The Hobbit

[Sketcher]

If he does make it, it could be very good - the only problem would be casting. Yes, McKellan as Gandalf is a requirement. But who's going to play all those dwarves? You can't have John Rhys-Davies, because Gimli isn't in it. Furthermore, he encompassed much of the dwarvish culture with that role, now you have to do 14 excellent dwarves, each with quirks. And Bilbo - Ian Holm isn't getting any younger.

I do hope that if he does it, he is able to work the Battle of the Five Armies in there. I can easily see where it would be easier to cut it off after they've killed Smaug.

 

[Squirrelfish]

I have to disagree with the comments on George Lucas's newer Star Wars movies. They were not sequels but legitimate pieces of the saga. He planned on making them for a long time and to say he was just trying to make some extra cash is ridiculous. All six were a part of his vision and he wanted to make them all, so he did. He only gets money to make movies. As far as The Hobbit goes, I'm sure he'll stick to the intentions of Tolkien. Jackson is a huge Tolien fan and a great filmaker, which is why the Trilogy was so good. Movies are about risk, and I beleive he should go for it and see what he gets.

what he said

 

[symphonyb]

I'm afraid to get me hopes up here. The Hobbit is it coming our way or not?

 

[drama_queen100]

i hope they make a hobbit!!!!!!!!! this is deff. good!!!!!!!!