The Baptism Poll

JM · May 6, 2013

For Reformed Calvinistic members only please.

I really do not want to debate in this poll thread we seem to be having a good dialogue over here = http://www.christianforums.com/t7730631/

JM · May 7, 2013

Interesting results so far. I thought this forum was filled with hyper Calvinistic Baptists! lol

Apologetic_Warrior · May 9, 2013

Only 12 votes? Where oh where have our Calvinist brothers and sisters slipped away to?

Osage Bluestem · May 9, 2013

Apologetic_Warrior said:
Only 12 votes? Where oh where have our Calvinist brothers and sisters slipped away to?

Were there ever more than 12?

AndOne · May 9, 2013

I picked "not sure" but only because I think both sides make excellent arguments. In practice I am credo but I don't have the conviction to tell a padeo that they are wrong.

Apologetic_Warrior · May 9, 2013

Osage Bluestem said:
Were there ever more than 12?

MichaelNZ · May 10, 2013

There is no verse in the Bible that prohibits paedobaptism.

jdbrown · May 10, 2013

MichaelNZ said:
There is no verse in the Bible that prohibits paedobaptism.

Nor is there a verse that commands it. And, the same can be said of credobaptism. So, we are left with making inferences from what is explicitly stated.

JM · May 13, 2013

I wonder how many are unsure but think baptisticly or how many baptize based upon conviction and not tradition...

Iosias · May 22, 2013

MichaelNZ said:
There is no verse in the Bible that prohibits paedobaptism.

Esdra · May 23, 2013

JM said:
Interesting results so far. I thought this forum was filled with hyper Calvinistic Baptists! lol

I've thought this sub-forum is rather for Evangelical-Reformed Christians? (meaning: UCC, Evangelical Reformed Church of America, Presbyterian etc) and not so much Baptists?

JM · May 23, 2013

MichaelNZ said:
There is no verse in the Bible that prohibits paedobaptism.

The Regulative principle of the Reformed confession read the same as the Particular Baptist confession. This would suggest, historically, Particular Baptists are Reformed on this issue. (see A Tabular Comparsion of the WCF and the LBC) It would contradiction confessionally Reformed doctrine to perform baptism on infants since it is not found in the revealed will of God or prescribed by scripture.

Iosias · May 24, 2013

JM said:
The Regulative principle of the Reformed confession read the same as the Particular Baptist confession...It would contradiction confessionally Reformed doctrine to perform baptism on infants since it is not found in the revealed will of God or prescribed by scripture.

Paedobaptism is in line with the regulative principle since it can be demonstrated by good and necessary inference!

JM · May 24, 2013

JM said:
The Regulative principle of the Reformed confession read the same as the Particular Baptist confession. This would suggest, historically, Particular Baptists are Reformed on this issue. (see A Tabular Comparsion of the WCF and the LBC) It would contradiction confessionally Reformed doctrine to perform baptism on infants since it is not found in the revealed will of God or prescribed by scripture.

(Most infant Baptists such as Roman Catholics, Eastern Orthodox and Anlgicans, etc. baptize based on tradition and church authority so I’m not interested in discussing there practice.)

Some Protestants will claim infant baptism is a necessary, inevitable, unavoidable, absolutely needed conclusion based on scripture. But is it? Baptism was revealed and explained in the New Testament so we find the revealed will of God concerning the practice of baptism here, where it is prescribed, for the proper worship of God and edification of His people. If you consider the clarity of the scriptures on the regulative principle and the New Testament teaching about baptism is infant baptism necessary, inevitable, unavoidable and absolutely needed conclusion? Probably not which is why so many arguments for infant baptism can we found. There really isn’t an unavoidable logical conclusion for the practice.

jm

Iosias · May 24, 2013

JM said:
baptize based on tradition and church authority

Which is ironic since your post links to the London Baptist Confession, and elsewhere you reject biblicism. Either one dismisses all non-biblical witnesses (Fathers, Creeds, Medieval Doctors, Councils, etc) or one does not.

Whenever we ask 'what does the scripture say' the question is 'what does the scripture say when interpreted through the lens of my favourite confession'.

The Baptism Poll

I believe the most biblical practice is

paedobaptism / pedobaptism

credobaptism

not sure

Confessional Free Catholic

Confessional Free Catholic

Pilgrim

Galatians 5:1

Deliver me oh Lord, from evil men

Pilgrim

Servus Mariae

Sola Dei Gloria

Confessional Free Catholic

Senior Contributor

Senior Contributor

Confessional Free Catholic

Senior Contributor

Confessional Free Catholic

Senior Contributor

Similar threads

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency