Simchat:
1) Orthodox Rabbis have pointed out, just as our dear friend Hix has done, that Kabbalah is much more ancient than the 13th century.
HT:
Since Hix lists their age as eighteen, they probably have not studied kabbalah under the supervision of a rabbi as you state needs to be done to have knowledge and understanding.
As I pointed out as well:
"and then turn around and use a system that came into the culture initially during the babylonian captivity, and then at a later time became a written system."
Simchat:
So when was Kabbalah formed? You keep changing your story! Was it during Babylonian captivity? Was it during the 13th century? which was it?
HT:
As stated above, the exposure initially came to the Jews during the captivity, and the sephardics in Spain came up with a defined written system.
Simchat:
Your refusal to seek guidance and instruction on this matter from an Orthodox Jew only compounds the ignorance you post.
HT:
Should I seek out a Lubavitcher, who certainly would be considered orthodox. Through the use of kabbalah as a form of scriptural interpretation, they determined that their rebbe was the Messiah.They were very disillusioned when he did not return. There is a history of this occuring.
Simchat:
2) Once again you are bordering awefully close to antisemitism.
HT:
Let's not use the anti-semitism card in place of scholarship. This is a ludicrous accusation, as some of my family members are known as Reuven and Levi, and a host of others. Is the statement below not true?
"They were written by men that were not believers in the Messiah."
1) Orthodox Rabbis have pointed out, just as our dear friend Hix has done, that Kabbalah is much more ancient than the 13th century.
HT:
Since Hix lists their age as eighteen, they probably have not studied kabbalah under the supervision of a rabbi as you state needs to be done to have knowledge and understanding.
As I pointed out as well:
"and then turn around and use a system that came into the culture initially during the babylonian captivity, and then at a later time became a written system."
Simchat:
So when was Kabbalah formed? You keep changing your story! Was it during Babylonian captivity? Was it during the 13th century? which was it?
HT:
As stated above, the exposure initially came to the Jews during the captivity, and the sephardics in Spain came up with a defined written system.
Simchat:
Your refusal to seek guidance and instruction on this matter from an Orthodox Jew only compounds the ignorance you post.
HT:
Should I seek out a Lubavitcher, who certainly would be considered orthodox. Through the use of kabbalah as a form of scriptural interpretation, they determined that their rebbe was the Messiah.They were very disillusioned when he did not return. There is a history of this occuring.
Simchat:
2) Once again you are bordering awefully close to antisemitism.
HT:
Let's not use the anti-semitism card in place of scholarship. This is a ludicrous accusation, as some of my family members are known as Reuven and Levi, and a host of others. Is the statement below not true?
"They were written by men that were not believers in the Messiah."
Upvote
0
