• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

  • CF has always been a site that welcomes people from different backgrounds and beliefs to participate in discussion and even debate. That is the nature of its ministry. In view of recent events emotions are running very high. We need to remind people of some basic principles in debating on this site. We need to be civil when we express differences in opinion. No personal attacks. Avoid you, your statements. Don't characterize an entire political party with comparisons to Fascism or Communism or other extreme movements that committed atrocities. CF is not the place for broad brush or blanket statements about groups and political parties. Put the broad brushes and blankets away when you come to CF, better yet, put them in the incinerator. Debate had no place for them. We need to remember that people that commit acts of violence represent themselves or a small extreme faction.

Trinitarian Monotheism?

Jump to latest Follow Reply
Sort by date Sort by votes
C

Ceridwen

Guest
Would you say that Christian Trinitarianism is more like Pagan Polytheism (e.g. the Greek Twelve Olympians Pantheon) or more like Islamic Monotheism (Tawheed)? Obviously it is different from both, but which is it more similar to? Here are some images of, in sequence, Christian Trinitarianism (represented by Rublev's icon of the Trinity), Pagan Polytheism (represented by Raffaello's Council of the Gods), and Islamic Monotheism (represented by arabic calligraphy of the word "Allah"):





 
Last edited:

yogosans14

Newbie
Mar 3, 2013
1,729
136
✟27,418.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
The Trinity is not pagan. It's explicitly implied in man places of the Bible. For starters Genesis 1:26, Matthew 28:19, 2 Corinthians 13:14, Johm 8:58, 10:30.

Another interesting point is when he is Called "Holy, holy, holy" 3 times he's called holy, the 3 persons of the Godhead are Holy.
 
Upvote 0
T

Thekla

Guest

The Rublev icon is called "The Hospitality of Abraham" and is not an icon of the Trinity, but a sort of "typos" of Trinity.
 
Reactions: seashale76
Upvote 0

~Anastasia~

† Handmaid of God †
Dec 1, 2013
31,129
17,440
Florida panhandle, USA
✟930,345.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
Thekla said:
The Rublev icon is called "The Hospitality of Abraham" and is not an icon of the Trinity, but a sort of "typos" of Trinity.
Click to expand...

I have never seen that icon before, but I wondered if it did not represent the three visitors to Abraham, given what Ceridewen was saying.

I don't know much about iconography, but one would never see an icon of God the Father, would they? And I'm guessing not of the Holy Spirit either, except perhaps as figured in Scripture, as a dove or tongues of flame?


Oh - and as far as an answer to the OP, the second picture isn't even showing to me, but if you're asking for a conclusion based on three illustrations you've chosen? I reject the question, as the one representing Trinitarian Monotheism does not represent what you claim it does.
 
Upvote 0

hedrick

Senior Veteran
Site Supporter
Feb 8, 2009
20,503
10,870
New Jersey
✟1,357,360.00
Faith
Presbyterian
Marital Status
Single
The kind of polytheism we typically think of has separate gods who squabble with each other. In Christian theology the Trinity has a single will, and all three persons are involved in all action. So God is a single actor.

Where things get more difficult is when you get more sophisticated polytheists who see the gods as just representations of different aspects of a single divinity. If you take that far enough you might have something that's as monotheistic as Christianity, though the concepts of God are (as far as I know) still different.

There has also been speculative theology within both Judaism and Islam that can look very similar to at least the economic Trinity. I don't believe however that they would go as far as the orthodox ontological Trinity.
 
Upvote 0
C

Ceridwen

Guest
Kylissa said:
the second picture isn't even showing to me
Click to expand...

Can you see it now? I changed the image to which the address is directed.

Thekla said:
The Rublev icon is called "The Hospitality of Abraham" and is not an icon of the Trinity, but a sort of "typos" of Trinity.
Click to expand...

Actually, what you've said is incorrect. Rublev's icon "Trinity" is not the same as the icon "Hospitality of Abraham." It is true that "Trinity" is based on "Hospitality of Abraham." However, Rublev removed the figures of Abraham and Sarah from the scene, and through a subtle use of composition and symbolism changed the subject to focus on the Mystery of the Trinity. "The figures of Abraham and Sarah, always in previous icons of this sacred event, are removed by St. Andrei to emphasize the transcendent revelation to Mankind of the Infinite yet ever-present One Triune Godhead."

https://www.skete.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=product.display&product_id=524

The differences can be seen when you compare the icons one after the other:



 
Upvote 0
N

Nanopants

Guest

Fascinating icons... I wonder if there is a correlation with the depictions here and with John 20:12:

And she saw two angels in white sitting, one at the head and the other at the feet, where the body of Jesus had lain.

... and with the ark of the testimony, and the altars that you often see in traditional churches. Whatever the case, iconography fascinates me.

Anyways, I don't think you're correct to say that something was changed to bear significance regarding the Trinity. The significance is made evident by the text itself.
 
Upvote 0
C

Ceridwen

Guest
hedrick said:
The kind of polytheism we typically think of has separate gods who squabble with each other.
Click to expand...

Even the pagan polytheists Socrates and Euthyphro believed that there was concord among the gods about the most important things. There were differences, but not about the fundamentals of right and wrong: "all the gods would be agreed as to the propriety of punishing a murderer: there would be no difference of opinion about that." According to them, the Olympic Pantheon have a different will with respect to minutia.
 
Upvote 0

prodromos

Senior Veteran
Site Supporter
Nov 28, 2003
23,937
14,413
60
Sydney, Straya
✟1,470,975.00
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married

They are essentially the same icon, Rublev has simply refined it, and none of the above discounts what Thekla said.
 
Reactions: seashale76
Upvote 0

BobRyan

Junior Member
Angels Team
Site Supporter
Nov 21, 2008
53,422
11,958
Georgia
✟1,103,944.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
SDA
Marital Status
Married
Ceridwen said:
Would you say that Christian Trinitarianism is more like Pagan Polytheism (e.g. the Greek Twelve Olympians Pantheon) or more like Islamic Monotheism (Tawheed)?
Click to expand...

One God in Three persons. The triune Godhead with one interest, one Goal, one purpose.

So in interest, goal, and purpose - like the Jewish "God is One" but in the OT and NT it is 3 persons not one person - and so in that one respect only it is like polytheism.

H2O -- Oxygen is not water - it is not 1/3 of water. But in combination you have one molecule of water.

in Christ,

Bob
 
Upvote 0

~Anastasia~

† Handmaid of God †
Dec 1, 2013
31,129
17,440
Florida panhandle, USA
✟930,345.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
And my answer is still that there is a problem with the question, because of the images and choices you present.

From Orthodox answers:

Is it appropriate to depict God the Father in iconography?

ANSWER:
No, it not appropriate to depict God the Father on icons. The only "possible exception" is the icon of the Hospitality of Abraham (Trinity) where one of the angels represents the Father. The entire theological foundation of icons at the seventh council was that although God the Father is invisible and beyond portrayal, we have still "seen" him in his icon who is Jesus Christ. Thus the icon of the Father is Jesus Christ.

Depicting God the Father was consistently condemned, ... The Seventh Council did not authorize the icon of God the Father and was very specific in what icons were acceptable.

In summary, our position here is that depicting God the Father is an anomaly which comes from strong Latin influences or a defective theology of the Trinity and iconography. ... However, it would be our view here that the icon of the Trinity of Roublev, because it is highly symbolic, is acceptable.

This icon is a representation of a Bible story - where the "three men" or "three angels" who visited Abraham were said to be representative of the Trinity.

However, God also said that "no man may see Him and live" ... so this is obviously not three men/angels walking around in physical bodies which are the actual Trinity.

The piece was only allowed because it was considered only representative of the Trinity. We do not see icons of three men consistently being produced in order to show "the Trinity" in human form. So the single allowed exception can hardly be fairly argued to represent the entire faith of Christian Trinitarian Monotheism, imo.

A quick search in Google for images of "Christian Trinity" turns up an image like this one much more often than the one you presented. (And in some variant of this form would appear to be the most common image available for "Christian Trinity").



If you chose this one, is it "more like" pagan pantheism or Islamic monotheism?
 
Upvote 0
G

GratiaCorpusChristi

Guest

Yes, but the philosophers of classical Athens and the later Hellenistic era are hardly representative of Homeric and Hesiodic Greek polytheism. They represent the opinions of the intellectual elite, not the operative religion of the cults in the city-states.
 
Upvote 0
T

Thekla

Guest

In its popular title, it is called the Trinity icon but is technically still the "Hospitality of Abraham"; as even the citation you gave states, " are removed by St. Andrei to emphasize the transcendent revelation to Mankind of the Infinite yet ever-present One Triune Godhead." The visitation of the three angels is an early vision/experience of the revelation of the Holy Trinity; the angels are not the Godhead itself.
 
Reactions: ~Anastasia~
Upvote 0
G

GratiaCorpusChristi

Guest
prodromos said:
They are essentially the same icon, Rublev has simply refined it, and none of the above discounts what Thekla said.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I don't know about that. The Russian Orthodox have been much more comfortable depicting members of the Trinity in their ecclesiastical art. The western-style Trinity of an Old Man, a Young Man, and a Dove is much more common in Russian art than in the classical (and canonical) iconography of Byzantium.

I'm not familiar with Rublev's intentions, but it wouldn't surprise me if he, or his immediate viewers, conceptually slipped from typological allusion to representative depiction.
 
Upvote 0

~Anastasia~

† Handmaid of God †
Dec 1, 2013
31,129
17,440
Florida panhandle, USA
✟930,345.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
And as far as "the gods" being in agreement ... have you read stories of mythology? They are pretty much driven by the disagreements between the gods and their attempts to circumvent one another?

Hardly a comparison to the unity present in the Holy Trinity.

I'm not sure what you're driving at exactly, but it seems way off.
 
Upvote 0
T

Thekla

Guest

There was a time when icons showing God the Father as the " Ancient of Days" were produced; according to some historians of iconography, this was due to western influence. There is some question on the canonicity of this mode of representation, but also this use is not found as often.
 
Upvote 0
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Christianity, Islam and the double standards of the leftist media
Replies
0
Views
165
General Politics
Michie
I
  • Locked
How should have Christians historically addressed Islam?
Replies
209
Views
7K
Christian Philosophy & Ethics
linux.poet
Islamic extremists killed over 22K in Africa over the past year, study finds
Replies
1
Views
229
Current News & Events (Articles Required)
RileyG
Release International prayer alerts, Malaysia, Iran
Replies
1
Views
250
Persecuted Christians
RileyG
Cardinal Sarah & Other Prelates Speak Out Against Fiducia Supplicans
Replies
1
Views
145
One Bread, One Body - Catholic
RileyG
Menu
Log in
Register