Nonsense - it's proof by counter-example.
You said it's never justified to disobey God (
#813).
We posed the question, "Even if God says to kill your child?" (
#815)
"Well", you replied, "I'd have to first determine whether God actually gave that command". (
#817)
To which the obvious response is: "How does one do that? What if the command was to kill your child
right now, precluding deliberation?" (
#820)
"Ah", you responded, "I know such a command wouldn't be from God as God said to
love our children" (
#823) Exact text: "
I would know [the voice] was not God because Christ has commanded that we love our children and to take care of them and to raise them up in the way that they should go."
To which the story of Abraham pops into mind - "So when Abraham was told to kill his son..." (
#830)
"STOP CHERRY PICKING"
"..."
Quite obviously we're not cherry-picking. You said it's never justified to disobey God. To examine this, we pose a hypothetical: suppose you were commanded to do something one ordinarily would consider morally evil, such as killing a child - your child, even. If the command was from God, would you do it? You said no - God wouldn't issue such a command (#823). Yet, according to the Bible, God
did issue such a command (Gen. 22:1-2). That would seem to be a discrepancy disproving your two premises:
- It is never justified to disobey God
- Any command to kill one's child is not from God