PART 1
Didpy said:
If I recall correctly, your did respond to that question before, but didn't answer the question, as you have not now either.
We obtain our salvation/justification from the root. It it were the Christian's life that came from the root, then, it appears to me, that all Christians walk would be alike.
GLJCA said:
There are not two kinds of fruit. There is only one kind of fruit that comes from an olive tree. To say that two kinds of fruit can come off of a good olive tree is saying that the tree is corrupt.
Luk 6:43 For a good tree bringeth not forth corrupt fruit; neither doth a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.
Jesus is telling us here that there can't be two kinds of fruit coming off of the same tree. All Christians have the same root but not all Christians choose to live according to the root. That is why the Jews in Romans 11 were cut off because they no longer believed and the life was cut off therefore they were fruitless. Paul tells us that if we are found in unbelief we also can be cut off.
No where does the Bible say that Abraham is the root of anything, yet Jesus tells us that He is the vine and we are the branches. Isaiah tells us that Jesus is the root of Jesse and Paul requotes it to the Gentile Church at Rome.
Isa 11:10 And in that day there shall be a root of Jesse, which shall stand for an ensign of the people; to it shall the Gentiles seek: and his rest shall be glorious.
Rom 15:12 And again, Esaias saith, There shall be a root of Jesse, and he that shall rise to reign over the Gentiles; in him shall the Gentiles trust.
We were in God's plan all along. The was not an intercalation as Ryrie says. God does not have a plan "B".
You will have a very hard time convincing me that only one type of fruit can come from an olive tree. Especially if the branches from a wild olive tree were grafted in. About 20 years ago I planted an apple tree in my back yard that did bare 5 different kinds of apples. 4 of those branches were "grafted in," however I couldn't tell you which ones they were. I had that tree removed this fall, after at least 20 years of yield. They all got their nurishment from the same roots, not 5 different kinds of roots.
I don't believe that the tree in Luke 6:43, that Jesus refered to, had any "grafted in" branches.
I will also agree that Jesus is the "root of Jesse." However, according to Isaiah 60:3, it was the Gentiles that were to come to the Jews for their "Light."
Isaiah 60:3 "And the Gentiles shall come to thy light, and the kings to the brightenss of thy shining." As promised to Abram in Genesis 12:1-3, it was his physical seed that was to bless the families (nations) of the earth. Nowhere in the OT do I find that the Jew and Gentile will be on equal footing, and without distinction. God had placed a "middle wall of partition" between the Jew and Gentile. Even Jesus Himself said in John 4:22
"Salvation is of the Jews."
Yes, the Gentiles will one day be blessed through Israel, as a nation, but that is still future.
The Cross was God's Plan "A" since before He created the world. However, it was kept secret "since the world began."
Dispy said:
Can't recall ever saying that righteousness came from the Law. However, I do recall saying that while those that were under the Law had to do the deed/works of the Law by FAITH in order for their sins to be covered. Our righteousness comes from our FAITH in the Cross work (death, burial and resurrection) of Christ. Salvation/Justification has ALWAYS been on the basis of FAITH.
GLJCA said:
No here is what you said exactly. Those that are the seed of Abram are saved by FAITH alone, just as members of the Body of Christ are today, and those that were required to perform deed/works of the Law were saved/justified by doing the deed/works of the law BY FAITH, like Abraham.
When you say that they were required to do the deeds of the law by faith in order for their sins to be covered you are adding to the gospel. It has always been by faith. The law was our schoolmaster to bring us to Christ. It was never designed as a way of salvation even if done by faith. No one could be justified by the deeds of the law.
Rom 3:20 Therefore by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified in his sight: for by the law [is] the knowledge of sin.
Even if done in faith they could not be justified. Therefore according to what you are saying Abraham is in Hell today because he could not keep the law even by faith.
Your statement saying that I said that righteousness came from the Law, is at best, an incomplete statement, and taken completely out of its context.
There were many Ceremonial and Sacrificial Laws that the children had to observe in order for their sins to be atoned (covered). They were repeated over and over. If not done according to the Law, and by
FAITH then their sins were not covered. FYI, Abram was not under the Law. The Law was given to Moses, years later.
Paul is addressing members of the Body of Christ, that are not under the Law, during this dispensation of Grace. The Law has been nailed to the Cross at that point in time of humand history.
Dispy said:
The original covenant to Abram was unconditional, however, for those future descendants that wanted to partake of that covenant, they had other conditions (circumcision and the Law, etc.) to follow in order to obtain the covenant promises.
GLJCA said:
I agree with this. If you will look at the statement that I had made right before you wrote this you will see I said the same thing that you did.
Glad we can agree on something.
Dispy said:
PLEASE tell me how the OT Jews were saved/justified it they didn't perform the deeds/works of the law by FAITH[/ B]Didn't God tell Moses to tell the children of Israel that if they kept his covnnant (commandments), that they would become a holy nation of priests (Exodus 19:3-8)? Even though those under the Law found it impossible to keep, God still provided a way for those sins to be atoned. However, they had to do what was required, BY FAITH.
GLJCA said:
I have told you. They were saved by faith in God and the coming Messiah just like you are today. They looked forward and we look backward to the Messiah.
Heb 11:13 These all died in faith, not having received the promises, but having seen them afar off, and were persuaded of [them], and embraced [them], and confessed that they were strangers and pilgrims on the earth.
How much more plain can it get. These folks died in faith but they saw the promises. They looked ahead to the Messiah that God had promised.
I reject your answer in total. You have no Scriptural foundation for your remarks. How could the OT children of Israel look forward to the Cross when it wasn't even invented as a way of punishment. It was a more recent inovation of the Romans. Also, the purpose of the Cross was still unknown until it was revealed to Paul (1Cor.2:7,8)
To be continued
God Bless.
Live Well, Laugh Often and Love the Lord!