• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

What do you like and dislike about Fantasy?

Alarum

Well-Known Member
Nov 5, 2004
4,833
344
✟6,792.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Politics
US-Democrat
gnombient said:
Another peeve about fantasy... I don't like how most fantasy stories these days revolve around "saving the world" in one way or another-- defeating the evil _____, retrieving/destroying the dangerous artifact, fulfilling the prophecy, etc. Of course, this is done by the unlikely hero (who is recruited by the kindly Mysterious Stranger) and his loyal (but diverse) band of companions. :yawn:

I long for the return of the likes of Conan, Fafhrd & the Gray Mouser, Nifft the Lean, et al. Why did they adventure? Often they had things stolen from them, had geases or other enchantments placed upon them by sorcerous types, were blackmailed by gods, or were hard up for some loot to replace that which they had just squandered; good old fashioned revenge was often a factor too...
Hate to say this, because people will get mad at me, but blame Tolkein. Tolkien was the one who started the 'unlikely hero saves the world' genre, and a generation or two of writers have been brought up sucking on that teat. It gets old, very quickly.

Anyway, if you like that sort of novel, Simon R. Green's Hawk and Fisher series is pretty much worth checking out. It's a pretty interesting bunch of novels. Green's novels always start out over the top and get wierder as they go on, so you have to enjoy a pretty madcap pacing, but they're great fun (I personally like the Deathstalker series better, but technically it's not fantasy, and it's pretty much save the universe). The heroes are always pretty properly heroic - there's no everyman heroes in his worlds, and they always have an extra ace (or sometimes deck of cards) up their sleeve. Of course their enemies are properly powerful too, so it gets confusing.
 
Upvote 0

Nienor

why so serious
Jun 7, 2004
12,714
342
37
Seattle
✟37,216.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Green
Alarum said:
Hate to say this, because people will get mad at me, but blame Tolkein. Tolkien was the one who started the 'unlikely hero saves the world' genre, and a generation or two of writers have been brought up sucking on that teat. It gets old, very quickly.

Anyway, if you like that sort of novel, Simon R. Green's Hawk and Fisher series is pretty much worth checking out. It's a pretty interesting bunch of novels. Green's novels always start out over the top and get wierder as they go on, so you have to enjoy a pretty madcap pacing, but they're great fun (I personally like the Deathstalker series better, but technically it's not fantasy, and it's pretty much save the universe). The heroes are always pretty properly heroic - there's no everyman heroes in his worlds, and they always have an extra ace (or sometimes deck of cards) up their sleeve. Of course their enemies are properly powerful too, so it gets confusing.
But Tolkien made it work.
I do wish people would stop leeching of lotr though. ...
 
Upvote 0

Mr_Hursh

Regular Member
Feb 26, 2006
130
9
✟22,812.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Republican
gnombient said:
Another peeve about fantasy... I don't like how most fantasy stories these days revolve around "saving the world" in one way or another-- defeating the evil _____, retrieving/destroying the dangerous artifact, fulfilling the prophecy, etc. Of course, this is done by the unlikely hero (who is recruited by the kindly Mysterious Stranger) and his loyal (but diverse) band of companions. :yawn:

I long for the return of the likes of Conan, Fafhrd & the Gray Mouser, Nifft the Lean, et al. Why did they adventure? Often they had things stolen from them, had geases or other enchantments placed upon them by sorcerous types, were blackmailed by gods, or were hard up for some loot to replace that which they had just squandered; good old fashioned revenge was often a factor too...
I know what the world needs - Fantasy CSI.
 
Upvote 0

stonetoflesh

Well-Known Member
Apr 20, 2004
2,810
52
Round Rock, TX
✟19,560.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Reformed
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Nienor said:
But Tolkien made it work.
I do wish people would stop leeching of lotr though. ...

Tolkien made it work, sure. He also made noble, forest-lovin' elves and grumpy, bearded, axe-wielding dwarves work. Heck, he made them work so well that at this point, I'm so sick of how common those tropes have become that I'm even sick of (gasp!) Tolkien's Middle-Earth as well.

Mr_Hursh said:
I know what the world needs - Fantasy CSI.

I could see something like that being parodied in a Discworld novel...
 
Upvote 0

Nienor

why so serious
Jun 7, 2004
12,714
342
37
Seattle
✟37,216.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Green
gnombient said:
Tolkien made it work, sure. He also made noble, forest-lovin' elves and grumpy, bearded, axe-wielding dwarves work. Heck, he made them work so well that at this point, I'm so sick of how common those tropes have become that I'm even sick of (gasp!) Tolkien's Middle-Earth as well.



I could see something like that being parodied in a Discworld novel...
:eek:
It's ok...I know how you feel. Part of the problem is Tolkien made it work while the people who copy him don't. Mostly since they don't have enough creativity to create their own characters, they don't have the creativity required to create langauges and cultures. That's partly why I can never get through the Shannara books...I think the Sword of Shannara was the most blatant rip off I have ever read....

And Terry Prattchet would definately be my choice to write a fantasy CSi....it woul be hilarious :D
 
Upvote 0

Lessien

It's what I do that defines me
Nov 14, 2004
14,694
233
35
You never know....
✟38,590.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
I never really made it through Eldest. It seemed really cliched to me, and it seemed like he was just reusing characters and settings from other books like LOTR.

It's like fantasy has become so cliched that no books are original anymore, but unless you use the cliches that have already been beaten to death, then people won't accept it as fantasy.
 
Upvote 0

Alarum

Well-Known Member
Nov 5, 2004
4,833
344
✟6,792.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Politics
US-Democrat
Mr_Hursh said:
So if people are sick of cliches, and if it is quite difficult to rid fantasy of cliches, would this mean that the Fantasy Genre is going out of style?
Nope, it means better fantasy is coming into style. We're finally seeing some really interesting works from teh genre, even some that are philosophical (which fantasy usually avoids like the black plague).
 
Upvote 0

Nienor

why so serious
Jun 7, 2004
12,714
342
37
Seattle
✟37,216.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Green
Alarum said:
Nope, it means better fantasy is coming into style. We're finally seeing some really interesting works from teh genre, even some that are philosophical (which fantasy usually avoids like the black plague).
i love the philosophical :)
 
Upvote 0

Tariel

Reader-Writer-Editor
Apr 25, 2005
55,605
1,232
36
✟76,337.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Lessien said:
Yeah. The only mistakes Eragon made were accidentally cursing Elva and making Arya mad. Like ANY of us can relate to the first one!

Roran was very courageous, going after Katrina like that, and his getting mad at Eragon is totally understandable. He seemed sweet, but kind of headstrong--while not always good, his good traits balance out the bad ones.

I kind of sympathised with Murtagh--his joining the Empire and all. In the first book he was my fave, and now, I still like him. You can relate to his turning to the "Dark Side," and even though he's sort of evil, I can still see a little niceness left :)
LOL!!!

In the second book Roran was easily my fav. character ^_^

Ann Murtagh is a close second (if only he had a pronoucable name ^_^)
 
Upvote 0

Tariel

Reader-Writer-Editor
Apr 25, 2005
55,605
1,232
36
✟76,337.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Lessien said:
I never really made it through Eldest. It seemed really cliched to me, and it seemed like he was just reusing characters and settings from other books like LOTR.

It's like fantasy has become so cliched that no books are original anymore, but unless you use the cliches that have already been beaten to death, then people won't accept it as fantasy.
It's true...Star Wars and LOTR all mixed into one story...and somehow I got through it all. Maybe it was because I was desperate for something to read on the plane ^_^
 
Upvote 0

stonetoflesh

Well-Known Member
Apr 20, 2004
2,810
52
Round Rock, TX
✟19,560.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Reformed
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Mr_Hursh said:
So if people are sick of cliches, and if it is quite difficult to rid fantasy of cliches, would this mean that the Fantasy Genre is going out of style?

I would say that fantasy as a literary genre been in the cycle of coming into and going out of style for at least 30 years. On another level I think it's been given a huge shot in the arm in the last 5+ years or so, what with the rousing successes of Harry Potter and the LOTR movies giving the genre an air of real mainstream credibility.

It's difficult to completely get rid of cliches in any fiction genre, be it fantasy, SF, mystery, romance, western, or whatever. There are certain genre cliches that are simply unavoidable-- Westerns are usually set in a particular historical period and geographic region of the US, there are always crimes of some sort in mystery novels, there's always a love interest in romance, etc.-- but this is not the case with fantasy. Does "high fantasy" have to include "elves" as noble pointy-eared vegetarians who live in the forest? Can it emulate, say, an ancient Roman or Mayan civilization instead of medieval Europe? Sure it can, but most of the time it doesn't. Fantasy is the most open-ended of genres, limited only by the author's imagination-- more so than SF even, because no "real world" social, historical or scientific extrapolation is required. Given the collective intellectual laziness on the part of most mainstream fantasy writers in their lassez-faire recycling of Tolkienian cliches, I would say that the fantasy genre deserves to go out of style.

Is it that "medieval fantasy sells, weird stuff doesn't?" I guess some people prefer the comfortable vanilla familiarity of the Tolkienian "high fantasy" world to wrestling with the learning curve of a more exotic setting; they see the same garden-variety elves, wizards, and dragons they loved in Tolkien's books, the same quasi-medieval-European setting, and they're off to the races. More power to them, I guess, but I'll take my vacations elsewhere.
[/rant] :sorry:
 
Upvote 0

Lessien

It's what I do that defines me
Nov 14, 2004
14,694
233
35
You never know....
✟38,590.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
Tariel said:
It's true...Star Wars and LOTR all mixed into one story...and somehow I got through it all. Maybe it was because I was desperate for something to read on the plane ^_^

lol. I was desperate for something to read at camp, but I figured I could do better than Eldest. I just skipped ahead to the end and read all the chapters that looked important so I could discuss it with my friends who seem to think Paolini is the next Tolkien. Maybe it's because he copied everything Tolkien did, then mixed it with a little Star Wars? :sick:

LOL!!!

In the second book Roran was easily my fav. character ^_^

Ann Murtagh is a close second (if only he had a pronoucable name ^_^)

YES! FINALLY! Someone who doesn't think Eragon was the best character since Frodo Baggins! ^_^
 
Upvote 0

Nienor

why so serious
Jun 7, 2004
12,714
342
37
Seattle
✟37,216.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Green
gnombient said:
I would say that fantasy as a literary genre been in the cycle of coming into and going out of style for at least 30 years. On another level I think it's been given a huge shot in the arm in the last 5+ years or so, what with the rousing successes of Harry Potter and the LOTR movies giving the genre an air of real mainstream credibility.

It's difficult to completely get rid of cliches in any fiction genre, be it fantasy, SF, mystery, romance, western, or whatever. There are certain genre cliches that are simply unavoidable-- Westerns are usually set in a particular historical period and geographic region of the US, there are always crimes of some sort in mystery novels, there's always a love interest in romance, etc.-- but this is not the case with fantasy. Does "high fantasy" have to include "elves" as noble pointy-eared vegetarians who live in the forest? Can it emulate, say, an ancient Roman or Mayan civilization instead of medieval Europe? Sure it can, but most of the time it doesn't. Fantasy is the most open-ended of genres, limited only by the author's imagination-- more so than SF even, because no "real world" social, historical or scientific extrapolation is required. Given the collective intellectual laziness on the part of most mainstream fantasy writers in their lassez-faire recycling of Tolkienian cliches, I would say that the fantasy genre deserves to go out of style.

Is it that "medieval fantasy sells, weird stuff doesn't?" I guess some people prefer the comfortable vanilla familiarity of the Tolkienian "high fantasy" world to wrestling with the learning curve of a more exotic setting; they see the same garden-variety elves, wizards, and dragons they loved in Tolkien's books, the same quasi-medieval-European setting, and they're off to the races. More power to them, I guess, but I'll take my vacations elsewhere.
[/rant] :sorry:
:amen:

My two favorite fantasy series at the moment are far from the cliches...George RR Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire is just amazing and works with a minimum of magic, which is something I enjoy, no one magically escapes.
The other is CS Friedman's Cold Fire Trilogy. One of the main characters who is forced to fight is one of the most hated villains. His relationship with the other main character is great. I love the whole series :)

On the other hand, I cannot stand Wheel of Time, Sword of Truth or Shannara.
 
Upvote 0

Alarum

Well-Known Member
Nov 5, 2004
4,833
344
✟6,792.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Politics
US-Democrat
Nienor said:
:amen:

My two favorite fantasy series at the moment are far from the cliches...George RR Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire is just amazing and works with a minimum of magic, which is something I enjoy, no one magically escapes.
The other is CS Friedman's Cold Fire Trilogy. One of the main characters who is forced to fight is one of the most hated villains. His relationship with the other main character is great. I love the whole series :)

On the other hand, I cannot stand Wheel of Time, Sword of Truth or Shannara.
There's someone else who has read the Coldfire Trilogy? Oh man! We're so rare!

Those books come highly recommended, for anyone who hasn't read them. They are very, very good.
 
Upvote 0

Nienor

why so serious
Jun 7, 2004
12,714
342
37
Seattle
✟37,216.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Green
Alarum said:
There's someone else who has read the Coldfire Trilogy? Oh man! We're so rare!

Those books come highly recommended, for anyone who hasn't read them. They are very, very good.
I'm just a surprised to find another person who has read them :D I also highly recommend them
 
Upvote 0

Tariel

Reader-Writer-Editor
Apr 25, 2005
55,605
1,232
36
✟76,337.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Lessien said:
lol. I was desperate for something to read at camp, but I figured I could do better than Eldest. I just skipped ahead to the end and read all the chapters that looked important so I could discuss it with my friends who seem to think Paolini is the next Tolkien. Maybe it's because he copied everything Tolkien did, then mixed it with a little Star Wars? :sick:
exactly :sick: I am sooo glad somebody else noticed! My best friend's little sister is obsessed with those books :sigh:


Lessien said:
YES! FINALLY! Someone who doesn't think Eragon was the best character since Frodo Baggins! ^_^

:amen:
 
Upvote 0