• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Veil removed...

Status
Not open for further replies.

BigNorsk

Contributor
Nov 23, 2004
6,736
815
67
✟33,457.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Married
Say Scott,

What part of the cities are you in now? Close to the capital or far out?

In order to find what you are looking for, do you need to go into the city or further out or just get a lot smaller? Say a duplex instead of a single family unit.

I was also wondering, why do you think your wife hasn't found the relationships a woman needs in a congregation where you have been. I know us guys tend to be doctrine doctrine doctrine, but it seems to me most women are a lot more in tune to whether others are friendly and really care and so on. And this isn't any hidden shot at the LCMS or anything. It's just if your wife met some real friends in the church I doubt if you could have pried her out with a big stick. More than a few congregations have a woman or two that do their best to chase people away, maybe your wife ran into one of those buzzsaws.

Some congregations do fall into a pattern of condemning young women all the time, I think without even realizing it. When you look at all the demands placed on them, a constant diet of "You aren't doing it right." would get pretty old pretty quick. Sometimes people hear that message when it is from within themselves and not from others.

Children issues also seems to be a time when in many marriages a conflict that didn't seem that large before, becomes more important because that's the church your children will hopefully grow up in. Maybe she has some issues with that congregation in particular or your synod in general that she still hasn't been able to really accept even though she has tried.

You don't need to respond, its just something to think about as you look for a new home.

We had quite a time finding a church home here when we got married. We even went to a church in Canada, they were real friendly but the problem was the border, and it didn't seem that we could get past being the "Americans". We just weren't going to really become a part of that congregation. It took awhile but we did settle at Ebenezer. We sure wish it wasn't that 30 mile drive all the time though.

My wife has talked quite a bit about starting a congregation here. A couple of times she thought we should join one of the missionary groups here. I guess I did what Chirho said and put my foot down. Though somehow it sounds a bit different when he says it. Anyway, it wasn't because I thought the groups were so bad, but there were things that were warning flags to me so I kind of vetoed any such idea. I would say that there were a couple of congregations that I could have been just fine at, that we didn't go to because of somewhat the same thing for my wife. So they just didn't fit us.

That's the thing, in marriage two become one. Our doctrine says it, yet I don't think a lot of people really believe it, they still treat a couple like two separate people. Your family is going through quite a time of change now, I sure hope is doesn't decline into your way vs. her way.

One thing I would suggest, it has it's own dangers, but I think you two are strong enough, is to go to some services at some of the churches you two "would never go to." Now why would I suggest that, it is so you can spend some time afterwards talking about them, what they did right, what they did wrong, and what is the proper way to worship. It's one way to bring up doctrine without having to start out with doctrine.

It's also good to do a little "the ideal congregation would be..."

You know, a lot of couples never go through a time of really getting to know each other after they get married, I guess what I am recommending is almost like when you were dating and you just couldn't wait to learn all about the other person, to go back to that a bit to make sure the family's course is going down a common path.

One thing I think you should examine is the issue of adiaphora. Now a lot might say something is adiaphora but in practice, they would require it. Now if something that is adiaphora becomes required then it is no longer adiaphora at all, but something to be fought against for to make the areas of freedom no freedom at all becomes a false gospel. It is likely in this area where some of the conflicts between you exist. You might say something is an area of freedom and she might respond with asking why then does every congregation you would consider do it that way? Where is the freedom?

And how is that pneumonia going?

Marv
 
Upvote 0

SPALATIN

Lifetime friend of Dr. Luther
May 5, 2004
4,905
139
63
Fort Wayne, Indiana
✟20,851.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
BigNorsk said:
Say Scott,

What part of the cities are you in now? Close to the capital or far out?

In order to find what you are looking for, do you need to go into the city or further out or just get a lot smaller? Say a duplex instead of a single family unit.

I was also wondering, why do you think your wife hasn't found the relationships a woman needs in a congregation where you have been. I know us guys tend to be doctrine doctrine doctrine, but it seems to me most women are a lot more in tune to whether others are friendly and really care and so on. And this isn't any hidden shot at the LCMS or anything. It's just if your wife met some real friends in the church I doubt if you could have pried her out with a big stick. More than a few congregations have a woman or two that do their best to chase people away, maybe your wife ran into one of those buzzsaws.

Some congregations do fall into a pattern of condemning young women all the time, I think without even realizing it. When you look at all the demands placed on them, a constant diet of "You aren't doing it right." would get pretty old pretty quick. Sometimes people hear that message when it is from within themselves and not from others.

Children issues also seems to be a time when in many marriages a conflict that didn't seem that large before, becomes more important because that's the church your children will hopefully grow up in. Maybe she has some issues with that congregation in particular or your synod in general that she still hasn't been able to really accept even though she has tried.

You don't need to respond, its just something to think about as you look for a new home.

We had quite a time finding a church home here when we got married. We even went to a church in Canada, they were real friendly but the problem was the border, and it didn't seem that we could get past being the "Americans". We just weren't going to really become a part of that congregation. It took awhile but we did settle at Ebenezer. We sure wish it wasn't that 30 mile drive all the time though.

My wife has talked quite a bit about starting a congregation here. A couple of times she thought we should join one of the missionary groups here. I guess I did what Chirho said and put my foot down. Though somehow it sounds a bit different when he says it. Anyway, it wasn't because I thought the groups were so bad, but there were things that were warning flags to me so I kind of vetoed any such idea. I would say that there were a couple of congregations that I could have been just fine at, that we didn't go to because of somewhat the same thing for my wife. So they just didn't fit us.

That's the thing, in marriage two become one. Our doctrine says it, yet I don't think a lot of people really believe it, they still treat a couple like two separate people. Your family is going through quite a time of change now, I sure hope is doesn't decline into your way vs. her way.

One thing I would suggest, it has it's own dangers, but I think you two are strong enough, is to go to some services at some of the churches you two "would never go to." Now why would I suggest that, it is so you can spend some time afterwards talking about them, what they did right, what they did wrong, and what is the proper way to worship. It's one way to bring up doctrine without having to start out with doctrine.

It's also good to do a little "the ideal congregation would be..."

You know, a lot of couples never go through a time of really getting to know each other after they get married, I guess what I am recommending is almost like when you were dating and you just couldn't wait to learn all about the other person, to go back to that a bit to make sure the family's course is going down a common path.

One thing I think you should examine is the issue of adiaphora. Now a lot might say something is adiaphora but in practice, they would require it. Now if something that is adiaphora becomes required then it is no longer adiaphora at all, but something to be fought against for to make the areas of freedom no freedom at all becomes a false gospel. It is likely in this area where some of the conflicts between you exist. You might say something is an area of freedom and she might respond with asking why then does every congregation you would consider do it that way? Where is the freedom?

And how is that pneumonia going?

Marv

Wow,

You have given me a lot to think about. Appreciate the advice. We right now live in a south metro suburb and are looking at moving further south and west of the Twin City Metro area.

Thanks Marv.
 
Upvote 0

ByzantineDixie

Handmaid of God, Mary
Jan 11, 2004
3,178
144
Visit site
✟26,649.00
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
ChiRho said:
Did you just say "Chicago Folk Service?" :doh:

I have never heard of such a thing.

Oh...we have been doing this for the past couple of months on Wednesday nights--it's old, from the 70's. My biggest complaints are that the absolution seems hidden (I keep waiting for the pronouncement in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit and it never comes), the order of worship throws me off, there doesn't seem to be a place for prayers of the faithful (or else we aren't using it properly) and I absolutely HATE, HATE, HATE the groovy tune used for the Agnus Dei! I have heard the Lamb of God set to all kinds of music and have heard many beautiful and reverent tunes for this section of the Liturgy but for the time in the service where this takes place...the Chicago Folk Service tune just seems horribly wrong. You know, ChiChi...you need to get out more to see what the rest of the world has to contend with for worship.

Now regarding the husband picking the house of worship...let's put the shoe on the other foot. What if my husband decided to be ELCA? Do these same "husband picks" rules apply? Well, what if he wanted to be Baptist or Pentacostal? Or better yet, a snake handler? Now you know that I fully support a husband's leadership in a marriage but this isn't as simple as it first appears. A woman must not knowingly embrace error. So don't make it appear so cut and dried. In real life it is far from it.
 
Upvote 0

Jim47

Heaven Bound
Site Supporter
Nov 28, 2004
12,394
825
77
Michigan
✟69,737.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Luthers Rose said:
Now regarding the husband picking the house of worship...let's put the shoe on the other foot. What if my husband decided to be ELCA? Do these same "husband picks" rules apply? Well, what if he wanted to be Baptist or Pentacostal? Or better yet, a snake handler? Now you know that I fully support a husband's leadership in a marriage but this isn't as simple as it first appears. A woman must not knowingly embrace error. So don't make it appear so cut and dried. In real life it is far from it.

Very good answer Rose. Its always to see an easy answer to someone elses problem, finding the correct answer however may take a little more time. I have 38 years of marriage under the belt and I'm still learning. :thumbsup:
 
Upvote 0

ChiRho

Confessional Lutheran Catholic
Mar 5, 2004
1,821
99
44
Fort Wayne
✟17,482.00
Faith
Lutheran
Politics
US-Libertarian
zion34736 said:
I knew you were from Minnesota - my Dad always used this last saying, too.

My husband and I got a hoot out of a 24 years old - (and I think I remember from another thread - porshe driving kid) giving advise on marriage to a husband and father of two. If my son (about ChiRho's age) were to mouth off to his Dad regarding me that way he'd learn something about respecting and submission. I think the woodshed comes to mind...spare the rod, spoil the ...

Your memory isn't what it used to be. The article that you "remember" was written by Vox Day. He was 23 years old witha Porsche and a record contract. I am 24 with none of that. Two completely different people.

Was I wrong in my advice? Could you show me where I have spoken error? Does age necessarily disqualify me from making a correct assessment? If so, how and why?

PS- Id like to see your husband take me behind the woodshed. :thumbsup:
 
Upvote 0

ChiRho

Confessional Lutheran Catholic
Mar 5, 2004
1,821
99
44
Fort Wayne
✟17,482.00
Faith
Lutheran
Politics
US-Libertarian
Luthers Rose said:
Oh...we have been doing this for the past couple of months on Wednesday nights--it's old, from the 70's. My biggest complaints are that the absolution seems hidden (I keep waiting for the pronouncement in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit and it never comes), the order of worship throws me off, there doesn't seem to be a place for prayers of the faithful (or else we aren't using it properly) and I absolutely HATE, HATE, HATE the groovy tune used for the Agnus Dei! I have heard the Lamb of God set to all kinds of music and have heard many beautiful and reverent tunes for this section of the Liturgy but for the time in the service where this takes place...the Chicago Folk Service tune just seems horribly wrong. You know, ChiChi...you need to get out more to see what the rest of the world has to contend with for worship.

Now regarding the husband picking the house of worship...let's put the shoe on the other foot. What if my husband decided to be ELCA? Do these same "husband picks" rules apply? Well, what if he wanted to be Baptist or Pentacostal? Or better yet, a snake handler? Now you know that I fully support a husband's leadership in a marriage but this isn't as simple as it first appears. A woman must not knowingly embrace error. So don't make it appear so cut and dried. In real life it is far from it.


I was waiting for someone to bring this up. We are always loyal to God first and then to man. If one's husband is choosing a different authority to guide his judgement by then Scripture, then no, one does not follow him into Hell. But this is not a light matter, as one's interpretation tends to seem objective with our sinful delusions. Careful and prayerful consideration must be excersized. A good place to start is the Creeds, followed by what catholic tradition has spoken during her continous 2000 year reign. If a church differs with these, then a sincere Q & A regarding why is necessary. Well, husband's, you've received one helluva responsibility. Don't screw it up....
 
Upvote 0

ByzantineDixie

Handmaid of God, Mary
Jan 11, 2004
3,178
144
Visit site
✟26,649.00
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
ChiRho said:
If one's husband is choosing a different authority to guide his judgement by then Scripture, then no, one does not follow him into Hell. But this is not a light matter, as one's interpretation tends to seem objective with our sinful delusions.

I kinda had to laugh at this...in each of my examples (well, except maybe for the ELCA) the husband would have said he surely is following Scripture! So whose interpretation of Scripture does one believe? You have heard the expression that sola scriptura makes every man a pope...so which little pope is right?

Ah...but you didn't stop here because you said:

ChiRho said:
A good place to start is the Creeds, followed by what catholic tradition has spoken during her continous 2000 year reign. If a church differs with these, then a sincere Q & A regarding why is necessary.

With this guide one does not have to agonize over or become subject to erroneous interpretation or to one little pope's interpretation. I am glad you included it.
 
Upvote 0

SPALATIN

Lifetime friend of Dr. Luther
May 5, 2004
4,905
139
63
Fort Wayne, Indiana
✟20,851.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
ChiRho said:
Your memory isn't what it used to be. The article which you "remember" was written by Vox Day. He was 23 years old witha Porsche and a record contract. I am 24 with none of that. Two completely different people.

Was I wrong in my advice? Could you show me where I have spoken error? Does age necessarily disqualify me from making a correct assessment? If so, how and why?

PS- Id like to see your husband take me behind the woodshed. :thumbsup:

ChiRho,


Watch it ChiRho, He might just the one to do it. ;)
 
Upvote 0

C.F.W. Walther

Well-Known Member
May 11, 2005
3,571
148
79
MissourA
✟19,479.00
Faith
Seeker
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Constitution
Here is a quote and then the link to an article written by a woman about husband/wife relationship in a Christian marriage.

http://www.lutherannews.info/articles/dpreus.htm



This is not easy. Husbands do not deserve it. Husbands are not capable. Husbands are not sensitive. Husbands are poor miserable sinners. But don't you think God knew all that when He had it recorded in scripture about wives submitting to their husbands? (Ephesians 5; I Peter 3) God said it so that settles it. Besides, wives are poor miserable sinners too. The husband has to love his wife as Christ loves the Church. The wife is probably not worth it except Jesus thought so. If the wife expects her husband to look at her as Christ looks at her, then she must look at her husband, with his shortcomings and all, as Christ looks at him. Love your husband as yourself. And talk theology.
So I fell in love with Rolf. He has a few flaws, but I thought I could live with them. We are going to live happily ever after. We talk theology. After we are married I adjust to these flaws and learn to live with them. Rolf points out he can live with these flaws of MINE as well. Sometimes we struggle to live with all these flaws. We adjust, talk theology and we adjust, talk theology and we adjust, talk theology and we live happily ever after.

It is the wife's duty to look to her husband as the head of the family. She can always find a good reason to take over the headship of the household, but I don’t think she is truly happy. God knows that the husband needs the respect of his wife and children. Remember God instituted marriage. It is God that uses marriage to explain the relationship between Christ and the church. When the wife submits to God's Word, her husband and her children will willingly respect and honor her all the more. In the same way, when the church submits to Christ she is blessed. God is good and gracious. Be humble and pray God will give your husband strength and wisdom through God’s Word. And talk theology.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.