• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Swingers - Swapping Partners

Status
Not open for further replies.

sunlover1

Beloved, Let us love one another
Nov 10, 2006
26,146
5,348
Under the Shadow of the Almighty
✟102,311.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
The point is, if God is so "technical" about stuff, we get all sorts of "techincal" problems. I've seen christians been all OK with someone who used to be "shacking up" and then married someone else, but if they were married and that didn't work out, they're pretty much screwed. Forever.
Yeah, but no. NOT forever.
Didnt "work out"?
Marriage is a blood covenant, not a conditional contract.
It's a spiritual joining that we cannot even comprehend.
Called a mystery in the Bible iirc.
YOu can bail... everyone's doing it. Heck, I did it.
It's not like He's going to rain down lightning on you.
But in the end, it's a matter of following the shephard.
If He TELLS you to stay, believe me, you want to ask
no questions and just OBEY... OR, you can learn
the hard way that He only has your best in mind.
Because we do have an enemy that roams about as
a roaring lion seeking whom he may devour.
My divorce was 15 years ago and just today I cried out
to God for help to forgive myself for hurting folks...
It's a blood covenant, not to be taken so lightly...
IF you have the things of God at heart. I didnt.


Anyway, it's not true that God is more interested in my character than in my comfort.
No? Are you sure? I'm more interested in my childrens character
than in their comfort.
Would you rather they be comfortably walking the wide road,
or have more character walking that narrow path?

If he's my dad, he'll treat me like a son and not as a slave.
Amen.

I have a child on the way myself, and the only reason I want the child to have character is for his own comfort and well-being.
Cool

Not for me or anybody else.
Not so that God can say, "Well done good and faithful servant"?

I'm not having a child so that he or she may live up to this or that expectation or demand or set of rules, that's not what being a father is all about. But maybe I have more grace for my children than God does...
I dont think that you're aware that you're erecting strawmen.
But that last paragraph was an example.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rick Otto
Upvote 0

Nadiine

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2006
52,800
48,336
Obama: 53% deserve him ;)
✟292,219.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Holo
If he's my dad, he'll treat me like a son and not as a slave.
This tends to be the problem I see w/ your worldview...
you put PEOPLE in God's place as if God is the same as people
on this earth...
God is more than the "father/son" relationship, He's King, He's
ruler of the entire universe - He's a GOD. (THEE God).
If you're viewing Him as just a human father, there will be
issues.

& I assure you, Anannias & Sapphira were his "kids' too... he struck
them dead for lying to His Spirit. God isn't a corrupted human w/
corrupted knowledge on true love or holiness or sin.
He can purely send out wrath & purely send out judgment IN LOVE.

& The truth is, you ARE a slave.... you're a slave to Christ or a
slave to sin/self/Satan. One or the other. We all serve a master.
GOD Almighty is a Christian's master.
Romans 12:1
[ Living Sacrifices to God ] I beseech you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God,
that you present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable to God, which is your reasonable service.

God expects your life to to be given to Him as a basic, reasonable service to Him. Nothing "spectacular & awe inspiring" - it's your
reasonable duty AS a proclaiming follower to give your whole life to Him.

& what is "sacrifice"? It means you suffer to give it to Him - you freely GIVE yourself & your fleshly wants/desires in order to
obey His commands. If that's not what you want to do, then you
need to evaluate what it is you're doing.

If self & happiness is more important to you than following God's mandates, then why pick Christianity at all?
That's like going to join the military & then when they put you
thru boot camp & send you out on missions, you refuse to do
1/2 the stuff they order you to do becuz you dislike it &
it puts you out too much.

"I'm not your slave".... excuses don't cut it in the military & they won't
cut it with God. We ARE His slaves - bondservants by choice.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

holo

former Christian
Dec 24, 2003
8,992
751
✟85,294.00
Country
Norway
Faith
Agnostic
Marital Status
Private
If I may. From what I've learned about God, His good will for us is
simply that we do nothing on our own. Adams mistake was acting without
God's endorsement. When we make ourselves god, and sort of disconnect
from the Head, we find ourselves, as you said, sinning.
Our relationship isnt' based on rules, laws. That was a "shadow".
The 'real deal" is God IN us. We now HEAR His voice in every decision.
So before they said do not divorce except for adultry, now Jesus
raised the bar... Dont divorce! Period.
Yes, Jesus did indeed raise the bar of the law. And if we're going to try and live according to that, there's not a single person here who has the right to point their finger at anybody's divorce, because we've all ben jealous of somebody lately, or taken a peek at somebody's butt yesterday.

(But I see we agree it's not about following a set of rules per se.)

Again, its' not about RULES to follow, it's about following the Lord
as He leads. LETTING Him rule in every single area, every single decision.
Sure, but if I didn't do that in the past, he won't deny me any good thing in the future. Our past mistakes are thrown in the sea of oblivion. Except for failed marriages?

And often we dont, and often we try and fall down and then with His
help, we get back up and try again. Why? To "make it to heaven"?
NOooooo. But because He said that if we LOVE him...
We'll.... OBEY him.
Obey what? Rules? No, His voice.
I don't believe Jesus is telling people they can never get married again because their first marriage fell apart.

Sure, Jesus did instruct the jews of his day (who were under the law, the ones he was sent to) on what marriage was supposed to be like - they practiced a form of "marriage" where you could get divorced in a day if you took a shining to somebody prettier. That's what Jesus was talking about.
 
Upvote 0

holo

former Christian
Dec 24, 2003
8,992
751
✟85,294.00
Country
Norway
Faith
Agnostic
Marital Status
Private
Yeah, but no. NOT forever.
Didnt "work out"?
Marriage is a blood covenant, not a conditional contract.
It's a spiritual joining that we cannot even comprehend.
Called a mystery in the Bible iirc.
YOu can bail... everyone's doing it. Heck, I did it.
It's not like He's going to rain down lightning on you.
But in the end, it's a matter of following the shephard.
If He TELLS you to stay, believe me, you want to ask
no questions and just OBEY...
I agree. But I don't think God tells everybody to stay. I know people who had to literally run for her life from her husband (and this was after she was already completely destroyed emotionally and spiritually). I don't believe for a second God ever told her to stay with that maniac (who is now on trial for murder btw).

That's one extreme example, but you get the point.

No? Are you sure? I'm more interested in my childrens character
than in their comfort.
Would you rather they be comfortably walking the wide road,
or have more character walking that narrow path?
Because their comfort is at the end of the narrow road, then.

Denying some to remarrying after a first marriage failed (regardless of why it failed) doesn't lead to a comfortable place.

Not so that God can say, "Well done good and faithful servant"?
I'm more a son than a servant. And I can't imagine God saying to someone "good job on not getting married again!"

I dont think that you're aware that you're erecting strawmen.
But that last paragraph was an example.
How's that? The bible compares God to a father all the time, to give people an idea of what he's like. I will have a lot of grace for my kids. But I know there's also a limit to that grace. But we can't even fathom the depths of God's grace. So I can't possibly be more gracious toward my own kids than God is to us.
 
Upvote 0

Nadiine

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2006
52,800
48,336
Obama: 53% deserve him ;)
✟292,219.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Yes, Jesus did indeed raise the bar of the law. And if we're going to try and live according to that, there's not a single person here who has the right to point their finger at anybody's divorce, because we've all ben jealous of somebody lately, or taken a peek at somebody's butt yesterday.
why do you consider giving God's instruction on divorce/remarriage
as "pointing fingers"?

We're relaying God's commands here - and JESUS gave them on this
subject.

It's about choice of who we're going to obey; self & desire or God.

Also, using OTHER sins is no license for this particular sin.
(that is if a divorce isn't spiritually lawful)
And it's a Christians duty to relay the truth of God - it's one thing to relay truth,
it's another to stand in condemnation.
condemnation has not been committed on this thread. It's a
discussion.

& another point, divorce isn't the "sin" - altho Jesus said He literally
Hates divorce, the remarriage is the true issue.
Remarrying on
nonbiblical grounds of divorce constitutes living in adultery -
THAT is why we speak up about it & take it so seriously.

Vows/covenants are nothing to take lightly where God is concerned.
They are permanent & binding.

Would we be better off just smiling & patting people on the back
to let them walk into a lifestyle of adultery without a word of caution
given to them? I don't see as that's love either.
 
Upvote 0

holo

former Christian
Dec 24, 2003
8,992
751
✟85,294.00
Country
Norway
Faith
Agnostic
Marital Status
Private
Holo
This tends to be the problem I see w/ your worldview...
you put PEOPLE in God's place as if God is the same as people
on this earth...
God is more than the "father/son" relationship, He's King, He's
ruler of the entire universe - He's a GOD. (THEE God).
If you're viewing Him as just a human father, there will be
issues.

& I assure you, Anannias & Sapphira were his "kids' too... he struck
them dead for lying to His Spirit. God isn't a corrupted human w/
corrupted knowledge on true love or holiness or sin.
He can purely send out wrath & purely send out judgment IN LOVE.
Where's the love in denying someone to ever be married?

& The truth is, you ARE a slave.... you're a slave to Christ or a
slave to sin/self/Satan. One or the other. We all serve a master.
GOD Almighty is a Christian's master.
Romans 12:1
[ Living Sacrifices to God ] I beseech you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God,
that you present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable to God, which is your reasonable service.

God expects your life to to be given to Him as a basic, reasonable service to Him. Nothing "spectacular & awe inspiring" - it's your
reasonable duty AS a proclaiming follower to give your whole life to Him.

& what is "sacrifice"? It means you suffer to give it to Him - you freely GIVE yourself & your fleshly wants/desires in order to
obey His commands. If that's not what you want to do, then you
need to evaluate what it is you're doing.
Absolutely, and that's why a lot of us need to learn to stop doing what we want to do (being judgmental and legalistic springs to mind as one of the greatest problems we have today), and start doing what God wants.

But we know God wants what is good for us, right? If it's not good for us, then God doesn't want us to do it. So the question is, how is being denyed to marry again good for us?

Not saying that marriage isn't holy or shouldn't be respected or that it shouldn't be seen as a covenant or that people should get to "bail out" easily. But just how is it good for a man (and the woman he loves) that they're never allowed to get married? Or is it good for somebody else, perhaps?

If self & happiness is more important to you than following God's mandates, then why pick Christianity at all?
I don't pick a religion. I believe what I believe. I can't choose to believe something or to stop believing in something.

And it's not like I choose to believe that God is OK with people getting married again (or any other kind of second chance) - it's simply my conviction based on how I've experienced God. I used to approach God like a slave would approach his master, or like a criminal would approach a judge, until I found out I was his child.

That's like going to join the military & then when they put you
thru boot camp & send you out on missions, you refuse to do
1/2 the stuff they order you to do becuz you dislike it &
it puts you out too much.
But being a child of God isn't like joining the army, it's like joining the family. :)

"I'm not your slave".... excuses don't cut it in the military & they won't
cut it with God. We ARE His slaves - bondservants by choice.
Sure, but what sort of good work are we doing for God by not remarrying? How are we helping him out by doing that?
 
Upvote 0

holo

former Christian
Dec 24, 2003
8,992
751
✟85,294.00
Country
Norway
Faith
Agnostic
Marital Status
Private
why do you consider giving God's instruction on divorce/remarriage
as "pointing fingers"?
The thing is, if you're going to take that literally as if it applied to us believers today, as opposed to the jews under the law who were the ones Jesus were talking to, on how to keep the law, you'll have to take the rest of it too. What he said about gouging out your eye and giving away all your possessions and so forth. We can't just pick out the things we prefer from Jesus' instructions to the jews and disregard the rest.

And I believe that either we live under the entire law, or we live under entire grace. So for example, when I make the choice every day to stay faithful to my wife, it has nothing to do with the law at all.

Vows/covenants are nothing to take lightly where God is concerned.
They are permanent & binding.
Yes they are, but sometimes we just fail, don't we. And God doesn't give up on us. It's not like he throws most of our sins in the sea of oblivion, but keeps the ones that have to do with marriage.

And besides, "what God has joined together" doesn't necessarily equal what a couple of teens did in Vegas when they were too young and didn't know what they were doing. And it's not God who joins together an innocent christian girl with a violent psychopath.

Would we be better off just smiling & patting people on the back
to let them walk into a lifestyle of adultery without a word of caution
given to them? I don't see as that's love either.
I agree with that. But I don't see it as adultery to want to take a second shot at a covenant just because the first one failed somehow. Hey, maybe you even learned something from your past mistake!
 
Upvote 0

Nadiine

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2006
52,800
48,336
Obama: 53% deserve him ;)
✟292,219.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Where's the love in denying someone to ever be married?
Do you not get this holo?
WE don't deny these things, GOD DOES.
What part of this is escaping your understanding? Sorry, but when
we relay God's mandates, IT ISN'T OUR RULE, IT'S HIS.
We're admonishing people to obey God - or get real in who they
really serve.

Do you go attacking the police becuz they're upholding the laws &
rules of their local govt.? No, they simply relay the rules to all
citizens. We act in God's name/ as His servants.

That means that ALL Christians have a duty to relay truth of God
to everyone. If you feel it's fine to make & break covenants to
God & others when they simply don't make you happy anymore,
then you have the problem, not God or us.


Absolutely, and that's why a lot of us need to learn to stop doing what we want to do (being judgmental and legalistic springs to mind as one of the greatest problems we have today), and start doing what God wants.
once again, you make false claims that obedience is "legalism".
So be it. Perhaps some people NEED "legalism".

& by the way, you're equally 'legalistic' as you admonish others to
"LOVE" like God tells us to & not to hate & not to 'harm' others. etc. :idea:



But we know God wants what is good for us, right? If it's not good for us, then God doesn't want us to do it. So the question is, how is being denyed to marry again good for us?
This is based on YOUR/man's corrupted sense of good. Denying God's
instruction of what is good.

& which God are speaking of? I'm speaking of the God relayed in my Bible
who gave clear instruction on this issue.

Not saying that marriage isn't holy or shouldn't be respected or that it shouldn't be seen as a covenant or that people should get to "bail out" easily. But just how is it good for a man (and the woman he loves) that they're never allowed to get married? Or is it good for somebody else, perhaps?
This is again humanist reasoning. It doesn't fly in God's system.
What does covenant mean to you? What does "VOW" mean to you
exactly?
Seemingly, not too much since 'human happiness' is more important.

I don't pick a religion. I believe what I believe. I can't choose to believe something or to stop believing in something.
We CAN choose to obey. & belief in Jesus doesn't mean one is saved either by the way. We know that from Judas & demons that they know
& believed who Jesus was, yet weren't His.

Mere belief about God isn't salvation. Fruit is the evidence.


And it's not like I choose to believe that God is OK with people getting married again (or any other kind of second chance) - it's simply my conviction based on how I've experienced God. I used to approach God like a slave would approach his master, or like a criminal would approach a judge, until I found out I was his child.
Holo, do & say what you want, THE BIBLE SAYS OTHERWISE.
& until your statements line up with that, I"ll continue to consider
them contrary to God's instruction.

But being a child of God isn't like joining the army, it's like joining the family. :)
You choose to be a Christian / or you are chosen... whichever anyone
wants to claim;
you aren't something when you deny the mandates of it & refuse to
follow it.
A Buddhist isn't a Muslim, a Muslim isn't a Christian, etc. etc.

One isn't 'joined' when they violate the teachings & live another way
according to their own precepts & ideologies. That's called
hypocrisy.

Sure, but what sort of good work are we doing for God by not remarrying? How are we helping him out by doing that?
how are we helping by disobeying God & breaking permanent vows to God & others?
Did you stop to think that the lost often use the Statistics of
Christian divorces which are EQUAL to the secular stats - to prove
that Christians are just like the non Christians & don't have better
& more successful marriages in their own religion? :idea::idea::idea:

THAT is harm & that is not helping God or the Christian name any!!

When the Christians are failing just as much as the lost & can't keep
their marital relationships, it casts a horrible light on God as we claim
that we can do all things thru Christ - & who gives us victorious
lives & who "changes us" inwardly into different people.

Who in their right minds wouldn't question a religion who's God doesn't
seem to change lives, fix/heal marriages & make the people loving
towards one another?

Again, all you focus on self satisfaction - not the source of the
issues. Like disobedience to God, bad Christian examples & broken families.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Zecryphon
Upvote 0

holo

former Christian
Dec 24, 2003
8,992
751
✟85,294.00
Country
Norway
Faith
Agnostic
Marital Status
Private
Do you not get this holo?
WE don't deny these things, GOD DOES.
I understand your point, but the question remains: where's the love in denying someone to remarry?

If it's God's demand, then there definitely must be some sort of advantage to it, something to be achieved, some sort of goal to it or meaning behind it. If God is love, then his rules would be for our best, right?

So that's my question, how is such a rule for our benefit? Or, if it's only for God's own benefit, how does he benefit from it? Or is it just a rule without any apparent reason?

That means that ALL Christians have a duty to relay truth of God
to everyone. If you feel it's fine to make & break covenants to
God & others when they simply don't make you happy anymore
I don't. It's not about feeling happy all the time, it's about serious problems breaking up serious marriages. It's about people who can't live together, and people who were never supposed to be married in the first place. It's not about taking things lightly.

once again, you make false claims that obedience is "legalism".
No, I'm just saying that one of the biggest problems we have today is judgmentalism and legalism. If people obeyed God they wouldn't be so legalistic!

This is based on YOUR/man's corrupted sense of good. Denying God's
instruction of what is good.
I'm not denying anything, I'm ASKING how this rule against remarrying is good for us.

BTW, if our sense of good is corrupted, how did you pick which of Jesus' instructions to apply to yourself and which ones to disregard?

This is again humanist reasoning. It doesn't fly in God's system.
What does covenant mean to you? What does "VOW" mean to you
exactly?
Seemingly, not too much since 'human happiness' is more important.
What is more important to God? That a person has a good life, or that he lives up to a promise he made (that maybe he shouldn't have made in the first place)?

God doesn't have a system, he has a family.

Holo, do & say what you want, THE BIBLE SAYS OTHERWISE.
& until your statements line up with that, I"ll continue to consider
them contrary to God's instruction.
What, shouldn't I approach God like a son approaches his father? Doesn't that line up with the bible?

What about the other instructions Jesus himself gave, that you ignore, or explain away?

You choose to be a Christian / or you are chosen... whichever anyone
wants to claim;
you aren't something when you deny the mandates of it & refuse to
follow it.
You don't become a member of a family by "following" it. You are a child of God because you are born of him. Nobody can change that. It's not a membership you've earned, it's your birthright.

One isn't 'joined' when they violate the teachings & live another way
according to their own precepts & ideologies. That's called
hypocrisy.
My child won't cease to be my child if he does something I don't want him to do.

how are we helping by disobeying God & breaking permanent vows to God & others?
I'm not saying we are. I'm asking how we're somehow helping God by never remarrying if our first marriage broke apart.

Did you stop to think that the lost often use the Statistics of
Christian divorces which are EQUAL to the secular stats - to prove
that Christians are just like the non Christians & don't have better
& more successful marriages in their own religion? :idea::idea::idea:
Yes, and that may be an indication that christians often have a slightly faulty idea of marriage, don't you think?

THAT is harm & that is not helping God or the Christian name any!!
It's not helping the christian religion that is based on living according to rules, because it's so obvious that the christians can't live up to their own standards. If christianity was generally known for grace and for focusing on people's hearts it owuld probably be different.

Who in their right minds wouldn't question a religion who's God doesn't
seem to change lives, fix/heal marriages & make the people loving
towards one another?
Exactly. We're not known for making people love each other, we're more known for being obliged to stay married even if the marriage is horrible (many christians will even get separated, living in different houses, but not actually get divorced, because that would be sin).

Denying people to remarry isn't exactly evidence of a changed life. It's evidence of certain sins never being forgiven.

Again, all you focus on self satisfaction - not the source of the
issues. Like disobedience to God, bad Christian examples & broken families.
The woman I mentioned, with her violent pshycopathic husband, do you think she's a bad example for running away from him and divorcing him?
 
Upvote 0

Nadiine

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2006
52,800
48,336
Obama: 53% deserve him ;)
✟292,219.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
I understand your point, but the question remains: where's the love in denying someone to remarry?
This is why I asked you to tell me what a VOW is Holo.

What is a promise? What is a covenant?
If God acted like this towards us, what covenant of GRACE
would you have? NONE. He'd randomly revert back to
OT Law when we sin & adulterate against Him becuz
He's just not happy with us for awhile when we backslide
or sin willfully.

Let me put this to you in a business sense, you sign a 2 year
contract/promise to do business with a company.
That company soon isn't as lucritive as it was 6 months prior,
yet you have 1 & 1/2 more years on your contract.
Do you break your contract & sign up with another company
instead to make more $?
If you do, you're legally bound to the first one & they'll sue you
for any extra $$ you'de make.
You aren't FREE to get into another contract with another
company becuz by law (in the Govt.s eyes) you're still
under contract with someone else.

THAT is why it's not lawful to remarry when you weren't FREE
from the first one - becuz you don't have the RIGHT to be
bound when you're already bound.
Divorcing for reasons that are not given by God to leave,
makes you still under contract with the former spouse to
continue permanently.
That is what marriage is. Two become one unit together.
Taking another into the relationship is adultery w/ another.

You're whole scope is "I wanna be happy" - God's scope is,
you HAVE to find happiness in the one you're bound to -
it's incentive to work out the problems to fulfill your vows.

It was YOUR word and YOUR covenant you gave and you're
obligated to fulfill that. Just like you expect God to fulfill
HIS covenant He made with us.

According to the NT, marriage is a reflection of our relationship
/bond with CHRIST. The church is Christ's "BRIDE". Would you
like God going back on His promise to you? Obviously not, becuz
that wouldn't benefit you.

If you think permanent covenants & your word are no big deal, then I
assure you, you have alot of bible study to do.
 
Upvote 0

holo

former Christian
Dec 24, 2003
8,992
751
✟85,294.00
Country
Norway
Faith
Agnostic
Marital Status
Private
This is why I asked you to tell me what a VOW is Holo.

What is a promise? What is a covenant?
If God acted like this towards us, what covenant of GRACE
would you have? NONE. He'd randomly revert back to
OT Law when we sin & adulterate against Him becuz
He's just not happy with us for awhile when we backslide
or sin willfully.
Well, we're not God, thankfully. We have the option of second chances when we've screwed up. And thankfully, God doesn't hold our past mistakes against us, no matter what the exact failture was.

Let me put this to you in a business sense, you sign a 2 year
contract/promise to do business with a company.
That company soon isn't as lucritive as it was 6 months prior,
yet you have 1 & 1/2 more years on your contract.
Do you break your contract & sign up with another company
instead to make more $?
If you do, you're legally bound to the first one & they'll sue you
for any extra $$ you'de make.
You aren't FREE to get into another contract with another
company becuz by law (in the Govt.s eyes) you're still
under contract with someone else.

THAT is why it's not lawful to remarry when you weren't FREE
from the first one - becuz you don't have the RIGHT to be
bound when you're already bound.
Divorcing for reasons that are not given by God to leave,
makes you still under contract with the former spouse to
continue permanently.
But it's not a contract. And a marriage may very well be a failure from the very beginning.

You're whole scope is "I wanna be happy" - God's scope is,
you HAVE to find happiness in the one you're bound to -
it's incentive to work out the problems to fulfill your vows.
The woman I mentioned, does she HAVE to go back to her violent and psychopathic husband and find happiness with him? Is that God's "scope"?

Anyway, how exactly do we apply these principles to real life? Because there are people, including christians, who have been married two or three times (and more). Should they get divorced from their current spouse? What about those who've married someone who were divorced earlier? Are they living in sin? Will God not bless their relationship?

How do you get this to work in practice?

And how can you take this specific teaching from Jesus to the jews and apply it to us, but not all the other things he taught?

It was YOUR word and YOUR covenant you gave and you're
obligated to fulfill that. Just like you expect God to fulfill
HIS covenant He made with us.
Yes, and thankfully, when I have failed, God gives me a second chance.

If you think permanent covenants & your word are no big deal, then I
assure you, you have alot of bible study to do.
I don't think I've even been close to suggesting that it's not a big deal.
 
Upvote 0

Nadiine

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2006
52,800
48,336
Obama: 53% deserve him ;)
✟292,219.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Well, we're not God, thankfully. We have the option of second chances when we've screwed up. And thankfully, God doesn't hold our past mistakes against us, no matter what the exact failture was.
In other words, THE HECK WITH WHAT JESUS SAID in Matthew.
That's fine Holo -
like I said, preach humanism all you want, but marriage is God's
institution; HIS creation, and it's HIS rules we go by, not our own.

You want to create a disposable world where we make promises that
we can violate & go back on our words. Great.
& yes, I"m afraid that marriage IS a contract. We make a promise by
it.

we don't just make our own rules & create our own religion despite the
Bible. Guess what, people don't change God's rules any, they merely
violate them when they're rejected.

But it's not a contract. And a marriage may very well be a failure from the very beginning.
What is the grace covenant? A Covenant is a promise - marriage is for
life. Two become one flesh & create their own family unit.
It is a BINDING relationship just like being God's child is binding.
The issue becomes if a person is actually God's child - or they're
deluded into thinking they are when actually they aren't.
This is shown in Mat. 7
17"So every good tree bears good fruit, but the bad tree bears bad fruit.
18"A good tree cannot produce bad fruit, nor can a bad tree produce good fruit.
19"Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire.
20"So then, you will know them by their fruits.
21"Not everyone who says to Me, 'Lord, Lord,' will enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father who is in heaven will enter.
22"Many will say to Me on that day, 'Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in Your name, and in Your name cast out demons, and in Your name perform many miracles?'
23"And then I will declare to them, 'I never knew you; DEPART FROM ME, YOU WHO PRACTICE LAWLESSNESS.'

The Two Foundations
24"Therefore everyone who hears these words of Mine and acts on them, may be compared to a wise man who built his house on the rock.

(those who LIVE BY & ACT ON WHAT THEY'RE TAUGHT IN GOD'S WORD
ARE WISE in obedience).

Peter said this:
just as also our beloved brother Paul, according to the wisdom given him, wrote to you,
16 as also in all his letters, speaking in them of these things, in which are some things hard to understand,
which the untaught and unstable distort, as they do also the rest of the Scriptures, to their own destruction.

** So anyone is free to ignore & deny God's teachings -
but it will be to their own destruction. (possibly eternal).


The woman I mentioned, does she HAVE to go back to her violent and psychopathic husband and find happiness with him? Is that God's "scope"?

Anyway, how exactly do we apply these principles to real life? Because there are people, including christians, who have been married two or three times (and more). Should they get divorced from their current spouse? What about those who've married someone who were divorced earlier? Are they living in sin? Will God not bless their relationship?
I think it's time to mention here that this discussion is now way off topic
& it needs to get back to the subject.

But every pastor I know says that violence/abuse is biblical grounds for
divorce due to the threat alone. I agree.
& if someone is doing that, they're most likely not Christian anyways which I think gives the spouse an "out".
If a spouse leaves (separates) and doesn't formally divorce, they can most likely count on the other to divorce them eventually & be free of it.

But there are many Christian professionals who have written books &
studies on marriage & when remarriage is not biblically lawful.
I'm talking about arbitrary fighting & being unhappy due to personal conflicts that people are divorcing.

How do you get this to work in practice?

And how can you take this specific teaching from Jesus to the jews and apply it to us, but not all the other things he taught?
Again we get back to "this is only to the Jews"... divorce & remarriage
affect EVERYONE, not just Jews. If you marry, you take on God's
instruction becuz marriage is a universal institution.

If it didn't pertain to you, God would say you aren't married in the NT
and be done with marriage.
The act of sex alone makes you ONE with another person - where does
that only apply to Jews?:confused: :o It pertains to all human beings who engage in
the sex act.

Are we now going to manipulate the bible to say "oh, murder was only
given to the Jews to obey - I can hate & murder anyone becuz
I'm a gentile" ^_^ =)~

Yes, and thankfully, when I have failed, God gives me a second chance.
Sin is sin - it has repercussions & consequences.
One of them is that you go on to live in adultery to remarry
outside lawful dissolution of your previous covenant.

Just becuz King David repented of adultery, doesn't mean he went
on to go find another man's wife to take for his own.

All you seem to be advocating here is that 'yes, I know it's adultery
if I remarry, I'll just remarry then 'repent' later on becuz I get a
2nd chance'.
Is that repentance? No it's not.
Sadly most people think remarriage is the answer that will bring
happiness too - in most cases, stats show the 2nd marriage doesn't
work either & it's harder with more baggage & emotional scars
& children from the first marriage.
You're assumption is that remarriage solves the problem - when it
often only moving from one set of problems to a new set of problems
& issues with the next.
Trading issues to cope with.

Either way, it doesn't matter what the outcome is, what matters is if we
obeyed God.
Too often people think if something good happens from sin, that it
must not be sin.
We're MUCH too focused on SELF & our will to pursue what makes
us feel good. In God's kingdom, this is wrong thinking & having a
wrong spirit.

2 Tim. 2
3 You therefore must endure hardship as a good soldier of Jesus Christ.
4 No one engaged in warfare entangles himself with the affairs of this life, that he may please him who enlisted him as a soldier.
5 And also if anyone competes in athletics, he is not crowned unless he competes according to the rules.

Are we more interested in ourselves, or pleasing God & doing
His service? This life isn't about us & our comfortability - contrary
to many people who drink the koolaid of postmodern thought.

Revelation 3:15-17

15 “I know your works, that you are neither cold nor hot. I could wish you were cold or hot.
16 So then, because you are lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I will vomit you out of My mouth.
17 Because you say, ‘I am rich, have become wealthy, and have need of nothing’—and do not know that you are wretched, miserable, poor, blind, and naked—

18 I counsel you to buy from Me gold refined in the fire, that you may be rich; and white garments, that you may be clothed, that the shame of your nakedness may not be revealed; and anoint your eyes with eye salve, that you may see.
19 As many as I love, I rebuke and chasten.
Therefore be zealous and repent.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Zecryphon
Upvote 0

sunlover1

Beloved, Let us love one another
Nov 10, 2006
26,146
5,348
Under the Shadow of the Almighty
✟102,311.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
Yes, Jesus did indeed raise the bar of the law. And if we're going to try and live according to that, there's not a single person here who has the right to point their finger at anybody's divorce, because we've all ben jealous of somebody lately, or taken a peek at somebody's butt yesterday.
Right, or something like that :blush:
And I'd never ever point my finger at someone's divorce.
This is a discussion about marriage and adultry etc.
So we're just offering our own sentiments about such.
No condemning. If someone FEELS condemned they
should take that to God, it could be plain old guilt or
conscience. Ignoring it can be detrimental to your 'comfort'.


Sure, but if I didn't do that in the past, he won't deny me any good thing in the future. Our past mistakes are thrown in the sea of oblivion. Except for failed marriages?
Failed marriages too! :clap: I attended a church that would not
allow a person who'd been divorced to work in any of the ministries.
HUGE well known denomination. I left because of what you just said.
Yes, divorce is included in forgiveness.

I don't believe Jesus is telling people they can never get married again because their first marriage fell apart.
And Peter couldnt see why Jesus could say that He was to die:
33 But when he had turned about and looked on his disciples,
he rebuked Peter, saying, Get thee behind me, Satan:
for thou savourest not the things that be of God,
but the things that be of men.



IOW, it's the difference of an eternal POV versus a temporal pov.
God's very best is for the covenant to stand. IF then something
comes along to interrupt that covenant, one can WAIT in faith,
and later, perhaps, work things out again. I remarried. And it
would have been better had I waited instead... but nobody
told me and I hadnt read it or sought God with all of my heart.

Sure, Jesus did instruct the jews of his day (who were under the law, the ones he was sent to) on what marriage was supposed to be like - they practiced a form of "marriage" where you could get divorced in a day if you took a shining to somebody prettier. That's what Jesus was talking about.
So part of that passage was to Jews and part was to 'whomsoever'?
Which parts are which?
Help a girl out here holo !
:pray:
 
Upvote 0

wkonwtrtom

Pastor
Oct 17, 2003
33
3
Phoenix, AZ
✟15,168.00
Faith
Charismatic
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Holo, you are pretty much on target and Nadine is mired in OT theology. When Jesus spoke about divorce, He was speaking to the Jews under the OT who were abusing the commandments and women in general. What he said to His believers from the NT was that there were only 2 Commandments - Love God and Love your neighbor as yourself. The neighbor part takes up pretty much everything we do in life, from work to our marriages. Our goal is to make our marriages work. But sometimes they do not. In fact, they do not in just as big a percentage as non-Christian's marriages unfortunately. Falling short of the goal is the definition of the word "sin". We fall short of almost all the goals that God has givien us everyday, but as you brought up, God's grace is there to take care of that.

Loving your neighbor means being forgiving not condemning. When someone in the church goes through a divorce, the rest of the church body should be standing along side BOTH spouses to try to mend the marriage, but that failing, to stand with both in recovery. A Christian should never be jumping from marriage to marriage as that would be an obvious violation of the Love your Neighbor commandment. But after going through some church/pastoral counseling, asking for and/or giving forgiveness from the spouse and God, and some time period after the divorce, remarriage would be appropriate. Getting a divorce is no greater sin than any other failing and as such is forgivable by God, at least according to Him.

So, once forgiven of any sin, it is like you never committed the sin, in God's eyes. Therefore, a person would again be free to remarry. However, as I mentioned already, jumping from marriage to marriage repeatedly would be an obvious problem, probably arising out of unrepentant selfishness or pride.

There are churches in many denominations that belive as Nadine does, that anyone getting a divorce can never remarry and they will throw someone out of the church for remarrying. Some act of love that is. I know - I came from just such a church. But I did not even realize it was happening like that until I went through a divorce. I had moved out and wanted to go through counseling but she claimed I abandoned her and filed for divorce. The entire church sided with her (probably because she volunteered at the church and was very close to all of the women in the office) without ever hearing anything from me, including the pastoral staff, and I was tossed. She got her divorce and I had no church.

So I moved back across country to be closer to other family, got involved in another church, spent a couple of years celibate (not even dating), getting solid pastoral counseling, and studying with God like never before. Then God literally brought me and my current wife (a divorcee that got saved) together without us even looking for the other. We were engaged in 10 weeks and married 10 weeks after that. We have been together now for 17+ years and God has been with us through it all, blessed us beyond measure and blessed all that we have laid our hands to. We have witnessed the same thing happen to numerous couples in our years together so we know that God is quite a bit more accepting than Nadine has indicated.

To paraphrase Paul, the law was made to show man the way to God was not through the law. Romans 8:3-4 Jesus is the end of the law for righteousness. Romans 10:4
 
  • Like
Reactions: holo
Upvote 0

wkonwtrtom

Pastor
Oct 17, 2003
33
3
Phoenix, AZ
✟15,168.00
Faith
Charismatic
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
I have read virtually everything written against swinging, premarital sex, and the "church's" position along with the history of those positions. The influence on church doctrine and scriptural interpretaion from pagans and gnostics is rediculous in it's scope particularly on the sex issues. The church has used the sex issues to bind and restrict the believers just as the Pharisees did to the Jews throughout history and were condemned for it by Jesus.

As I pointed out, the "health issues" are erroneous, made up and/or blown out of proportion to reality.



wkonwtrtom, have you read other posts against swinging or just this one? you will find several other arguments that you should also consider particularily health issues.
 
Upvote 0

Nadiine

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2006
52,800
48,336
Obama: 53% deserve him ;)
✟292,219.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
I have read virtually everything written against swinging, premarital sex, and the "church's" position along with the history of those positions. The influence on church doctrine and scriptural interpretaion from pagans and gnostics is rediculous in it's scope particularly on the sex issues. The church has used the sex issues to bind and restrict the believers just as the Pharisees did to the Jews throughout history and were condemned for it by Jesus.

As I pointed out, the "health issues" are erroneous, made up and/or blown out of proportion to reality.
everything's erroneous when compared to the source:

IT'S SIN. Period. You need no other reason other than it's
using other people's bodies for fun & jollies which is abuse
of the dignity God gave human kind.

Being covenanted with a spouse & having random sex w/ other
partners is adultery & God told us that's sin.
A sin that happened to carry a death penalty in the OT.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sunlover1
Upvote 0

wkonwtrtom

Pastor
Oct 17, 2003
33
3
Phoenix, AZ
✟15,168.00
Faith
Charismatic
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
everything's erroneous when compared to the source:

IT'S SIN. Period. You need no other reason other than it's
using other people's bodies for fun & jollies which is abuse
of the dignity God gave human kind.

Being covenanted with a spouse & having random sex w/ other
partners is adultery & God told us that's sin.
A sin that happened to carry a death penalty in the OT.
Adultery (biblically) is not simply the act of sex with another person when married. It is the stealing of another man's wife to be your own. It is a property issue not a sex issue. Jesus made men and women equal (Gal 3:28) and husbands and wives owners of each other's bodies (1Cor7:4). So, if a husband and wife agree to share the other's body with a person or persons unmarried to them, then it is not adultery by biblcal definition. By man's definition it would be, but by man's definition it was illegal for Daniel to worship God and we know how that turned out.
 
Upvote 0

wkonwtrtom

Pastor
Oct 17, 2003
33
3
Phoenix, AZ
✟15,168.00
Faith
Charismatic
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
everything's erroneous when compared to the source:

IT'S SIN. Period. You need no other reason other than it's
using other people's bodies for fun & jollies which is abuse
of the dignity God gave human kind.

Being covenanted with a spouse & having random sex w/ other
partners is adultery & God told us that's sin.
A sin that happened to carry a death penalty in the OT.
Argueing with your father also carried a death penalty in the OT - do we still belive that today?
 
Upvote 0

wkonwtrtom

Pastor
Oct 17, 2003
33
3
Phoenix, AZ
✟15,168.00
Faith
Charismatic
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
everything's erroneous when compared to the source:

IT'S SIN. Period. You need no other reason other than it's
using other people's bodies for fun & jollies which is abuse
of the dignity God gave human kind.

Being covenanted with a spouse & having random sex w/ other
partners is adultery & God told us that's sin.
A sin that happened to carry a death penalty in the OT.
"Fun and Jollies" - does that include paying to see two men box? How about 22 guys beat each other up on a football field? Aren't you using them for your entertainment? Is watching Dancing with the Stars a sin too for using them for your entertainment?

Swingers do not use other people for thier "fun and jollies". They are enjoying sex together with their spouse and for the sexual fulfillment of the other participants together and unselfishly. Swinging is not about self gratification but mutual enjoyment of all participants. It is that lack of selfishness and the pursuit of someone else's sexual enjoyment that makes swinging, in the purest sense, almost Agape-like in nature. Sure there are those that are there only for there own pleasure. But there are those that come to Church for there own pleasure and recognition too. The motive behind any act is what God is most concerned with, not the act itself.
 
Upvote 0

sunlover1

Beloved, Let us love one another
Nov 10, 2006
26,146
5,348
Under the Shadow of the Almighty
✟102,311.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
Holo, you are pretty much on target and Nadine is mired in OT theology.
Interesting opinion. I disagree. :p

When Jesus spoke about divorce, He was speaking to the Jews under the OT who were abusing the commandments and women in general. What he said to His believers from the NT was that there were only 2 Commandments - Love God and Love your neighbor as yourself. The neighbor part takes up pretty much everything we do in life, from work to our marriages. Our goal is to make our marriages work. But sometimes they do not. In fact, they do not in just as big a percentage as non-Christian's marriages unfortunately. Falling short of the goal is the definition of the word "sin".
And Adams sin was believing the lie that we can be our own God.
We fall short of almost all the goals that God has givien us everyday, but as you brought up, God's grace is there to take care of that.
Unless one is actively pursuing holiness, this is a perversion of
the grace of God which actually denies Jesus!

But now I find that I must write about something else, urging you to
defend the faith that God has entrusted once for all time to his holy people.
4 I say this because some ungodly people have wormed their way into your churches,
saying that God’s marvelous grace allows us to live immoral lives.
The condemnation of such people was recorded long ago,
for they have denied our only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ.



Loving your neighbor means being forgiving not condemning. When someone in the church goes through a divorce, the rest of the church body should be standing along side BOTH spouses to try to mend the marriage, but that failing, to stand with both in recovery.
Amen. AND speaking the truth in love they should encourage both
to not remarry, depending on the circumstances.

A Christian should never be jumping from marriage to marriage as that would be an obvious violation of the Love your Neighbor commandment. But after going through some church/pastoral counseling, asking for and/or giving forgiveness from the spouse and God, and some time period after the divorce, remarriage would be appropriate.
It is written? Or is this just your ideal?


So, once forgiven of any sin, it is like you never committed the sin, in God's eyes. Therefore, a person would again be free to remarry.
Forgiveness doesnt change consequences though.


So I moved back across country to be closer to other family, got involved in another church, spent a couple of years celibate (not even dating), getting solid pastoral counseling, and studying with God like never before. Then God literally brought me and my current wife (a divorcee that got saved) together without us even looking for the other. We were engaged in 10 weeks and married 10 weeks after that. We have been together now for 17+ years and God has been with us through it all, blessed us beyond measure and blessed all that we have laid our hands to.

We have witnessed the same thing happen to numerous couples in our years together so we know that God is quite a bit more accepting than Nadine has indicated.
Sin is sin, God will never leave us or forsake us, but we can have God's
best or we can have second best. And in some cases, perhaps as yours
it's been blessed. IMO it depends on the motives of the heart.

To paraphrase Paul, the law was made to show man the way to God was not through the law. Romans 8:3-4 Jesus is the end of the law for righteousness. Romans 10:4
I think Jesus made it a bit more clear:

And the Pharisees also, who were covetous, heard all these things: and they derided him.
15 And he said unto them, Ye are they which justify yourselves before men;
but God knoweth your hearts:
for that which is highly esteemed among men is abomination in the sight of God. 1
6 The law and the prophets were until John:
since that time the kingdom of God is preached, and every man presseth into it.
17 And it is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one tittle of the law to fail.
18 Whosoever putteth away his wife, and marrieth another, committeth adultery:
and whosoever marrieth her that is put away from her husband committeth adultery.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.