is a Muslim Palestinian in the government!
 
Upvote 0

GeratTzedek

Meaning Righteous Proselyte to Judaism
Aug 5, 2007
4,213
339
64
Los Angeles area
Visit site
✟6,003.00
Faith
Judaism
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
Jews are obligated to observe Torah. To the degree that they can do so and participate in society is the degree to which they can assimilate. It's really that simple.

I can be Modern Orthodox and teach public elementary school in Los Angeles. Where else in the world would I have this same freedom, without loss of status?
 
Upvote 0

Jebediah

Senior Veteran
Dec 8, 2005
2,639
220
48
✟3,940.00
Faith
Pagan
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
After thinking, I have to ask you, Jebediah, if you actually do think there is any validity to anti-semitism.

I believe in pan-nationalism (really, I believe nations should be very small, so perhaps pan-tribalism is more correct, but you get the idea). I believe that people defining themselves under a shared set of values and a vector of social progress (they have a shared "vision" about how to live and what counts as "progress" vs "decay") should have their own lands and stay uninvolved with other nations. I am against the notion of modern liberal political theory, democracy (I do not believe that putting average people in large numbers somehow grants them the ability to make above-average choices), and the notion of the economic nation-state. This is essentially what I call my "metatheory" as in "how I think the world should work in a way that would be good for everyone".

My "microtheory", however, is that of a very angry heathen/pagan who identifies strongly with his Nordic ancestors. I am in a world built by the invaders and destroyers of my people and faith, and wish to see justice for their crimes. I am fundamentally a religious person, seeing the world through a religious lens, and so those are the terms that cash out as important to me. Thus, essentially, I am radically anti-Christian. I am radically anti-Muslim as well, but don't wish any harm to them, I just want them to not spread their world into a global monoculture as the Christians have attempted to. I essentially believe that monotheism, the notion that there is a "right true only way" and one god for all peoples, leads naturally to cultural and military invasions. Jews just get caught in the mix. I am not particularly anti-Semite...I am anti-"Yod-Heh-Vav-Heh", in whichever outfit he is dressed up as to the different groups he seems to motivate.

So I suppose the right way to explain myself is as a religious extremist or rather zealot. I don't think there are master races or such things, I just think a desert god who got too big for his britches inspired people to invasion, sedition, and psychological warfare to conquer the world. I exist as an occupied person in an occupied land, with the conditions of my existence dictated by a framework of life and morals that are not my own. And, knowing western history, I know who did it, why they did it, and whose name they did it in. Knowing all this, I know who my enemies are. Jews I just think should have their own lands and be left to their own devices. Christianity I want gone, period.
 
Upvote 0

Jebediah

Senior Veteran
Dec 8, 2005
2,639
220
48
✟3,940.00
Faith
Pagan
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
Jeb:

What value did my post contain which you did not share? I was concerned about your misreprentation of me. Do you not also value people being honest and truthful and representing others fairly? Most of my pagan friends do...

Or are you saying that because we do not share ALL values, that you don't care about anything I say? Please let me know, so that I can choose to ignore you and not respond in the future if such is the case. I hate to spin my wheels.

Oh, I think we share some values. But I do not respond to threats of virtual punishments on web-forums. If you think I really broke the rules, report me, but I do not respond to normative discourse; you are not my family, lover, friend, kin, or leader and thus I am not open to moral correction from you. You maintain your own behaviour and let the cards fall where they may as far as reports go, and I will do the same.
 
Upvote 0

vajradhara

Diamond Thunderbolt of Indestructable Wisdom
Jun 25, 2003
9,403
466
57
Dharmadhatu
✟34,720.00
Faith
Buddhist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
US-Others
Namaste francais,

thank you for the post.

français said:
months back, I was very anti Islam. Anyone here could tell you that.

Thankfully though, I promised a member here that I would do more research into Islam and be open minded about it.(The member was Oxy2Hydro)

if you actually have an interest in learning about another religion the only way to gain a valid cognition of it is to begin your study with an open mind.

I have, and have learned a lot. And, I have come to appreciate Islam so much.

it is a valid spiritual refuge.

And now as I view this forum, it brings me to tears, because people are so hateful here of Islam. Some people say the meanest things, and make the same accusations over and over.

i would suggest that the nature of this forum is rather contentious debate and discussion so it is natural to expect strong statements either pro or con.

of course your observation applies precisely to those same Muslims that engage in the same behavior.

many people are convinced of the correctness of their view regardless of what anyone else may have to say about thus continually posting the same arguments and critiques.

Every Muslim on this site has condemned 9/11 and terrorism against innocents.

how do you know this?

Many Muslims are pro Palestine, but so what! If you could not go to work without crossing checkpoints, and if your homes were being bulldozed, I am sure you would be pro palestine too.

i disagree. i think that the Palestinian Intefada is purely political and not actually in the interest of helping those that need it. not to be trite but this situation could be easily resolved if the surrounding Arab nations would simply give Palestine land.

and then people call Hamas terrorist, simply because they do not recognize Israel.

that's not why i call them terrorists. one of the many reasons that i would lable them terrorists is due to their stated lack of concern for killing children through homicide bombings.

Well you know, there are MANY Israeli's who are anti Palestine and want them dead. But we always look over this.

perhaps you overlook this but that doesn't seem to be a fair characterization of everyone else.

A good friend of mine named Eliad is lives in Israel. I told him how I did not like his government because they kill a lot of innocents. He said "So, that is good and I hope we kill more, because they are nasty people." And he had a smile on his face too because he was on webcam.

sounds like you need to change your circle of friends.

And sure, many Muslims support the fighters in Iraq. But hey, if 140,000 people invaded your country and pushed and shoved you, wouldn't you?!

no.

Muslims have EVERY right to want US troops out of Iraq, and they have every right to support the "terrorists" who are simply trying to get the troops to leave.

don't the Muslims that want the international troops there have any "rights" or say regarding this? why do the ones that kill the women and children get to decide these things for the rest of them?

Sure, many Muslims may support these things.. But how many support killing innocent Jews at a mall, or 9/11, or killing innocent people elsewhere? VERY FEW. And the Muslims on this forum have made it loud and clear many times.

firstly, the Muslims on this forum only speak for themselves and therefore cannot constitute anything resembling a unity of views within the Muslim world. secondly, you have no idea how many Muslims support killing Jews or killing Americans simply because they are Jewish or American and to claim this knowledge for yourself tends to undercut the point which you are attempting to make, in my estimation.

How often do Muslims worry about killing people for committing adultery?! Not often!

do more studying. i don't know what you studied but it certainly doesn't seem consonant with the political operation of many Muslim nations.

Instead, they worry about other issues, more contemporary issues that the average Joe and Joanne would worry about.

of course Muslims are humans and thus they have the same concerns as other humans.... no point in even saying this unless you were previously of the opinion that Muslims weren't humans and feel remorse at your prior view.

So please, just leave your anti Islam outside. If you sincerely have questions, then go to a MUSLIM FORUM and ask, but do not post the same things here over and over.

why not? this is the Non-Christian religions section of this forum and it is, consequently, the only place to ask Muslims questions on this forum as they hardly ever (i can't recall reading a single post in the Science subforums, for instance) visit anywhere else on the site.

I am just sick of these hate threads. I am sick of the close mindedness. I am sick of the anti Islamic brainwashing and the same threads over and over. Change is needed.

it seems to me that your chief complaint here is how you feel when you read a thread which is anti Islam. perhaps you shouldn't read those threads if they bother you? that you consider disagreement with Islam to be brainwashing is quite unusual to my way of thinking.

metta,

~v
 
Upvote 0

Kutte

Regular Member
Dec 30, 2007
1,197
66
USA
✟39,166.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Widowed
Politics
US-Green
Seems to me that it is wrong to speak of hate.
But certain Muslim extremist groups themselves such as Al Queda are to blame for creating a dislike for Muslims in general, which, of course, is unfortunate.

Kutte
**************************
Check out my blog WAR PRAYER
 
Upvote 0

GeratTzedek

Meaning Righteous Proselyte to Judaism
Aug 5, 2007
4,213
339
64
Los Angeles area
Visit site
✟6,003.00
Faith
Judaism
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
Muslims ...have every right to support the "terrorists" who are simply trying to get the troops to leave.

No one has the right to support the deliberate targeting of innocents. It doesn't matter if those targeting innocents are Muslims or Catholics or Jews or Pagans or LIttle Green Men from Mars. To deliberately TARGET innocents (as opposed to killing them by accident, or as an indirect result of targeting an enemy combatant) is INNATELY EVIL. There is no reason on this planet that excuses it.

and then people call Hamas terrorist, simply because they do not recognize Israel.
Actually, there are plenty of anti-Israel groups NOT labeled terrorist. Hamas is labeled as terrorist not because of its beliefs but because of its actions -- TARGETING INNOCENTS.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.