I can relate to that as just the other day I came out of the grocery store and walked up to my car.......and saw a huge dent! argh! A few seconds passed before I realized it was the same make and model, same color, just a diff car parked near where I was. whew.
But that's not my only same car story. Some years back I was on vacation in the Caribbean and my rental car was broken into (not exactly uncommon there). Shortly after that I was coming out of another place and saw someone closing the door to my car!! I ran up and confronted the scumbag.......only to then notice the exact same car, same color, not 3 spots away. Needless to say he got indignant but chilled out when I explained.