Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
First try to answer my question. Why did I add the word "human" to your statement?
First try to answer my question. Why did I add the word "human" to your statement?
Maybe you read Watership Down and believe in talking bunnies...I don't know and really don't care. Again...we both know I was speaking about humans so get on with it. Lets hear all these objective moral laws.
I'm asking you to define the scope of this discussion. If you won't answer my question, all I can do (based on the above response) is assume you are restricting the discussion to only humans. If so, I answered you in post #98.
I can discuss the observed morality of chimpanzees.
If you would like.
I'm asking you to define the scope of this discussion. If you won't answer my question, all I can do (based on the above response) is assume you are restricting the discussion to only humans. If so, I answered you in post #98.
... or god ...
Actually, you're just dodging the question.
They are very human like in how they behave within their groups, both in considering immoral and moral acts. Chimps have been observed saving the young of other members in their group at the risk of themselves, punishing their children for bullying smaller babies of other parents, and attempting to aid the sick as well as morning the deaths of loved ones (sometimes for years, especially in the case of a child). They have also been observed warring with other chimp groups to gain territory, committing murder and then being punished for that (death or exile), stealing, etc.
Even better, since they can learn human language to an extent, you can actually ask them about it and get a response.
Ah, so you did know why I added that word. Or at least you had a good guess.
No, I meant what I said. I asked you to set the scope of your question. Since you (sort of) answered my question, I'll reciprocate: Exodus 20:15.
I'll also offer a definition of "moral" as "a rule for proper conduct". If you disagree, let me know.
I expect we'll also be doing some dancing around the word "objective" as this proceeds.
I'm sorry...my bibleness is a little rusty. I've got exodus 20-15 as "Thou shall not steal". If you're claiming that's the entire moral code....this will be a short convo. Care to reconsider?
I'm fine with your definition of "moral" if you give me a definition of "proper". I'm also going to want a definition for "objective" before you start dancing or this is all a bit pointless again.
You're right, it's, "You shall not steal." They're all going to come from the Bible, so I'm not planning on typing out the whole Bible for you. This one is an example for us to use.
Proper would mean: appropriate to the purpose.
I was asking you to start the ball rolling on "objective." Even the definition of "moral" was just a suggestion. The reference to objective morality first came from you didn't it? (post #95).
Objective morality is a commonly misused term, but the way it's misused is fairly consistent. As I know it, it's the idea there are moral "goods" and "bads" for every possible situation a human can be in and they never change regardless of circumstances or time or individuals or groups...or anything really. Is that what you mean?
Well you could've just said, "All the moral laws contained in the bible." That would've sped things along. There are problems with that though, do you ascribe to all the moral laws in the bible or do you just pick and choose which ones you like?
It was you who brought it up, which is why I wanted you to define it.
Given that is what you mean, I'll have to retract my offer. No, I don't think I could give you anything that would meet that definition.
I do my best to follow the Bible.
Actually, in post 87, you bring up your belief in "moral absolutes". So if you didn't mean the objective morality I've described...what did you mean?
I'm sure you think you do....but you find yourself disagreeing with it at times don't you?
Why do you take an interest in the behaviors of chimps?
A few reasons, namely because apes such as chimps are considered the second most intelligent animals on earth after humans, and how cool is it that you can have a legitimate conversation with a nonhuman animal?
You're right. I did. Exodus 20:15 would be an example. And what does it mean to steal? To take the property of another without the right to do so. It is never acceptable to violate that command, and so is absolute. But it doesn't do what you laid out in your definition, as I think I've acknowledged.
Sure. But as I've explained before, desires don't negate laws. A burglar desires to escape punishment, but if he is caught, the punishment happens despite his desire.
We aren't speaking about laws, we're speaking about morality....I wouldn't want you to confuse the two.
So, to you, even a child stealing food to survive is immoral?
Do you also consider exodus 21:20-21 also to be a moral absolute? (You know, since you're using exodus)
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?