• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Socialism vs. Capitalism

Which do you think is the most moral economic system: Socialism or Capitalism?

  • Socialism

  • Capitalsim

  • Other


Results are only viewable after voting.

godisreal36

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2010
1,645
94
State of ohio, USA
✟2,178.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
Your leagalistic mumbo jumbo that you use against others who have not had this meaninglesss education, when you have them at a disadvantage, full well knowing there are many capitalist who know such things and would put your words to shame, when you attemp to shame another with your useless education...that's not love bro. And if you cannot see this, you havn't got the slightest idea of love's meaning. As i said we both failed to love. Can we at least agree on that?
 
Upvote 0

TheReasoner

Atheist. Former Christian.
Mar 14, 2005
10,294
684
Norway
✟37,162.00
Country
Norway
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
Your leagalistic mumbo jumbo that you use against others who have not had this meaninglesss education, when you have them at a disadvantage, full well knowing there are many capitalist who know such things and would put your words to shame, when you attemp to shame another with your useless education...that's not love bro. And if you cannot see this, you havn't got the slightest idea of love's meaning. As i said we both failed to love. Can we at least agree on that?

I'll rephrase then. A Christian man should NEVER say something is true or false if he does not KNOW it. To do so is proud and sinful. Never EVER say something bad about another person unless you KNOW it is true. Even then be careful and loving in your statement.

Is saying this "legalistic mumbo jumbo" godisreal? Is it "unloving" to expect integrity and honesty from one who follows Jesus?

No, it is not. And stop hiding behind a lesser education. You do not have to have an education to avoid slander and defamation. If Obama is so terrible, fine. Prove it. But if you have no proof don't slander and don't defame. It is not proper for a Christian to do so.


edit:oops wrong thread. Point still stands. Never EVER make a claim you cannot back. EVER.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

godisreal36

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2010
1,645
94
State of ohio, USA
✟2,178.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
Yes brother i said i was leaving and i did, i have come back like a dog who eats it's own vomit. But i will attempt to correct the wrong in which i myself have started. Politics does not belong together with god's word. Never should we serve two masters as you have said. We both, you and i brother are guilty. But this is what i asked for, so i hold no bad feelings against you. As a matter of fact, i like politics, i am addicted to it like a drug. But i think it ends in folly where Gods words are concerned. I hate my own political views disrupting Gods word and i hate it when the other side does it too. Will you say that Obama follows Jesus when he spreads others wealth around and uses bible scripture to back it up? Man, i would be carefull that you not fall into the political trap brother. Obama doesn't serve God, how do i know this? GOD DAMN AMERICA! That is what his children hear in church! Obama covered the name of Jesus, without correcting it, not worthy of praise.
 
Upvote 0

godisreal36

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2010
1,645
94
State of ohio, USA
✟2,178.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
Yes brother, i was wrong in being politically motivated. But i stuck up for my brother, same as you should do. Im not better than you by any means, i don't even think it. You try and shame my brother and i will try and shame you! We should love one another as jesus said. Forgive me brother for insulting you, i was wrong.
 
Upvote 0

godisreal36

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2010
1,645
94
State of ohio, USA
✟2,178.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
even now i am wrong for not loving you like i should. these are the things we should talk about, we should love oneanother, you and me, put our foolish ideas behind us, we are both acting like fools when we talk of things not concerning to God. I am wrong, wrong, wrong. Forgive me brother seriously. Im sorry.
 
Upvote 0

TheReasoner

Atheist. Former Christian.
Mar 14, 2005
10,294
684
Norway
✟37,162.00
Country
Norway
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
Yes brother i said i was leaving and i did, i have come back like a dog who eats it's own vomit. But i will attempt to correct the wrong in which i myself have started. Politics does not belong together with god's word. Never should we serve two masters as you have said. We both, you and i brother are guilty. But this is what i asked for, so i hold no bad feelings against you. As a matter of fact, i like politics, i am addicted to it like a drug. But i think it ends in folly where Gods words are concerned. I hate my own political views disrupting Gods word and i hate it when the other side does it too. Will you say that Obama follows Jesus when he spreads others wealth around and uses bible scripture to back it up? Man, i would be carefull that you not fall into the political trap brother. Obama doesn't serve God, how do i know this? GOD DAMN AMERICA! That is what his children hear in church! Obama covered the name of Jesus, without correcting it, not worthy of praise.

I like politics too. As a rather scientifically minded person however I am extremely careful to research the different people and positions before I criticize or praise them. My adoption of socialistic principles only occurred after years of thought.

Yes brother, i was wrong in being politically motivated. But i stuck up for my brother, same as you should do. Im not better than you by any means, i don't even think it. You try and shame my brother and i will try and shame you! We should love one another as jesus said. Forgive me brother for insulting you, i was wrong.

I did not mean to belittle him at all. Thanks for pointing out that my words can be read that way. I admit I was a little annoyed at unsubstantiated claims, but I try not to belittle anyone. And I certainly didn't intend to do so now.
And if someone tries to shame someone else, I remind you as a brother that we are supposed to turn the other cheek, and lovingly chastise those among us who do wrong. Shaming is not a valid procedure. I understand your reaction though, and I can do nought but say I am sorry for appearing to shame him.

even now i am wrong for not loving you like i should. these are the things we should talk about, we should love oneanother, you and me, put our foolish ideas behind us, we are both acting like fools when we talk of things not concerning to God. I am wrong, wrong, wrong. Forgive me brother seriously. Im sorry.

Well, I like talking about different things. Testing my views. Finding other people who have spent a decade or two forming their views as I have mine. I find few. Very very few. Most adopt a viewpoint without thinking it through, and guard it ferociously. I find it extremely hard to respect a viewpoint which is absolute and at the same time not based on anything but a desire, wish or opinion.

Did you see what i wrote about darwin? what do you think about it brother?

Ah. Yes I read it. No, I did not intend to say that if Darwin was wrong capitalism is wrong. Social darwinism is something rather different from the theory of evolution. Social darwinism is the attempt at employing extreme competition into society to let the strong root out the weak and prevail over them. While the theory of evolution is a matter of observations and deductions from those observations about how nature works, social darwinism is a philosophical or ideological approach to society.

The two are as different as night is from day.

To boil it down: Evolution does not concern itself with what should be or morals and ethics. Social Darwinism DOES. And when I have spoken with American creationists one of their primary arguments against evolution has been that it encourages social darwinism. And some say that social darwinism came into being because of the theory of evolution.

There are multiple problems with this. First off, if you read Plato's "The Republic" he describes social darwinism rather explicitly in his description of the perfect state as he saw it. So it is rather older than Darwin. About 2000 years older at the very least. Probably much more so. As old as sin itself I'd think. And secondly: It is a logical fallacy to claim that one can draw conclusions as to how things should be from how they are. Thirdly a scientific theory does not concern itself with what should be or what is right. It merely concerns itself with what is, based on empirical data.

So what about capitalism? Well, it is based upon the principles of social darwinism in that it strengthens the strong and enables the strong to push the weak off of the playing field. It, as a system, is socio-darwinistic. I took a class in philosophy last semester and spoke to my professor about my perceptions of capitalism as a sociodarwinistic ideology. He said the observation was apt, and quite correct. The sociodarwinistic principles are embedded in the ideology and the more laissez faire it is, the more it becomes a pure form of social darwinism.

So what I intended to say is that if you base your belief on Evolution being wrong because you find it immoral, then you should by the same measure discard capitalism as it embodies that which most creationists I know consider the evil in evolution.

Did that answer your question?
 
Upvote 0

godisreal36

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2010
1,645
94
State of ohio, USA
✟2,178.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
The bible doesn't use such words bro. There is a place among scientists and other professionals for this. But to say i have no education is wrong, i have educated myself in truth, Ive been paying attention since i was young and since Bill Clinton. thats 18 years Ive been paying attention. You say that because i have no education that i don't know what goes on in reality concerning politics? You misjudge. Do you say that only highly educated elites can know and operate in politics? Wow. You my friend are educated but also delusional concerning yourself, if that's what you believe. You may be overeducated if you believe that. We don't think like that in America, we fought a war of Independence against that sort of thing. Moses could not speak very well yet god made him a profit.

So you are also saying that Darwin was Wrong? Do you agree?
 
Upvote 0

godisreal36

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2010
1,645
94
State of ohio, USA
✟2,178.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
Forget that, maybe i misjudge you a little, that stuff gave me a migraine reading it, Let's keep things simple. I like to read responses but not a novel. I see that i am attacking you and you are only defending, I'm sorry my apologies sir.

Now, you say that capitalism is evil, but it's not, no more than socialism anyways. I think our poor have many benefits here in USA, the problem is government corruption, and drug abuse and other things, not capitalism.

The reason i think Darwin's theory of evolution is wrong, it's not only the bible, evolution seems to consistently and slowly change it's opinion. Also i think Scientific data supports the bible more that Darwin. Also many scientists are creationists, if that's the proper term. Darwin himself thought women lower on the scale of evolution. He himself has said if we find no evidence in the future out of the fossil record that his theory was wrong. And we haven't found any. I think Darwin should be considered wrong about women and evolution, not that some form of evolution could be going on, just that Darwin's theory sure seems to be wrong. Man made Global warming, Evolution, Socialism is not evil, all lies ridiculous theories and the way of the world.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

TheReasoner

Atheist. Former Christian.
Mar 14, 2005
10,294
684
Norway
✟37,162.00
Country
Norway
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
The bible doesn't use such words bro. There is a place among scientists and other professionals for this. But to say i have no education is wrong, i have educated myself in truth, Ive been paying attention since i was young and since Bill Clinton. thats 18 years Ive been paying attention. You say that because i have no education that i don't know what goes on in reality concerning politics? You misjudge. Do you say that only highly educated elites can know and operate in politics? Wow. You my friend are educated but also delusional concerning yourself, if that's what you believe. You may be overeducated if you believe that. We don't think like that in America, we fought a war of Independence against that sort of thing. Moses could not speak very well yet god made him a profit.

I never made such claims. But it is a benefit to know much.
What I am saying is that if you want to make bold statements you had better know what you are talking about. You call socialism a lie. Yet I see no basis for this claim. I wrote to you - in length - presenting rather significant evidence in socialism's favor. You do not contest my evidence but ignore it. This has nothing to do with education but with integrity. When someone is presented with evidence revealing they were wrong the sound thing to do is to check against verifiable sources and then either dismiss the claims made - or dismiss your own position. You have done neither, but persist in calling that which you do not agree with a lie. I expect more from a brother in Christ godisreal. I expect that those who follow Christ are able to admit when wrong, and also that they are able and willing to test claims like "*** is a lie" where *** can be socialism, evolution whatever.
Slander and false witness, which are things which include saying "Socialism is a lie" when you do not KNOW that this is so IS bearing false witness, and it is very very wrong.

So you are also saying that Darwin was Wrong? Do you agree?

You often go back to that question. I will answer with a question of my own - for now.

Do you know of geocentrism?
Back in the old days when people thought the earth was the center of the universe Galileo Galilei discovered that it wasn't. This really upset a lot of believers who thought the earth was the center of all things, and the stars mearly lights in a firm shell above. Some priests supported Galileo, but he was tried by the inquisition for heresy. Many hated what Galileo had discovered, and said it was against the bible.

Today we know that Galileo was right. The earth orbits the sun. Not the other way around. And most Christians don't see why there should have been a problem with this fact. Most probably do not know it was a problem.

So. My question: When Galileo discovered what he did, he was attacked for attacking God although he did not do that. It turned out the attackers were wrong, and even today we see people rejecting Christ because of what those people did.
So: Could it be that the interpretation you use when you say evolution is wrong is also wrong? Could it be - is it even remotely possible - that you could be wrong and that God did use evolution to create us?
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

The4thrider

Powered by caffine and hate...sometimes whiskey
May 17, 2010
791
96
✟23,890.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single
129169053672915750.jpg


Capitalist!
 
  • Like
Reactions: shinbits
Upvote 0

godisreal36

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2010
1,645
94
State of ohio, USA
✟2,178.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
Evolution, the theory of mans origin. Yes i believe its possible that evolution may actually be a term one could use to decribe Gods creation. But Darwin's theory is ridiculous. Man from Ape? Women are lower on the scale of evolution than men?
The lack of the missing link in the fossil record would seem to indicate that if evolution does occur, we don't currently have a good theory on it. I know some things like birds, fish and dogs can evolve somewhat but it's built into their genetic code to do so and only by mixing different breeds does this "evolution" occur. Also allot of things appear to not evolve at all because it's not in their code to evolve. The genetic code poses some real problems for evolution i think. Theres are creatonist scientists with some pretty amazing evidence and theories of their own. After the fall of Darwin's theory and the 'man made' global warming lie, if i was a scientist i would seek out my creationist colleagues and see what they believe. Science is amazing.
 
Upvote 0

godisreal36

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2010
1,645
94
State of ohio, USA
✟2,178.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
Can someone in a socialist/communist nation get fired from a job?

What is comunism? What is capitalism or socialism? Forget all that, apples and oranges. I know comunism is bad, if you can even get a job in a communist country, you won't have to worry about getting fired, getting shot in the back of the head, exucution style and getting dumped into an unmarked grave is what i would worry about in communist countries. China is still communist.

Socialist countries are more complex im learning. They seem to want to be like one big happy work union where no one can get fired, even not for failing to show up for work. Maybe it's just a false stereotype. Idk, but i think france had some trouble in that department.

Capitalism, ah yes something i know about, yes you can get fired and will. Unions help the working class, but like everything else is very corrupt. Most labor unions don't serve the people but politics instead, i think. Politics, a stumbeling block my freinds.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

TheReasoner

Atheist. Former Christian.
Mar 14, 2005
10,294
684
Norway
✟37,162.00
Country
Norway
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
What is comunism? What is capitalism or socialism? Forget all that, apples and oranges. I know comunism is bad, if you can even get a job in a communist country, you won't have to worry about getting fired, getting shot in the back of the head, exucution style and getting dumped into an unmarked grave is what i would worry about in communist countries. China is still communist.

Socialist countries are more complex im learning. They seem to want to be like one big happy work union where no one can get fired, even not for failing to show up for work. Maybe it's just a false stereotype. Idk, but i think france had some trouble in that department.

Capitalism, ah yes something i know about, yes you can get fired and will. Unions help the working class, but like everything else is very corrupt. Most labor unions don't serve the people but politics instead, i think. Politics, a stumbeling block my freinds.

Tell me. What is communism, godisreal? You seem to claim to know much about it, so tell me: What IS it? What are the central tenests of communism, and why are they evil?
 
Upvote 0

godisreal36

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2010
1,645
94
State of ohio, USA
✟2,178.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
Politics is horrible freinds. I sit in judgment over my political enemies, yes i do this and am guilty of pride and of judging my brothers and sisters. I am guilty and i must confess and ask your forgiveness. Seriously folks i hate myself for engaging in politics and yet i cannot stop myself, i try and rationalise it by "being nice" yet i still feel convicted, i want to be perfect yet i cannot, politics is a stumbling block i think... May god help
 
Upvote 0

gluadys

Legend
Mar 2, 2004
12,958
682
Toronto
✟39,020.00
Faith
Protestant
Politics
CA-NDP
Can someone in a socialist/communist nation get fired from a job?

Ideally, in a socialist nation, the workers own the enterprise they are working in, so the question of being fired doesn't arise. If you aren't pulling your weight, your partners will certainly let you know.
 
Upvote 0

TheReasoner

Atheist. Former Christian.
Mar 14, 2005
10,294
684
Norway
✟37,162.00
Country
Norway
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
Can someone in a socialist/communist nation get fired from a job?

Hypothetically? I don't know if the term "job" would have any meaning in a true communist society as wages would not - as we know it. The way I understand the true communist utopia. Oh sure you'f have tasks to fulfil for your brethren. As a related question we could ask: Do jobs exist in a commune, for example a convent or monastery? In essence some of those can be considered communistic societies after all, where no-one owns anything but everyone shares every possession. In larger institutions such as a town, city or even country this would naturally include the factory, research institution, whatever in which they work.

As for how it is here - given this is a social democracy - it is hard to get fired. Not showing up on time, being drugged or abusive does it though. But you'd have to neglect your job rather seriously. I have nearly fired people before, so I know a little about the process. The time in question we assembled a board of about ten administrators and myself as their boss. We discussed the case in question, reviewed case files and after about two hours discussion decided to ask the man in question to leave his position or be fired. He left.
It was very well deserved, but we had to make sure we left no way for him to seek legal action against us. Or me specifically, for that matter.
Don't ask me about legal details though, I am VERY rusty, as I ran a small company of about 10 people back in 2000, and was responsible, as a boss consultant and manager for about 48 people when I worked in the army - and I left the army back in 2004, so it's a while back.

As a former employer and business manager I like the way the system works. It makes an employer - or most employers I think - consider the hiring process more carefully. What we often do is hire a person for six months, and then possibly expent the contract to a year. After a year or so like this we can extend an offer of permanent employment which gives the employee more security, and the employer as well. The employer will for example know that the employee is bound to the contract, that he or she cannot leave/quit the job without ample warning. Given the 6 month to a year contract the employer will also know the person in question is capable and so secures hi or herself a steady reliable employee.
For the most part.
There are of course lazy and deceitful people out there.

It does have it's reasons. The system is there to protect the employee - as sometimes an employer can abuse his or her power. But it is also there to ensure that a boss does not for personal reasons fire someone. To fire someone you must document the reason. This is so to ensure that the employer does not make up reasons for firing.
 
Upvote 0

Notamonkey

Member
Dec 17, 2007
1,203
57
61
Mount Morris, MI
✟24,153.00
Faith
Nazarene
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Pardon? I really did not intend snobbery. Or an attack on educational level. I merely sought to ask if he had it as it seemed from his opinions that he does not. Surely you agree that a Christian should not promote ideas if he does not have sound evidence that said claims are in fact true? Is it not important that we show integrity and care to always be as truthful as possible in all situations? And as this surely is the case a Christian man should not at any point claim anything to be absolutely true unless he can point his finger at both the bible and creation and say "Look! This is how it is!"
I apologize if I came across poorly, I am not very good with people though I love them. I am better with data.

I do resent you saying that snobbery is the hallmark of socialism though brother. Why do you launch this irrational attack?

Show me were socialism has ever made people prosper. The problem is that you can't because there isn't any example. So, you promote socialism under some other motive because you haven't learned from history.

Simpley declaring socialism to be so good doesn't make it so, nor does pointing out spelling errors. European socialism? They are broke and rioting in the streets. We are headed to the same end because of socialistic programs of entitlement no country can afford. You can talk all you want about how great it is in your mind but it is not sustainable.
 
Upvote 0