What is the Orthodox take on Islam?

[Moros]

It's a Koran, which is obvious, but here is some reading material.

http://www.crusadeforcatholics.com/pope.htm
http://www.romancatholicism.org/jpii-koran1.html

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=pope+kisses+koran

 

[Dominus Fidelis]

Oh, I'm well aware of the accusations, but I'm interested in how you know that its a Koran. If it is obvious, show me how it is obvious.

 

[prodromos]

I want to see the Catholic refutation of it being the Koran. Where is the official statement in the face of this controversy?

John.

 

[Dominus Fidelis]

I want to see the Catholic refutation of it being the Koran. Where is the official statement in the face of this controversy?

John.

Perhaps it is the Koran and the Pope meant it as a sign of respect for the Muslim PEOPLE, not the Muslim errors themselves.

 

[prodromos]

Perhaps it is the Koran and the Pope meant it as a sign of respect for the Muslim PEOPLE, not the Muslim errors themselves.

Then the right thing to do would have been to kiss a Muslim person, rather than scandalising his brethren, don't you think?

 

[Dominus Fidelis]

Then the right thing to do would have been to kiss a Muslim person, rather than scandalising his brethren, don't you think?

So now we are your brethren? From reading the threads in here lately it would seem we are "distant cousins" at best, heretics at worse.

Make up your minds please.

 

[Oblio]

So now we are your brethren? From reading the threads in here lately it would seem we are "distant cousins" at best, heretics at worse.

Make up your minds please.

DoF,

John was (I think) speaking of the relationship between the Pope and Catholics. Further, Orthodox, like Catholics are made up of a diverse group and AFAIK there is no doctrine concerning what to call other Christians. I would not expect unity on this issue.

 

[Dominus Fidelis]

DoF,

John was (I think) speaking of the relationship between the Pope and Catholics. Further, Orthodox, like Catholics are made up of a diverse group and AFAIK there is no doctrine concerning what to call other Christians. I would not expect unity on this issue.

Oh, my mistake...I guess I was hoping he was calling us brothers, but I guess not.

 

[prodromos]

John was (I think) speaking of the relationship between the Pope and Catholics.

Affirmative

 

[prodromos]

Oh, my mistake...I guess I was hoping he was calling us brothers, but I guess not.

Hey, I often refer to you guys as my brethren (actually I think I refer to you as "our" brethren which might ruffle a few feathers ). However, if I was required to qualify my use of the term I think I would refer to you as "seperated" brethren. I hope that isn't offensive.

John.

 

[Dominus Fidelis]

Hey, I often refer to you guys as my brethren (actually I think I refer to you as "our" brethren which might ruffle a few feathers ). However, if I was required to qualify my use of the term I think I would refer to you as "seperated" brethren. I hope that isn't offensive.

John.

Not offensive. From your perspectives it is us who left you. From ours, it is you that left us.

 

[Sergius_Lucius]

I recommend Orthodoxy and Islam

Some articles may be too harsh but this one by an Orthodox missionary in Indonesia is very interesting: http://www.geocities.com/umaximov/fddb3.htm

 

[nicodemus]

What was it that he said?

I will have to dig up the original sources at home, but basically stuff about all religions worshipping the same god, etc.

 

[Moros]

I am quite familiar with the Koran. Read the articles that say that particular koran was presented to the "pope" and finding out for yourself?

 

[Dominus Fidelis]

I am quite familiar with the Koran. Read the articles that say that particular koran was presented to the "pope" and finding out for yourself?

I'd rather read from the Pope's own encyclical's and the Catechism that says Jesus is the only way to be saved.

 

[Orthodox Andrew]

Almost as bad

(singing: "Blame Canada")

I agree.

 

[Umut]

Islam is a religion that claims you should wash your plate with sand literally 30 times if a dog's mouth happens to touch it. The dog's mouth is 15% cleaner than the human mouth, and it has a germ killing substance in its mouth!

Get into the mentality of Muhammed. He plagirized the New Testament which came out 600 years before him. Isn't it obvious? We look at Genesis 2:7 "And he breathed in to his nostrils the breath of life..."

We see the same exact words in the Koran; word for word!

I mean... Muhammed was a merchant and the stories have it that he did not know how to read and write. 1) How can a merchant not read and write? 2) How can he write anything if he cannot read and write?

The fact that he claims that Gabriel was to tell him the words to write the in Kuran is just wrong. Look into it, you will see that it is self-contradictory. Plus it is said that since Muhammed didn't know how to read and write; his slaves wrote it. Also, another myth has it that it was written on a big stone in heaven by Allah...

Three things that contradict eachother.

Plus we're talking about a religion that sees women as posession and count them in with silver, gold, plates, donkeys, animals. Obviously this religion is only directed at the people in its time; which proves that Muhammed was just a man in search of power. It is blatantly obvious that he conquered city by city with the sword. Doesn't Islam mean peace?

*Scratches head*

Please tell me your opinions.

I have a file thicker than a line of dust in a mosque that's full of contradictions.

These are just very basic ones. Please tell me if anyone finds this offensive, and feel free to edit this. But sometimes these blind people get me angry... Especially when they kidnap people and try to convert them, and take over the most divine Church in Istanbul (constantinople) and change it into a filthy mosque. I would've had the chance to go and see it, seeing as how I was born in Istanbul... but no... Let us be idiots and worship Allah!

Sorry, I have to get these words out...

 

[Suzannah]

" The Devil, disguised as an angel of light, appeared to a brother and said to him, 'I am Gabriel and I have been sent to you.' The brother said to him, 'See if it is not someone else to whom you have been sent; as for me, I am not worthy of it.' And immediately, the Devil vanished."

--Wisdom of the Desert Fathers

 

[Moros]

I'd rather read from the Pope's own encyclical's and the Catechism that says Jesus is the only way to be saved.

That has nothing to do with the pope kissing a koran.