• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Was Mary without sin?

Was Mary without sin?

  • Yes

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Iollain

Jer 18:2-6
May 18, 2004
8,269
48
Atlantic Coast
✟8,725.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
In Relationship
Also , why do not the early - ECF's not talk about Mary being bodily resurrected? They talk about Jesus being bodily resurrected, and the bodily resurrection of humans THAT IS TO COME, not not once do they talk about Mary's bodily resurrection, that would have really been something to mention, ya know.
 
Upvote 0

Catherineanne

Well-Known Member
Sep 1, 2004
22,924
4,646
Europe
✟84,370.00
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Female
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Widowed
The Orthodox Churches teach that she was made pure and whole (the stain of Adam's removed) when Christ entered her womb, and that she was born just like the rest of us.

That, in a nutshell is the difference between the beliefs of The Church of Rome and the other Churches concerning Mary's sinlessness.

Forgive me...


This makes a great deal of sense to me, as an Anglican. It is consistent with God's holiness, and with our humanity.

Therefore I see no reason why the Anglican church would find anything to disagree with in this. Won't stop some Anglicans from having their own views, but this is consistent with all that I know.

:wave:

(Absolvo te ... :) )
 
Upvote 0

Benedicta00

Well-Known Member
Jun 25, 2003
28,512
838
Visit site
✟55,563.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Private
The Orthodox Churches teach that she was made pure and whole (the stain of Adam's removed) when Christ entered her womb, and that she was born just like the rest of us.

That, in a nutshell is the difference between the beliefs of The Church of Rome and the other Churches concerning Mary's sinlessness.

Forgive me...
I'm aware of that but I don't think IAA is. I think she was pinning her hopes of proving since 300 AD the sinlessness of Mary was in dispute because the IC doctrine is what was in dispute.

We understand that when Rome makes a dogma it is to end any dispute amongst the theologians and the faithful. That now we are to accept the doctrine with out question. Orthodox are not under that authority.

It is she who doesn't understand the two are not the same and that no ECF ever disputed her sinlessness.
 
Upvote 0

Benedicta00

Well-Known Member
Jun 25, 2003
28,512
838
Visit site
✟55,563.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Private
I stated that this dogma that you all follow was not even brought around until the 5th century.. By Pope Pius and He didn't even have the council on it He just stated it and said that anyone who went against this teaching was athema...
yes I know but this has little to with all of Christendom who never doubted her sinlessness. if you think they did, then cite them please.
 
Upvote 0

Benedicta00

Well-Known Member
Jun 25, 2003
28,512
838
Visit site
✟55,563.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Private
I don't think sinless people die. All of mankind are going to die, unless your the ones who are in the Rapture.....they will be changed into incorruptible.
The Church says it's okay to speculate that she may not have died in the same way you and I will. We call this her dormition.
 
Upvote 0

OrthodoxyUSA

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Jul 6, 2004
25,292
2,868
61
Tupelo, MS
Visit site
✟187,274.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Also , why do not the early - ECF's not talk about Mary being bodily resurrected? They talk about Jesus being bodily resurrected, and the bodily resurrection of humans THAT IS TO COME, not not once do they talk about Mary's bodily resurrection, that would have really been something to mention, ya know.

They did, your just ignoring the ones who did.

Forgive me...:liturgy:
 
Upvote 0

Benedicta00

Well-Known Member
Jun 25, 2003
28,512
838
Visit site
✟55,563.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Private
Also , why do not the early - ECF's not talk about Mary being bodily resurrected? They talk about Jesus being bodily resurrected, and the bodily resurrection of humans THAT IS TO COME, not not once do they talk about Mary's bodily resurrection, that would have really been something to mention, ya know.
Bodily Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary

"If the Holy Virgin had died and was buried, her falling asleep would have been surrounded with honour, death would have found her pure, and her crown would have been a virginal one...Had she been martyred according to what is written: 'Thine own soul a sword shall pierce', then she would shine gloriously among the martyrs, and her holy body would have been declared blessed; for by her, did light come to the world."
Epiphanius,Panarion,78:23(A.D. 377),in PG 42:737

"[T]he Apostles took up her body on a bier and placed it in a tomb; and they guarded it, expecting the Lord to come. And behold, again the Lord stood by them; and the holy body having been received, He commanded that it be taken in a cloud into paradise: where now, rejoined to the soul, [Mary] rejoices with the Lord's chosen ones..."
Gregory of Tours, Eight Books of Miracles,1:4(inter A.D. 575-593),in JUR,III:306

"As the most glorious Mother of Christ,our Savior and God and the giver of life and immortality, has been endowed with life by him, she has received an eternal incorruptibility of the body together with him who has raised her up from the tomb and has taken her up to himself in a way known only to him."
Modestus of Jerusalem,Encomium in dormitionnem Sanctissimae Dominae nostrae Deiparae semperque Virginis Mariae(PG 86-II,3306),(ante A.D. 634) from Munificentis simus Deus

"It was fitting ... that the most holy-body of Mary, God-bearing body, receptacle of God, divinised, incorruptible, illuminated by divine grace and full glory ... should be entrusted to the earth for a little while and raised up to heaven in glory, with her soul pleasing to God."
Theoteknos of Livias,Homily on the Assumption(ante A.D. 650),in THEO,57

"You are she who, as it is written, appears in beauty, and your virginal body is all holy, all chaste, entirely the dewlling place of God, so that it is henceforth completely exempt from dissoultion into dust. Though still human, it is changed into the heavenly life of incorruptibility, truly living and glorious, undamaged and sharing in perfect life."
Germanus of Constantinople,Sermon I(PG 98,346),(ante A.D. 733),from Munificentis simus Deus

"It was fitting that the she, who had kept her virginity intact in childbirth, should keep her own body free from all corruption even after death. It was fitting that she, who had carried the Creator as a child at her breast, should dwell in the divine tabernacles. It was fitting that the spouse, whom the Father had taken to himself, should live in the divine mansions. It was fitting that she, who had seen her Son upon the cross and who had thereby received into her heart the sword of sorrow which she had escaped when giving birth to him, should look upon him as he sits with the Father, It was fitting that God's Mother should possess what belongs to her Son, and that she should be honored by every creature as the Mother and as the handmaid of God"
John of Damascene,Dormition of Mary(PG 96,741),(ante A.D. 749) from Munificentis simus Deus

" 'St. Juvenal, Bishop of Jerusalem, at the Council of Chalcedon (451), made known to the Emperor Marcian and Pulcheria, who wished to possess the body of the Mother of God, that Mary died in the presence of all the Apostles, but that her tomb, when opened upon the request of St. Thomas, was found empty; wherefrom the Apostles concluded that the body was taken up to heaven.' "
John of Damascene,PG(96:1)(A.D. 747-751)

"Venerable to us, O Lord, is the festivity of this day on which the holy Mother of God suffered temporal death, but still could not be kept down by the bonds of death, who has begotten Thy Son our Lord incarnate from herself."
Gregorian Sacramentary,Veneranda(ante A.D. 795), from Munificentis simus Deus

"[A]n effable mystery all the more worthy of praise as the Virgin's Assumption is something unique among men."
Gallican Sacramentary, from Munificentis simus Deus

"God, the King of the universe, has granted you favors that surpass nature. As he kept you virgin in childbirth, thus he kept your body incorrupt in the tomb and has glorified it by his divine act of transferring it from the tomb." Byzantine Liturgy, from Munificentis simus Deus

"[T]he virgin is up to now immortal, as He who lived, translated her into the place of reception"
Timotheus of Jerusalem(6th-8th century),in OTT,208
 
Upvote 0

Iollain

Jer 18:2-6
May 18, 2004
8,269
48
Atlantic Coast
✟8,725.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
In Relationship
"If the Holy Virgin had died and was buried, her falling asleep would have been surrounded with honour, death would have found her pure, and her crown would have been a virginal one...Had she been martyred according to what is written: 'Thine own soul a sword shall pierce', then she would shine gloriously among the martyrs, and her holy body would have been declared blessed; for by her, did light come to the world."
Epiphanius,Panarion,78:23(A.D. 377),in PG 42:737

So what does this say about Mary being risen to incorruptible? The resurrection of the body did not happen yet, only Jesus, as the early ECF's all say and the Bible.

This guy is talking like he does not have a clue what happened, if Mary was martyred or not he does not know.
 
Upvote 0

Iollain

Jer 18:2-6
May 18, 2004
8,269
48
Atlantic Coast
✟8,725.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
In Relationship
"[T]he Apostles took up her body on a bier and placed it in a tomb; and they guarded it, expecting the Lord to come. And behold, again the Lord stood by them; and the holy body having been received, He commanded that it be taken in a cloud into paradise: where now, rejoined to the soul, [Mary] rejoices with the Lord's chosen ones..."
Gregory of Tours, Eight Books of Miracles,1:4(inter A.D. 575-593),in JUR,III:306


So where did he get this from and why does he think that Mary has been bodily resurrected, and why does he think there are others in Heaven that have been bodily resurrected?

I suppose the rest all got this from this guy.


1Cr 15:22 For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive.


1Cr 15:23 But every man in his own order: Christ the firstfruits; afterward they that are Christ's at his coming.
 
Upvote 0

Iollain

Jer 18:2-6
May 18, 2004
8,269
48
Atlantic Coast
✟8,725.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
In Relationship
as per standard, nothing prior to AD 300. earliest A.D. 377. typical of marian doctrines!

This was not until 575-593, that someone even suggested that Mary was resurrected uncorruptible, the first one there does not say a thing about it.
 
Upvote 0

StTherese

Peace begins with a smile :)
Aug 23, 2006
3,222
855
✟30,233.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Married
I voted No..I think something that important would have been mentioned by the apostles as an exception to "all have sinned"..pax..Kim
What about innocent children who die before they have sinned? What about Christ...wasn't He without sin?
 
Upvote 0

Kenpo

Active Member
Mar 1, 2007
249
12
In my home
✟15,439.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
What about innocent children who die before they have sinned? What about Christ...wasn't He without sin?
And Scripture does point out that Jesus was sinless. There is precedent there in that it was clearly pointed out that he was. I guess it seemed note worthy.
 
Upvote 0

Iollain

Jer 18:2-6
May 18, 2004
8,269
48
Atlantic Coast
✟8,725.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
In Relationship
What about innocent children who die before they have sinned? What about Christ...wasn't He without sin?





Rom 5:12 ¶ Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned:


Rom 5:13 (For until the law sin was in the world: but sin is not imputed when there is no law.


Rom 5:14 Nevertheless death reigned from Adam to Moses, even over them that had not sinned after the similitude of Adam's transgression, who is the figure of him that was to come.


Rom 5:15 But not as the offence, so also [is] the free gift. For if through the offence of one many be dead, much more the grace of God, and the gift by grace, [which is] by one man, Jesus Christ, hath abounded unto many.


Rom 5:16 And not as [it was] by one that sinned, [so is] the gift: for the judgment [was] by one to condemnation, but the free gift [is] of many offences unto justification.


Rom 5:17 For if by one man's offence death reigned by one; much more they which receive abundance of grace and of the gift of righteousness shall reign in life by one, Jesus Christ.)


Rom 5:18 Therefore as by the offence of one [judgment came] upon all men to condemnation; even so by the righteousness of one [the free gift came] upon all men unto justification of life.


Rom 5:19 For as by one man's disobedience many were made sinners, so by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous.


Rom 5:20 Moreover the law entered, that the offence might abound. But where sin abounded, grace did much more abound:


Rom 5:21 That as sin hath reigned unto death, even so might grace reign through righteousness unto eternal life by Jesus Christ our Lord.




Innocent children who die before they sin are still going to Sheol because they are from and are Adam, they would have no chance of getting out of death without the spotless sinless sacrafice, and the resurrection of Jesus.







Yes Christ was without sin:


2 Corinthians 5
21For he hath made him to be sin for us, who knew no sin; that we might be made the righteousness of God in him.

Hebrews 4:
15For we have not an high priest which cannot be touched with the feeling of our infirmities; but was in all points tempted like as we are, yet without sin.


Romans 8
3For what the law could not do, in that it was weak through the flesh, God sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin, condemned sin in the flesh:

Romans 8:
4That the righteousness of the law might be fulfilled in us, who walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit.


Revelation 3:
21To him that overcometh will I grant to sit with me in my throne, even as I also overcame, and am set down with my Father in his throne.


The Word never knew sin.
 
Upvote 0

Axion

Senior Veteran
Feb 5, 2003
2,942
301
uk
Visit site
✟4,616.00
Faith
Catholic
The verse saying "all have sinned" is normally used out of its context, since it does not appear in scripture with any reference to Mary. Therefore the only way that it can possibly be made to apply to Mary is if the word 'ALL' is an absolute that rules out all possible exceptions. Yet Jesus, the heavenly angels, the newborn, and some in other categories are clear exceptions to Romans 3.23. The key here is that the word 'ALL' in this verse is the Greek word, 'PAS', which can have different meanings to the absolute that we immediately think of - as shown in other verses of Holy Scripture.

John 12:
19, "All the world has gone after him!" Did everyone in the entire world really go after Christ?

Mt 3:
5-6, "Then went out to Him Jerusalem, and ALL Judea, and ALL the region about the Jordan; and they were baptized by him in the Jordan, confessing their sins."
Were all of the people of Judea, and the region about the Jordan baptized?


Luke 2:1 "And an order went out from caesar Augustus that ALL the world should be counted."
Was everyone in the whole world counted?

Rom 11:
26, "ALL Israel shall be saved." Will everyone in Israel truly be saved?

Rom 15:
14, "...you yourselves are full of love, filled with ALL knowledge..." The only person filled with 'ALL' knowledge is God Himself.

The Greek word 'PAS' in many verses in Scripture simply means a 'great number', 'most of', or 'a lot'. So its appearance in the quoted passage can in no way be used as an objection to the sinlessness of the Virgin Mary.
 
Upvote 0

sunlover1

Beloved, Let us love one another
Nov 10, 2006
26,146
5,348
Under the Shadow of the Almighty
✟102,311.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
The verse saying "all have sinned" is normally used out of its context, since it does not appear in scripture with any reference to Mary. Therefore the only way that it can possibly be made to apply to Mary is if the word 'ALL' is an absolute that rules out all possible exceptions. Yet Jesus, the heavenly angels, the newborn, and some in other categories are clear exceptions to Romans 3.23. The key here is that the word 'ALL' in this verse is the Greek word, 'PAS', which can have different meanings to the absolute that we immediately think of - as shown in other verses of Holy Scripture.

John 12:
19, "All the world has gone after him!" Did everyone in the entire world really go after Christ?

Mt 3:
5-6, "Then went out to Him Jerusalem, and ALL Judea, and ALL the region about the Jordan; and they were baptized by him in the Jordan, confessing their sins."
Were all of the people of Judea, and the region about the Jordan baptized?


Luke 2:1 "And an order went out from caesar Augustus that ALL the world should be counted."
Was everyone in the whole world counted?

Rom 11:
26, "ALL Israel shall be saved." Will everyone in Israel truly be saved?

Rom 15:
14, "...you yourselves are full of love, filled with ALL knowledge..." The only person filled with 'ALL' knowledge is God Himself.

The Greek word 'PAS' in many verses in Scripture simply means a 'great number', 'most of', or 'a lot'. So its appearance in the quoted passage can in no way be used as an objection to the sinlessness of the Virgin Mary.
Thank you Axion.
So it really means all have sinned
except some?
Or is it all have sinned except Mary
and Jesus?
 
Upvote 0

Axion

Senior Veteran
Feb 5, 2003
2,942
301
uk
Visit site
✟4,616.00
Faith
Catholic
Thank you Axion.
So it really means all have sinned
except some?
Or is it all have sinned except Mary
and Jesus?

I is a rhetorical "all" used to make a point about the need to stop depending on ther Mosaic law and to follow Jesus. It is not an absolute dogmatic ruling
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.