Tolkien

globalmouse · May 15, 2005

Yo! I'm a newbie here, any Tolkien fans out there?

Lessien · May 15, 2005

Hi!!! I love Tolkien.....I've read the first book 3 times, the second book twice, and the 3rd book once (but that's only because one of my friends has it and we haven't gotten it back....).

Katrien · May 15, 2005

Yup, I'm a Tolkien fan. ^_^

I've read the LOTR books (the third one was my fave). Has anyone here read some of his other works besides the LOTR trilogy? If so, which ones would you reccomend to others?

Lessien · May 15, 2005

I think that the 3rd book was the best, but that's just my opinion.....

I've never read any of his other works...but my bro read the Silmerillion.....he said it was really boring...

Nienor · May 15, 2005

Katrien said:
Yup, I'm a Tolkien fan. I've read the LOTR books (the third one was my fave). Has anyone here read some of his other works besides the LOTR trilogy? If so, which ones would you reccomend to others?

read the Silmarillion. The history of ME is fascinating. i particulary enjoy the story of Turin. in fact my username comes from the Sil. Unfinished tales is good as well, but not as interesting. i've read other stories by him as well. i don't remember what they were called right now, but they were pretty good.

as you might of guessed, i'm a huge Tolkien fan. I've read the trilogy countless times, the Hobbit almost as many. i ate slept and breathed LotR for about three years. i still love it, but i'm not quite as obsessed. :wave:

bainecaileag86 · May 16, 2005

I read the hobbit and the trilogy a few years ago. I reread the first book, but haven't had the time or motivation to reread the other two. I'm working on the Silmarillion right now, and it is somewhat difficult to read...I just don't try to understand and I like it a lot better. It has beautiful language, the opening chapter about the Music of the Ainur is absolutely incredible, my favorite part so far.

Abbadon · May 16, 2005

Lessien said:
I've never read any of his other works...but my bro read the Silmerillion.....he said it was really boring...

I've tried reading the Simarillion. Imagine reading a religious text that focuses on a large portion of the historic bits of mythology. There were a few good bits, but it is boring.

McDLT · May 16, 2005

I'm a total Tolkien fan - so much so that I even have a forum dedicated to him. (PM me if you want the url - I don't want to do any shameless advertising)

I loved the Sil, not so much the first time I read it but when I read it again after reading The Hobbit and LotR, it made a lot more sense. One thing I'm not that good with is geography, so that kind of hindered the process. The Sil does have a great creation story.

Joy_Everlasting · May 16, 2005

I love Tolkien. I've read the trilogy, The Hobbit, and the Silmarillion.

texmex · May 16, 2005

I have read the LotR Trilogy and the Hobbit. I really want to read the Silmarillion but can never find it anywhere.

Now that I think about it I think I read another one of his books...Roverandom or something like that. It was ages ago, so I can't remember.

heavensworthit · May 16, 2005

I am a fan, however I started the LOTR books and never finished..lol just picked up the series at the library this afternoon..

globalmouse · May 18, 2005

Lessien said:
Hi!!! I love Tolkien.....I've read the first book 3 times, the second book twice, and the 3rd book once (but that's only because one of my friends has it and we haven't gotten it back....).

Aarg! Get it back, get it back! I hate it when people do that personally!

globalmouse · May 18, 2005

heavensworthit said:
I am a fan, however I started the LOTR books and never finished..lol just picked up the series at the library this afternoon..

Cool, that'll keep you busy for a while....

Phil Caracas · May 19, 2005

globalmouse said:
Cool, that'll keep you busy for a while....

I read so darn fast it only kept me busy for a week.

globalmouse · May 20, 2005

Yeah, it only took me a week too....mind you I didn't sleep much.

Meriadoc · May 20, 2005

Tolkien is awesome!

A suggestion for fand trying to get through the Silmarillion: Try buying or checking out the Audio version of the Silmarillion from your library. If you listen to it a couple times it makes the book easier and makes you appreciate the story more.

On a related note: I want a movie to be made about Tolkien and C.sS.Lewis. I think it would be interesting and inspiring.

Telrunya · May 20, 2005

I'm a Tolkin fan all the way. I never appreciated Christopher's commentary on his father's works though, especially in "The Lost Road". I've read them all though, several times.

tryniti · May 20, 2005

I really enjoy tolkien's works. Its incredible how he is able to create entire languages almost on a whim. I love the stories, but I'm not so much a fan of his writing style. I don't mind the older dialect that he uses, I just don't care so much for his style. I read his works all the time though, because I love the stories and the world that he created.

stonetoflesh · May 21, 2005

tryniti said:
Its incredible how he is able to create entire languages almost on a whim.

I would hardly think that his languages are products of whims, being that they're functional languages-- this isn't just someone cobbling together a bunch of gibberish words and calling it a "language". IIRC, Tolkien's linguistic studies gave birth to the Quenya and Sindarin languages, which he later used as classroom examples of language development for his Oxford philology students. The catalyst for the creation of Middle-Earth (begun in the Silmarillion) was Tolkien's desire to create a people to speak the languages he designed...

tryniti · May 22, 2005

spacedout said:
I would hardly think that his languages are products of whims, being that they're functional languages-- this isn't just someone cobbling together a bunch of gibberish words and calling it a "language". IIRC, Tolkien's linguistic studies gave birth to the Quenya and Sindarin languages, which he later used as classroom examples of language development for his Oxford philology students. The catalyst for the creation of Middle-Earth (begun in the Silmarillion) was Tolkien's desire to create a people to speak the languages he designed...

Ok, I'll clarify what I meant

It's the fact that he was able to do it so naturally, and that so much came from when he was in a rabbit-hole during WWI. I've also been told that he created the fundamentals for a language when he was 12.

Tolkien

Member

It's what I do that defines me

Active Member

It's what I do that defines me

why so serious

Active Member

Self Bias Resistor - goin' commando in a cassock!

Well-Known Member

My camera has a photographic memory.

I'm marching to a different accordian

Veteran

Member

Member

Active Member

Member

Well-Known Member

Student of the Word

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Similar threads